{
  "instance_id": "bin_packing_large_s42",
  "problem_type": "bin_packing",
  "size": "large",
  "winner": "cp_sat",
  "oracle_solver": "cp_sat",
  "selector_accuracy": true,
  "par10_score": 0.175,
  "oracle_regret": 0.0,
  "results": [
    {
      "solver_id": "cp_sat",
      "solver_config": {
        "time_limit_sec": 10.0,
        "num_search_workers": 4,
        "presolve": true,
        "search_branching": "automatic",
        "heuristic_frequency": 0.5
      },
      "instance_id": "bin_packing_large_s42",
      "problem_type": "bin_packing",
      "metrics": {
        "runtime_sec": 0.488,
        "optimality_gap_pct": 0.0,
        "feasible": true,
        "time_to_first_feasible_sec": 0.1708,
        "best_bound": 9.0,
        "gap_improvement_rate": 0.15,
        "search_speed": 147.54,
        "objective_value": 9.0,
        "status": "OPTIMAL",
        "memory_mb": 0.18,
        "nodes": 0
      },
      "solution": {}
    },
    {
      "solver_id": "highs",
      "solver_config": {
        "time_limit_sec": 10.0,
        "presolve": "on",
        "threads": 4,
        "mip_rel_gap": 0.01,
        "cut_strategy": "automatic"
      },
      "instance_id": "bin_packing_large_s42",
      "problem_type": "bin_packing",
      "metrics": {
        "runtime_sec": 0.1217,
        "optimality_gap_pct": 2.58,
        "feasible": true,
        "time_to_first_feasible_sec": 0.0319,
        "best_bound": 8.8839,
        "gap_improvement_rate": 0.212,
        "search_speed": 591.6,
        "objective_value": 9.072,
        "status": "FEASIBLE",
        "memory_mb": 12.14,
        "nodes": 203
      },
      "solution": {}
    },
    {
      "solver_id": "cbc",
      "solver_config": {
        "time_limit_sec": 10.0,
        "presolve": "on",
        "cuts": "on",
        "heuristics": "on",
        "threads": 2
      },
      "instance_id": "bin_packing_large_s42",
      "problem_type": "bin_packing",
      "metrics": {
        "runtime_sec": 0.1428,
        "optimality_gap_pct": 2.58,
        "feasible": true,
        "time_to_first_feasible_sec": 0.0374,
        "best_bound": 8.8839,
        "gap_improvement_rate": 0.1807,
        "search_speed": 504.2,
        "objective_value": 9.072,
        "status": "FEASIBLE",
        "memory_mb": 12.14,
        "nodes": 203
      },
      "solution": {}
    },
    {
      "solver_id": "scip",
      "solver_config": {
        "time_limit_sec": 10.0,
        "presolving": true,
        "separating": true,
        "heuristics": true,
        "threads": 4
      },
      "instance_id": "bin_packing_large_s42",
      "problem_type": "bin_packing",
      "metrics": {
        "runtime_sec": 0.1306,
        "optimality_gap_pct": 2.66,
        "feasible": true,
        "time_to_first_feasible_sec": 0.0345,
        "best_bound": 8.8803,
        "gap_improvement_rate": 0.2037,
        "search_speed": 551.26,
        "objective_value": 9.072,
        "status": "FEASIBLE",
        "memory_mb": 12.14,
        "nodes": 200
      },
      "solution": {}
    },
    {
      "solver_id": "glpk",
      "solver_config": {
        "time_limit_sec": 10.0,
        "presolve": true,
        "mip_gap": 0.02
      },
      "instance_id": "bin_packing_large_s42",
      "problem_type": "bin_packing",
      "metrics": {
        "runtime_sec": 0.1648,
        "optimality_gap_pct": 3.86,
        "feasible": true,
        "time_to_first_feasible_sec": 0.0484,
        "best_bound": 8.8263,
        "gap_improvement_rate": 0.2343,
        "search_speed": 436.97,
        "objective_value": 9.072,
        "status": "FEASIBLE",
        "memory_mb": 12.14,
        "nodes": 168
      },
      "solution": {}
    },
    {
      "solver_id": "gurobi",
      "solver_config": {
        "time_limit_sec": 10.0,
        "Presolve": 2,
        "MIPFocus": 1,
        "Heuristics": 0.25,
        "Threads": 4
      },
      "instance_id": "bin_packing_large_s42",
      "problem_type": "bin_packing",
      "metrics": {
        "runtime_sec": 0.1127,
        "optimality_gap_pct": 2.34,
        "feasible": true,
        "time_to_first_feasible_sec": 0.0289,
        "best_bound": 8.8947,
        "gap_improvement_rate": 0.2076,
        "search_speed": 638.66,
        "objective_value": 9.072,
        "status": "FEASIBLE",
        "memory_mb": 12.14,
        "nodes": 209
      },
      "solution": {}
    },
    {
      "solver_id": "minizinc",
      "solver_config": {
        "time_limit_sec": 10.0,
        "solver": "chuffed",
        "neighborhood_size": 16
      },
      "instance_id": "bin_packing_large_s42",
      "problem_type": "bin_packing",
      "metrics": {
        "runtime_sec": 0.1373,
        "optimality_gap_pct": 2.5,
        "feasible": true,
        "time_to_first_feasible_sec": 0.0357,
        "best_bound": 8.8875,
        "gap_improvement_rate": 0.1821,
        "search_speed": 524.37,
        "objective_value": 9.072,
        "status": "FEASIBLE",
        "memory_mb": 12.14,
        "nodes": 205
      },
      "solution": {}
    },
    {
      "solver_id": "alns",
      "solver_config": {
        "time_limit_sec": 10.0,
        "neighborhood_size": 24,
        "destroy_pct": 0.3,
        "initial_solution": "greedy"
      },
      "instance_id": "bin_packing_large_s42",
      "problem_type": "bin_packing",
      "metrics": {
        "runtime_sec": 0.102,
        "optimality_gap_pct": 3.38,
        "feasible": true,
        "time_to_first_feasible_sec": 0.0288,
        "best_bound": 8.8479,
        "gap_improvement_rate": 0.3314,
        "search_speed": 705.88,
        "objective_value": 9.072,
        "status": "FEASIBLE",
        "memory_mb": 12.14,
        "nodes": 181
      },
      "solution": {}
    }
  ],
  "instance_features": {
    "general": {
      "n_variables": 72,
      "n_constraints": 36,
      "pct_binary": 1.0,
      "pct_integer": 1.0,
      "sparsity": 0.05,
      "coefficient_range": 100,
      "constraint_tightness": 0.224
    },
    "graph": {
      "graph_density": 0.0,
      "clustering_coefficient": 0.0,
      "avg_degree": 0.0,
      "connected_components": 36,
      "treewidth_approx": 1.0
    },
    "problem": {
      "n_machines": 0,
      "n_jobs": 36,
      "capacity_utilization": 1.1087,
      "customer_clustering": 0.0,
      "demand_variance": 0.0,
      "time_window_tightness": 0.0
    }
  }
}