text: This is so old and tired as an argument it can simply be cut and pasted by all trads in all their comments about renewal.  It ignores the fact that the Church always has and always will change.  Growth, revelation, knowledge, theology, and human insight into the divine all push the Church (all too slowly) to a different place in many ways and by many means.  All you have written here, I'm afraid, constitutes part of the ash heap of Church history and is of use to really no one.  To accuse those who work for a renewal of the Faith as you have done is more the work of division that you, apparently, even realize.  I firmly believe that it is the orthodox conservatives that have created the division and the chasm that haunt our Church.  History has proven me right, if you care to explore it.