TITLE: History of Tarski's problems on free groups
QUESTION [11 upvotes]: As is known, Tarski posed his questions about first-order theories of non-abelian free groups around 1945. However, the questions were not published in his papers or books.
What is the original published source of reliable information about posing Tarski's problems on free groups? When exactly had Tarski posed these questions at first time? Did it happen at some seminar or conference?

REPLY [5 votes]: Why did I guess that Tarski's problems 
about first-order theories of non-abelian free groups
were not published in his papers or books, and he posed
the problems around 1945? Here are the reasons of that:
$\bullet$ 
In the papers of Kharlampovich-Myasnikov
[J. Algebra  302  (2006),  no. 2, 451-552]
and Sela 
[Geom. Funct. Anal.  16  (2006), no. 3, 707-730]
with solutions of Tarski's problems
there is no references to his publications;
$\bullet$ 
In the Kharlampovich-Myasnikov paper it is written that
the Tarski's conjectures were formulated around 1945;
$\bullet$ 
Lyndon in his paper [Problems in combinatorial group theory, 
in: Combinatorial group theory and topology, Ann. Math. Stud., Princeton Univ. Press,
1987] formulated the problem on elementary equivalence of all non-abelian free groups
and called it a folklore problem of Alfred Tarski.
I checked Tarski's papers and books and now I know that his problems
on the elementary theory of free groups had been formulated in some of his
publications; so these problems were not `folklore'.
Also, it seems the problems had been posed not around 1945 but later.
The first Tarski's publication where the decision problem for 
the theory of non-abelian free groups was mentioned
is the Tarski's book [Undecidable theories, North-Holland, 1953]. On p. 77 he informed that
he stated his result of undecidability of the elementary theory of groups
at a conference in Princeton in December, 1946.
On p. 85, he wrote: 'For many extensions of the elementary theory of
groups, e.g. for elementary theories of finite groups and non-Abelian free groups, 
the decision problem remains open'.
Note that it was not a conjecture on decidability of the elementary theory
of non-abelian free groups;  he just said that it was not known whether
the theory is decidable or not. Clearly, the question had been raised
between 1945 and 1953, and I don't know when exactly.
In that Tarski's book the problem of elementary equivalence 
of all non-abelian free groups was not mentioned.
First time it was published in Vaught's abstract
[Bull. AMS, 61 (1955), N 2, 173-174], where he formulated his theorem implying
that standard embeddings of free groups of infinite rank are elementary and wrote:
'These investigations arose from a still unresolved conjecture of Tarski's 
that any two free groups with at least two generators are arithmetically equivalent'.
That theorem was a result from Chapter 3 of Vaught's PhD thesis (Berkeley, 1954),
the supervisor of which was Tarski.
Later the Vaught's theorem and the Tarski's conjecture were published in Tarski-Vaught's paper
[Compositio Math.  13 (1957), 81-102]; see pages 82 and 98.
Also, in the introduction of the paper it is written that the decision problem for the elementary theory of
free non-abelian groups is a closely related open problem.