Jev-Style-2B-Decision-v3-MLX / validation /parity /compare_mlx_affine8-g64_base_vs_block.json
chaoliangUNSW's picture
Jev-Style-2B-Decision-v3: release
11ce5d7 verified
Raw History Blame
7.7 kB
{
"format": "8bit",
"temperature": 0.8278650620942867,
"overall": {
"n": 43,
"top1_agreement": 1.0,
"top1_flips": 0,
"max_abs_dscore": 0.4653351306915283,
"mean_abs_dscore": 0.023077200647273945,
"mean_kl": 0.0006975644872166873,
"n_gold": 43,
"nll_ref": 0.670433307194272,
"nll_cand": 0.6868139442506376,
"dnll": 0.01638063705636561,
"mean_abs_row_dnll": 0.030139399526949388,
"acc_ref": 0.7209302325581395,
"acc_cand": 0.7209302325581395,
"acc_drop_pp": 0.0
},
"per_category": {
"catalogue_overflow": {
"n": 3,
"top1_agreement": 1.0,
"top1_flips": 0,
"max_abs_dscore": 0.2735496163368225,
"mean_abs_dscore": 0.019241230377298316,
"mean_kl": 0.0012829640019479873,
"n_gold": 3,
"nll_ref": 0.5023960827418966,
"nll_cand": 0.46349011750257935,
"dnll": -0.038905965239317275,
"mean_abs_row_dnll": 0.039379824994875905,
"acc_ref": 0.6666666666666666,
"acc_cand": 0.6666666666666666,
"acc_drop_pp": 0.0
},
"catalogue_overflow_long_state": {
"n": 1,
"top1_agreement": 1.0,
"top1_flips": 0,
"max_abs_dscore": 0.09829854965209961,
"mean_abs_dscore": 0.02608197888001701,
"mean_kl": 0.00037418306666026774,
"n_gold": 1,
"nll_ref": 1.868953922917252,
"nll_cand": 1.8305656122814864,
"dnll": -0.03838831063576564,
"mean_abs_row_dnll": 0.03838831063576564,
"acc_ref": 0.0,
"acc_cand": 0.0,
"acc_drop_pp": 0.0
},
"long_16k": {
"n": 3,
"top1_agreement": 1.0,
"top1_flips": 0,
"max_abs_dscore": 0.4653351306915283,
"mean_abs_dscore": 0.04898447410160343,
"mean_kl": 0.005652873428140343,
"n_gold": 3,
"nll_ref": 1.098996986024778,
"nll_cand": 1.3040987437659517,
"dnll": 0.20510175774117378,
"mean_abs_row_dnll": 0.2051017577411738,
"acc_ref": 0.6666666666666666,
"acc_cand": 0.6666666666666666,
"acc_drop_pp": 0.0
},
"long_24k": {
"n": 2,
"top1_agreement": 1.0,
"top1_flips": 0,
"max_abs_dscore": 0.068747878074646,
"mean_abs_dscore": 0.03896120687325796,
"mean_kl": 0.0007690578648421433,
"n_gold": 2,
"nll_ref": 0.43411292245601785,
"nll_cand": 0.43100727732191557,
"dnll": -0.003105645134102275,
"mean_abs_row_dnll": 0.019953016950989222,
"acc_ref": 1.0,
"acc_cand": 1.0,
"acc_drop_pp": 0.0
},
"many_options": {
"n": 2,
"top1_agreement": 1.0,
"top1_flips": 0,
"max_abs_dscore": 0.06005406379699707,
"mean_abs_dscore": 0.01609148249030113,
"mean_kl": 3.102768330017338e-06,
"n_gold": 2,
"nll_ref": 0.012124599411053285,
"nll_cand": 0.012000711496263293,
"dnll": -0.00012388791478999163,
"mean_abs_row_dnll": 0.00012388791478999076,
"acc_ref": 1.0,
"acc_cand": 1.0,
"acc_drop_pp": 0.0
},
"multi_block_3k": {
"n": 2,
"top1_agreement": 1.0,
"top1_flips": 0,
"max_abs_dscore": 0.037885069847106934,
"mean_abs_dscore": 0.015739992260932922,
"mean_kl": 0.00011035902286322221,
"n_gold": 2,
"nll_ref": 0.10264503770560551,
"nll_cand": 0.09882922575086513,
"dnll": -0.0038158119547403863,
"mean_abs_row_dnll": 0.00429795147361977,
"acc_ref": 1.0,
"acc_cand": 1.0,
"acc_drop_pp": 0.0
},
"multi_block_5k": {
"n": 2,
"top1_agreement": 1.0,
"top1_flips": 0,
"max_abs_dscore": 0.0428202748298645,
"mean_abs_dscore": 0.02182019054889679,
"mean_kl": 4.99818269133305e-05,
"n_gold": 2,
"nll_ref": 0.41414880456154163,
"nll_cand": 0.40767085022183286,
"dnll": -0.006477954339708769,
"mean_abs_row_dnll": 0.006477954339708783,
"acc_ref": 1.0,
"acc_cand": 1.0,
"acc_drop_pp": 0.0
},
"multi_block_9k": {
"n": 2,
"top1_agreement": 1.0,
"top1_flips": 0,
"max_abs_dscore": 0.02951335906982422,
"mean_abs_dscore": 0.02005617693066597,
"mean_kl": 6.540709706121381e-06,
"n_gold": 2,
"nll_ref": 1.387121106483142,
"nll_cand": 1.3792866299819007,
"dnll": -0.00783447650124125,
"mean_abs_row_dnll": 0.00783447650124136,
"acc_ref": 0.5,
"acc_cand": 0.5,
"acc_drop_pp": 0.0
},
"multi_question": {
"n": 10,
"top1_agreement": 1.0,
"top1_flips": 0,
"max_abs_dscore": 0.06343865394592285,
"mean_abs_dscore": 0.018984448437889417,
"mean_kl": 0.00014264548450480086,
"n_gold": 10,
"nll_ref": 0.7606667410227165,
"nll_cand": 0.7742217565907421,
"dnll": 0.01355501556802563,
"mean_abs_row_dnll": 0.016602018627922027,
"acc_ref": 0.7,
"acc_cand": 0.7,
"acc_drop_pp": 0.0
},
"prefix_boundary": {
"n": 7,
"top1_agreement": 1.0,
"top1_flips": 0,
"max_abs_dscore": 0.07407116889953613,
"mean_abs_dscore": 0.02506211300690969,
"mean_kl": 0.000275167227242767,
"n_gold": 7,
"nll_ref": 0.9445710499909146,
"nll_cand": 0.9592024225354618,
"dnll": 0.014631372544547272,
"mean_abs_row_dnll": 0.026803385065686018,
"acc_ref": 0.5714285714285714,
"acc_cand": 0.5714285714285714,
"acc_drop_pp": 0.0
},
"qtype_choice": {
"n": 1,
"top1_agreement": 1.0,
"top1_flips": 0,
"max_abs_dscore": 0.039629340171813965,
"mean_abs_dscore": 0.01868373155593872,
"mean_kl": 9.758721027128357e-05,
"n_gold": 1,
"nll_ref": 1.2471588298811915,
"nll_cand": 1.2644290223938441,
"dnll": 0.017270192512652605,
"mean_abs_row_dnll": 0.017270192512652605,
"acc_ref": 0.0,
"acc_cand": 0.0,
"acc_drop_pp": 0.0
},
"qtype_noul": {
"n": 1,
"top1_agreement": 1.0,
"top1_flips": 0,
"max_abs_dscore": 0.04642695188522339,
"mean_abs_dscore": 0.02744242548942566,
"mean_kl": 0.00046207429765575576,
"n_gold": 1,
"nll_ref": 0.3643240477162341,
"nll_cand": 0.3445434412562239,
"dnll": -0.01978060646001023,
"mean_abs_row_dnll": 0.01978060646001023,
"acc_ref": 1.0,
"acc_cand": 1.0,
"acc_drop_pp": 0.0
},
"qtype_score": {
"n": 1,
"top1_agreement": 1.0,
"top1_flips": 0,
"max_abs_dscore": 0.04161477088928223,
"mean_abs_dscore": 0.015557724237442016,
"mean_kl": 1.4547309373278143e-05,
"n_gold": 1,
"nll_ref": 0.9393375234945696,
"nll_cand": 0.9372245712212975,
"dnll": -0.0021129522732720174,
"mean_abs_row_dnll": 0.0021129522732720174,
"acc_ref": 0.0,
"acc_cand": 0.0,
"acc_drop_pp": 0.0
},
"short_sb": {
"n": 6,
"top1_agreement": 1.0,
"top1_flips": 0,
"max_abs_dscore": 0.12482678890228271,
"mean_abs_dscore": 0.01820988009964663,
"mean_kl": 0.0005014431591724873,
"n_gold": 6,
"nll_ref": 0.11428482960768895,
"nll_cand": 0.123207743102961,
"dnll": 0.00892291349527205,
"mean_abs_row_dnll": 0.008996485578208901,
"acc_ref": 1.0,
"acc_cand": 1.0,
"acc_drop_pp": 0.0
}
},
"gates": {
"coverage_finite_tokens": {
"pass": true,
"problems": {},
"reference_missing_requests": 0
},
"top1": {
"threshold": 0.98,
"value": 1.0,
"pass": true
},
"dnll": {
"threshold": 0.02,
"value": 0.01638063705636561,
"pass": true
},
"acc_drop_pp": {
"threshold": 0.3,
"value": 0.0,
"resolution_pp": 2.3255813953488373,
"pass": null,
"note": "UNRESOLVED: 43 gold questions -> one flip = 2.33pp > 0.3pp; this fixture cannot resolve the gate (use the gate fixture with >= 334 rows; statistical power needs far more)"
}
},
"verdict": "INCONCLUSIVE",
"resolution_pp_per_flip": 2.3255813953488373,
"note": "small fixtures cannot resolve 0.3pp accuracy gates; accuracy on a parity fixture is only indicative (synthetic long rows carry the base row's gold label).",
"ref": "runs/macjev/runtime_v2_dev/reference_trained/ref_block_fp32.jsonl",
"cand": "runs/macjev/release_2b/parity/pred_mlx_affine8-g64_base.jsonl",
"fixture": "runs/macjev/runtime_v2_dev/reference_base/fixture.jsonl"
}