Datasets:
id stringlengths 20 20 | title stringclasses 1
value | text stringlengths 116 6.16k |
|---|---|---|
0009637481ad811ea317 | NATO has allowed many members a free ride on U.S. military capability. The little ‘burden sharing’ that is going on can’t hide the fact that the main contributor is the U.S. and that especially the EU-members have not been investing enough in their own military capability. This has led to NATO becoming, in the words of... | |
0010347553fd8bb49187 | science general universe house would colonize moon It is impossibly expensive and lacks the kind of popular support required to get the 1969 mission of the ground
To make the kind of funding this project would require available, massive public and political will would be needed. This simply doesn’t exist.
The Cold Wa... | |
001df08c37757d74990b | global science censorship ip internet digital freedoms intellectual ACTA is needed to protect brands
There is a genuine value to a brand – in part because, for clothing companies for example, it is a mark of quality as much as it is of origin. However even if that were not the case, the brand identity of a company is ... | |
00213bce322a5a0099a3 | warpeace digital freedoms intellectual property house would use targeted How do we determine what is proportionate? If some valuable intellectual property, such as part of the designs for the US's latest fighter jet the F35, which were hacked in 2009. [1] Then what can be the response to this? Can it simply be the cost... | |
0029713085da65614fe1 | y political philosophy politics leadership house believes move left good labour A shift to the left means labour is no longer a party of government
A shift to the left means that Labour is no longer a real contender for government. This is not only bad for Labour but bad for the country as a whole. Voters need to have... | |
002bc5775854cf35051a | free know house supports decision state bavaria publish mein kampf Money for blood.
If Mein Kampf were presented by a contemporary writer to a contemporary publisher, nobody would go near it; simply because nobody would buy it. There is virtually no market for books of its kind, of which it is a poor example, and even... | |
002c6372ed2f0bda40ad | rnational middle east law human rights international law punishment politics defence Impunity
In addition to events mentioned in the introduction, Sharon was accused of, along with troops under his command, execution-style killings of 49 Egyptian civilians taken prisoner by the IDF in the Saini peninsula in 1956 [1] -... | |
00496e87e0e967e22ab3 | africa global house would reserve permanent unsc seat veto power african Proportionality
When looking at contributions to the UN, in 2010 no African countries are in the Top 27. [1] Those who fund an organisation deserve to lead it and have their opinion count the most. Of course, there is the need for a democratic co... | |
004fb6641764efda4ca6 | osophy life religion family house would allow parents genetically screen Modern society discriminates itself against the principles of individuals choosing self-determination and parental rights when it comes to the opposite case. There are high double standards when for example a couple chooses that their child should... | |
005a40376e3a056869d2 | Who will write and edit the work?
You can’t take the end result out of the system and assume all the rest of it will continue as usual. Journal articles don’t write themselves; there will still be costs for editors, typesetters, reviewing etc., as well as the time and cost of the writer. The average cost of publishing... | |
00619488fe082346c828 | primary secondary teaching house would ban homework Homework has a lot of educational value, the reason it has not shown this is because teachers do not set the right kind of homework or they set the wrong amount of it. Some teachers believe homework is for reviewing material, others think it is better for learning new... | |
0062142e81aea477566a | law general punishment politics government house would grant politicians immunity Seeing a politician put on trial hurts the integrity of their office.
It does tremendous damage to the public perception of a given political position to see the holder of that position on trial for criminal acts. Politicians are importa... | |
0067b859258566e39c80 | law general society gender house would legalise prostitution Prohibition does more harm than good
Criminalizing the acts of selling and buying sexual services does not protect those who sell or buy such services, but rather pushes these activities underground. While market exchanges of sexual services involve some ris... | |
006aba4e9be242895bf4 | To argue that the ends justify the means does not justify research upon animals. Firstly we do not know the extent to which animals are capable of holding interests or experiencing suffering, as they are unable to communicate with us. Our shared similarities give us cause to believe they must have at least a truncated ... | |
0079e873592593e66808 | y general international africa defence warpeace minorities house believes Ethno-religious divides are a bigger security threat
Poverty is clearly an immense problem for Africa but it is not primarily a security problem. There are parts of the globe such as South Asia and parts of South East Asia that have comparable p... | |
0079f8077b0342450775 | climate energy pollution house would cease exploitation arctic region Creating jobs and opportunities
The areas covered are among the least developed in the world. Standards of education and income for indigenous peoples are very low and, to date, there has been little to motivate any nation to do anything about that.... | |
007b0fff862f19b4c751 | economic policy eurozone crisis house believes uk would be better economically Britain can have free trade without all the baggage of political decisions being made in Brussels. Just as the EU accounts for a high portion of UK trade so the UK is a high proportion of EU trade; around 16% of EU exports go to the UK, [1] ... | |
008792dd7816406490f2 | africa law international law house believes icc biased against africa Africa has invited ICC intervention
Far from the ICC being biased against Africa it is Africa’s embrace of the ICC and the opportunity for international justice that has led to so many Africans being tried at the Hague. The reality is that the only ... | |
009acc6316ea5836e01a | ic policy economy general international americas house supports creation Protectionism cannot create a healthy national industry. Only by competing openly against each other on the global market, companies become truly efficient and effective. And small, local companies and industries can often have the advantage in su... | |
00a294c7acc733388dc2 | Investment is needed: but by who?
Housing is required, however, a crucial component within the debate is who needs to provide funding and be involved in decision making; does it need to be the government? The consequences of investment are influenced by the actors involved. With the need for quality control adamant, g... | |
00b0123802b4080a4bd3 | eurozone crisis economy general international europe house believes european While it might be true that some of these benefits are a consequence of the political union, all of these can be maintained in other forms. This is particularly evident by the fact that non-EU countries such as Switzerland and Iceland particip... | |
00bd4e615ce039fb8fe5 | onal europe politics voting house would vote stay eu after camerons deal 0 While it is quite correct that the UK should not have to be signed up to taking part in a European super-state the renegotiation does not represent a big leap forward. With its’ opt outs that are not time limited the UK was already not further i... | |
00c318ca1c3629f9556c | ation university law law general society minorities house would censor hate speech The need for interaction is all the more reason to ensure that all ideas are in the marketplace. This way, the veracity of all ideas are questioned. For example, if someone brings bigoted ideas with them as a freshman, perhaps because th... | |
00cac6015040ebf90e49 | healthcare genetics family house would ban human cloning Cloning is unsafe
The technology is unsafe. The nuclear transfer technique that produced Dolly required 277 embryos, from which only one healthy and viable sheep was produced. [1] The other foetuses were hideously deformed and either died or were aborted. Even t... | |
00d134c8f66d930e9cda | ic policy environment environment general international africa house would Several points require countering. Firstly, the focus on the brain drain suggests air travel will continue to be dominated by an elite class, however, open-skies acts to enable a broader customer base. Secondly, migration brings a range of benef... | |
00d3293d088f28ab686d | general free speech debate internet freedom science computers phones It is unfair for people to suffer for silly past mistakes
People make silly mistakes, especially when they are young. The age from which you can join Facebook is 13 and pretty much anyone can post videos to Youtube, run a blog or post comments. It is... | |
00d9b20389ed8979cc44 | education general house believes parents should be held responsible their One way to deal with this argument is by noting that this would be one tool in a school’s arsenal. If it proves to be obviously counterproductive, then it will not be employed, in the same way that other disciplinary tactics schools/society can i... | |
00e738bde39778310aea | rnational global law human rights society immigration minorities house would Repatriation is a more direct solution to the problem, and it is not sure whether these alternatives would work. Tougher border controls will only result in immigrants finding better ways to avoid them; improving economical conditions in poor ... | |
00e7dea578655dbe177f | gender youth house believes age consent laws should be made more liberal lowered The principle reason some countries have higher ages of consent for males compared to females [1] is simply because of the medical evidence that males reach sexual maturity at a later age than females. [2] This has nothing to do with discr... | |
00e83efb2ea11b8e3192 | ic policy economy general international europe philosophy political Neo-functionalism explains the cause of integration
Spill-over is the following concept – in order to enjoy the full benefits of integration of the first sector you need to integrate the related sectors. An example of this is the ECSC (European Coal a... | |
00f75324f85fc5cf76b7 | health general healthcare politics government house believes united states Mandatory health insurance is analogous to constitutional mandates
Federal mandates are a cornerstone of the American legal system and the everyday life of every American. As Ohio Attorney General Richard Cordray and Iowa's attorney general Tom... | |
010fe30dc1bbc152538c | ure education education general law law general house would hold students legally Bullys are frequently as disturbed and victimised as those they target
According to studies, bullies are often children who are plagued by their own problems: a troubled family situation, feeling of inadequacy, depression, or pressure to... | |
0117eecb9a475906251d | europe house believes european union should adopt single working language Politics touches on emotional issues. Emotional issues specific to a country are best expressed by that country in their native language. If the EU Member States must communicate through a foreign language, this means there is a barrier between a... | |
011aab8860d2d0ef70de | philosophy political philosophy house would remove bush tax cuts wealthy There are a number of social ties that the rich have to the U.S.A. with many of them having inherited wealth or having families in the U.S.
Moving to another country is inconvenient as it leads to the removal of all of these social ties, further ... | |
0129f178dddce4997a17 | While countries like Australia are going to be hit by Climate Change they at least have the resources to carry out adaptation on their own. Poor countries don’t have the money so there will not be any adaptation. The result will be more natural disasters and deaths through disease both things that are seen as worthy of... | |
012b41ad9088a0773a03 | nothing sacred house believes blasphemy has no place statute books This is the truly the argument of rogues. Where a mob seeks to gather to deliver their own brand of very immediate justice would be against the law and should be dealt with as such. For governments to argue such an approach is a complete abdication of r... | |
013f1ee6145e5a53f9bf | intellectual property house would cut length copyright protection Control of an artistic work and its interaction in the public sphere is the just province of the creator and his or her designated successors
The creator of a piece of copyrighted material has brought forth a novel concept and product of the human mind.... | |
0142e818b2238f9560f1 | global house believes world government Although the problems of resource depletion and environmental deterioration are indeed serious global problems, it is unreasonably optimistic and idealistic to believe that a world government, in and of itself, would be an effective instrument toward the reduction of these problem... | |
0158d45322c72c88f44b | economic policy international africa society gender family immigration house Land titles provide a voice in the legal system.
Land titles mean women will be recognised as citizens, with rights. Women will be included in the system of justice and their rights to occupy, build, and use, land, recognised. Titles will pro... | |
015dd4b9c6f01d5550d1 | africa politics terrorism warpeace house believes france right intervene If terrorism is the concern then the French intervening is one of the worst possible options. Having France fighting in Mali may well result in the internationalization of the conflict bringing in jihadists. [1] Already the islamists are saying th... | |
016fc351c5cb8b091000 | economic policy international americas house believes nafta has benefitted all NAFTA has interfered with Canadian laws concerning environmental protection.
Under NAFTA, if foreign investors believe they are being harmed by regulations, they may sue for reparations under special tribunals1. Canada regulates commercial ... | |
017d34e1dd70d5bac87a | europe politics defence government house would create single european union NATO has established a precedent for multilateral military action
NATO has been crucial to maintaining the balance of power during the cold war. Although there have been some arguments amongst its member states, NATO has shown us that a standi... | |
0187da5479ea610e5a23 | ional americas society immigration house believes mexico us border fence Safety arguments are a red herring; terrorism will not be effectively prevented by the erection of the border fence. We need a proactive strategy that gathers intelligence and works with counterterrorism officials abroad to disrupt recruitment and... | |
01882840df2aca96c883 | The foreign aid budget can be made more effective and transparent
While a second Obama administration is not going to cut back on foreign aid the Obama campaign however, does argue for pragmatic budgetary approaches to foreign aid, [1] creating transparency measures [2] to ensure that “assistance [is] more transparent... | |
0188af78824193ade9b5 | team sports house would introduce restrictions overseas players football The youngsters from poor nations who excel in Europe do so because of their move, not irrespective of it. It is a fallacy to suggest that all players develop in a vacuum, that their ability is irrespective of their development opportunities. For t... | |
018a6cc6416c846c6654 | finance economy general international politics politics general house prefers Trade does not allocate resources effectively
Aid allows for money in a given country to be allocated well against need. At the micro- level as well as the macro, trade is an inefficient distributor of resources in a developing country. Unde... | |
018aec9fcdd9ef50a80b | africa terrorism house welcomes us help fighting terrorist organisations Increased global security
The presence of US military equipment and counter-terrorism forces in Africa will result in greater security for the rest of the world. Many of the terrorist groups which have existed in the ‘ungoverned’ spaces of Africa... | |
019612e365322dad62a9 | onal europe politics defence house would extend nato membership georgia and It is far from the settled will of the Georgian and Ukrainian peoples that they wish to join NATO. Georgia’s President Saakashvili did wish to join, but after his disastrous attempt to regain control of South Ossetia was unable to bring his cou... | |
019ad2d84e62c45051cd | economic policy international africa society gender family immigration house Land titles are not affordable to poor women
The cost of obtaining land titles is higher than the benefits sought. Research has shown that although there is a desire, by women, to obtain land titles the reality is land titles remain unafforda... | |
019e24953f9d83e2ab4a | This will limit the control of the rich over key scarce resources
Some resources –most notably housing – are very important to large numbers of people, and owning them gives people a great deal of happiness. This policy will limit richer people owning several properties while others live in rented accommodation or sma... | |
01b0d4a7e54825a17c2b | economic policy finance tax house would prioritise eliminating budget deficit Nobody is going to risk financial instability in the US by calling in the principle sum on the loans that it has taken out
There really is no problem with the Federal Government running at a deficit virtually permanently – as it has for most... | |
01b1cbcb337bb01e8fc0 | conomy general politics politics general government house would give obama The reality is fairly simple; Obama is a skilled politician, that is beyond dispute. However, he is also a respected constitutional scholar, the man who caught Bin Laden after eight years of Bush-bluster, who delivered the Democrats – and the Am... | |
01b74bcdf5a485937cae | primary secondary teaching poetry should not be taught schools junior Poetry is too difficult for school students
There are people who dedicate their lives to studying poetry and still have trouble understanding its meaning. If these people constantly debate the nature of poetry how can school children be expected to ... | |
01b7624ccd763a3714b2 | ucation education general law law general house would hold students legally The law should always punish actions that inflict serious harm - whether physical or psychological
Bullying can inflict serious psychological harm on its victims, especially in the case of young people. It leads to low self-esteem, depression,... | |
01c3d22a74a231be33be | freedom expression house would use foreign aid funds research and Far from being a violation of sovereignty it should be considered that the internet is a global commons that needs to be defended against the encroachment of sovereignty. As Hillary Clinton has argued “The internet has become the public space of the 21st... | |
01e07e98783fb4e9037b | on education general health sex sexuality house would promote safe sex through True, but nor does it make sense to make the classes mandatory once the child reaches an age where it is legally able to decide whether it wants to partake of them. Nor does this mean that these classes need to be promoting safe sex rather t... | |
01ee5779b3265c13b21f | y political philosophy politics leadership house believes move left good labour “I'm fed up with the Punch and Judy politics of Westminster, the name calling, backbiting, point scoring, finger pointing.” Not Jeremy Corbyn, David Cameron in 2005 when he became opposition leader. [1] Every new opposition party leader sta... | |
020b21413bf11b64c552 | global law human rights international law house believes united nations has Blanket commitment creates a slippery slope of when to intervene.
A blanket commitment could lead the United Nations and the word into great dangers. It must be considered whether intervention with force is always practical. For example, in th... | |
020ff429bdfb2f96ac99 | europe politics local government voting house would allow referendum Catalan independence would lead to further break up of the Spanish state
The issue of Catalan independence does not just affect Catalonia but the whole of Spain. All the regions of Spain have strong regional identities and Catalan is merely most wide... | |
021f9349f72436d70507 | e policing law general punishment society youth house would scrap anti social No system is perfect
Of course, some ASBOs fail. But no aspect of the justice system has a 100% success rate, and by their nature ASBOs are more likely to be abused because (unlike prison) the offender remains in his own environment. Should ... | |
0221ea8dfea0d88f1e8e | global politics government leadership house would throw russia out g8 But Russia, as with any country – particularly any powerful country – is interested in symbolism and international prestige. Many analysts suggest that Putin’s takeover of Crimea may be about revenge for having ‘lost’ Ukraine, or out of a desire to s... | |
0221fa1cd33d133553bc | addiction disease health general politics house would further restrict smoking Restrictions benefit the health of third parties
This argument is built on the premise that a ban or higher taxation in practice will lead to less smokers, especially protecting the families of smokers and other non-smoking citizens from po... | |
022496b21d77dc0b54f2 | crime policing law general house would arm police The police should be equipped to react to contemporary social problems
The old-fashioned notions of friendly neighborhood unarmed policing reflect the aspirations of a different age. As armed violence has increased sharply in parts of the developed world, the police ne... | |
022ea30e5d4f51d9a4e4 | americas law crime policing house believes united states responsible U.S. policies have helped create the cartels
A change in US immigration law in 1996 meant that non-citizens and foreign born citizens sentenced to more than a year in jail are deported. This moved the problem from the USA’s cities to cities in Centra... | |
02340099624ead366692 | business economy general house would prohibit retailers selling certain items If retailers need to unload an item, it is totally within their rights to do that, as long as they don't use that item to trick consumers into buying more expensive items. Selling off goods at a low price, when not planned, would also not har... | |
023a802632aa100cc202 | Providing the choice to donate at expense of one’s life will simply increase the pressure on those who do not wish to donate as they now are presented with a much bigger burden when their loved one dies as they could lawfully have prevented it. Moreover the person who is receiving the donation would also have that sens... | |
024dd0b5a29d72dc4655 | americas middle east house believes nato countries and government The Taliban are not the only regime in the world to have sheltered terrorists – Syria, Iran, Iraq, Cuba and North Korea are all viewed by the USA’s State Department as state sponsors of terrorism. Indeed, although the Taliban provide shelter for terroris... | |
02561c38b63ab427d5f0 | americas global house believes united states benign hegemon The US used its power to establish a set of open global institutions which have been broadly beneficial.
As Robert Cox argues, American hegemony has been successful because the US has been able to maintain its dominance through a high level of global consensu... | |
025707ce4108e8a6da54 | middle east human rights international law society immigration minorities The inalienable rights of refugees are not negotiable, nor are they subject to the interests of the state which they would be returning to. International law considers agreements between an occupier and the occupied to be null and void if they de... | |
0259a034433103d78272 | onal middle east law human rights international law punishment politics defence If Sharon is tried then many others would have to be as well
While many of the actions of Sharon were unacceptable, he is not the only person who committed horrible acts: not just only in the Israeli-Palestinian conflicts, but across the w... | |
025a1de53470da2d7f83 | The VDP is providing a number a solution to the lack of human resources within Zambia’s health sector. VDP is enabling the growth of local jobs, for Zambian nationals. Although there are no current figures to estimate the amount of jobs that will be provided within the health sector, the VDP has currently been rolled o... | |
0276db5ca905410bd0ab | onal africa middle east politics defence government terrorism warpeace house Factionalism is too strong
Since the 1970s, Arab state governments have become especially corrupt and oppressive, and have failed to provide essential social services on a consistent basis. Over the past forty years, people in the region have... | |
027f0bc41365e5ec7636 | Government has a role in establishing what is an acceptable level of behaviour within society. Full in the knowledge that some people will use any substance responsibly and others less so, governments make decisions to protect their citizens and to show a lead. It is the settled will of most people in most countries th... | |
0295f0b52ce1a4d75234 | defence house would replace trident The cost of replacing trident is prohibitive
Britain is in the longest recession it has ever been in – longer even than the great depression of the 1930s – with the economy not having recovered to pre-recession levels four years after the start of the downturn. [1] This is obviously... | |
0299beb73048ab389551 | The opposition present us with a false dichotomy here. It is not true that we have to make a choice between saving lives and protecting cultural property. The hypothetical situation where a site of high cultural and historical value would have to be destroyed in order to provide famine relief or prevent genocide seems ... | |
02a078318e8936efb52c | The marketplace of ideas
The truth can only emerge from competition between various ideas in free, transparent discourse. To silence any idea is to remove ideas from the marketplace thus reducing the individual’s ability to use his/her reason and intellect to arrive at a conclusion. [1] Silencing ideas also creates se... | |
02a192372bc58ed46415 | human rights punishment philosophy ethics life house believes capital punishment Capital punishment is a comparatively small issue
Whatever the merits, capital punishment in Africa is a small issue. Capital punishment opponents should focus on China, which uses capital punishment in a secretive manner for all variety ... | |
02a285bfbab4301fdc49 | education general secondary house would raise school leaving age 18 Raising the school-leaving age is a crucial investment in society's future
Doing so increases the economic potential of the future workforce, and so will bring increased tax revenues in the long term to more than cover any initial costs. Although some... | |
02a9921c931f8384ae7a | Buying time only helps the terrorists. It gives them time to arm themselves and gain allies abroad so enabling a more deadly series of attacks later on. Terrorist groups usually only have a very finite number of resources so the state should seek to press the terrorist group until it has nothing left to fall back on. I... | |
02b40fb7dda832a21651 | health general weight society youth tthw prohibit sale childrens toys part fast This is not exactly a ban on the sale of fast food to children. This ban does not affect the options of bad foods that parents can continue to feed to their young children if they choose to do so. They will even be able to continue buying h... | |
02b997097891480c62fe | asia politics defence house would ignore north korean provocations Rounds of sanctions and engagement does not bring a solution any closer
The responses to North Korean provocations do not bring a solution any closer. North Korea has yet to sign a peace treaty with the South and the United States. It is however partic... | |
02bfb334da03b921bcd2 | life society family house would never have children Having children has a devastating effect on lives of parents
Parenting effectively prevents people from pursuing their own interests and fulfilling their own goals. The child becomes the center and the only valid part of parents’ lives. By having kids, people turn fr... | |
02c75bb6e0e3689984f7 | education general teaching youth house supports home schooling Home schooling involves good community involvement and social interaction.
Homeschooling families do not operate in isolation. There are extensive support networks (particularly in the USA the nation with the largest proportion of the population homeschool... | |
02cc9afa8d54a17cd7bd | gender family house believes homosexuals should be able adopt Gay people have the right to a family life.
Getting married and raising a family is considered in most societies one of the most important and fulfilling experiences one can aspire to. It is so important it is considered a human right (Article 8 of the Euro... | |
02d26aa7f1e7db2687f9 | A world government would be ineffective in practice
From the early 1990s, at about the time of the collapse and dissolution of the Soviet Union, there has developed an immense literature on global governance in the post-Cold War era. It is agreed by many if not most international relations authorities that the existin... | |
02dde9cf73f3099949ca | pollution weight society house would drive out town shopping centre Out of town retail developments actually reduce effective competition because smaller urban outlets are not able to compete with them on price. In the United States for example, Wal-Mart pays workers the bare minimum and imports goods produced for a lo... | |
02e308554f930bacdd8d | It doesn’t solve the problem of protecting countries outside of Europe from losing players
In practice this plan will do nothing for football in countries outside Europe. Already many overseas players have dual nationality (which is especially easy to obtain for South American players wanting to play in Spain or Portu... | |
02eb014a7770cb35a9f0 | finance health healthcare politics house would introduce system universal Universal healthcare systems are inefficient
One of the countries lauded for its universal health care is France. So what has the introduction of universal coverage brought the French? Costs and waiting lists.
France’s system of single-payer he... | |
02ed7e738245feac6ad5 | primary secondary teaching university house believes history has no place The teaching of history does not either to the maintenance of memory or the learning of lessons. Examples have shown that states can use history lessons to in fact erase certain memories, denying any lessons to future generations. Furthermore, te... | |
02f29ececf874c3c4439 | africa law international law house believes icc biased against africa One of strongest current criticisms of the African Union is that the ICC is ignoring its opinions. In particular, the AU has very strong views on the treatment of the Kenyan President and his deputy by the ICC in the Kenyan investigation, which the I... | |
02f3d8c9b3f2e6420fb0 | onal africa politics politics general government leadership house believes mo Recognition when credit is due
The past few years have seen African governments, and heads of state, reluctant to leave office; driving political coups; and leading violent crimes against humanity. Mugabe, Kabila, and Kenyatta are but a few ... | |
02f667c9818b572c0673 | employment house believes unemployed should be made work their welfare money Workfare will damage the existing labour market
Workfare harms those already in employment but on very low pay, because their menial jobs are the kind of labour that workfare projects will provide. Why should a local authority pay people to p... | |
03048adb2bfc97e18f20 | africa europe house believes cape verdes regional future lies europe not While Cape Verde may have a history and culture that is closer to Europe than all other African states this does not mean it does not have an African culture. There are of course many African states all with their own histories, culture and indepe... | |
0309d5329358d7900afd | Armed police already exist in a number of situations and a rise in mistaken shootings that the opposition fear is not evident in these areas. | |
030bb1506ba2150f85ef | e policing law general punishment society youth house would scrap anti social The wackier examples of ASBOs are actually demonstrations of what the order can do and other laws cannot. The woman who has an ASBO restraining her from jumping into rivers shows that the order can help with the thorny problem of actions that... | |
0312fff8e9f945127884 | europe politics leadership house believes uk would have more influence The UK needs to be part of a block to remain relevant
History is moving towards bigger and bigger blocks being relevant. The US and USSR dwarfed the previous global power the UK [1] and China and India look set too be bigger again. In a world where... | |
0313c283eb356a7a6ec7 | africa law human rights international law house would create african Drugs trafficking was considered as a role for the ICC, but rejected as unworkable – an ACC would face the same problems. “Unconstitutonal change of government” would be open to rampant political abuse, allowing existing governments to cling on to pow... | |
03188b4efad09c82023c | punishment house supports death penalty worst worst By keeping a person locked up for life, which may well be appropriate for the “worst of the worst”, they are incapacitated for life. It similarly satisfied any retributive instinct, providing a total punishment, a form of internal banishment and total civil death – if... | |
031fd005215a37cc719b | economic policy international africa government house would put taxesrevenue oil Oil wealth flowing to politicians discourages democracy
The wealth from oil, or other natural resources, holds back democratization as a result of the “resources curse” or “paradox of plenty”. Resources provide money, and money is what is... | |
0327c18d0fc2caae249b | culture general media modern culture television house believes reality television Reality TV does not discourage hard work or education, rather it creates a society whereby we have shared experiences and a strong sense of community. As such, reality TV provides an important social glue. Once upon a time there were only... |
RLHN ArguAna — Training, unified schema
The arguana subset of rlhn/rlhn-680K (RLHN: the BGE retrieval training collection with its false hard negatives relabelled by a GPT-4o-mini → GPT-4o cascade; Thakur et al., 2025), reshaped into the strict schema shared by every dataset in this collection.
| Source | rlhn/rlhn-680K @ d5323fad7aea, subset arguana |
| Task | argument → counter-argument |
| Domain · languages | argument · eng |
| Queries / documents / qrels | 2,508 / 7,713 / 3,155 |
| Qrels per query | min 1 · mean 1.26 · max 4 |
| Score values | 2 ×3,155 (2: RLHN's original positive, 1: a hard negative RLHN relabelled as relevant) |
| Layout | queries · corpus · qrels · hard-negatives · teacher-scores, split train |
| Splits | corpus: train · hard-negatives: train · qrels: train · queries: train · teacher-scores: train |
| Hard negatives | sources: dataset, dense · 290,374 rows |
| Teacher scores | none yet (0 rows): jinaai/jina-reranker-v3.5 scores come next |
| Ids | sha1(text)[:20]; identical texts collapse to one document / query |
| License | cc-by-sa-4.0 |
Schema
| config | columns | rules |
|---|---|---|
queries |
id: string, text: string |
ids unique and non-empty; every query has ≥ 1 qrel |
corpus |
id: string, title: string, text: string |
title is always present ("" when the source has none) |
qrels |
query-id: string, corpus-id: string, score: int32 |
referential integrity to both tables; no duplicate pairs; no floats |
hard-negatives |
query-id: string, corpus-id: string, rank: int32, source: string |
one row per negative; (query-id, corpus-id, source) unique; never a labelled positive of the same query |
teacher-scores |
query-id: string, corpus-id: string, teacher: string, score: float32 |
one row per scored pair (positives included); a row means scored — never a placeholder |
Files are Parquet, sorted by id, zstd-compressed, sharded at 500 MB. Every rule above is checked before publishing; provenance.json records the source revision, what changed, and the output file hashes. teacher-scores holds no rows yet; datasets cannot return a 0-example split, so read that file with pyarrow / pandas until it is filled.
What changed from the source
- subset: the rows of
rlhn/rlhn-680Kwhosesubsetisarguana(ArguAna in the BGE training collection) - positives: each query's positive passages; RLHN's original positive at grade 2, the hard negatives its LLM cascade relabelled as relevant at grade 1
- negatives: RLHN's remaining hard negatives in RLHN's order (
rank1, 2, …),source=dataset - decontaminated (exact queries): 370 queries whose normalised text equals an evaluation query (the 23 test sets and the 6 dev sets) were removed
- decontaminated (overlap audit): 304 passages that equal or nearly copy an evaluation document some evaluation query judges relevant, and 303 queries that nearly copy an evaluation query (word 13-grams for passages, 8-grams for queries; at least half shared with one evaluation text) were removed, and with them 317 queries in total; near copies of evaluation-corpus documents that no evaluation query judges relevant were kept
- text: leading and trailing whitespace stripped
- ids re-keyed to
sha1(text)[:20]: 0 documents and 870 queries collapsed into identical texts - not published: the order scores the local conversion uses in place of teacher scores (RLHN has no teacher)
Hard negatives and teacher scores
Filled by the collection's annotation pipeline (annotation=jina35). Interim: the candidates are final, the teacher scores are still to come.
- Candidates: dense retrieval with
jinaai/jina-embeddings-v5-text-smallover this corpus to depth 1,000; 100 candidates per query drawn from the rank windows 1–30 (30), 31–100 (30), 101–300 (20), 301–1000 (20), the query's labelled positives excluded.rankis the dense rank;sourceisdensefor a mined row anddatasetfor a negative the source labels itself. - Teacher scores: none yet.
teacher-scoresholds 0 rows until thejinaai/jina-reranker-v3.5scores (listwise, as in the other repositories) are filled in;datasetscannot return a 0-example split, so read that file withpyarrow/pandasmeanwhile. The candidates stay.
| configs | queries | hard negatives | teacher scores |
|---|---|---|---|
hard-negatives · teacher-scores |
2,508 (all) | 290,374 (42,633 dataset, 247,741 dense) | 0 |
Load it
from datasets import load_dataset
queries = load_dataset("Hyukkyu/train-rlhn-arguana", "queries", split="train")
corpus = load_dataset("Hyukkyu/train-rlhn-arguana", "corpus", split="train")
qrels = load_dataset("Hyukkyu/train-rlhn-arguana", "qrels", split="train")
negatives = load_dataset("Hyukkyu/train-rlhn-arguana", "hard-negatives", split="train")
License and attribution
RLHN is released under CC BY-SA 4.0, and so is this copy (share-alike). The underlying ArguAna data carries its own terms. All credit belongs to the original authors; see rlhn/rlhn-680K. This repository is an independent repackaging. Please cite RLHN:
@misc{thakur2025relabel,
title={Fixing Data That Hurts Performance: Cascading LLMs to Relabel Hard Negatives for Robust Information Retrieval},
author={Nandan Thakur and Crystina Zhang and Xueguang Ma and Jimmy Lin},
year={2025},
eprint={2505.16967},
archivePrefix={arXiv},
primaryClass={cs.IR},
url={https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.16967},
}
- Downloads last month
- -