TITLE: Is there a nonabelian topological group operation on the reals?
QUESTION [8 upvotes]: Inspired by A binary operation, closed over the reals, that is associative, but not commutative. That question asks for a noncommutative semigroup operation on $\Bbb R$, for which right projection is a continuous solution. If you ask for inverses as well, that is, a nonabelian group operation, then you can use bijection tricks from any other nonabelian group of cardinality $\frak c$, for example the group $M_2(\Bbb R)$ of $2\times 2$ real matrices. But this will not usually give a continuous group operation on $\Bbb R$ because the bijection is usually exotic.
To "upper bound" the properties needed, according to @PseudoNeo, if we require that the group operation be not just continuous but $C_1$, then it is necessarily of the form $x\ast y=\phi^{−1}(\phi(x)+\phi(y))$ for some $C_1$ diffeomorphism $\phi$, which is manifestly abelian. (Anyone have a reference for this result?)
My question lies between these extremes:

Is there a nonabelian topological group operation on the reals? That is, a group operation $\ast$ such that $\ast:\Bbb R\times\Bbb R\to\Bbb R$ is continuous and so is ${}^{-1}:\Bbb R\to\Bbb R$.

REPLY [7 votes]: I believe L.E.J. Brouwer showed (in his thesis "Over de Grondslagen der Wiskunde", in Dutch (1907), in a relatively unknown chapter not published elsewhere, AFAIK) that Hilbert's problem on "continuous groups" (i.e. topological groups) being Lie groups was true for the one-dimensional case, the real line. It is believed that Brouwer added this to add some "gravitas" to the thesis (which also contained some more controversial stuff on the foundations of maths).
This answer provides a argument in the same vein. It is pretty elementary, but leaves some details to check.