matter-embryogenesis / baseline_v1 /SOURCE_AUDIT.md
PureOne's picture
Release Matter Embryogenesis v3.0.0: theory, code, data and audit
52fc221 verified
|
Raw History Blame
3.33 kB

Source and novelty audit

Search date: 19 September 2026. The review is targeted and non-exhaustive; it cannot establish research or patent priority. The manuscript distinguishes new derivation from established ingredients. No third-party full papers are bundled.

Reference Evidence accessed Use and limit
Soloveichik & Winfree, shape complexity Primary arXiv abstract and bibliographic record, arXiv:cs/0412096 Establishes prior connection to Kolmogorov complexity; not a new claim here
Doty et al., intrinsic universality Primary arXiv abstract and record, arXiv:1111.3097 Prior universal tile system and distributed genome language
Winfree & Bekbolatov, proofreading Publisher chapter page and abstract, DOI 10.1007/978-3-540-24628-2_13 Prior error-correction construction; no copied proof
Woods et al., molecular algorithms Publisher abstract, metadata, reference list; author-repository result 355 tile species, 21 selected algorithms, reported aggregate tile error; not a universal error parameter
Gomez et al., active tile universality Primary arXiv abstract and proceedings record, arXiv:2407.11545 Formal universality and approximate formal state count
Holmes-Cerfon & Wyart, hierarchy Primary arXiv abstract and rendered manuscript, arXiv:2501.02611 Hierarchical interaction design predates this report
Benoist & Sartori, assembly factors Primary APS abstract and dated publication metadata Recent adjacent kinetic principle; full-paper novelty comparison not completed
Michelson et al., inorganic frameworks (2024) Author-laboratory hosted first page/abstract and publication record Restricted material conversion precedent; not arbitrary chemistry
Michelson et al., devices (2025) Primary publication metadata and authors' laboratory research highlight Framework photocurrent and conversion precedent; publisher full text failed and PMC was blocked by a browser check
Teng et al., patterning (2025) Primary publisher article, abstract, and methods context Large-area externally patterned assembly, not seed-only arbitrary structures
Nguyen & Vaikuntanathan, nonequilibrium assembly Primary publisher PDF text and bibliographic record Thermodynamic precedent; publisher HTML redirected to a cookie page

All bibliographic URLs and titles appear in the manuscript. The inaccessible full texts are not represented as fully reviewed. General probability, conservation, and diffusion derivations were performed explicitly in this report. Their standard mathematical ingredients are not claimed as new.

Novelty boundary

Candidate original contribution: the specific reliability-access co-design window and its finite optimal exponent under redundant-volume-dependent depletion. This is an original derivation within this document, with priority unverified. The key novelty question for expert review is whether equivalent coupled reliability/transport/conversion bounds already exist in algorithmic assembly, reliable distributed systems, reaction-network design, or manufacturing-process optimization.

No new DNA motif, nanoparticle synthesis, working inorganic repair mechanism, molecular compiler, universal manufacturing phase transition, or successful general-purpose device platform is claimed.