TITLE: Weighted Jaccard Similarity
QUESTION [9 upvotes]: I'd like to calculate the similarity between two sets using Jaccard but temper the results using the relative frequency of each item within a corpus.
Jaccard is defined as the magnitude of the intersection of the two sets divided by the magnitude of the union of them both.
$jaccard(A, B) = \frac{|A \bigcap B|}{ |A\bigcup B|}$
If I use inverse document frequency (the log of the number of documents divided by the frequency of the item) ...
$idf(i) = log\frac{| D |}{f(i)+1}$
$|D|$ is the number of documents
$|f(i)|$ is the frequency of the item in the documents.
... can I define my weighted Jaccard similarity function as the sum of the IDFs of the items in the intersections divided by the sum of the IDFs of the union? (Sorry describing this in LaTeX reaches the limits of my knowledge of notation.)  Will this scale the similarity appropriately? Are a collection of weights better suited to a cosine similarity?

REPLY [2 votes]: Yes! There's a paper that does exactly that using exponentially distributed hashes for idf weighting.
https://www.robots.ox.ac.uk/~vgg/publications/2008/Chum08a/chum08a.pdf
If your hash function maps to (0,1], then apply the transformation $\frac{-\log(h(x))}{w_i}$ where $w_i$ is the weight of item i.
Then apply the original minhash algorithm using these biased hashes instead of the uniform ones, and it has the properties you desire.
Check out the section on "probability distributions" in this article for a derivation of how it works. https://moultano.wordpress.com/2018/11/08/minhashing-3kbzhsxyg4467-6/