path string | audio audio | sentence string | video_id int32 | chunk_id int32 | sr_no int32 | case_name string | case_number string | hearing_date string |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_10_211.wav | issue a mandamus to the Speaker to decide within seven days? And there will be a constitutional crisis because the Speaker will not obey. That we don't know now. I don't know, It is possible. It has happened before. It has happened before. Nekchandra is the only case where there is a direction for an early disposal of ... | 10 | 211 | 9 | Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra and Ors. | W.P.(C) No. 493/2022 | 21.02.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_17_293.wav | 1948 shall, insofar as, they relate to matters for which provision is made in this Act and are not inconsistent, therewith be deemed to have been made under this act, as if, this act has been enforced on the date on which such rules were made and shall continue in force unless and until they are superseded by any rules... | 17 | 293 | 36 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 27.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_3_334.wav | thread is confidentiality. And the enabling part falls from Section 31 of the RBI Act. Once you enable them, how do you go about regulating? That thought process triggered, which is those connected legislation which need to be addressed. For all those connected legislations which have a proximity to the question of mov... | 3 | 334 | 3 | ASSOCIATION FOR DEMOCRATIC REFORMS & ANR. (Petitioner) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. (Respondent) | Writ Petition (Civil) No.880/2017 | 02.11.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_11_111.wav | or by any person or authority authorized by it in this behalf. That's correct. So the Whip is really a person who is authorized by the political party. That's correct. That's how it functions. Because the direction has to be given by the political party. It can't keep on giving a direction. It's a larger body. So there... | 11 | 111 | 9 | Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra and Ors. | W.P.(C) No. 493/2022 | 22.02.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_20_391.wav | fees, license fees, or fees for services rendered.' This can be found in Article 110, which deals with 'Money bill.' Distinct words. Then Royalty is used in Schedule 6, para 9, My Lord, of the Constitution. | 20 | 391 | 38 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 14.03.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_12_116.wav | Your principle which must guide judicial decision making, is that arbitration is essentially a voluntary assumption of an obligation by contracting parties to resolve their disputes to a private Tribunal. The intent of the parties is expressed in the terms of their agreement, where commercial entities and persons of bu... | 12 | 116 | 10 | IN RE: THE INTERPLAY BETWEEN ARBITRATION AGREEMENTS UNDER THE ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT, 1996 AND THE INDIAN STAMP ACT 1899 | Arbitration Case No. 25/2023 | 12.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_16_289.wav | of each state, thereafter if any elimination was to be made, from the list so notified, or any addition was to be made, that must be made by the Parliament and not the President. The object, now, My Lord, this is the italicized part, The object is to eliminate any kind of political factors having a play in the matter o... | 16 | 289 | 35 | THE STATE OF PUNJAB vs. DAVINDER SINGH | Civil Appeal No. 2317/2011 | 06.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_5_316.wav | page of piece of paper. Yes, thank you, Mr. Attorney General. | 5 | 316 | 5 | SITA SOREN Petitioner(s) v. UNION OF INDIA Respondent(s) | Crl. A. No. 451/2019 | 05.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_8_441.wav | 55 of the Constitution as long as they applied to State of Jammu and Kashmir. Now My Lords, Your Lordships will notice each of these orders were issued under D(1), D(1) all of these orders. B(1)? D(1), all of these orders. Then in 1952, on the 10th of June, My Lords on June 10th, '52, the basic principles of Committee ... | 8 | 441 | 6 | In re: Article 370 of the Constitution | Writ Petition (Civil) No.1099/2019 | 02.08.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_19_367.wav | to be kind. Kindly My Lord, | 19 | 367 | 38 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 12.03.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_11_122.wav | is passed, very interesting. My Lords it is signed by Bharat Gogawale. Very interesting document. This tells you the story. Resolution of the meeting of the Shiv Sena Legislative Assembly, Maharashtra Legislative Assembly 1990 to 2024, we the following members of the 14th Maharashtra Legislative Assembly belonging to t... | 11 | 122 | 9 | Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra and Ors. | W.P.(C) No. 493/2022 | 22.02.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_10_350.wav | what has happened here. So you have to interpret the Tenth Schedule and its provisions to ensure that there is no bulk defection and the concept of minority is over. Bulk majority also will be subject to disqualification. | 10 | 350 | 9 | Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra and Ors. | W.P.(C) No. 493/2022 | 21.02.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_16_006.wav | Doesn't make a difference at all. The stand is the same. Stand is the same. Who will be taking a contrary viewpoint? I am appearing for state of Tamil Nadu. Right. So my turn will be after Mr. Sibal or...? We are not aware of that sequencing. But whenever... it's Your Lordships call. We'll take a call. After the partie... | 16 | 6 | 35 | THE STATE OF PUNJAB vs. DAVINDER SINGH | Civil Appeal No. 2317/2011 | 06.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_7_360.wav | of that power is one of the most fraudulent invidious exercises that we have seen in this country since 1970. And why do I say 1970? In 1970, when they wanted to get rid of the privy process, they moved up Constituent Assembly Bill... Amendment Bill. That bill went to the Lok Sabha and passed through the Lok Sabha. It ... | 7 | 360 | 6 | In re: Article 370 of the Constitution | Writ Petition (Civil) No.1099/2019 | 23.08.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_5_273.wav | page of piece of paper. Yes, thank you, Mr. Attorney General. | 5 | 273 | 5 | SITA SOREN Petitioner(s) v. UNION OF INDIA Respondent(s) | Crl. A. No. 451/2019 | 05.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_4_065.wav | internal page 57, which should be page 360. Yes. Page 360. Just one minute... 358 of the PDF page. Paragraph? | 4 | 65 | 4 | BHASKAR RAJU & BROTHERS v. DHARMARATNAKARA RAI BAHADUR ARCOT NARAINSWAMY MUDALIAR CHATTRAM | Arbitration Case No. 25/2023 | 11.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_15_347.wav | This is 60 of your written submissions? This is my written submission. Also, when we use the expression, Article 30 uses the expression "establish and administer." Now, there is | 15 | 347 | 34 | ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR FAIZAN MUSTAFA vs NARESH AGARWAL & ORS | Civil Appeal No. 2286/2006 | 23.01.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_16_221.wav | special provision for only these Scheduled Castes in my state or these Scheduled Tribes in my state? Or, is it bound, if you make that special provision, that it must apply to all Scheduled Castes and Tribes in the state. Because, any in 15(4) qualifies only the Caste and Schedule Tribe. That's right. So as far as the ... | 16 | 221 | 35 | THE STATE OF PUNJAB vs. DAVINDER SINGH | Civil Appeal No. 2317/2011 | 06.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_10_277.wav | to the proceedings pending before this court as well as without considering that no adjudication can take place till disqualification petition is pending against delinquent MLAs are decided, Election Commission issued noticed to Uddhav Thackeray on the petition file by Eknath Shinde. And on 25th July aggrieved by the i... | 10 | 277 | 9 | Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra and Ors. | W.P.(C) No. 493/2022 | 21.02.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_15_468.wav | it brings into being will not militate under the minority right under 30. We can't whittle down Article 30, just because a statute exists. And that is a defect in Azeez Basha, followed by the Allahabad High Court. Now if I'm right, the learned Chief Justice does not want me to go into the Allahabad decision which is un... | 15 | 468 | 34 | ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR FAIZAN MUSTAFA vs NARESH AGARWAL & ORS | Civil Appeal No. 2286/2006 | 23.01.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_11_107.wav | legislature. Yes, yes. My Lords it will be entirely unworkable because you will then say that there is no relationship between the members of the Legislature and the party. They are independent of the parties. They can take whatever decision they like. It will be destructive of, if you ask me the basic structure of a s... | 11 | 107 | 9 | Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra and Ors. | W.P.(C) No. 493/2022 | 22.02.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_20_230.wav | the other principle invoked was generalia specialibus non derogant. Entry 50 is special entry. 49 is general. Therefore Entry 50 will not be, so | 20 | 230 | 38 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 14.03.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_17_190.wav | So, here again we find a taxing entry in the state list which alludes to, or which is subjected to List III, which apart from fee, doesn't contain a taxing power. Kindly see | 17 | 190 | 36 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 27.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_19_439.wav | According to my understanding imposed by Parliament, in law relating to mineral development. We have a law relating to mineral development. In that law where is the limitation? Which section provides for limitation? So basically, three things, who, how and in what methodology of, who, how and about what? Who? By Parlia... | 19 | 439 | 38 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 12.03.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_13_157.wav | today.' The judgment is, My Lord, delivered, 'unless extended by speaking order on the above parameters...' Now, next line is also important. 'Same course may also be adopted by Civil and Criminal Appellate Revisional Courts under the jurisdiction of the High Courts, the Trial Courts may, on expiry of the period, resum... | 13 | 157 | 11 | HIGH COURT BAR ASSOCIATION ALLAHABAD v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH AND ORS. | Crl. A No. 3589/2023 | 13.12.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_11_138.wav | My Lords. I will. Yes. I made that argument. Yes, I will try. Of course the constitutional position of the Speaker to decide. I'll tell Your Lordship the problem in that in that area. But.. There are still problems in the area. We see that. But, you know also we understand the significance of the point which you have m... | 11 | 138 | 9 | Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra and Ors. | W.P.(C) No. 493/2022 | 22.02.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_4_492.wav | dealt with by Justice Roy in his dissent in four paragraphs, which I will show My Lord, and then I will just summarize my submissions in My Lord, two pages. Your Lordship just may just see the dissent of Justice Roy on this aspect. Your Lords may come to | 4 | 492 | 4 | BHASKAR RAJU & BROTHERS v. DHARMARATNAKARA RAI BAHADUR ARCOT NARAINSWAMY MUDALIAR CHATTRAM | Arbitration Case No. 25/2023 | 11.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_20_202.wav | all overruled and a new law was laid down. So, the whole journey of this court is to protect the state and the surest will, way of killing the states, the federalism is to squeeze and strangulate the fiscal power. My Lord, My Learned friend is finishing now. There are a number of new points he has made because, frankly... | 20 | 202 | 38 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 14.03.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_11_256.wav | much. Exception of Ninth Schedule. That holds for Mr. Jethmalani also, Right? My personal opinion is this is my personal... I don't want to say it the fact of the matter is if you want to practice, you should practice. You want to be in Parliament, devote your time to Parliament. That should be. Otherwise My Lords we c... | 11 | 256 | 9 | Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra and Ors. | W.P.(C) No. 493/2022 | 22.02.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_5_469.wav | or as Justice Narasimha just observed, defamation. So someone's character is to be besmudged. So you agree among yourselves, that I'll say it in Parliament. What is 120(a) My Lords? | 5 | 469 | 5 | SITA SOREN Petitioner(s) v. UNION OF INDIA Respondent(s) | Crl. A. No. 451/2019 | 05.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_14_051.wav | UGC Act comes, the Minority Act comes, and there's a load of decisions My Lord, which say, look at the historical antecedent. Azeez Basha looks at it and says, it's now irrelevant because we have decided that the Act, in fact established what | 14 | 51 | 34 | ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR FAIZAN MUSTAFA vs NARESH AGARWAL & ORS | Civil Appeal No. 2286/2006 | 09.01.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_20_416.wav | today, How many were deleted? Out of 66, seven were deleted. 7 have been omitted. Yes, by different amendments, including 101st Amendment. 36 entries are without limitations whatsoever or restrictions, I'll not use the word limitation, restrictions whatsoever. And 23 entries have | 20 | 416 | 38 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 14.03.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_16_212.wav | belong to that cast. In any case, that litigation I'm doing in the High Court. So, just sharing it with Your Lordship. So, there this whole interpretation of Milind and comma and a separate entry, we are engaged in the debate My Lord, that whether, if confers the same benefit amongst them as a caste. Why should they be... | 16 | 212 | 35 | THE STATE OF PUNJAB vs. DAVINDER SINGH | Civil Appeal No. 2317/2011 | 06.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_8_317.wav | architecture, that's with consultation. Now you come to B. Such other matters that is again, the power of Parliament to make laws. Such other matters in the said list so, apart from the list that are in the Instrument of Accession such other matters in the said list... No, This list refers to union and concurrent list.... | 8 | 317 | 6 | In re: Article 370 of the Constitution | Writ Petition (Civil) No.1099/2019 | 02.08.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_17_485.wav | lease at such times and in the manner provided in Part V and VI... I have placed this provision already. Then 11. As mentioned herein before, there is an obligation of the lessee to pay rent and other charges mentioned in the said clause and all other Central and State Government dues except demands for land revenue. T... | 17 | 485 | 36 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 27.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_12_095.wav | in relation to Section 5 of the Indian Stamp Act, that the | 12 | 95 | 10 | IN RE: THE INTERPLAY BETWEEN ARBITRATION AGREEMENTS UNDER THE ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT, 1996 AND THE INDIAN STAMP ACT 1899 | Arbitration Case No. 25/2023 | 12.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_8_381.wav | established between those States and unions and the centre. Kashmir's conditions are, as I have said special and requires special treatment. I do not want to take much time of the house, but I should briefly indicate the special conditions are. In the first place, there has been a war going on within the limits of Jamm... | 8 | 381 | 6 | In re: Article 370 of the Constitution | Writ Petition (Civil) No.1099/2019 | 02.08.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_17_480.wav | So that's how, My Lord, the matter came up. Now, what is to be noted is, My Lord, that here the cess which has been imposed is with respect to land revenue and royalty is one element. If we come back to the explanation in Section | 17 | 480 | 36 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 27.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_5_207.wav | Narasimha Rao need not be revisited, to just respond to that. I think in my understanding and the facts of this case where the election to the Council of States happens outside and not a function or a business or a work or the Parliament or the Legislature, then Narasimha Rao would not apply. Narasimha Rao is a case wh... | 5 | 207 | 5 | SITA SOREN Petitioner(s) v. UNION OF INDIA Respondent(s) | Crl. A. No. 451/2019 | 05.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_5_179.wav | to say that. So, posterior to your conduct has no difficulty at all. What speech, what vote was given in the Parliament, motives will not be inquired into. So, what persuasions went to, will not be inquired into. Talking about something anterior to what happens inside, and before the speech or vote is given, that's wha... | 5 | 179 | 5 | SITA SOREN Petitioner(s) v. UNION OF INDIA Respondent(s) | Crl. A. No. 451/2019 | 05.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_17_193.wav | provisions of List I with regard to rates of stamp duty. Entry 91 of List I. Entry 91 of List I. 'The rates of stamp duty in respect of bills of exchange, checks so and so'. But in case of this 91 and 63, once these documents are actually out of the | 17 | 193 | 36 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 27.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_14_285.wav | We see in 23 proviso My Lord. Then | 14 | 285 | 34 | ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR FAIZAN MUSTAFA vs NARESH AGARWAL & ORS | Civil Appeal No. 2286/2006 | 09.01.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_3_343.wav | regardless of all that, that will be put to test. I don't know whether it can be stretched to that extent. To a debate from 1958 onwards and the Companies Act '69, one way, and then in '85, another way of looking at it. The debates in the Parliament yesterday to a very multi, kind of discussion that took place in the P... | 3 | 343 | 3 | ASSOCIATION FOR DEMOCRATIC REFORMS & ANR. (Petitioner) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. (Respondent) | Writ Petition (Civil) No.880/2017 | 02.11.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_1_294.wav | "The section does | 1 | 294 | 1 | IN RE SECTION 6A OF THE CITIZENSHIP ACT 1955 | Writ Petition (C) No.274/2009 | 12.12.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_8_157.wav | minorities and contain appropriate provisions guaranteeing into the freedom of conscience, freedom of speech, and freedom of assembly. The National Assembly as soon as the work of framing the new Constitution is completed, submit it through the Council of Ministers for my acceptance. In conclusion, I repeat and hope th... | 8 | 157 | 6 | In re: Article 370 of the Constitution | Writ Petition (Civil) No.1099/2019 | 02.08.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_8_085.wav | 7. PDF page is | 8 | 85 | 6 | In re: Article 370 of the Constitution | Writ Petition (Civil) No.1099/2019 | 02.08.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_20_307.wav | was said that resources are unevenly distributed again and again it was harped upon. And therefore, few states, handful of states having resources will blackmail or do whatever, sinister. But the reality is the states which have these mineral resources are the poorest states in the country. I'm so grateful. That's exac... | 20 | 307 | 38 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 14.03.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_8_273.wav | Otherwise My Lord, then it's exercise of paramount power. submission as I understand is J&K is an exception because a temporary provision was created for a period of time and after that it is engrafted permanently into the Constitution. Because you can't revive the Constituent Assembly. I'm just saying. I understand wh... | 8 | 273 | 6 | In re: Article 370 of the Constitution | Writ Petition (Civil) No.1099/2019 | 02.08.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_8_270.wav | states. There were states which were part of the British Crown. They had to be amalgamated, and each of them had certain conditions. But then ultimately, they all agreed. Okay, for the states that were part of 562, all agreed. But this particular state of Jammu and Kashmir was an exception. And the exception was consti... | 8 | 270 | 6 | In re: Article 370 of the Constitution | Writ Petition (Civil) No.1099/2019 | 02.08.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_5_439.wav | powers, but Your Lordships are not examining the concept of privilege as such, and therefore I am not reading any of these judgments. Then, development of the law on privileges, again from the narrow compass of bribery vis-a-vis privilege do not have much assistance. But since Your Lordship said that whatever research ... | 5 | 439 | 5 | SITA SOREN Petitioner(s) v. UNION OF INDIA Respondent(s) | Crl. A. No. 451/2019 | 05.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_15_305.wav | Now look at 3, 'Subject to the provisions of this Act, the court shall exercise the following powers and perform the following duties.' This is the supreme body consisting of Muslims. 'making statutes and/or amending or repealing the same, of considering | 15 | 305 | 34 | ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR FAIZAN MUSTAFA vs NARESH AGARWAL & ORS | Civil Appeal No. 2286/2006 | 23.01.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_18_086.wav | purchaser and the denomination of the Electoral Bond; and b) Details of each Electoral Bond redeemed by political parties, | 18 | 86 | 37 | STATE BANK OF INDIA vs. ASSOCIATION FOR DEMOCRATICS REFORMS | 10382 / 2024
MA 486/2024 in W.P.(C) No. 880/2017 | 11.03.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_3_103.wav | that it's nearer... The Registrar will escort you, so you can take your iPad.. Mr. Sibal...That's exactly what I told him when I said... The moment he is here, we will ask him to escort you. My Lord, my gesture was in... We realized the moment you said that....that you go to my chamber. The video will be on. You can ke... | 3 | 103 | 3 | ASSOCIATION FOR DEMOCRATIC REFORMS & ANR. (Petitioner) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. (Respondent) | Writ Petition (Civil) No.880/2017 | 02.11.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_19_651.wav | a limitation that whole field is then transferred to the taxing power of the Union. That is Mr. Salve's and Mr. Mehta's argument. I'm now doing a totally different, nuanced argument. That first part Your Lordship has, totally occupied, et cetera, I am not dedicating. That they succeed, if Your Lordship holds it this wa... | 19 | 651 | 38 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 12.03.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_11_089.wav | it. Not Eknath Shinde | 11 | 89 | 9 | Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra and Ors. | W.P.(C) No. 493/2022 | 22.02.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_16_339.wav | at the outset My Lord, the exceptions which they talk of are only on two issues. One is on presumption of backwardness, which they opine on, and then creamy layer. These two Your Lordships may note. They do not opine on sub-classification. | 16 | 339 | 35 | THE STATE OF PUNJAB vs. DAVINDER SINGH | Civil Appeal No. 2317/2011 | 06.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_6_185.wav | adopted in the Constitution. Parliamentary democracy is a part of the basic structure of the Constitution, an interpretation of the provision of Article, provisions of Article 105(2), which would enable a member of Parliament to claim immunity from prosecution in a criminal court for an offense of bribery in connection... | 6 | 185 | 5 | SITA SOREN Petitioner(s) v. UNION OF INDIA Respondent(s) | Crl. A. No. 451/2019 | 04.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_5_197.wav | leads to or is connected to the speech made or vote given. This test requires disregarding the nature of the antecedent conduct. All that 197 CrPC sanction etc. The nexus test will not be a safe guide. At the same time, the possibility of any hostile or adverse action being taken on an estimation of perception of a spe... | 5 | 197 | 5 | SITA SOREN Petitioner(s) v. UNION OF INDIA Respondent(s) | Crl. A. No. 451/2019 | 05.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_13_137.wav | there was an amendment in the Income Tax Act, Section 254(2A), was inserted, that a stay | 13 | 137 | 11 | HIGH COURT BAR ASSOCIATION ALLAHABAD v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH AND ORS. | Crl. A No. 3589/2023 | 13.12.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_10_152.wav | mark of 249? 124 My Lords. 125. 125. And he had 125. Exactly the same. Yes. And at 12:01, they moved a resolution expressing disqualification, expressing no confidence, it is defeated and later again and defeated. My Lord, there were three independent | 10 | 152 | 9 | Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra and Ors. | W.P.(C) No. 493/2022 | 21.02.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_19_222.wav | to answer My Lord, come back to My Lord, that high taxation part, value of... Mr. SG, the query of our Chief Justice was... Yes. it itself contemplates that states will continue to levy taxes, and that will be taken into consideration while fixing the Royalty. My Lord, I am answering that. My Lord, please come | 19 | 222 | 38 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 12.03.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_8_151.wav | becomes difficult. Yes. In accordance with | 8 | 151 | 6 | In re: Article 370 of the Constitution | Writ Petition (Civil) No.1099/2019 | 02.08.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_6_142.wav | account in a court for a speech which you have made. No court can say that, well, why did you make this speech? Or you are answerable to us as a judicial institutions, in respect of a speech which you made or a vote which you cast. That's the purpose. This does not really seek to implicate other aspects, such as an asp... | 6 | 142 | 5 | SITA SOREN Petitioner(s) v. UNION OF INDIA Respondent(s) | Crl. A. No. 451/2019 | 04.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_12_004.wav | the issue of determination of stamp objections to the Tribunal. The first is, the Doctrine of Separability, which is housed in | 12 | 4 | 10 | IN RE: THE INTERPLAY BETWEEN ARBITRATION AGREEMENTS UNDER THE ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT, 1996 AND THE INDIAN STAMP ACT 1899 | Arbitration Case No. 25/2023 | 12.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_4_424.wav | Justice or it's designate, because that was SBP, has decided something in a mini trial finally. So, how dare an arbitrator go behind a Section 11 order in a Section 16 situation. That is the impact of the quote of paragraph 12 which is quoted in some detail here and My Lord that quotation of SBP, which is relied on by ... | 4 | 424 | 4 | BHASKAR RAJU & BROTHERS v. DHARMARATNAKARA RAI BAHADUR ARCOT NARAINSWAMY MUDALIAR CHATTRAM | Arbitration Case No. 25/2023 | 11.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_14_238.wav | Our interpretation, taking into mind the antecedent history which Your Lordships now accepts, has to be taken into account. St. Stephen's has a huge para on this. It says, even the motives, if you see it's in Stephen's, even the motives show its character. Now when Siddharth Shankar Ray was arguing for the Allahabad Hi... | 14 | 238 | 34 | ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR FAIZAN MUSTAFA vs NARESH AGARWAL & ORS | Civil Appeal No. 2286/2006 | 09.01.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_17_250.wav | Government. By exercising a rule making power, it could fix both existing leases. | 17 | 250 | 36 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 27.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_14_412.wav | It says at the top of 72, what the State says, I have money and I shall distribute it, but I shall not give you any of the unless you surrender to me your right to administration. Then the State must not grant aid in such manner, as will take away the fundamental right of the minority community under Article 30. | 14 | 412 | 34 | ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR FAIZAN MUSTAFA vs NARESH AGARWAL & ORS | Civil Appeal No. 2286/2006 | 09.01.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_14_330.wav | So, submission we'll look at. Please have a seat. Please have a seat Dr. Dhavan. Look at the, look at the antecedent history of the institution, one, the purpose of this statute and place the provisions of the statute in the backdrop of the antecedent history and its purpose, and the mere fact that the statutory provis... | 14 | 330 | 34 | ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR FAIZAN MUSTAFA vs NARESH AGARWAL & ORS | Civil Appeal No. 2286/2006 | 09.01.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_14_426.wav | under, by or under. Therefore, you cannot have a university, you cannot have a university without degrees, without it and therefore, My Lord, you can't read down, with the UGC Act, you can't read down Article 30. And then Your Lordships have seen in the reference in 2019, the National | 14 | 426 | 34 | ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR FAIZAN MUSTAFA vs NARESH AGARWAL & ORS | Civil Appeal No. 2286/2006 | 09.01.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_3_530.wav | legislative capture, strictly not corruption, either. The final stage would be corruption or bribery. The only in my respectful submission, the only constitutional safeguard against preventing quid pro quo is in fact, public disclosure. One Constitutional Court in South Africa. I just want to place two paras in rejoind... | 3 | 530 | 3 | ASSOCIATION FOR DEMOCRATIC REFORMS & ANR. (Petitioner) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. (Respondent) | Writ Petition (Civil) No.880/2017 | 02.11.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_1_244.wav | and this I don't believe Parliament can do, even though it has the legislative competence. No action under our Constitution can be so completely devoid of any rationality or any basis. You prescribed it. All right. Good luck. You prescribed it. But then what's your machinery to determine these four points that the pers... | 1 | 244 | 1 | IN RE SECTION 6A OF THE CITIZENSHIP ACT 1955 | Writ Petition (C) No.274/2009 | 12.12.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_7_172.wav | submission as. You have not formulated anything in your submissions on 370. submissions. Let us see that and then we can close on that. 619 to 623 of our written submissions | 7 | 172 | 6 | In re: Article 370 of the Constitution | Writ Petition (Civil) No.1099/2019 | 23.08.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_17_210.wav | And to complete this chain of thoughts with regard to Entries, there is a doctrine developed by this Court note, and that is with respect to 'federalism being a basic feature of the Constitution' and that is a doctrine which applies in a limited way. Because ultimately, federalism has two parts, both the Centre and the... | 17 | 210 | 36 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 27.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_17_244.wav | accept the Constitution which is coming. So, this variations are taking care of. In 1950, January 26. Yes. In fact, Goa came much later. Goa was... Goa, Dadra and Nagar Haveli. Dadra and Nagar Haveli and all that. Three is | 17 | 244 | 36 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 27.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_15_372.wav | status, which is at variance with St. Stephens, Proost and Patro. Because they recognize antecedent history and just give it the go-by. That point about Nexus and continuity... origins. What is the origin? In St. Stephen's, they go right through the origins, and they | 15 | 372 | 34 | ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR FAIZAN MUSTAFA vs NARESH AGARWAL & ORS | Civil Appeal No. 2286/2006 | 23.01.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_3_269.wav | Constitution. There has to be something very precise, direct and not too over-broad statements, which may resemble a political debate. I understand, that good part of the arguments made come closer to a political debate, rather than precise statements of infringement of any particular Constitutional | 3 | 269 | 3 | ASSOCIATION FOR DEMOCRATIC REFORMS & ANR. (Petitioner) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. (Respondent) | Writ Petition (Civil) No.880/2017 | 02.11.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_17_241.wav | 'Development of Minerals.' Now, Your Lordships will see that, both oil fields and that... they are covered by this, same. They were not separately dealt with. | 17 | 241 | 36 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 27.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_17_231.wav | 'Takes place' is just taken away. Anyway you referred to 286(3), right? Yes. I referred to it because I'll be relying upon the case which is directly on this to say that they should be specific and... What next, Mr.? Now, I would like to place the Mines and Minerals Development Act, because that's a law made by Parliam... | 17 | 231 | 36 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 27.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_1_368.wav | So very wide. Now, this is the regime which applies across India for foreigners. This is their power, which they have and please see Subsection 3. Any... of 3. Any authority prescribed in this behalf may, with respect to any particular foreigner, make orders under Clauses (e), (f) of subsection 2, which, as Your Lordsh... | 1 | 368 | 1 | IN RE SECTION 6A OF THE CITIZENSHIP ACT 1955 | Writ Petition (C) No.274/2009 | 12.12.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_16_223.wav | Scheduled Tribes, Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes My Lord.. In which case the state can considerably say that, well, though these Scheduled Castes have been designated in my state, in my opinion out of them only these are not adequately represented in my services. So My Lord the recording of opinion..... In Mahara... | 16 | 223 | 35 | THE STATE OF PUNJAB vs. DAVINDER SINGH | Civil Appeal No. 2317/2011 | 06.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_15_528.wav | the students the motive and objective of the college, the Glory of God." This all emanates from "found." The primary right is | 15 | 528 | 34 | ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR FAIZAN MUSTAFA vs NARESH AGARWAL & ORS | Civil Appeal No. 2286/2006 | 23.01.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_7_045.wav | MPs, stake a claim. The Governor is not there. We cannot determine where the Governor is, but we can inform you. It is on record that the Secretary has acknowledged the WhatsApp message. He does not answer the phone. Fax doesn't go through. He is informed on WhatsApp and a public tweet tagging the Governor, is issued. ... | 7 | 45 | 6 | In re: Article 370 of the Constitution | Writ Petition (Civil) No.1099/2019 | 23.08.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_3_215.wav | Privacy under Article 21 clearly postulates that there exists a claim on part of the donors to make donations without fear of reprisal. It is submitted that such right would obviously not be absolute and would have to be counterbalanced with public interest and concept of free and fair elections, and further optimized ... | 3 | 215 | 3 | ASSOCIATION FOR DEMOCRATIC REFORMS & ANR. (Petitioner) v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. (Respondent) | Writ Petition (Civil) No.880/2017 | 02.11.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_8_506.wav | Constitution. Now kindly note My Lords, the temporary provision was over. Still be governed. Why was this required to say it is to be governed if it is a permanent feature? Sorry? Why was there a requirement in to say this will continue to govern when it was a permanent....? My Lords, it also reiterates the Residuary P... | 8 | 506 | 6 | In re: Article 370 of the Constitution | Writ Petition (Civil) No.1099/2019 | 02.08.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_20_101.wav | involved. Page 8, which? Para 4. If Your Lordship looks at Entry 23 and 27 and 67 of List I. | 20 | 101 | 38 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 14.03.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_6_168.wav | Undoubtedly... notwithstanding that. The other things, they stand apart. The criminality stands apart. That has got nothing to do with the Parliament. But that is where my argument, that in respect of... So, to that extent, the Parliament can... the House can go into, whether babies there or not there, vote is there or... | 6 | 168 | 5 | SITA SOREN Petitioner(s) v. UNION OF INDIA Respondent(s) | Crl. A. No. 451/2019 | 04.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_15_551.wav | Patro since it appears to be in close parallel with the case at hand, it would be useful to drive the contentions. Then My Lord, the contentions are there. And then what happened, in para 27. On appeal the judgment of the High Court was reversed by this court mainly | 15 | 551 | 34 | ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR FAIZAN MUSTAFA vs NARESH AGARWAL & ORS | Civil Appeal No. 2286/2006 | 23.01.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_8_082.wav | My Lords, kindly come to PDF page... yes. PDF page 7, Offer of Accession by Maharaja Hari Singh on 26th of October 1947. | 8 | 82 | 6 | In re: Article 370 of the Constitution | Writ Petition (Civil) No.1099/2019 | 02.08.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_14_019.wav | may also be decided once and for all.' Then a reference is made to the various criticisms, which the court noted. 'A large number of jurists, including Mr. Seervai, learned counsel for the Petitioner, Mr. Garg and Interveners, Dixit and Kaskar, have also stated the this case requires reconsideration. In view of the urg... | 14 | 19 | 34 | ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY THROUGH ITS REGISTRAR FAIZAN MUSTAFA vs NARESH AGARWAL & ORS | Civil Appeal No. 2286/2006 | 09.01.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_7_337.wav | 1972, after his prolonged incarceration, when he was to come back and form the government, they entered into an agreement. Sheikh Abdullah and Mrs. Gandhi and it's interesting because that agreement provided for the fact that there would be no question of you asking for an abrogation of 370 Clause 3, the accession is a... | 7 | 337 | 6 | In re: Article 370 of the Constitution | Writ Petition (Civil) No.1099/2019 | 23.08.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_5_272.wav | page of piece of paper. Yes, thank you, Mr. Attorney General. | 5 | 272 | 5 | SITA SOREN Petitioner(s) v. UNION OF INDIA Respondent(s) | Crl. A. No. 451/2019 | 05.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_4_097.wav | if you now get into validity, you are really rupturing the entire scheme in my humble submission because validity is left to the arbitrator. They decide the validity. The Arbitral Tribunal decision is not final. It's subject to judicial review by a 34 court. Under 34(111)222. Please | 4 | 97 | 4 | BHASKAR RAJU & BROTHERS v. DHARMARATNAKARA RAI BAHADUR ARCOT NARAINSWAMY MUDALIAR CHATTRAM | Arbitration Case No. 25/2023 | 11.10.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_16_328.wav | to make a law dividing the Scheduled Caste list of the state by tracing its legislative competence to entry 41 of list 2 or entry 25 of list 3. Therefore, we are of the opinion that in pith and substance, the enactment is not a law governing the field of education or the field of state public services. Here 16(4) shoul... | 16 | 328 | 35 | THE STATE OF PUNJAB vs. DAVINDER SINGH | Civil Appeal No. 2317/2011 | 06.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_17_487.wav | One can comprehend that part of it. But as I submitted that in this case, the cess was not on royalty, but cess on land revenue and royalty was one | 17 | 487 | 36 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 27.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_17_402.wav | Bearing Areas Act? Yes, Coal Bearing Areas (Acquisition and Development) Act. Where do we get it? | 17 | 402 | 36 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 27.02.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_23_013.wav | be expressed as entitling the holder to drive a motor vehicle specified as transport vehicle or non-transport vehicle with manual gear selection or automatic gear selection, as the case may be of one or more of the following classes, namely Light Motor Vehicle, Category 1. So, what they've done is they've divided light... | 23 | 13 | 41 | M/S. BAJAJ ALLIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE CO.LTD. vs. RAMBHA DEVI | 29686 / 2017
C.A. No. 841/2018 | 16.04.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_10_150.wav | If 39 MLAs are excluded from the strength of the Legislative Assembly, the effective strength comes down to 249. And out of those.. | 10 | 150 | 9 | Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra and Ors. | W.P.(C) No. 493/2022 | 21.02.2023 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_19_320.wav | to be kind. Kindly My Lord, | 19 | 320 | 38 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 12.03.2024 | |
/content/wavs/aligned_output_30s_final/audio_20_219.wav | Royalty as required, by Section 9...' So, Section 9 is straight away applied here. | 20 | 219 | 38 | MINERAL AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. vs. M/S STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA . | 9012 / 1999
C.A. No. 4056-4064/1999 | 14.03.2024 |
End of preview. Expand in Data Studio
README.md exists but content is empty.
- Downloads last month
- 21