tokedo commited on
Commit
e7e78b3
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 240f5ca

README: add Run report section — full report migrated from the site run page (run pages became compact cards). Pure insertion; data files and citable tags untouched.

Browse files
Files changed (1) hide show
  1. README.md +87 -0
README.md CHANGED
@@ -72,6 +72,93 @@ gemini spent six days stuck pre-registration, then registered,
72
  completed three quests, and bought a level-31 kami 90 minutes before
73
  the wall.
74
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
75
  ## Layout
76
 
77
  ```
 
72
  completed three quests, and bought a level-31 kami 90 minutes before
73
  the wall.
74
 
75
+ ## Run report
76
+
77
+ The run's full report, migrated here from the site's run page on
78
+ 2026-07-29 when run pages became compact cards
79
+ ([kamibench.ai/experiments/001-budget-boxed](https://kamibench.ai/experiments/001-budget-boxed));
80
+ every number is frozen as originally published.
81
+
82
+ ### What happened
83
+
84
+ The three arms diverged sharply. Haiku completed the entire onboarding
85
+ chain on day one — registered, funded its operator, bought two kamis,
86
+ finished five quests — and exhausted its budget in 17 hours.
87
+ GPT-4o-mini ran the full week and never once called
88
+ `register_account`: 166 sessions, all 24 of its game transactions
89
+ reverted, zero quests. Gemini spent six days stuck pre-registration,
90
+ was unblocked by a single legible validation error, then completed
91
+ three quests and bought a level-31 kami 90 minutes before the wall.
92
+ Cost per quest: haiku $2.15, gemini $3.00, gpt-4o-mini ∞.
93
+
94
+ ### Milestones
95
+
96
+ First success per onboarding/economy milestone, against cumulative
97
+ inference. These rows are the frozen baseline that stack iterations
98
+ ([Run 2](https://kamibench.ai/experiments/002-stack-delta) onward)
99
+ are compared against at fixed milestones.
100
+
101
+ | milestone | haiku-4.5 | gpt-4o-mini | gemini-2.5-flash-lite |
102
+ |---|---|---|---|
103
+ | bridge ETH mainnet→Yominet landed | 07-10 23:10 · h1.4 · s2 · 0.14M tok · $0.14 | 07-12 04:45 · h31.0 · s32 · 10.33M tok · $1.56 | 07-11 03:35 · h5.8 · s6 · 0.62M tok · $0.06 |
104
+ | operator wallet funded | 07-10 23:30 · h1.7 · s4 · 0.65M tok · $0.67 | 07-12 22:40 · h48.9 · s49 · 17.58M tok · $2.65 | 07-11 15:30 · h17.7 · s17 · 5.84M tok · $0.59 |
105
+ | account registered in game | 07-10 23:30 · h1.7 · s4 · 0.68M tok · $0.70 | — | 07-16 15:15 · h137.5 · s129 · 62.57M tok · $6.30 |
106
+ | first quest completed | 07-10 23:30 · h1.8 · s4 · 0.87M tok · $0.89 | — | 07-16 15:16 · h137.5 · s129 · 63.01M tok · $6.35 |
107
+ | first kami bought | 07-11 00:35 · h2.8 · s5 · 2.30M tok · $2.34 | — | 07-17 20:30 · h166.7 · s156 · 87.83M tok · $8.84 |
108
+ | first MUSU harvest started | 07-11 01:40 · h3.9 · s6 · 3.14M tok · $3.20 | — | — |
109
+ | first MUSU banked (harvest stop/collect) | 07-11 01:50 · h4.1 · s7 · 3.51M tok · $3.57 | — | — |
110
+
111
+ Cell = first success: UTC time · hours since run start · session
112
+ number · cumulative tokens (in+out) · cumulative USD at that moment;
113
+ "—" = never happened.
114
+
115
+ ### What we learned
116
+
117
+ - **Error legibility, not model capability, was the sharpest
118
+ differentiator.** The same model that ignored opaque chain reverts
119
+ for four days corrected a human-readable validation error in one
120
+ turn.
121
+ - **A single missing step was the cleanest capability
122
+ discriminator.** Two arms completed every onboarding step *except*
123
+ registration, and neither ever identified it as the blocker.
124
+ - **Cost structure dominated spend.** The 84-tool surface re-billed
125
+ on every call dominated token spend, prompt caching was never
126
+ engaged, and un-broken poll loops reached $0.55 per session —
127
+ making repetition detection a budget control, not just hygiene.
128
+ - **Orientation speed and decision quality are different axes.**
129
+ Haiku moved fast and bought level-1 kamis; gemini moved slowly and
130
+ bought a level-31 kami near floor price.
131
+
132
+ Most of what this run taught us was about the stack, not the models —
133
+ which is what a stress test is for.
134
+
135
+ ### What it changed in the stack
136
+
137
+ Each learning above became a concrete change, and the whole bundle
138
+ was pinned and re-measured by the next run:
139
+
140
+ - **Legible pre-transaction validation** — environment interface
141
+ v1.4.0 → v1.5.1. A blocked game action now fails with a factual
142
+ precondition error before any gas is spent, instead of an opaque
143
+ on-chain revert. Directly from the legibility finding and the
144
+ registration blocker.
145
+ - **A repetition breaker** — scaffold v0.2.0. Looping sessions end
146
+ instead of billing; Run 1's un-broken poll loops made repetition
147
+ detection a budget control, not just hygiene.
148
+ - **Session caps and agent-chosen wake scheduling** — scaffold
149
+ v0.2.0. Bounded session cost, and pacing left to the agent as an
150
+ explicit, logged choice.
151
+ - **Cache-aware budget accounting** — scaffold v0.2.0. Prompt caching
152
+ engaged and priced into the budget math, against Run 1's uncached
153
+ 84-tool re-billing.
154
+
155
+ [Run 2 (Experiment 002)](https://kamibench.ai/experiments/002-stack-delta)
156
+ re-ran this exact protocol with the same three models and the same
157
+ $10 on that stack. Measured against the frozen rows above, the
158
+ changes cut chain revert rates from 0.58 / 0.97 / 0.94 to
159
+ 0.048 / 0.000 / 0.011, got all three arms registered in-game, and
160
+ lifted quests at fixed budget (haiku 5→8, gemini 3→5).
161
+
162
  ## Layout
163
 
164
  ```