TITLE: Algorithm for the class field tower problem?
QUESTION [8 upvotes]: This is a spur of the moment algebraic number theory question prompted by a side remark I made in a course I'm teaching:
Let $K$ be a number field.  The (Hilbert) class field tower of $K$ is the sequence defined by $K^0 = K$ and for all $n \geq 0$, $K^{n+1}$ is the Hilbert class field of $K^n$.  Put $K^{\infty} = \bigcup_n K^n$.  We say that the class field tower is infinite if $[K^{\infty}:K] = \infty$ (equivalently $K^{n+1} \supsetneq K^n$ for all $n$).  Golod and Shafarevich gave examples of number fields with infinite class field tower, and thus which admit everywhere unramified extensions of infinite degree.  It is now known that a number field with "sufficiently many ramified primes" has infinite class field tower.
My question is this: is there a known algorithm which, upon being given a number field, decides whether the Hilbert class field tower of $K$ is infinite?

REPLY [5 votes]: There's little if nothing to add to Cam's answer, except that I want to point out that there is a big technical difference between class field towers and $p$-class field towers.
I have never seen any conjecture in the direction of the statement "if $K$ has infinite class field tower, then some subfield of the class field tower has infinite $p$-class field tower for some prime $p$". All known infinite class field towers in fact come from some $p$-class field tower, for which Golod-Shafarevich applies.
Thus general class field towers are a very difficult topic. For $p$-class field towers, on the other hand, I would guess that most specialists indeed think that if such a tower is infinite, then some subfield satisfies the Golod-Shafarevich bound. In this connection, see

F. Hajir, On the growth of $p$-class groups in $p$-class field towers,
J. Algebra 188, No.1, 256-271 (1997)

But even if this were known, there would not be a terminating algorithm for deciding the finiteness of the $p$-class field tower. There are nontrivial cases in which the $2$-tower was shown to be finite; for some recent calculations see e.g. 

H. Nover, Computation of Galois groups associated to the 2-class towers of some imaginary quadratic fields with 2-class group $C_2 \times C_2\times C_2$,
J. Number Theory 129, No. 1, 231-245 (2009)

This approach shows that certain types of class groups in small subfields prevent the $p$-class field tower from becoming infinite for group theoretic reasons. But there's a large gap between these results and Golod-Shafarevich, where no one really knows what is happening.