{
  "instance_id": "lastmile_small_s456",
  "strategies": {
    "routefinder": {
      "final_metrics": {
        "total_distance": 2864.05,
        "total_lateness_min": 24165.45,
        "total_objective": 196187.65,
        "reoptimization_count": 145,
        "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.07
      },
      "stability_metrics": {
        "schedule_stability_score": 0.8476,
        "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.07,
        "reoptimization_count": 145,
        "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083,
        "driver_disruption_index": 1.085
      },
      "n_steps": 145
    },
    "rolling_horizon": {
      "final_metrics": {
        "total_distance": 2953.73,
        "total_lateness_min": 24154.82,
        "total_objective": 196200.85,
        "reoptimization_count": 145,
        "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.423
      },
      "stability_metrics": {
        "schedule_stability_score": 0.8405,
        "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.423,
        "reoptimization_count": 145,
        "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083,
        "driver_disruption_index": 6.564
      },
      "n_steps": 145
    },
    "alns": {
      "final_metrics": {
        "total_distance": 2866.98,
        "total_lateness_min": 24560.36,
        "total_objective": 199349.86,
        "reoptimization_count": 145,
        "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.608
      },
      "stability_metrics": {
        "schedule_stability_score": 0.8368,
        "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.608,
        "reoptimization_count": 145,
        "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083,
        "driver_disruption_index": 9.421
      },
      "n_steps": 145
    },
    "monte_carlo": {
      "final_metrics": {
        "total_distance": 2822.56,
        "total_lateness_min": 23936.77,
        "total_objective": 194316.72,
        "reoptimization_count": 145,
        "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.102
      },
      "stability_metrics": {
        "schedule_stability_score": 0.8469,
        "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.102,
        "reoptimization_count": 145,
        "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083,
        "driver_disruption_index": 1.588
      },
      "n_steps": 145
    },
    "scenario_tree": {
      "final_metrics": {
        "total_distance": 2722.11,
        "total_lateness_min": 23898.54,
        "total_objective": 193910.43,
        "reoptimization_count": 145,
        "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.086
      },
      "stability_metrics": {
        "schedule_stability_score": 0.8472,
        "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.086,
        "reoptimization_count": 145,
        "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083,
        "driver_disruption_index": 1.333
      },
      "n_steps": 145
    },
    "ortools": {
      "final_metrics": {
        "total_distance": 2746.84,
        "total_lateness_min": 20630.6,
        "total_objective": 167791.62,
        "reoptimization_count": 145,
        "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.195
      },
      "stability_metrics": {
        "schedule_stability_score": 0.8451,
        "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.195,
        "reoptimization_count": 145,
        "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083,
        "driver_disruption_index": 3.02
      },
      "n_steps": 145
    },
    "reinforcement_learning": {
      "final_metrics": {
        "total_distance": 2913.46,
        "total_lateness_min": 24270.34,
        "total_objective": 197076.18,
        "reoptimization_count": 145,
        "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.031
      },
      "stability_metrics": {
        "schedule_stability_score": 0.8483,
        "avg_route_change_penalty": 0.031,
        "reoptimization_count": 145,
        "reopt_rate_per_hour": 12.083,
        "driver_disruption_index": 0.48
      },
      "n_steps": 145
    }
  },
  "ranking": [
    "ortools",
    "scenario_tree",
    "monte_carlo",
    "routefinder",
    "rolling_horizon",
    "reinforcement_learning",
    "alns"
  ],
  "winner": "ortools"
}