studia_bas: licence version resolved to CC BY 3.0 PL (evidence + tests, no data change)

artifacts/source_findings.md

@@ -2136,3 +2136,37 @@ day and the 0 GFDL-era documents are unchanged.
 so 13,565 were not checked; two further pages stay in the release with the source's direction
 unresolved (`wikivoyage_2477`, `wikivoyage_989`); E1 (v2#56); the 6 boundary documents; the
 markup residue.
+
+## `studia_bas`: licence version resolved to CC BY 3.0 PL
+
+**Investigated:** 2026-10-06
+**Verdict:** no data change; 112 documents stay CC BY 3.0 PL, no per-row version label. The
+resolution is recorded in `data/studia_bas/studia_bas.license-evidence.json`
+(`version_resolution`) and pinned by `src/test_studia_bas_contract.py`. Tracks the 2026-10
+rights audit action "check live site manually (CAPTCHA); resolve 3.0 vs 4.0".
+
+### Verified
+
+- The journal's own pages say CC BY 3.0 PL: seven Wayback captures (2021-07-11 to 2024-09-08,
+  open-access page and author instructions, PL and EN) and the three live pages on
+  2026-10-06. The cutoff is issue 2(66)/2021 wherever one is stated, which is where the data
+  starts. The newest issue listed live is 2(82)2025, the last one in the data.
+- Plain GET requests with an identifying User-Agent returned the live pages, not the
+  human-verification page, so nothing was answered or bypassed. Archived captures from
+  2025-11-15 on are the verification page, and it may come back.
+- DOAJ is the only source that says 4.0 (journal-level `license.url`, record updated
+  2026-09-17). Its own `copyright.url` and `oa_statement` point at the journal pages above.
+  Crossref holds no licence deposit for any of the 246 works.
+- Live PL author-instructions paragraph now names "Studia i Ekspertyzy Sejmowe" and drops the
+  "Od numeru 2(66) 2021" cutoff (2022-2024 captures have both). It still says CC BY 3.0 PL.
+
+### Not established
+
+- The notice inside each PDF (the fetcher's gate and the evidence file's PDF quotes) was not
+  re-read: that needs the 17 issue PDFs (51,701,823 bytes) from orka.sejm.gov.pl.
+- The journal's wording between 2024-09-08 and 2026-10-06 (no readable capture). By the
+  four-a-year numbering, issues 80-82 (11 rows) fall in that window.
+- CEJSH and BazHum: guessed record URLs returned 404.
+
+**Lesson:** the audit found the live site behind a verification page, yet a plain read-only
+GET returned it on 2026-10-06. Retry that before routing a check to a human.

data/studia_bas/studia_bas.license-evidence.json

@@ -167,5 +167,192 @@
       "bytes": 2359571,
       "sha256": "40426dad520e291370a8172b4da4275789f3fc91587fc306fe6580c9bd6fcf3e"
     }
-  ]
+  ],
+  "version_resolution": {
+    "checked_at": "2026-10-06",
+    "question": "The registry and every row say CC BY 3.0 PL; the DOAJ record of the journal lists CC BY 4.0 (rights audit 2026-10, action \"resolve 3.0 vs 4.0\"). Which version applies?",
+    "conclusion": "CC BY 3.0 PL for all 112 rows. Every statement by the publisher that could be read names 3.0 PL: seven archived captures from 2021-07-11 to 2024-09-08 and three live pages on 2026-10-06, in Polish and English, with the cutoff at issue 2(66)/2021 wherever a cutoff is stated. The newest issue listed is 2(82)2025, the last issue in the data, so the live statement covers every row. Nothing shows a version change between issues, so no per-row version label is needed. DOAJ is the only source that says 4.0.",
+    "method": "Read-only. Wayback Machine replays (id_ form, bodies hashed after HTTP content decoding) of the journal's open-access page (seria=4) and author-instructions page (view=5), found with the CDX API. No Save Page Now request, no CAPTCHA was answered, the live site was not opened.",
+    "journal_statements_readable": [
+      {
+        "wayback_timestamp": "20210711180906",
+        "original_url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?seria=4&lang=EN",
+        "replay_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20210711180906id_/https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?seria=4&lang=EN",
+        "language": "EN",
+        "sha256": "1abd908a3f563f72fc500782c4fe052e854b85140a3b6d71988e11f71a78757f",
+        "bytes": 11917,
+        "quoted": [
+          "Starting from No. 2(66)2021, “Studia BAS” journal is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License (CC-BY 3.0 PL)"
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "wayback_timestamp": "20220609055923",
+        "original_url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=PL",
+        "replay_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20220609055923id_/https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=PL",
+        "language": "PL",
+        "sha256": "1fe1b1ce6477a0ac537a2afb36d8df8c9728dbac9fa5b6fd593398daee990088",
+        "bytes": 141752,
+        "quoted": [
+          "Od numeru 2(66) 2021 r. jego zawartość jest udostępniana na wolnej licencji CC BY 3.0 PL"
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "wayback_timestamp": "20220624130722",
+        "original_url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=EN",
+        "replay_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20220624130722id_/https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=EN",
+        "language": "EN",
+        "sha256": "6782ba019e0a450b8e218c896a2b2393bf33e4e1d11626e70ff384d49520ce70",
+        "bytes": 140453,
+        "quoted": [
+          "Starting from No. 2(66)2021 it is is licensed under the CC BY 3.0 PL license."
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "wayback_timestamp": "20230627164626",
+        "original_url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=PL",
+        "replay_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20230627164626id_/https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=PL",
+        "language": "PL",
+        "sha256": "96b5b2da652e10d0c99a6bc21be1a5360e2a016854d12b9553d80031c057c0b7",
+        "bytes": 142169,
+        "quoted": [
+          "wyraża zgodę, aby Kancelaria Sejmu udostępniała dzieło na licencji Creative Commons-Uznanie autorstwa 3.0 PL (CC-BY 3.0 PL)",
+          "Od numeru 2(66) 2021 jego zawartość jest udostępniana na wolnej licencji CC BY 3.0 PL"
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "wayback_timestamp": "20240528160016",
+        "original_url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?seria=4&lang=EN",
+        "replay_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20240528160016id_/https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?seria=4&lang=EN",
+        "language": "EN",
+        "sha256": "92fce3023ee92ee871867deb772086f0cb27138668257ab06648b4225940fce5",
+        "bytes": 18983,
+        "quoted": [
+          "Starting from No. 2(66)2021, “Studia BAS” is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Poland License (CC-BY 3.0 PL)"
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "wayback_timestamp": "20240528160037",
+        "original_url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=PL",
+        "replay_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20240528160037id_/https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=PL",
+        "language": "PL",
+        "sha256": "80ca3a0739330df5656f5938452bb3672d435fc2216064adf9316a99070c2a7c",
+        "bytes": 161993,
+        "quoted": [
+          "wyraża zgodę, aby Kancelaria Sejmu udostępniała dzieło na licencji Creative Commons-Uznanie autorstwa 3.0 PL (CC-BY 3.0 PL)",
+          "Od numeru 2(66) 2021 jego zawartość jest udostępniana na wolnej licencji CC BY 3.0 PL"
+        ]
+      },
+      {
+        "wayback_timestamp": "20240908064157",
+        "original_url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=EN",
+        "replay_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20240908064157id_/https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=EN",
+        "language": "EN",
+        "sha256": "ab6d39c4767a25a5f1ff96c483f7118f448450ba807ad3acd62b30030a2959ee",
+        "bytes": 161161,
+        "quoted": [
+          "The author consents that the Chancellery of Sejm makes the work available under the Creative Commons-Attribution 3.0 PL license (CC-BY 3.0 PL)",
+          "Starting from No. 2(66)2021 it is is licensed under the CC BY 3.0 PL license."
+        ]
+      }
+    ],
+    "journal_statements_live": {
+      "note": "Plain GET requests with an identifying User-Agent, three pages, one request each. The server returned the pages, not the human-verification page; nothing was answered or bypassed. The hash is of that one response (the pages carry a per-session id, so a later fetch hashes differently).",
+      "pages": [
+        {
+          "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T00:37Z",
+          "url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?seria=4&lang=EN",
+          "language": "EN",
+          "sha256": "4b41bad432e25cd4257c301f670cb1fd0ddb8c899fde3727a7f80f800085e1d9",
+          "bytes": 15723,
+          "quoted": [
+            "Starting from No. 2(66)2021, “Studia BAS” is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Poland License (CC-BY 3.0 PL)",
+            "2(82)2025 Michał Bernardelli Social and economic security from a national and European perspective: Vol. II"
+          ]
+        },
+        {
+          "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T00:38Z",
+          "url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=EN",
+          "language": "EN",
+          "sha256": "ca66dc3a29d580e1493361849d819a6ae6572ee6e12ff8c2e962671a30a5d502",
+          "bytes": 156433,
+          "quoted": [
+            "The author consents that the Chancellery of Sejm makes the work available under the Creative Commons-Attribution 3.0 PL license (CC-BY 3.0 PL)",
+            "Starting from No. 2(66)2021 it is is licensed under the CC BY 3.0 PL license."
+          ]
+        },
+        {
+          "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T00:38Z",
+          "url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=PL",
+          "language": "PL",
+          "sha256": "0844f2e0c7258d5fc9fa1026696bd61fd816b35f90e5bfc67936cb4d54850c34",
+          "bytes": 157566,
+          "quoted": [
+            "wyraża zgodę, aby Kancelaria Sejmu udostępniała dzieło na licencji Creative Commons-Uznanie autorstwa 3.0 PL (CC-BY 3.0 PL)",
+            "Jego zawartość jest udostępniana na wolnej licencji CC BY 3.0 PL"
+          ],
+          "note": "This paragraph now names „Studia i Ekspertyzy Sejmowe\" instead of Studia BAS and no longer carries the \"Od numeru 2(66) 2021\" cutoff that the 2022-2024 captures have. It still says CC BY 3.0 PL. The English pages keep the cutoff."
+        }
+      ],
+      "latest_issue_listed": "2(82)2025"
+    },
+    "journal_statements_blocked": {
+      "note": "These archived captures are a human-verification page, not the journal page. The earliest is 2025-11-15. The archive therefore holds no readable copy after 2024-09-08; the live pages above close that gap for 2026-10-06. The human-verification page can come back for other clients or request rates.",
+      "captures": [
+        {
+          "wayback_timestamp": "20251115205852",
+          "original_url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=EN",
+          "sha256": "859d6b7afe79f28de547d6f78fdab25a89838bfe74eea3c2fc526a6c0e95ea31",
+          "content": "bot-check page (\"Please enable JavaScript to view the page content\", image-code question); no licence text"
+        },
+        {
+          "wayback_timestamp": "20260521121416",
+          "original_url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=PL",
+          "sha256": "f432fa108cfc2d0cfc74b46bf851abafdeb46a1e2955bb0d1c6ed1b4b79c3c90",
+          "content": "bot-check page (\"Please enable JavaScript to view the page content\", image-code question); no licence text"
+        },
+        {
+          "wayback_timestamp": "20260613175157",
+          "original_url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?seria=4&lang=EN",
+          "sha256": "8fcbeab130ee046b8702e6b5521224909d22eb1c327ecf435e6d0f2bb7eac976",
+          "content": "bot-check page (\"Please enable JavaScript to view the page content\", image-code question); no licence text"
+        },
+        {
+          "wayback_timestamp": "20260613181517",
+          "original_url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=EN",
+          "sha256": "6c40fc462fcc8376c67986b34fabe28a5fae00931ec3f845001dc4c0d6a873f8",
+          "content": "bot-check page (\"Please enable JavaScript to view the page content\", image-code question); no licence text"
+        }
+      ]
+    },
+    "contrary_evidence": {
+      "doaj": {
+        "api_url": "https://doaj.org/api/v2/search/journals/issn:2082-0658",
+        "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T00:21:47Z",
+        "record_last_updated": "2026-09-17T10:49:01Z",
+        "license": {
+          "type": "CC BY",
+          "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"
+        },
+        "copyright_url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?view=5&seria=4&lang=EN",
+        "oa_statement_url": "https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/Journal.nsf/pubBAS.xsp?seria=4&lang=EN",
+        "license_display": [
+          "Embed"
+        ],
+        "license_display_example_url": "https://orka.sejm.gov.pl/WydBAS.nsf/0/41A8433B5FEED18DC125889500283EE2/$file/1.Skrzetuska.pdf",
+        "reading": "Journal-level field. The record's own copyright and OA-statement links point at the two journal pages whose archived copies above say 3.0 PL. The PDF at license_display_example_url was not downloaded, so what its licence line says is not checked."
+      }
+    },
+    "no_licence_deposit": {
+      "crossref_journal_url": "https://api.crossref.org/journals/2082-0658",
+      "crossref_works_url": "https://api.crossref.org/journals/2082-0658/works?rows=1000&select=DOI,license",
+      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06",
+      "works": 246,
+      "works_with_license_deposit": 0
+    },
+    "not_established": [
+      "No readable capture exists between 2024-09-08 and 2026-10-06, so the journal's wording in that window is unknown. Only the PDF notices of issues 80-82 (4/2024 to 2/2025 by the four-a-year numbering) would show a change in it; they were not re-read.",
+      "The PDF notices (pdf_issue_editorial_notice, pdf_article_license_notice above) were not re-read: they would need a download of the issue PDFs (17 files, 51,701,823 bytes) from orka.sejm.gov.pl.",
+      "CEJSH and BazHum: guessed record URLs returned 404, no record was located."
+    ]
+  }
 }

src/test_studia_bas_contract.py

@@ -636,3 +636,85 @@ def test_remove_terminal_bibliography_variants():
         remove_terminal_bibliography(text_appendix4)
         == "wstęp\n\nZałącznik 1. Transpozycja\n\nTreść"
     )
+
+
+# --- licence version: 3.0 PL (journal) against 4.0 (DOAJ), rights audit 2026-10 ---
+
+ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[1]
+STUDIA_BAS_DATA = ROOT / "data" / "studia_bas"
+SHA256_RE = re.compile(r"[0-9a-f]{64}")
+
+
+def _version_resolution():
+    evidence = json.loads((STUDIA_BAS_DATA / "studia_bas.license-evidence.json").read_text(encoding="utf-8"))
+    return evidence, evidence["version_resolution"]
+
+
+def _attribution():
+    path = STUDIA_BAS_DATA / "studia_bas.attribution.jsonl"
+    return [json.loads(line) for line in path.read_text(encoding="utf-8").splitlines() if line]
+
+
+def test_every_row_and_the_registry_carry_the_one_version_the_journal_states():
+    import pyarrow.parquet as pq
+    from sources import SOURCES
+
+    evidence, _ = _version_resolution()
+    rows = pq.read_table(STUDIA_BAS_DATA / "studia_bas.parquet", columns=["license"]).column("license").to_pylist()
+    attribution = _attribution()
+    assert len(rows) == len(attribution) == 112
+    assert {evidence["license_spdx"], SOURCES[SOURCE]["license"], SOURCES[SOURCE]["license_spdx"], LICENSE} == {"CC-BY-3.0-PL"}
+    assert set(rows) == {a["license"] for a in attribution} == {"CC-BY-3.0-PL"}
+    assert {a["license_url"] for a in attribution} == {CC_BY_URL} and "/by/3.0/pl/" in CC_BY_URL
+
+
+def test_archived_and_live_journal_statements_all_say_3_0_pl_and_never_4_0():
+    _, resolution = _version_resolution()
+    archived = resolution["journal_statements_readable"]
+    live = resolution["journal_statements_live"]["pages"]
+    assert len(archived) >= 7 and len(live) == 3
+    stamps = [c["wayback_timestamp"] for c in archived]
+    assert stamps == sorted(stamps) and stamps[0] >= "20210711" and stamps[-1] <= "20240908999999"
+    assert {c["language"] for c in archived} == {c["language"] for c in live} == {"PL", "EN"}
+    for capture in archived:
+        assert capture["replay_url"] == f"https://web.archive.org/web/{capture['wayback_timestamp']}id_/{capture['original_url']}"
+        assert capture["original_url"].startswith("https://studiabas.sejm.gov.pl/")
+    for statement in archived + live:
+        assert SHA256_RE.fullmatch(statement["sha256"]) and statement["bytes"] > 0
+        assert statement["quoted"]
+    # the live root page also quotes its issue list; only the licence sentences are held to 3.0 PL
+    licence_quotes = [q for s in archived + live for q in s["quoted"] if re.search(r"CC[ -]BY|Creative Commons", q)]
+    assert len(licence_quotes) >= 15
+    assert all(re.search(r"3\.0 (PL|Poland)", q) and "4.0" not in q for q in licence_quotes)
+
+
+def test_cutoff_and_latest_issue_agree_with_the_rows():
+    evidence, resolution = _version_resolution()
+    issues = {int(a["issue"]) for a in _attribution()}
+    assert min(issues) == evidence["scope_and_cutoff"]["cutoff_issue"] == 66
+    live = resolution["journal_statements_live"]
+    match = re.fullmatch(r"\d\((\d+)\)\d{4}", live["latest_issue_listed"])
+    assert match and int(match.group(1)) == max(issues) == 82
+    # every English statement that states a cutoff states the issue the data starts at
+    cutoff_quotes = [q for s in resolution["journal_statements_readable"] + live["pages"] for q in s["quoted"] if "Starting from No." in q]
+    assert cutoff_quotes and all("2(66)2021" in q for q in cutoff_quotes)
+
+
+def test_bot_check_captures_hold_no_licence_text_and_postdate_the_readable_ones():
+    _, resolution = _version_resolution()
+    blocked = resolution["journal_statements_blocked"]["captures"]
+    last_readable = resolution["journal_statements_readable"][-1]["wayback_timestamp"]
+    assert blocked and all(c["wayback_timestamp"] > last_readable and "no licence text" in c["content"] for c in blocked)
+    assert all(SHA256_RE.fullmatch(c["sha256"]) for c in blocked)
+
+
+def test_the_doaj_4_0_is_recorded_as_the_only_dissent_with_what_was_not_checked():
+    _, resolution = _version_resolution()
+    doaj = resolution["contrary_evidence"]["doaj"]
+    assert doaj["license"]["url"] == "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"
+    assert doaj["copyright_url"].endswith("view=5&seria=4&lang=EN")
+    assert "DOAJ is the only source that says 4.0" in resolution["conclusion"]
+    assert resolution["no_licence_deposit"]["works_with_license_deposit"] == 0
+    # the open points stay visible: the PDF notices were not re-read and CEJSH/BazHum were not located
+    open_points = " ".join(resolution["not_established"])
+    assert "not re-read" in open_points and "CEJSH" in open_points