from pathlib import Path import json import numpy as np import pandas as pd # ============================================================ # AYARLAR # ============================================================ INPUT_FILE = Path( "analysis/benchmark_results.csv" ) THRESHOLD_SCAN_OUTPUT = Path( "analysis/threshold_scan.csv" ) THRESHOLD_JSON_OUTPUT = Path( "analysis/selected_threshold.json" ) THRESHOLD_TXT_OUTPUT = Path( "analysis/selected_threshold.txt" ) # ============================================================ # BENCHMARK BEKLENTİLERİ # ============================================================ EXPECTED_TOTAL = 30 EXPECTED_POSITIVE = 20 EXPECTED_NEGATIVE = 10 # ============================================================ # THRESHOLD SCAN # ============================================================ THRESHOLD_MIN = 0.20 THRESHOLD_MAX = 0.80 THRESHOLD_STEP = 0.001 # ============================================================ # BAŞLANGIÇ # ============================================================ print( "\n" + "=" * 80 ) print( "07 - THRESHOLD SELECTION" ) print( "=" * 80 ) # ============================================================ # INPUT KONTROLÜ # ============================================================ if not INPUT_FILE.exists(): raise FileNotFoundError( f"{INPUT_FILE} bulunamadı.\n" "Önce 06_run_benchmark.py çalıştırılmalıdır." ) print( f"\nInput dosyası:\n" f"{INPUT_FILE}" ) # ============================================================ # VERİYİ OKU # ============================================================ df = pd.read_csv( INPUT_FILE ) print( f"\nToplam benchmark satırı: " f"{len(df)}" ) # ============================================================ # GEREKLİ KOLONLAR # ============================================================ required_columns = [ "question_number", "question_type", "question", "top1_similarity", "top1_title", ] missing_columns = [ column for column in required_columns if column not in df.columns ] if missing_columns: raise ValueError( "Eksik kolonlar bulundu:\n" + "\n".join( missing_columns ) ) # ============================================================ # LABEL NORMALIZATION # ============================================================ df[ "question_type" ] = ( df[ "question_type" ] .astype(str) .str.strip() .str.lower() ) valid_labels = { "positive", "negative", } invalid_labels = set( df[ "question_type" ].unique() ) - valid_labels if invalid_labels: raise ValueError( "Geçersiz question_type değerleri bulundu:\n" f"{invalid_labels}" ) # ============================================================ # SIMILARITY KONTROLÜ # ============================================================ df[ "top1_similarity" ] = pd.to_numeric( df[ "top1_similarity" ], errors="raise" ) if not np.isfinite( df[ "top1_similarity" ].to_numpy() ).all(): raise ValueError( "Similarity değerlerinde " "NaN veya Inf bulundu." ) # ============================================================ # BENCHMARK SAYILARI # ============================================================ total_count = len( df ) positive_count = int( ( df[ "question_type" ] == "positive" ).sum() ) negative_count = int( ( df[ "question_type" ] == "negative" ).sum() ) print( f"\nToplam : {total_count}" ) print( f"Pozitif : {positive_count}" ) print( f"Negatif : {negative_count}" ) if total_count != EXPECTED_TOTAL: raise ValueError( "Toplam benchmark sayısı beklenenden farklı." ) if positive_count != EXPECTED_POSITIVE: raise ValueError( "Pozitif benchmark sayısı beklenenden farklı." ) if negative_count != EXPECTED_NEGATIVE: raise ValueError( "Negatif benchmark sayısı beklenenden farklı." ) print( "\nBenchmark validation: OK" ) # ============================================================ # LABEL -> 0 / 1 # ============================================================ # positive = dokümanlarda cevap bulunuyor # negative = dokümanlarda cevap bulunmuyor y_true = ( df[ "question_type" ] .map( { "positive": 1, "negative": 0, } ) .to_numpy( dtype=np.int32 ) ) scores = ( df[ "top1_similarity" ] .to_numpy( dtype=np.float64 ) ) # ============================================================ # METRIC FONKSİYONU # ============================================================ def calculate_metrics( threshold ): # ---------------------------------------- # SCORE >= THRESHOLD -> POSITIVE # ---------------------------------------- y_pred = ( scores >= threshold ).astype( np.int32 ) # ---------------------------------------- # CONFUSION MATRIX # ---------------------------------------- tp = int( np.sum( (y_true == 1) & (y_pred == 1) ) ) tn = int( np.sum( (y_true == 0) & (y_pred == 0) ) ) fp = int( np.sum( (y_true == 0) & (y_pred == 1) ) ) fn = int( np.sum( (y_true == 1) & (y_pred == 0) ) ) # ---------------------------------------- # ACCURACY # ---------------------------------------- accuracy = ( (tp + tn) / len(y_true) ) # ---------------------------------------- # PRECISION # ---------------------------------------- if ( tp + fp ) > 0: precision = ( tp / (tp + fp) ) else: precision = 0.0 # ---------------------------------------- # RECALL / SENSITIVITY # ---------------------------------------- if ( tp + fn ) > 0: recall = ( tp / (tp + fn) ) else: recall = 0.0 # ---------------------------------------- # SPECIFICITY # ---------------------------------------- if ( tn + fp ) > 0: specificity = ( tn / (tn + fp) ) else: specificity = 0.0 # ---------------------------------------- # F1 # ---------------------------------------- if ( precision + recall ) > 0: f1 = ( 2 * precision * recall / ( precision + recall ) ) else: f1 = 0.0 # ---------------------------------------- # BALANCED ACCURACY # ---------------------------------------- balanced_accuracy = ( recall + specificity ) / 2 return { "threshold": float( threshold ), "tp": tp, "tn": tn, "fp": fp, "fn": fn, "accuracy": float( accuracy ), "precision": float( precision ), "recall": float( recall ), "specificity": float( specificity ), "f1": float( f1 ), "balanced_accuracy": float( balanced_accuracy ), } # ============================================================ # SCORE DISTRIBUTION # ============================================================ positive_scores = ( df.loc[ df[ "question_type" ] == "positive", "top1_similarity" ] .to_numpy( dtype=np.float64 ) ) negative_scores = ( df.loc[ df[ "question_type" ] == "negative", "top1_similarity" ] .to_numpy( dtype=np.float64 ) ) positive_min = float( positive_scores.min() ) positive_max = float( positive_scores.max() ) positive_mean = float( positive_scores.mean() ) negative_min = float( negative_scores.min() ) negative_max = float( negative_scores.max() ) negative_mean = float( negative_scores.mean() ) gap = ( positive_min - negative_max ) print( "\n" + "=" * 80 ) print( "SCORE DAĞILIMI" ) print( "=" * 80 ) print( f""" Pozitif: mean : {positive_mean:.6f} min : {positive_min:.6f} max : {positive_max:.6f} Negatif: mean : {negative_mean:.6f} min : {negative_min:.6f} max : {negative_max:.6f} Gap: {gap:.6f} """ ) # ============================================================ # THRESHOLD SCAN # ============================================================ print( "=" * 80 ) print( "THRESHOLD SCAN" ) print( "=" * 80 ) thresholds = np.arange( THRESHOLD_MIN, THRESHOLD_MAX + THRESHOLD_STEP / 2, THRESHOLD_STEP, ) scan_rows = [] for threshold in thresholds: metrics = ( calculate_metrics( threshold ) ) scan_rows.append( metrics ) scan_df = pd.DataFrame( scan_rows ) # ============================================================ # OUTPUT DİZİNİ # ============================================================ THRESHOLD_SCAN_OUTPUT.parent.mkdir( parents=True, exist_ok=True ) # ============================================================ # SCAN CSV # ============================================================ scan_df.to_csv( THRESHOLD_SCAN_OUTPUT, index=False, encoding="utf-8-sig", ) print( f"\nToplam test edilen threshold: " f"{len(scan_df)}" ) # ============================================================ # EN İYİ F1 # ============================================================ best_f1 = float( scan_df[ "f1" ].max() ) best_f1_rows = ( scan_df[ np.isclose( scan_df[ "f1" ], best_f1, atol=1e-12, ) ] .copy() ) best_accuracy = float( scan_df[ "accuracy" ].max() ) print( f"\nEn iyi F1 : " f"{best_f1:.6f}" ) print( f"En iyi Accuracy : " f"{best_accuracy:.6f}" ) # ============================================================ # FINAL THRESHOLD SEÇİMİ # ============================================================ # Eğer pozitif ve negatifler tamamen ayrışıyorsa: # # max negative < min positive # # iki grubun arasındaki boşluğun orta noktasını seçiyoruz. # # Bu yaklaşım threshold'u sınırlardan birine yapıştırmak # yerine iki sınıfa da eşit mesafede bırakır. if gap > 0: selection_method = ( "midpoint_between_max_negative_and_min_positive" ) exact_threshold = ( negative_max + positive_min ) / 2 # İnsan tarafından okunması ve final RAG kodunda # rahat kullanılması için 3 decimal. selected_threshold = round( exact_threshold, 3 ) # Yuvarlama yanlışlıkla gap dışına çıkarsa # exact değeri kullan. if not ( negative_max < selected_threshold <= positive_min ): selected_threshold = ( exact_threshold ) else: # -------------------------------------------------------- # OVERLAP VARSA # -------------------------------------------------------- # # Öncelik: # 1. F1 # 2. Accuracy # 3. Balanced Accuracy # # Aynı performansı veren birden fazla threshold varsa # bunların orta threshold'u seçilir. # -------------------------------------------------------- selection_method = ( "best_f1_accuracy_balanced_accuracy" ) ranked_df = ( scan_df .sort_values( by=[ "f1", "accuracy", "balanced_accuracy", ], ascending=[ False, False, False, ], ) .copy() ) best_row = ( ranked_df.iloc[0] ) target_f1 = float( best_row[ "f1" ] ) target_accuracy = float( best_row[ "accuracy" ] ) target_balanced = float( best_row[ "balanced_accuracy" ] ) tied = ( scan_df[ np.isclose( scan_df[ "f1" ], target_f1 ) & np.isclose( scan_df[ "accuracy" ], target_accuracy ) & np.isclose( scan_df[ "balanced_accuracy" ], target_balanced ) ] ) selected_threshold = float( tied[ "threshold" ].median() ) exact_threshold = ( selected_threshold ) # ============================================================ # SELECTED THRESHOLD METRICS # ============================================================ selected_metrics = ( calculate_metrics( selected_threshold ) ) # ============================================================ # CONFUSION MATRIX # ============================================================ print( "\n" + "=" * 80 ) print( "SEÇİLEN THRESHOLD" ) print( "=" * 80 ) print( f""" Seçim yöntemi: {selection_method} Exact threshold: {exact_threshold:.6f} Final threshold: {selected_threshold:.6f} Observed negative max: {negative_max:.6f} Observed positive min: {positive_min:.6f} """ ) print( "=" * 80 ) print( "CONFUSION MATRIX" ) print( "=" * 80 ) print( f""" Predicted NEG POS Actual NEG {selected_metrics['tn']:>3} {selected_metrics['fp']:>3} Actual POS {selected_metrics['fn']:>3} {selected_metrics['tp']:>3} """ ) # ============================================================ # METRICS # ============================================================ print( "=" * 80 ) print( "FINAL METRICS" ) print( "=" * 80 ) print( f""" Accuracy : {selected_metrics['accuracy']:.6f} Precision : {selected_metrics['precision']:.6f} Recall : {selected_metrics['recall']:.6f} Specificity : {selected_metrics['specificity']:.6f} F1 : {selected_metrics['f1']:.6f} Balanced Accuracy : {selected_metrics['balanced_accuracy']:.6f} """ ) # ============================================================ # HER SORUNUN FINAL PREDICTION'I # ============================================================ df[ "predicted_type" ] = np.where( df[ "top1_similarity" ] >= selected_threshold, "positive", "negative", ) df[ "threshold_correct" ] = ( df[ "question_type" ] == df[ "predicted_type" ] ) # ============================================================ # HATALI SINIFLANDIRMALAR # ============================================================ errors_df = ( df[ ~df[ "threshold_correct" ] ] .copy() ) print( "\n" + "=" * 80 ) print( "HATALI SINIFLANDIRMALAR" ) print( "=" * 80 ) if len( errors_df ) == 0: print( "\nHatalı sınıflandırma yok." ) else: print( errors_df[ [ "question_number", "question_type", "question", "top1_similarity", "predicted_type", "top1_title", ] ] .to_string( index=False ) ) # ============================================================ # THRESHOLD'A EN YAKIN SORULAR # ============================================================ df[ "distance_to_threshold" ] = np.abs( df[ "top1_similarity" ] - selected_threshold ) closest_df = ( df .sort_values( "distance_to_threshold" ) .head(10) ) print( "\n" + "=" * 80 ) print( "THRESHOLD'A EN YAKIN 10 SORU" ) print( "=" * 80 ) print( closest_df[ [ "question_number", "question_type", "question", "top1_similarity", "distance_to_threshold", "top1_title", ] ] .to_string( index=False ) ) # ============================================================ # JSON OUTPUT # ============================================================ threshold_data = { "selected_threshold": float( selected_threshold ), "exact_threshold": float( exact_threshold ), "selection_method": ( selection_method ), "embedding_model": ( "Qwen/Qwen3-Embedding-0.6B" ), "distance_metric": ( "cosine" ), "benchmark_total": int( total_count ), "benchmark_positive": int( positive_count ), "benchmark_negative": int( negative_count ), "positive_min_similarity": float( positive_min ), "negative_max_similarity": float( negative_max ), "observed_gap": float( gap ), "metrics": { "tp": int( selected_metrics[ "tp" ] ), "tn": int( selected_metrics[ "tn" ] ), "fp": int( selected_metrics[ "fp" ] ), "fn": int( selected_metrics[ "fn" ] ), "accuracy": float( selected_metrics[ "accuracy" ] ), "precision": float( selected_metrics[ "precision" ] ), "recall": float( selected_metrics[ "recall" ] ), "specificity": float( selected_metrics[ "specificity" ] ), "f1": float( selected_metrics[ "f1" ] ), "balanced_accuracy": float( selected_metrics[ "balanced_accuracy" ] ), }, } with open( THRESHOLD_JSON_OUTPUT, "w", encoding="utf-8" ) as file: json.dump( threshold_data, file, ensure_ascii=False, indent=4, ) # ============================================================ # TXT OUTPUT # ============================================================ with open( THRESHOLD_TXT_OUTPUT, "w", encoding="utf-8" ) as file: file.write( "TURKISH MEDICAL RAG - THRESHOLD SELECTION\n" ) file.write( "=" * 60 + "\n\n" ) file.write( f"Selected threshold: " f"{selected_threshold:.6f}\n" ) file.write( f"Exact midpoint : " f"{exact_threshold:.6f}\n" ) file.write( f"Selection method : " f"{selection_method}\n\n" ) file.write( f"Positive min : " f"{positive_min:.6f}\n" ) file.write( f"Negative max : " f"{negative_max:.6f}\n" ) file.write( f"Observed gap : " f"{gap:.6f}\n\n" ) file.write( f"Accuracy : " f"{selected_metrics['accuracy']:.6f}\n" ) file.write( f"Precision : " f"{selected_metrics['precision']:.6f}\n" ) file.write( f"Recall : " f"{selected_metrics['recall']:.6f}\n" ) file.write( f"Specificity : " f"{selected_metrics['specificity']:.6f}\n" ) file.write( f"F1 : " f"{selected_metrics['f1']:.6f}\n" ) # ============================================================ # FINAL OUTPUT # ============================================================ print( "\n" + "=" * 80 ) print( "OUTPUT DOSYALARI" ) print( "=" * 80 ) print( f""" Threshold scan: {THRESHOLD_SCAN_OUTPUT} Selected threshold JSON: {THRESHOLD_JSON_OUTPUT} Selected threshold TXT: {THRESHOLD_TXT_OUTPUT} """ ) print( "=" * 80 ) print( "07 THRESHOLD SELECTION TAMAMLANDI" ) print( "=" * 80 )