TITLE: Possible distinct positive real $x,y,z \neq 1$ with $x^{(y^z)} = y^{(z^x)} = z^{(x^y)}$ in cyclic permutation?
QUESTION [40 upvotes]: Can we have distinct positive real  $x,y,z \neq 1$ with
$$  x^{\left( y^z \right)}  =   y^{\left( z^x \right)}  =  z^{\left( x^y \right)}      $$ in cyclic permutation?
It does not work well if any variable is 1. Also, it obviously works if all three are equal. I think if two are equal, probably the third must match as well. If there is anything else, one would expect a curve of some sort..I guess from what I am asking, one might as well demand $x < y < z.$ NO, not the same as $x < z < y$ as not cyclically equivalent, so maybe drop that.
Suggested by what is the largest number here?

REPLY [3 votes]: I think I've solved it, but I just don't trust myelf.  So please hop on and correct me if I've done something stupid..
By way of contradiction, let's assume the equality $x^{(y^z)}=y^{(z^x)}=z^{(x^y)}$ holds. Now define the function $f(y,z)= x^{(y^z)}- y^{(z^x)}$. On one hand, $f(y,z)$ is identically zero, so all its first partials vanish.  On the other hand, we may compute them formally as $$f_y=\frac{x^{(y^z)}zy^z\ln{x} -y^{(z^x)}z^x}{y}\quad \mbox{and} \quad f_z=\ln{y}\left(x^{(y^z)}y^z\ln{x}-y^{(z^x)}xz^{x-1}\right)$$ Setting each of these to zero, and using the fact that $x^{(y^z)}=y^{(z^x)}$, we obtain $$zy^z\ln{x}=z^x\quad \mbox{and} \quad y^z\ln{x}=xz^{x-1}$$  From here it is fairly trivial to show that either $z=0$ or $x=1$, but each of these possibilities is ruled out by hypothesis. 
Note that in the proof, I only used the asumption that $x^{(y^z)}= y^{(z^x)}$.