{ "what": "the UNQUANTIZED bf16 model with relative Gaussian noise 0.001 on one tensor (layer 1 down_proj): the agreement any quantization of this model is bounded by", "note": "text_* fields are the deviation from the reference on documents rendered inside user turns; they are a fidelity number, not a quality metric", "klref": { "sequences": 28, "positions": 68370, "median_kl": 0.06028680503368378, "mean_kl": 0.7488869428634644, "p90": 2.2322335243225098, "p95": 4.25889778137207, "p99": 9.620244026184082, "kl_max": 26.808528900146484, "top1_pct": 71.58841597191751, "top5_pct": 85.82272926722247, "top10_pct": 89.08585636975282, "text_ppl_q": 67.33650207519531, "text_ppl_ref": 64.08563232421875, "text_ppl_ratio": 1.0507272481918335, "text_nll_delta_mean": 0.049482543021440506, "text_nll_delta_sem": 0.007424323470551016, "text_positions_compared_pct": 100.0, "text_ppl_unbiased": true, "text_top1_acc_q_pct": 44.4493198771391, "text_top1_acc_ref_pct": 44.99195553605382, "call_positions": 911, "call_nll_q": 1.9571926593780518, "call_nll_ref": 1.8504042625427246, "call_nll_delta": 0.10678845643997192, "call_nll_delta_sem": 0.07356708820417222, "call_top1_acc_q_pct": 72.44785949506037, "call_top1_acc_ref_pct": 74.86278814489572, "call_p_correct_q_geomean": 0.14125441014766693, "call_p_correct_ref_geomean": 0.15717361867427826, "per_domain": { "academic_mc": { "sequences": 2, "positions": 3123, "median_kl": 0.07163441926240921, "mean_kl": 0.4941253066062927, "p90": 1.2521964311599731, "p95": 2.463402509689331, "p99": 6.70340633392334, "kl_max": 21.34412956237793, "top1_pct": 73.07076528978547, "top5_pct": 89.94556516170348, "top10_pct": 93.01953250080052, "text_ppl_q": 77.51740264892578, "text_ppl_ref": 83.09352111816406, "text_ppl_ratio": 0.9328935146331787, "text_nll_delta_mean": -0.06946424394845963, "text_nll_delta_sem": 0.028082956470559688, "text_positions_compared_pct": 100.0, "text_ppl_unbiased": true, "text_top1_acc_q_pct": 38.52065321805956, "text_top1_acc_ref_pct": 38.58469420429075 }, "agentic": { "sequences": 4, "positions": 7411, "median_kl": 0.0958956927061081, "mean_kl": 0.8795613646507263, "p90": 2.719298839569092, "p95": 4.733425617218018, "p99": 9.887956619262695, "kl_max": 19.4514217376709, "top1_pct": 66.92754014303063, "top5_pct": 82.33706652273646, "top10_pct": 86.26366212386992, "text_ppl_q": 155.5294189453125, "text_ppl_ref": 144.7749786376953, "text_ppl_ratio": 1.0742839574813843, "text_nll_delta_mean": 0.07165432721376419, "text_nll_delta_sem": 0.023170038994200767, "text_positions_compared_pct": 100.0, "text_ppl_unbiased": true, "text_top1_acc_q_pct": 39.69774659290245, "text_top1_acc_ref_pct": 40.08905680744839, "call_positions": 315, "call_nll_q": 2.1134989261627197, "call_nll_ref": 1.8950586318969727, "call_nll_delta": 0.218440443277359, "call_nll_delta_sem": 0.126491185309146, "call_top1_acc_q_pct": 72.38095238095238, "call_top1_acc_ref_pct": 76.19047619047619, "call_p_correct_q_geomean": 0.1208145022392273, "call_p_correct_ref_geomean": 0.1503095179796219 }, "chinese": { "sequences": 2, "positions": 3158, "median_kl": 0.0375639982521534, "mean_kl": 0.540226936340332, "p90": 1.2133997678756714, "p95": 3.0907554626464844, "p99": 9.696211814880371, "kl_max": 19.559850692749023, "top1_pct": 77.83407219759341, "top5_pct": 90.75364154528182, "top10_pct": 93.35022165927802, "text_ppl_q": 146.9723358154297, "text_ppl_ref": 139.631103515625, "text_ppl_ratio": 1.052575707435608, "text_nll_delta_mean": 0.0512402206659317, "text_nll_delta_sem": 0.037088767409218, "text_positions_compared_pct": 100.0, "text_ppl_unbiased": true, "text_top1_acc_q_pct": 35.718809373020896, "text_top1_acc_ref_pct": 35.718809373020896 }, "coding": { "sequences": 5, "positions": 8249, "median_kl": 0.030682625249028206, "mean_kl": 0.7262228727340698, "p90": 2.2243595123291016, "p95": 4.3674492835998535, "p99": 9.655651092529297, "kl_max": 22.811620712280273, "top1_pct": 73.7059037459086, "top5_pct": 86.33773790762517, "top10_pct": 89.34416292883985, "text_ppl_q": 51.62739562988281, "text_ppl_ref": 48.28934097290039, "text_ppl_ratio": 1.0691256523132324, "text_nll_delta_mean": 0.06684114784002304, "text_nll_delta_sem": 0.02025469839937471, "text_positions_compared_pct": 100.0, "text_ppl_unbiased": true, "text_top1_acc_q_pct": 48.66044369014426, "text_top1_acc_ref_pct": 49.399927263910776 }, "cybersec": { "sequences": 4, "positions": 6653, "median_kl": 0.02382112666964531, "mean_kl": 0.6448559165000916, "p90": 1.9087097644805908, "p95": 4.029167652130127, "p99": 8.73491096496582, "kl_max": 23.606565475463867, "top1_pct": 76.41665414098902, "top5_pct": 88.20081166391101, "top10_pct": 90.80114234180068, "text_ppl_q": 44.303619384765625, "text_ppl_ref": 40.27240753173828, "text_ppl_ratio": 1.1000986099243164, "text_nll_delta_mean": 0.09539978206157684, "text_nll_delta_sem": 0.021676263560214893, "text_positions_compared_pct": 100.0, "text_ppl_unbiased": true, "text_top1_acc_q_pct": 51.66090485495265, "text_top1_acc_ref_pct": 52.72809258980911 }, "general": { "sequences": 3, "positions": 5311, "median_kl": 0.07391507178544998, "mean_kl": 0.6419679522514343, "p90": 1.8744210004806519, "p95": 3.544818878173828, "p99": 8.784656524658203, "kl_max": 19.794815063476562, "top1_pct": 71.49312747128602, "top5_pct": 86.44323102993786, "top10_pct": 89.68179250611938, "text_ppl_q": 134.31143188476562, "text_ppl_ref": 122.87806701660156, "text_ppl_ratio": 1.0930465459823608, "text_nll_delta_mean": 0.08896876871585846, "text_nll_delta_sem": 0.028080449858036344, "text_positions_compared_pct": 100.0, "text_ppl_unbiased": true, "text_top1_acc_q_pct": 38.7497646394276, "text_top1_acc_ref_pct": 39.20165693842967 }, "long_agentic": { "sequences": 2, "positions": 10190, "median_kl": 0.1518646776676178, "mean_kl": 1.174489974975586, "p90": 3.756044387817383, "p95": 6.036811351776123, "p99": 11.245322227478027, "kl_max": 19.850561141967773, "top1_pct": 63.65063788027477, "top5_pct": 78.32188420019627, "top10_pct": 82.6594700686948, "text_ppl_q": 80.446533203125, "text_ppl_ref": 77.45440673828125, "text_ppl_ratio": 1.038630723953247, "text_nll_delta_mean": 0.037903208285570145, "text_nll_delta_sem": 0.024527187599360113, "text_positions_compared_pct": 100.0, "text_ppl_unbiased": true, "text_top1_acc_q_pct": 44.94602551521099, "text_top1_acc_ref_pct": 45.37782139352306, "call_positions": 596, "call_nll_q": 1.874580979347229, "call_nll_ref": 1.8268033266067505, "call_nll_delta": 0.047777753323316574, "call_nll_delta_sem": 0.09040192085424628, "call_top1_acc_q_pct": 72.48322147651007, "call_top1_acc_ref_pct": 74.16107382550335, "call_p_correct_q_geomean": 0.15341924130916595, "call_p_correct_ref_geomean": 0.1609271764755249 }, "long_coding": { "sequences": 2, "positions": 9390, "median_kl": 0.035911377519369125, "mean_kl": 0.7038131952285767, "p90": 2.17490816116333, "p95": 4.21785306930542, "p99": 9.04932689666748, "kl_max": 19.187047958374023, "top1_pct": 74.49414270500533, "top5_pct": 86.74121405750799, "top10_pct": 89.55271565495208, "text_ppl_q": 37.17418670654297, "text_ppl_ref": 37.08015441894531, "text_ppl_ratio": 1.0025359392166138, "text_nll_delta_mean": 0.0025327790062874556, "text_nll_delta_sem": 0.01903810936491189, "text_positions_compared_pct": 100.0, "text_ppl_unbiased": true, "text_top1_acc_q_pct": 51.9275825346113, "text_top1_acc_ref_pct": 52.51331203407881 }, "long_longctx": { "sequences": 2, "positions": 10990, "median_kl": 0.0587487667798996, "mean_kl": 0.5435295701026917, "p90": 1.2706959247589111, "p95": 2.847358226776123, "p99": 8.863947868347168, "kl_max": 23.567869186401367, "top1_pct": 74.00363967242947, "top5_pct": 89.7179253867152, "top10_pct": 92.72065514103731, "text_ppl_q": 50.387821197509766, "text_ppl_ref": 48.85396957397461, "text_ppl_ratio": 1.0313963890075684, "text_nll_delta_mean": 0.03091362863779068, "text_nll_delta_sem": 0.015269082721638993, "text_positions_compared_pct": 100.0, "text_ppl_unbiased": true, "text_top1_acc_q_pct": 41.51046405823476, "text_top1_acc_ref_pct": 42.029117379435846 }, "science": { "sequences": 2, "positions": 3895, "median_kl": 0.09950811415910721, "mean_kl": 0.8198201060295105, "p90": 2.446251153945923, "p95": 4.460198879241943, "p99": 9.16201114654541, "kl_max": 26.808528900146484, "top1_pct": 68.54942233632862, "top5_pct": 85.57124518613607, "top10_pct": 88.98587933247754, "text_ppl_q": 54.17967224121094, "text_ppl_ref": 47.66631317138672, "text_ppl_ratio": 1.1366446018218994, "text_nll_delta_mean": 0.1280806064605713, "text_nll_delta_sem": 0.029425310867253786, "text_positions_compared_pct": 100.0, "text_ppl_unbiased": true, "text_top1_acc_q_pct": 40.821566110397946, "text_top1_acc_ref_pct": 41.54043645699615 } } }, "tool_conversations_native_format": { "sequences": 96, "positions": 65719, "median_kl": 0.29158198833465576, "mean_kl": 0.9305510520935059, "p90": 2.485236644744873, "p95": 3.8753490447998047, "p99": 9.514266967773438, "kl_max": 27.091535568237305, "top1_pct": 55.055615575404374, "top5_pct": 78.43698169479147, "top10_pct": 84.22982699067241, "text_ppl_q": 1861.92822265625, "text_ppl_ref": 1744.8138427734375, "text_ppl_ratio": 1.067121148109436, "text_nll_delta_mean": 0.06496450304985046, "text_nll_delta_sem": 0.0065325011678668814, "text_positions_compared_pct": 100.0, "text_ppl_unbiased": true, "text_top1_acc_q_pct": 18.725178411113987, "text_top1_acc_ref_pct": 18.764740790334606, "call_positions": 8544, "call_nll_q": 5.430123805999756, "call_nll_ref": 5.388685703277588, "call_nll_delta": 0.041438471525907516, "call_nll_delta_sem": 0.018797064849230553, "call_top1_acc_q_pct": 41.725187265917604, "call_top1_acc_ref_pct": 42.017790262172284, "call_p_correct_q_geomean": 0.004382553044706583, "call_p_correct_ref_geomean": 0.0045679728500545025, "decisions": { "call": { "n": 112, "argmax_agree_pct": 91.96428571428571, "call_answer_flips": 9, "reference_starts_tool_call": 100, "model_starts_tool_call": 97, "median_p_toolcall_ref": 0.8585168123245239, "median_p_toolcall_q": 0.8496556878089905, "min_p_toolcall_q": 0.053277384489774704, "max_p_toolcall_q": 0.9938733577728271 }, "answer": { "n": 96, "argmax_agree_pct": 91.66666666666667, "call_answer_flips": 0, "reference_starts_tool_call": 1, "model_starts_tool_call": 1, "median_p_toolcall_ref": 0.0023557787062600255, "median_p_toolcall_q": 0.002312922733835876, "min_p_toolcall_q": 0.00013880895858164877, "max_p_toolcall_q": 0.3773735463619232 } } } }