ropedia-xperience-10m-task-suite-artifacts / docs /data /omni_model_comparison.json
cy0307's picture
Update final Qwen public data
95d41d9 verified
Raw History Blame
21.4 kB
{
"title": "Ropedia Xperience-10M Current Result Versions",
"generated_at_utc": "2026-06-06T23:26:13+00:00",
"status": "pass",
"version_count": 3,
"comparison_rule": "Compare only rows with the same scope and target. Single-episode raw-feature metrics, 128-episode metadata baselines, Qwen3 structured JSON metrics, and Cosmos3 future-window metrics answer different questions.",
"version_reading_notes": [
"Version 1 is the public-sample 12-task harness with minimal and neural heads.",
"Version 2 is the selected 128-episode same-split simple/NN baseline alignment.",
"Version 3 is the verified model-branch layer: the current final Qwen3-Omni LoRA package is the JSON-task diagnostic result, while Cosmos3-Nano is a future-window compatibility result rather than a full Cosmos diffusion fine-tune."
],
"versions": [
{
"id": "v1_single_episode_public_sample",
"title": "Single-Episode Public-Sample Task Suite",
"status": "verified",
"scope": "one public Xperience-10M sample episode",
"source": "results/episode_task_suite/summary_report.json",
"split": "chronological 70/30 within one episode",
"counts": {
"episodes": 1,
"windows": 1161,
"frames": 5821,
"feature_dim": 8546,
"task_count": 12,
"neural_task_count": 12
},
"models": [
"minimal task heads",
"compact neural MLP task heads"
],
"task_metrics": [
{
"task": "caption_grounding",
"task_display_name": "Language Grounding",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "mrr",
"simple_primary_score": 0.016023479050338015,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "mrr",
"neural_primary_score": 0.01684125567132316
},
{
"task": "contact_prediction",
"task_display_name": "Contact State Prediction",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"simple_primary_score": 1.0,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"neural_primary_score": 1.0
},
{
"task": "cross_modal_retrieval",
"task_display_name": "Cross-Modal Retrieval",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "mrr",
"simple_primary_score": 0.26925966892956127,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "mrr",
"neural_primary_score": 0.1299971898648288
},
{
"task": "hand_trajectory_forecast",
"task_display_name": "Hand Trajectory Forecasting",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "mpjpe",
"simple_primary_score": 0.8646570444107056,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "mpjpe",
"neural_primary_score": 0.10785018652677536
},
{
"task": "misalignment_detection",
"task_display_name": "Multimodal Synchronization Detection",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "f1",
"simple_primary_score": 0.5051698670605613,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "f1",
"neural_primary_score": 0.7152682255845944
},
{
"task": "modality_reconstruction",
"task_display_name": "Cross-Modal Reconstruction",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "r2",
"simple_primary_score": -0.015271898913936655,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "r2",
"neural_primary_score": -0.010171410134180991
},
{
"task": "next_action",
"task_display_name": "Next-Action Prediction",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"simple_primary_score": 0.05925925925925927,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"neural_primary_score": 0.04186046511627907
},
{
"task": "object_relevance",
"task_display_name": "Object Relevance Prediction",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "micro_f1",
"simple_primary_score": 0.18034382095361662,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "micro_f1",
"neural_primary_score": 0.1679279279279279
},
{
"task": "temporal_order",
"task_display_name": "Temporal Order Verification",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "accuracy",
"simple_primary_score": 0.4540229885057471,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "accuracy",
"neural_primary_score": 0.8577586206896551
},
{
"task": "timeline_action",
"task_display_name": "Action Recognition",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"simple_primary_score": 0.05,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"neural_primary_score": 0.014814814814814814
},
{
"task": "timeline_subtask",
"task_display_name": "Procedure Step Recognition",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"simple_primary_score": 0.05056355513846935,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"neural_primary_score": 0.02810810810810811
},
{
"task": "transition_detection",
"task_display_name": "Action Boundary Detection",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"simple_primary_score": 0.6118237590630229,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"neural_primary_score": 0.5862068965517241
}
],
"interpretation": "This layer verifies the 12 task contracts and raw multimodal feature pipeline on the public sample. It is not a cross-episode benchmark."
},
{
"id": "v2_multi_episode_128_aligned_metadata_baselines",
"title": "128-Episode Aligned Simple/NN Baselines",
"status": "pass",
"scope": "selected 128-episode 96/16/16 split",
"source": "results/omni_finetune/multi_episode_128_task_baselines/BASELINE_ALIGNMENT_REPORT.md",
"split": "train/val/test by selected episode/session",
"counts": {
"rows": 3808,
"split_counts": {
"train": 2848,
"val": 512,
"test": 448
},
"episode_counts": {
"test": 16,
"train": 96,
"val": 16
},
"task_count": 12,
"simple_supported_task_count": 8,
"neural_supported_task_count": 6
},
"models": [
"metadata/text simple baselines",
"metadata/text neural MLP baselines"
],
"task_metrics": [
{
"task": "timeline_action",
"task_display_name": "Action Recognition",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"simple_primary_score": 0.00017511601435951318,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"neural_primary_score": 0.0
},
{
"task": "timeline_subtask",
"task_display_name": "Procedure Step Recognition",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"simple_primary_score": 0.0,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"neural_primary_score": 0.0
},
{
"task": "transition_detection",
"task_display_name": "Action Boundary Detection",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"simple_primary_score": 0.5219803670507895,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"neural_primary_score": 0.45822172492907925
},
{
"task": "next_action",
"task_display_name": "Next-Action Prediction",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"simple_primary_score": 0.00019966057701906761,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"neural_primary_score": 0.0
},
{
"task": "hand_trajectory_forecast",
"task_display_name": "Hand Trajectory Forecasting",
"simple_status": "unsupported_without_raw_128_feature_blocks",
"simple_primary_metric": "mpjpe",
"simple_primary_score": null,
"neural_status": "not_run",
"neural_primary_metric": "",
"neural_primary_score": null
},
{
"task": "contact_prediction",
"task_display_name": "Contact State Prediction",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"simple_primary_score": 0.5167950693374422,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "macro_f1",
"neural_primary_score": 0.21951219512195122
},
{
"task": "object_relevance",
"task_display_name": "Object Relevance Prediction",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "micro_f1",
"simple_primary_score": 0.18221614227086183,
"neural_status": "pass",
"neural_primary_metric": "micro_f1",
"neural_primary_score": 0.1053878034339846
},
{
"task": "caption_grounding",
"task_display_name": "Language Grounding",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "mrr",
"simple_primary_score": 0.012785504572093487,
"neural_status": "not_run",
"neural_primary_metric": "",
"neural_primary_score": null
},
{
"task": "cross_modal_retrieval",
"task_display_name": "Cross-Modal Retrieval",
"simple_status": "unsupported_without_raw_128_feature_blocks",
"simple_primary_metric": "mrr",
"simple_primary_score": null,
"neural_status": "not_run",
"neural_primary_metric": "",
"neural_primary_score": null
},
{
"task": "modality_reconstruction",
"task_display_name": "Cross-Modal Reconstruction",
"simple_status": "unsupported_without_raw_128_feature_blocks",
"simple_primary_metric": "r2",
"simple_primary_score": null,
"neural_status": "not_run",
"neural_primary_metric": "",
"neural_primary_score": null
},
{
"task": "temporal_order",
"task_display_name": "Temporal Order Verification",
"simple_status": "pass",
"simple_primary_metric": "f1",
"simple_primary_score": 0.32713178294573647,
"neural_status": "not_run",
"neural_primary_metric": "",
"neural_primary_score": null
},
{
"task": "misalignment_detection",
"task_display_name": "Multimodal Synchronization Detection",
"simple_status": "unsupported_without_raw_128_feature_blocks",
"simple_primary_metric": "f1",
"simple_primary_score": null,
"neural_status": "not_run",
"neural_primary_metric": "",
"neural_primary_score": null
}
],
"interpretation": "This layer aligns the previous simple and neural baseline framing to the same selected 96/16/16 split used by the model branches. It uses public-safe JSONL metadata/text features, so raw-feature-only tasks remain explicitly unsupported until 128-run sensor feature blocks exist."
},
{
"id": "v3_multi_episode_foundation_model_branches",
"title": "128-Episode Foundation-Model Branches",
"status": "partial_verified",
"scope": "selected 128-episode split and compatible derived windows",
"source": "results/omni_finetune/verified_public/",
"split": "episode/session held-out split; exact task target depends on backbone contract",
"counts": {
"verified_branch_count": 4,
"qwen3_verified_package_count": 3,
"cosmos3_verified_package_count": 1
},
"models": [
"Qwen3-Omni LoRA",
"Cosmos3-Nano future-window compatibility branch"
],
"branches": [
{
"id": "xperience10m_cosmos3_nano_128ep_future_window_h5_compat_adapter_eval_test_full",
"title": "Cosmos3-Nano Future-Window World Model",
"status": "verified",
"backbone": "cosmos_world_model",
"dataset_contract": "xperience10m_future_window_world_model_v0",
"training_objective": "future_window_and_action_conditioned_world_modeling",
"source": "results/omni_finetune/verified_public/xperience10m_cosmos3_nano_128ep_future_window_h5_compat_adapter_eval_test_full/verified_result_summary.json",
"dataset_run_id": "xperience10m_cosmos3_nano_128ep_future_window_h5_compat",
"train_run_id": "xperience10m_cosmos3_nano_128ep_future_window_h5_compat_adapter",
"eval_run_id": "xperience10m_cosmos3_nano_128ep_future_window_h5_compat_adapter_eval_test_full",
"counts": {
"dataset_samples": 3213,
"dataset_episodes": 119,
"split_counts": {
"train": 2403,
"test": 378,
"val": 432
},
"train_samples": 2403,
"val_samples": 432,
"eval_samples": 378,
"held_out_episode_count": 14,
"num_processes": 1
},
"primary_metrics": {
"future_retrieval_mrr": 0.022138720585222767,
"future_retrieval_recall_at_5": 0.015873015873015872,
"temporal_consistency": 0.09523809523809523,
"feature_reconstruction_error": 3479.218317102503,
"transition_accuracy": 0.9682539682539683,
"contact_accuracy": 0.7433862433862434,
"held_out_episode_count": 14
},
"history": [
{
"epoch": 0,
"train_loss": null,
"val_loss": null,
"note": "closed-form mean-delta adapter; no Cosmos diffusion weights fine-tuned in this compatibility run"
}
]
},
{
"id": "xperience10m_qwen3_omni_128ep_96train_16val_16test_valmon_20260605_eval",
"title": "Qwen3-Omni LoRA",
"status": "verified",
"backbone": "qwen3_omni_lora",
"dataset_contract": "xperience10m_episode_json_qa_v1",
"training_objective": "structured_episode_understanding_json_qa",
"source": "results/omni_finetune/verified_public/xperience10m_qwen3_omni_128ep_96train_16val_16test_valmon_20260605_eval/verified_result_summary.json",
"dataset_run_id": "xperience10m_qwen3_omni_128ep_96train_16val_16test_valmon_20260605",
"train_run_id": "xperience10m_qwen3_omni_128ep_96train_16val_16test_valmon_20260605_lora",
"eval_run_id": "xperience10m_qwen3_omni_128ep_96train_16val_16test_valmon_20260605_eval",
"counts": {
"dataset_samples": 3808,
"dataset_episodes": 119,
"split_counts": {
"train": 2848,
"val": 512,
"test": 448
},
"train_samples": 2848,
"val_samples": 512,
"eval_samples": 448,
"held_out_episode_count": 14,
"num_processes": 8
},
"primary_metrics": {
"json_validity_rate": 0.875,
"action_macro_f1": 0.0026621494447581404,
"subtask_accuracy": 0.006696428571428571,
"transition_accuracy": 0.8504464285714286,
"next_action_accuracy": 0.024553571428571428,
"contact_accuracy": 0.6450892857142857,
"object_micro_f1": 0.22299431459254582,
"held_out_episode_count": 14
},
"history": [
{
"epoch": 1,
"train_loss": 0.41304643672440994,
"val_loss": 0.0330660454928875,
"global_step": 356
}
]
},
{
"id": "xperience10m_qwen3_omni_128ep_fullsplit_fast8gpu_lora_fsdp_full_train_noval_tail_logits_fullstatesave_v6_eval_test_full",
"title": "Qwen3-Omni LoRA",
"status": "verified",
"backbone": "qwen3_omni_lora",
"dataset_contract": "xperience10m_episode_json_qa_v1",
"training_objective": "structured_episode_understanding_json_qa",
"source": "results/omni_finetune/verified_public/xperience10m_qwen3_omni_128ep_fullsplit_fast8gpu_lora_fsdp_full_train_noval_tail_logits_fullstatesave_v6_eval_test_full/verified_result_summary.json",
"dataset_run_id": "xperience10m_qwen3_omni_128ep_fullsplit_fast8gpu",
"train_run_id": "xperience10m_qwen3_omni_128ep_fullsplit_fast8gpu_lora_fsdp_full_train_noval_tail_logits_fullstatesave_v6",
"eval_run_id": "xperience10m_qwen3_omni_128ep_fullsplit_fast8gpu_lora_fsdp_full_train_noval_tail_logits_fullstatesave_v6_eval_test_full",
"counts": {
"dataset_samples": 3808,
"dataset_episodes": 119,
"split_counts": {
"train": 2848,
"val": 512,
"test": 448
},
"train_samples": 2848,
"val_samples": 0,
"eval_samples": 448,
"held_out_episode_count": 14,
"num_processes": 8
},
"primary_metrics": {
"json_validity_rate": 0.8526785714285714,
"action_macro_f1": 0.00213753459655099,
"subtask_accuracy": 0.004464285714285714,
"transition_accuracy": 0.828125,
"next_action_accuracy": 0.022321428571428572,
"contact_accuracy": 0.6517857142857143,
"object_micro_f1": 0.23062730627306272,
"held_out_episode_count": 14
},
"history": [
{
"epoch": 1,
"train_loss": 0.4121775626560694,
"val_loss": null,
"global_step": 356
}
]
},
{
"id": "xperience10m_qwen3_omni_128ep_structured_json_v2_reuse_full8gpu_lora_eval_test_full",
"title": "Qwen3-Omni LoRA",
"status": "verified",
"backbone": "qwen3_omni_lora",
"dataset_contract": "xperience10m_episode_json_qa_v1",
"training_objective": "structured_episode_understanding_json_qa",
"source": "results/omni_finetune/verified_public/xperience10m_qwen3_omni_128ep_structured_json_v2_reuse_full8gpu_lora_eval_test_full/verified_result_summary.json",
"dataset_run_id": "xperience10m_qwen3_omni_128ep_96train_16val_16test_valmon_20260605",
"train_run_id": "xperience10m_qwen3_omni_128ep_structured_json_v2_reuse_full8gpu_lora",
"eval_run_id": "xperience10m_qwen3_omni_128ep_structured_json_v2_reuse_full8gpu_lora_eval_test_full",
"counts": {
"dataset_samples": 3808,
"dataset_episodes": 119,
"split_counts": {
"train": 2848,
"val": 512,
"test": 448
},
"train_samples": 2848,
"val_samples": 512,
"eval_samples": 448,
"held_out_episode_count": 14,
"num_processes": 8
},
"primary_metrics": {
"json_validity_rate": 0.9977678571428571,
"action_macro_f1": 0.0024331644885523347,
"subtask_accuracy": 0.002232142857142857,
"transition_accuracy": 0.9709821428571429,
"next_action_accuracy": 0.029017857142857144,
"contact_accuracy": 0.71875,
"object_micro_f1": 0.30160427807486634,
"held_out_episode_count": 14
},
"history": [
{
"epoch": 1,
"train_loss": 0.41282760031950355,
"val_loss": 0.03288277983665466,
"global_step": 356
},
{
"epoch": 2,
"train_loss": 0.027745448225544075,
"val_loss": 0.027823254466056824,
"global_step": 712
}
]
}
],
"interpretation": "This layer contains the held-out foundation-model packages. Qwen3-Omni packages evaluate structured JSON task prediction; Cosmos3-Nano currently evaluates a future-window world-model compatibility adapter, not a full diffusion-weight fine-tune."
}
],
"pending": [
"Use the final Qwen3 full-eval package as the current Qwen result; older Qwen package rows remain historical diagnostics for comparison.",
"Promote Cosmos3 from compatibility adapter to full Cosmos3 fine-tuning only after a separate environment with matching Diffusers/Cosmos dependencies is prepared."
]
}