{
  "scope": "80 fixed requests, both explicit efforts; merged-model comparison, not independent generalization evidence",
  "checkpoint_step": 3000,
  "base_id": "Qwen/Qwen3.5-9B",
  "base_revision": "c202236235762e1c871ad0ccb60c8ee5ba337b9a",
  "comparison": {
    "passed": false,
    "gate": "identical160_argmax_and_max_probability_delta_le_0.05",
    "depths": {
      "16": {
        "before_correct": 63,
        "after_correct": 63,
        "changed_decisions": [],
        "max_probability_abs_difference": 0.08810508251190186,
        "mean_probability_abs_difference": 0.0019464968157012663,
        "max_logit_abs_difference": 0.265625,
        "mean_logit_abs_difference": 0.02963104248046875
      },
      "32": {
        "before_correct": 68,
        "after_correct": 68,
        "changed_decisions": [],
        "max_probability_abs_difference": 0.062176525592803955,
        "mean_probability_abs_difference": 0.001304240933347387,
        "max_logit_abs_difference": 0.25,
        "mean_logit_abs_difference": 0.03828125
      }
    },
    "before_sha256": "28412c70d8b456b35bb884a2fba4e85801b0135fc7957190927994a56d268a6f",
    "after_sha256": "3f01a868d4fba91a8a1749df37a87f10f0874823eec5a978291c93231773c365",
    "verified_at_unix": 1789984423.7235599
  },
  "runtime_validation": {
    "status": "passed",
    "decisions": 160,
    "max_probability_delta": 0.0,
    "no_jev_import": true,
    "long_input_rejected": true,
    "invalid_effort_rejected": true,
    "text_scope": "Execution smoke only; not TYPE accuracy or speed validation",
    "source_sha256": "70d686828090965063966dddac6d8454cf981c6614a406c1647617986e534c5d"
  },
  "decision_release": {
    "passed": true,
    "scope": "Independent BF16 merged variant, frozen80 decision parity; NOT a probability-equivalent replacement",
    "post_observation_scope_amendment": true,
    "original_numerical_gate_passed": false,
    "original_gate": "identical160_argmax_and_max_probability_delta_le_0.05",
    "original_comparison_sha256": "d2ea8a7af10f09fdfde166384ffb18fb5a19ebf1a1281c58cb72806a45878c41",
    "decision_agreement": 160,
    "total_decisions": 160,
    "independent_questions": 80,
    "probability_calibration_transfer_validated": false,
    "automatic_routing_validated": false,
    "required_followup": "Recalibrate all probability, rejection and routing thresholds; independently evaluate new tasks",
    "depths": {
      "16": {
        "before_correct": 63,
        "after_correct": 63,
        "changed_decisions": [],
        "max_probability_abs_difference": 0.08810508251190186,
        "mean_probability_abs_difference": 0.0019464968157012663,
        "max_logit_abs_difference": 0.265625,
        "mean_logit_abs_difference": 0.02963104248046875
      },
      "32": {
        "before_correct": 68,
        "after_correct": 68,
        "changed_decisions": [],
        "max_probability_abs_difference": 0.062176525592803955,
        "mean_probability_abs_difference": 0.001304240933347387,
        "max_logit_abs_difference": 0.25,
        "mean_logit_abs_difference": 0.03828125
      }
    },
    "publication_requires": "Further portable-runtime160, weight arithmetic, full file hashes and fresh HF reload gates"
  },
  "reviewed_variant": {},
  "decision_parity_passed": true,
  "decision_agreement": 160,
  "weight_arithmetic_status": "passed",
  "raw_inputs_included": false
}