TITLE: When do Borel $\sigma$-algebras generated by the total variation norm and the weak* topology coincide?
QUESTION [6 upvotes]: I am almost certain that I read somewhere that the following is true, but I cannot seem to locate the reference. I would be most appreciative if someone could point me to a reference. The result was in one of the following forms.

Premise: Let $X$ be a Polish space. Let $S$ be the vector space of totally finite signed Borel measures on $X$. Let $T_N$ be the topology induced by the total variation norm on $S$. Let $T_{WC}$ be the topology of weak convergence of measures on $S$ (sometimes called the weak* topology).
Conclusion: Then the Borel $\sigma$-algebras generated by $T_N$ and $T_{WC}$ are the same.

Other form (which would imply the above):

Premise: Let $X$ be a measurable space with a countably generated $\sigma$-algebra. Let $S$ be the vector space of totally finite signed measures on $X$. Let $T_N$ be the topology induced by the total variation norm on $S$. Let $A$ be the $\sigma$-algebra on $S$ generated by maps of the form $\mu \mapsto \int_X f d\mu$ where $f\colon X \to \mathbb{R}$ varies over bounded measurable real-valued functions on $X$.
Conclusion: Then $A$ is equal to the Borel $\sigma$-algebras generated by $T_N$.

REPLY [6 votes]: No, it isn't true.
Let $E$ be a non-Borel set in $X$ and consider the set of Dirac measures
$E' = \{ \delta_x : x \in E\} \subset S$.  Note that for each Dirac measure $\mu$, the total-variation ball of radius 1/2 about $\mu$ contains no other Dirac measure.  Hence $E'$ is closed in $T_N$, hence Borel in $T_N$.  
On the other hand, it is well known that the map $F : X \to (S, T_{WC})$ defined by $x \mapsto \delta_x$ is continuous (in fact, a homeomorphism onto its image).  In particular, it is Borel measurable.  Since $E = F^{-1}(E')$ is not Borel in $X$, we conclude that $E'$ is not Borel in $T_{WC}$.
A statement that is true is that the total-variation norm is a Borel function on $(S, T_{WC})$; indeed, it is lower semi-continuous.  This is an immediate consequence of the identity
$$\|\mu\| = \sup \left\{ \int \varphi \,d\mu : \varphi \in C_b(X), \|\varphi\|_\infty \le 1\right\}$$
which follows from the fact that each finite $\mu$ on a Polish space is regular.  So every total-variation ball is $\sigma(T_{WC})$ measurable.  But since $T_N$ is not second countable, we can't conclude that the open balls generate $\sigma(T_N)$, and indeed they do not.