| Agreement, quadratic-weighted Cohen's kappa, n=24 |
| (the 4 items with no model answer are excluded: both coders were told to score them 0) |
| intent_inference kappa 0.88 exact 92% |
| social_appropriateness kappa 0.30 exact 62% |
| unsupported_assumptions kappa 0.70 exact 83% |
| semantic_preservation kappa 0.89 exact 92% |
| pooled kappa 0.72 |
| totals: correlation 0.88, mean absolute difference 0.71 |
|
|
| Coder 1 |
| language, context implicit -1.14 [-3.86, +2.29] n=7 |
| language, context explicit -1.71 [-4.00, +1.00] n=7 |
| context, English +1.14 [-2.29, +4.57] n=7 |
| context, Roman Urdu +0.57 [-0.86, +2.00] n=7 |
| language, implicit, clean only -3.25 [-5.75, -1.50] n=4 |
| per scenario, English implicit to Roman Urdu implicit: |
| ambiguity 8.0 -> 5.0 |
| code_switch 8.0 -> 5.0 (truncated response in this scenario) |
| deference 0.0 -> 8.0 (truncated response in this scenario) |
| face_saving 0.0 -> 0.0 (truncated response in this scenario) |
| family_obligation 8.0 -> 7.0 |
| favor_indirect 8.0 -> 6.0 |
| kinship_context 8.0 -> 1.0 |
|
|
| Coder 2 |
| language, context implicit -0.43 [-3.57, +3.00] n=7 |
| language, context explicit -0.29 [-2.29, +2.00] n=7 |
| context, English +0.86 [-2.57, +4.29] n=7 |
| context, Roman Urdu +1.00 [-0.86, +3.14] n=7 |
| language, implicit, clean only -2.25 [-6.00, +0.00] n=4 |
| per scenario, English implicit to Roman Urdu implicit: |
| ambiguity 8.0 -> 7.0 |
| code_switch 8.0 -> 6.0 (truncated response in this scenario) |
| deference 0.0 -> 8.0 (truncated response in this scenario) |
| face_saving 0.0 -> 0.0 (truncated response in this scenario) |
| family_obligation 8.0 -> 8.0 |
| favor_indirect 8.0 -> 8.0 |
| kinship_context 8.0 -> 0.0 |
|
|
| Mean of both coders |
| language, context implicit -0.79 [-3.71, +2.64] n=7 |
| language, context explicit -1.00 [-3.00, +1.50] n=7 |
| context, English +1.00 [-2.43, +4.43] n=7 |
| context, Roman Urdu +0.79 [-0.86, +2.57] n=7 |
| language, implicit, clean only -2.75 [-5.88, -0.75] n=4 |
| per scenario, English implicit to Roman Urdu implicit: |
| ambiguity 8.0 -> 6.0 |
| code_switch 8.0 -> 5.5 (truncated response in this scenario) |
| deference 0.0 -> 8.0 (truncated response in this scenario) |
| face_saving 0.0 -> 0.0 (truncated response in this scenario) |
| family_obligation 8.0 -> 7.5 |
| favor_indirect 8.0 -> 7.0 |
| kinship_context 8.0 -> 0.5 |
|
|
