| # Evidence Contract |
|
|
| This project is intentionally audit-first. Every visible claim should point to a |
| local artifact that a reader can inspect before trusting the dashboard. |
|
|
| | Claim | Current evidence | Status | Boundary | |
| | --- | --- | --- | --- | |
| | A first-pass reviewer has a compact current-state scorecard. | `REVIEWER_SCORECARD.md`, `docs/data/reviewer_scorecard.json` | Verified guide | Summarizes existing evidence and boundaries; it does not add new experimental claims | |
| | The public dataset description is aligned with the official gated Xperience-10M dataset card and public sample card. | `XPERIENCE10M_DATASET_CARD_ALIGNMENT.md`, `docs/data/xperience10m_dataset_card_alignment.json` | Verified description alignment | Summarizes upstream public metadata, API listing facts, sample license/tooling, and card facts; does not grant access or mirror raw data | |
| | Source facts and boundary markers are validated across repo, website, and HF cards. | `SOURCE_ALIGNMENT_AUDIT.md`, `docs/data/source_alignment_audit.json`, `scripts/validate_source_alignment.py` | Verified source audit | Offline committed-fact audit; does not fetch private gated data | |
| | Public figures are indexed as reviewer evidence. | `FIGURE_INDEX.md`, `docs/data/figure_index.json`, `scripts/build_figure_index.py` | Verified visual evidence | Derived figures and thumbnails only; does not include raw MP4/HDF5/RRD data | |
| | The project logo is consistently packaged across public surfaces. | `docs/data/brand_assets.json`, `docs/assets/brand/`, `scripts/build_brand_assets.py` | Verified brand packaging | Generated presentation assets only; does not contain raw Xperience-10M data or model weights | |
| | The public Xperience-10M sample has been converted into aligned model windows. | `results/episode_task_suite/windows.csv`, `results/episode_task_suite/shared_windows.npz`, `results/episode_task_suite/summary_report.json` | Verified for 5,821 frames and 1,161 windows | One public sample episode only | |
| | The current feature contract is explicit and reviewable. | `results/episode_task_suite/feature_manifest.json`, `results/episode_task_suite/available_modalities.json` | Verified for an 8,378-d feature vector | Audio is present in MP4 streams but not yet a feature block | |
| | The task evaluation protocol is explicit and generated from committed metrics. | `EVALUATION_PROTOCOL.md`, `docs/data/evaluation_protocol.json`, `scripts/build_evaluation_protocol.py` | Verified protocol | Defines windows, split, per-task metrics, leakage controls, and unsupported interpretations; does not prove cross-episode quality | |
| | The public sample modalities are inspectable without raw data redistribution. | `docs/data/modality_atlas.json`, `docs/assets/modalities/`, website modality atlas | Verified derived thumbnail atlas | Thumbnails are presentation/review assets, not a replacement for official raw data access | |
| | Public task cards stay readable for non-expert reviewers. | `docs/data/task_surface_integrity.json`, `scripts/validate_task_surface.py`, website task cards/player | Verified task-surface gate | Presentation integrity only; it does not add model quality or new data | |
| | The 12 task heads are real scripts and artifacts, not presentation placeholders. | `scripts/episode_task_suite.py`, `results/episode_task_suite/*/metrics.json`, `results/episode_task_suite/*/predictions.*` | Verified for all 12 task definitions | Chronological single-episode split, not cross-episode generalization | |
| | Minimal and neural heads use the same task contracts. | `scripts/neural_task_models.py`, `results/episode_task_suite/neural_mlp/`, `docs/assets/task_architectures.png` | Verified for 12 minimal heads and 12 neural MLP heads | Small heads only; not a foundation model | |
| | Four Ropedia research directions are mapped honestly as direct, proxy, or diagnostic evidence. | `results/episode_task_suite/research_directions/research_direction_taxonomy.json`, `docs/data/research_directions.json` | Verified taxonomy | Some directions remain proxy-only | |
| | Four extra direction probes are coded and evaluated. | `results/episode_task_suite/research_direction_extensions/research_direction_extension_results.json`, `docs/data/research_direction_extensions.json` | Verified single-episode probes | Not full human modeling, neural rendering, intent modeling, or world modeling solutions | |
| | Qwen3-Omni infrastructure has passed readiness checks. | `results/omni_finetune/RUN_REPORT.md`, `results/omni_finetune/dataset_manifest.json`, `results/omni_finetune/metrics_eval.json` | Readiness-only evidence | One episode, 128 train windows; not a 32-episode pilot | |
| | The real 32-episode LoRA pilot is blocked on gated data access, not on repo presentation. | `results/omni_finetune/DATA_BLOCKER_REPORT.md`, `results/omni_finetune/MULTI_EPISODE_ACCESS_STATUS.md`, `results/omni_finetune/source_discovery.json` | Blocker documented | No 32-episode metric should be claimed until the gate passes | |
| | Historical `32ep` path strings are not treated as 32-episode results. | `scripts/validate_scope_claims.py`, `docs/data/scope_claims_audit.json` | Verified pass | Classifies old run/path identifiers and fails if public presentation claims real 32-episode metrics | |
| | Prepared GitHub/Hugging Face mirrors carry matching critical files. | `scripts/validate_mirror_parity.py`, `docs/data/mirror_parity.json` | Verified pass | Compares prepared data files, visual assets, website HTML, and validator scripts before upload; live URLs are checked after publishing | |
| | The public GitHub and Hugging Face bundles are publication-clean. | `scripts/validate_publication_package.py`, `docs/data/publication_audit.json` | Verified pass | Checks public files, HF bundles, and public-card freshness; ignored local scratch outputs are excluded | |
| | The public website has checked local references. | `scripts/validate_website_integrity.py`, `docs/data/website_integrity.json` | Verified pass | Checks local links, anchors, JSON data, and referenced images; external URLs are not fetched | |
| | The release gate is explicit and reviewable. | `QUALITY_GATES.md`, `scripts/build_quality_gates.py`, `docs/data/quality_gates.json` | Verified pass | Summarizes packaging and live-mirror checks; it does not prove cross-episode model quality | |
| | The live public mirrors are checked after upload. | `scripts/verify_live_publication.py`, `docs/data/live_publication_status.json` | Verified pass | Fetches public GitHub/HF URLs; it does not validate private training state | |
| | The core proof artifacts are indexed and grouped for fast review. | `ARTIFACT_GUIDE.md`, `scripts/build_artifact_index.py`, `docs/data/artifact_index.json` | Verified guide and index | Selective source-of-truth catalog, not a complete inventory of every output file | |
| | The public reproduction path is documented. | `REPRODUCIBILITY.md`, `docs/data/reproducibility_matrix.json`, `notes/reproducibility_audit.md` | Verified documentation and prior exact-match audit | Publicly reproduces the single-episode pipeline, not the gated 32-episode Qwen3-Omni pilot | |
| | The project is externally citable and machine-readable. | `CITATION.cff`, `codemeta.json`, `docs/data/project_manifest.json`, `LICENSE` | Verified metadata files | Code license does not override original Xperience-10M dataset terms | |
| | A first-time reviewer has an explicit audit path. | `docs/data/reviewer_packet.json`, website reviewer section, README reviewer path | Verified reviewer packet | It guides inspection; it does not add new experimental claims | |
|
|
| ## Review Order |
|
|
| 1. Read `REVIEWER_SCORECARD.md` and `docs/data/reviewer_scorecard.json` for |
| the fastest current-state decision table. |
| 2. Read `docs/data/reviewer_packet.json` for the shortest audit path and proof |
| boundary. |
| 3. Read `XPERIENCE10M_DATASET_CARD_ALIGNMENT.md` and |
| `docs/data/xperience10m_dataset_card_alignment.json` to check the official |
| dataset-card wording and how the current repo is scoped against it. |
| 4. Read `SOURCE_ALIGNMENT_AUDIT.md` and |
| `docs/data/source_alignment_audit.json` to verify the same source facts are |
| present across repo, website, and HF cards. |
| 5. Read `FIGURE_INDEX.md`, `docs/data/figure_index.json`, and |
| `docs/data/brand_assets.json` to verify public figures, charts, modality |
| thumbnails, logo assets, dimensions, hashes, and source scripts. |
| 6. Read `EVALUATION_PROTOCOL.md` and `docs/data/evaluation_protocol.json` to |
| check windowing, split policy, per-task metrics, leakage controls, and |
| unsupported interpretations. |
| 7. Read `ARTIFACT_GUIDE.md` and `docs/data/artifact_index.json` to see grouped |
| reviewer artifacts, indexed proof artifacts, |
| sizes, and stable-file hashes. |
| 8. Read `docs/assets/task_suite_infographic.png` and |
| `docs/data/modality_atlas.json` for the high-level map and modality atlas. |
| 9. Read `REPRODUCIBILITY.md` and `docs/data/reproducibility_matrix.json` before |
| rerunning the public pipeline. |
| 10. Inspect `results/episode_task_suite/summary_report.json` for the task and |
| metric source of truth. |
| 11. Inspect `results/episode_task_suite/feature_manifest.json` to see which |
| modalities enter the current feature vector. |
| 12. Inspect `results/episode_task_suite/neural_mlp/` to compare minimal and |
| neural heads under the same splits. |
| 13. Inspect `docs/data/scope_claims_audit.json` before interpreting historical |
| `32ep` strings in Qwen3-Omni readiness artifacts. |
| 14. Inspect `docs/data/mirror_parity.json` before assuming the GitHub and |
| Hugging Face mirrors contain the same critical data, visual, HTML, and |
| validator files. |
| 15. Inspect `results/omni_finetune/DATA_BLOCKER_REPORT.md` and |
| `results/omni_finetune/MULTI_EPISODE_ACCESS_STATUS.md` before interpreting |
| any Qwen3-Omni artifact. |
| 16. Inspect `QUALITY_GATES.md`, `docs/data/quality_gates.json`, |
| `docs/data/publication_audit.json`, and `docs/data/website_integrity.json` |
| before publishing or sharing the project externally. |
| 17. Inspect `CITATION.cff`, `codemeta.json`, and `LICENSE` before reusing or |
| citing the project. |
|
|
