country stringclasses 4
values | language stringclasses 4
values | qa_id stringlengths 38 68 | query stringclasses 340
values | response stringlengths 658 5.74k | paragraph_idx_list stringclasses 59
values | error_group_id stringlengths 41 71 | error_group stringlengths 510 19.4k | category stringclasses 67
values |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
us | en | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Create a story about an American family discussing their upcoming holiday destination during dinner. | The kitchen smelled like garlic and lemon-roasted chicken. Plates clinked, and a low hum of radio came from the counter. Outside, a late summer sky bled pink. Around the table, the Lewis family passed mashed potatoes and opinions.
“Okay, final call,” Mike said, leaning back with his coffee. “Where are we going for vac... | [0] | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_02 | {'us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_0_0_US-2_1': {'paragraph_idx_list': [0], 'detector_id': 'US-2', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'a low hum of radio', 'explanation': "The phrase sounds awkward and unnatural. A more standard and grammatically correct phrasing would be 'the low hum of the radio'.", 'ra... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error', 'Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Create a story about an American family discussing their upcoming holiday destination during dinner. | The kitchen smelled like garlic and lemon-roasted chicken. Plates clinked, and a low hum of radio came from the counter. Outside, a late summer sky bled pink. Around the table, the Lewis family passed mashed potatoes and opinions.
“Okay, final call,” Mike said, leaning back with his coffee. “Where are we going for vac... | [6] | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_03 | {'us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_6_6_gemini-3-pro-preview_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [6], 'detector_id': 'gemini-3-pro-preview', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'the boy’s slides', 'explanation': "It is unnatural for an American father to refer to his son as 'the boy' in the third person while speaki... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Create a story about an American family discussing their upcoming holiday destination during dinner. | The kitchen smelled like garlic and lemon-roasted chicken. Plates clinked, and a low hum of radio came from the counter. Outside, a late summer sky bled pink. Around the table, the Lewis family passed mashed potatoes and opinions.
“Okay, final call,” Mike said, leaning back with his coffee. “Where are we going for vac... | [7] | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_04 | {'us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_7_7_US-6_7': {'paragraph_idx_list': [7], 'detector_id': 'US-6', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'vinyl shops', 'explanation': 'The phrase "vinyl shops" sounds unnatural in American English; a native speaker would typically refer to them as "record stores".', 'raw_anno... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Create a story about an American family discussing their upcoming holiday destination during dinner. | The kitchen smelled like garlic and lemon-roasted chicken. Plates clinked, and a low hum of radio came from the counter. Outside, a late summer sky bled pink. Around the table, the Lewis family passed mashed potatoes and opinions.
“Okay, final call,” Mike said, leaning back with his coffee. “Where are we going for vac... | [7] | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_05 | {'us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_7_7_gpt-5.1-2025-11-13_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [7], 'detector_id': 'gpt-5.1-2025-11-13', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'one of Dad’s ‘scenic routes’ that add', 'explanation': 'There is a subject-verb agreement error. The phrase refers to "one of Dad’s ‘scenic rou... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Create a story about an American family discussing their upcoming holiday destination during dinner. | The kitchen smelled like garlic and lemon-roasted chicken. Plates clinked, and a low hum of radio came from the counter. Outside, a late summer sky bled pink. Around the table, the Lewis family passed mashed potatoes and opinions.
“Okay, final call,” Mike said, leaning back with his coffee. “Where are we going for vac... | [11] | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_06 | {'us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_11_11_US-6_8': {'paragraph_idx_list': [11], 'detector_id': 'US-6', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'vinyl shop', 'explanation': "In American English, the term 'record store' is much more idiomatic and commonly used than 'vinyl shop'. Given that the story is specifical... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Create a story about an American family discussing their upcoming holiday destination during dinner. | The kitchen smelled like garlic and lemon-roasted chicken. Plates clinked, and a low hum of radio came from the counter. Outside, a late summer sky bled pink. Around the table, the Lewis family passed mashed potatoes and opinions.
“Okay, final call,” Mike said, leaning back with his coffee. “Where are we going for vac... | [12] | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_07 | {'us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_12_12_US-6_9': {'paragraph_idx_list': [12], 'detector_id': 'US-6', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Sarah made a pros and cons list on a napkin', 'explanation': 'It is logically inconsistent and impractical for Sarah to write a pros and cons list on a napkin, as earli... | ['Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Create a story about an American family discussing their upcoming holiday destination during dinner. | The kitchen smelled like garlic and lemon-roasted chicken. Plates clinked, and a low hum of radio came from the counter. Outside, a late summer sky bled pink. Around the table, the Lewis family passed mashed potatoes and opinions.
“Okay, final call,” Mike said, leaning back with his coffee. “Where are we going for vac... | [12] | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_08 | {'us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_12_12_US-6_10': {'paragraph_idx_list': [12], 'detector_id': 'US-6', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Plates were cleared', 'explanation': 'The sequencing of events is illogical. The plates are cleared after Mike brings his laptop to the dinner table and Sarah writes o... | ['Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Create a story about an American family discussing their upcoming holiday destination during dinner. | The kitchen smelled like garlic and lemon-roasted chicken. Plates clinked, and a low hum of radio came from the counter. Outside, a late summer sky bled pink. Around the table, the Lewis family passed mashed potatoes and opinions.
“Okay, final call,” Mike said, leaning back with his coffee. “Where are we going for vac... | [13] | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_09 | {'us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_13_13_US-6_11': {'paragraph_idx_list': [13], 'detector_id': 'US-6', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'By the time dessert arrived,', 'explanation': "The use of the word 'arrived' implies that the family is dining at a restaurant and being served by a waiter. Since the ... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Create a story about an American family discussing their upcoming holiday destination during dinner. | The kitchen smelled like garlic and lemon-roasted chicken. Plates clinked, and a low hum of radio came from the counter. Outside, a late summer sky bled pink. Around the table, the Lewis family passed mashed potatoes and opinions.
“Okay, final call,” Mike said, leaning back with his coffee. “Where are we going for vac... | [13] | us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_10 | {'us_story-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_13_13_US-2_3': {'paragraph_idx_list': [13], 'detector_id': 'US-2', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'a holiday', 'explanation': "In American English, a leisure trip is typically referred to as a 'vacation,' whereas 'holiday' is generally reserved for specific festive d... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Create a narrative about an American parent of young children, describing the location they chose for a weekend outing and their day at that place. | We woke to a clear Saturday and a weather app promising mid‑70s — perfect for the plan I'd been muttering about all week. I loaded the SUV with a cooler, two sunscreens, a diaper bag that felt heavier than it should have, a folded blanket, and the wagon the kids insist is “our chariot.” Emma, three, packed her stuffed ... | [2] | us_story-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_00 | {'us_story-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_US-6_4': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'US-6', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'a crown for his shoes', 'explanation': "The phrase creates confusing and unnatural imagery. In the context of a child playing with sand, it is difficult to logically visua... | ['Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Create a narrative about an American parent of young children, describing the location they chose for a weekend outing and their day at that place. | We woke to a clear Saturday and a weather app promising mid‑70s — perfect for the plan I'd been muttering about all week. I loaded the SUV with a cooler, two sunscreens, a diaper bag that felt heavier than it should have, a folded blanket, and the wagon the kids insist is “our chariot.” Emma, three, packed her stuffed ... | [2] | us_story-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_01 | {'us_story-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_US-6_5': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'US-6', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'coordinate a sandcastle', 'explanation': 'The word "coordinate" is an unnatural and incorrect verb choice in this context. While people can coordinate efforts or activitie... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a diary entry from the perspective of an American son or daughter preparing gifts for their parents whom they are visiting after a long time. | June 12
I can hardly believe I'm finally doing this — bags half‑packed, tickets printed, and a stack of small things on my kitchen table like a miniature shrine to home. It's been three years since I moved for work, and every phone call and photo has felt like a tiny bridge. Tomorrow I cross the whole bridge in one go... | [1] | us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_00 | {'us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_1_1_US-7_1': {'paragraph_idx_list': [1], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'every phone call and photo has felt like a tiny bridge. Tomorrow I cross the whole bridge in one go.', 'explanation': "The metaphor comparing a phone call or photo to a 't... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a diary entry from the perspective of an American son or daughter preparing gifts for their parents whom they are visiting after a long time. | June 12
I can hardly believe I'm finally doing this — bags half‑packed, tickets printed, and a stack of small things on my kitchen table like a miniature shrine to home. It's been three years since I moved for work, and every phone call and photo has felt like a tiny bridge. Tomorrow I cross the whole bridge in one go... | [1] | us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_01 | {'us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_1_1_US-4_1': {'paragraph_idx_list': [1], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Tomorrow I cross the whole bridge in one go.', 'explanation': "The phrase is overly wordy. Using a more concise expression, such as 'Tomorrow I cross the bridge.', would i... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a diary entry from the perspective of an American son or daughter preparing gifts for their parents whom they are visiting after a long time. | June 12
I can hardly believe I'm finally doing this — bags half‑packed, tickets printed, and a stack of small things on my kitchen table like a miniature shrine to home. It's been three years since I moved for work, and every phone call and photo has felt like a tiny bridge. Tomorrow I cross the whole bridge in one go... | [2] | us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_02 | {'us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_US-7_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Gifts feel oddly important, more than presents.', 'explanation': 'The words "gifts" and "presents" are direct synonyms in English. Because the text does not follow up to e... | ['Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a diary entry from the perspective of an American son or daughter preparing gifts for their parents whom they are visiting after a long time. | June 12
I can hardly believe I'm finally doing this — bags half‑packed, tickets printed, and a stack of small things on my kitchen table like a miniature shrine to home. It's been three years since I moved for work, and every phone call and photo has felt like a tiny bridge. Tomorrow I cross the whole bridge in one go... | [2, 4] | us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_03 | {'us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_4_US-4_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2, 4], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'says: I', 'explanation': "The annotator suggests replacing the colon with a comma, which is the conventional punctuation used after verbs like 'says' to introduce a bri... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a diary entry from the perspective of an American son or daughter preparing gifts for their parents whom they are visiting after a long time. | June 12
I can hardly believe I'm finally doing this — bags half‑packed, tickets printed, and a stack of small things on my kitchen table like a miniature shrine to home. It's been three years since I moved for work, and every phone call and photo has felt like a tiny bridge. Tomorrow I cross the whole bridge in one go... | [3, 4] | us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_04 | {'us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_3_4_US-4_3': {'paragraph_idx_list': [3, 4], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'says:', 'explanation': 'The colon should be replaced with a comma to properly introduce the short, informal thought or statement that follows.', 'raw_annotation': '{"er... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a diary entry from the perspective of an American son or daughter preparing gifts for their parents whom they are visiting after a long time. | June 12
I can hardly believe I'm finally doing this — bags half‑packed, tickets printed, and a stack of small things on my kitchen table like a miniature shrine to home. It's been three years since I moved for work, and every phone call and photo has felt like a tiny bridge. Tomorrow I cross the whole bridge in one go... | [3] | us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_05 | {'us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_3_3_US-4_4': {'paragraph_idx_list': [3], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Midwest', 'explanation': 'The word "Midwest" does not need to be capitalized in this context and should be written in lowercase as "midwest".', 'raw_annotation': '{"error_... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a diary entry from the perspective of an American son or daughter preparing gifts for their parents whom they are visiting after a long time. | June 12
I can hardly believe I'm finally doing this — bags half‑packed, tickets printed, and a stack of small things on my kitchen table like a miniature shrine to home. It's been three years since I moved for work, and every phone call and photo has felt like a tiny bridge. Tomorrow I cross the whole bridge in one go... | [4] | us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_06 | {'us_story-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_4_4_US-4_5': {'paragraph_idx_list': [4], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': ', 20 prints', 'explanation': "The annotator suggests replacing the comma with a period to split the text into two sentences, and spelling out the number '20' as 'Twenty' s... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I want to rebrand a lesser-known small town in the United States as a family travel destination. Plan some killer contents. | Great — here’s a compact, ready-to-execute content plan to rebrand a small town as a family travel destination. Customize details to your town’s unique assets (parks, festivals, history, farms, museums).
**Campaign name**
- “[Town] Family Getaway” (or “[Town] for Little Explorers”); hashtag: #FamilyFinds[Town]
**Co... | [0] | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_00 | {'us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_0_0_gpt-5.1-2025-11-13_1': {'paragraph_idx_list': [0], 'detector_id': 'gpt-5.1-2025-11-13', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'Customize details to', 'explanation': "This phrasing is slightly unidiomatic in English. A more natural construction would be 'Customize the det... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I want to rebrand a lesser-known small town in the United States as a family travel destination. Plan some killer contents. | Great — here’s a compact, ready-to-execute content plan to rebrand a small town as a family travel destination. Customize details to your town’s unique assets (parks, festivals, history, farms, museums).
**Campaign name**
- “[Town] Family Getaway” (or “[Town] for Little Explorers”); hashtag: #FamilyFinds[Town]
**Co... | [2] | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_01 | {'us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_US-4_1': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'farmers’', 'explanation': 'The apostrophe is unnecessary. In this context, "farmers" functions as an attributive noun rather than a possessive one, so it is often preferred... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I want to rebrand a lesser-known small town in the United States as a family travel destination. Plan some killer contents. | Great — here’s a compact, ready-to-execute content plan to rebrand a small town as a family travel destination. Customize details to your town’s unique assets (parks, festivals, history, farms, museums).
**Campaign name**
- “[Town] Family Getaway” (or “[Town] for Little Explorers”); hashtag: #FamilyFinds[Town]
**Co... | [3] | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_02 | {'us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_3_3_US-1_1': {'paragraph_idx_list': [3], 'detector_id': 'US-1', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'killer examples', 'explanation': 'The phrase "killer examples" feels awkward and out of place, as it clashes with the professional and family-friendly tone maintained throu... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I want to rebrand a lesser-known small town in the United States as a family travel destination. Plan some killer contents. | Great — here’s a compact, ready-to-execute content plan to rebrand a small town as a family travel destination. Customize details to your town’s unique assets (parks, festivals, history, farms, museums).
**Campaign name**
- “[Town] Family Getaway” (or “[Town] for Little Explorers”); hashtag: #FamilyFinds[Town]
**Co... | [3] | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_03 | {'us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_3_3_US-1_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [3], 'detector_id': 'US-1', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Mini‑doc', 'explanation': "The abbreviation 'Mini‑doc' introduces an informal tone that clashes with the professional terminology used in the rest of the response. Expandin... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I want to rebrand a lesser-known small town in the United States as a family travel destination. Plan some killer contents. | Great — here’s a compact, ready-to-execute content plan to rebrand a small town as a family travel destination. Customize details to your town’s unique assets (parks, festivals, history, farms, museums).
**Campaign name**
- “[Town] Family Getaway” (or “[Town] for Little Explorers”); hashtag: #FamilyFinds[Town]
**Co... | [4] | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_04 | {'us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_4_4_US-4_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [4], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'fam‑trip', 'explanation': "The term 'fam‑trip' is ambiguous and confusing in this context. While it may be intended as a 'FAM trip' (a familiarization trip, which is standa... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I want to rebrand a lesser-known small town in the United States as a family travel destination. Plan some killer contents. | Great — here’s a compact, ready-to-execute content plan to rebrand a small town as a family travel destination. Customize details to your town’s unique assets (parks, festivals, history, farms, museums).
**Campaign name**
- “[Town] Family Getaway” (or “[Town] for Little Explorers”); hashtag: #FamilyFinds[Town]
**Co... | [5] | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_05 | {'us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_5_5_gpt-5.1-2025-11-13_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [5], 'detector_id': 'gpt-5.1-2025-11-13', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': '1–6‑hour drive radius', 'explanation': 'The phrase mixes a time-based measure (hours of driving) with a spatial term (radius), which is conceptu... | ['Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I want to rebrand a lesser-known small town in the United States as a family travel destination. Plan some killer contents. | Great — here’s a compact, ready-to-execute content plan to rebrand a small town as a family travel destination. Customize details to your town’s unique assets (parks, festivals, history, farms, museums).
**Campaign name**
- “[Town] Family Getaway” (or “[Town] for Little Explorers”); hashtag: #FamilyFinds[Town]
**Co... | [6] | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_06 | {'us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_6_6_gpt-5.1-2025-11-13_3': {'paragraph_idx_list': [6], 'detector_id': 'gpt-5.1-2025-11-13', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'with hashtag for prize.', 'explanation': 'This phrase is slightly ungrammatical and lacks necessary articles. In standard English, it should be ... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I want to rebrand a lesser-known small town in the United States as a family travel destination. Plan some killer contents. | Great — here’s a compact, ready-to-execute content plan to rebrand a small town as a family travel destination. Customize details to your town’s unique assets (parks, festivals, history, farms, museums).
**Campaign name**
- “[Town] Family Getaway” (or “[Town] for Little Explorers”); hashtag: #FamilyFinds[Town]
**Co... | [7] | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_07 | {'us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_7_7_US-1_3': {'paragraph_idx_list': [7], 'detector_id': 'US-1', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'measure what matters', 'explanation': "The phrase is vague and fails to clearly define the acronym KPI. A more precise phrasing, such as 'key performance indicators to meas... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I want to rebrand a lesser-known small town in the United States as a family travel destination. Plan some killer contents. | Great — here’s a compact, ready-to-execute content plan to rebrand a small town as a family travel destination. Customize details to your town’s unique assets (parks, festivals, history, farms, museums).
**Campaign name**
- “[Town] Family Getaway” (or “[Town] for Little Explorers”); hashtag: #FamilyFinds[Town]
**Co... | [8] | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_08 | {'us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_8_8_US-4_4': {'paragraph_idx_list': [8], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'fam‑trip', 'explanation': 'The term "fam" is used here as an industry abbreviation for "familiarization." However, in the context of a campaign focused on family travel, th... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I want to rebrand a lesser-known small town in the United States as a family travel destination. Plan some killer contents. | Great — here’s a compact, ready-to-execute content plan to rebrand a small town as a family travel destination. Customize details to your town’s unique assets (parks, festivals, history, farms, museums).
**Campaign name**
- “[Town] Family Getaway” (or “[Town] for Little Explorers”); hashtag: #FamilyFinds[Town]
**Co... | [8] | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_09 | {'us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_8_8_US-1_4': {'paragraph_idx_list': [8], 'detector_id': 'US-1', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'fam‑trip', 'explanation': 'The abbreviation "fam‑trip" is inappropriately casual in the context of a professional marketing plan. It should be written out as "family trip" ... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I want to rebrand a lesser-known small town in the United States as a family travel destination. Plan some killer contents. | Great — here’s a compact, ready-to-execute content plan to rebrand a small town as a family travel destination. Customize details to your town’s unique assets (parks, festivals, history, farms, museums).
**Campaign name**
- “[Town] Family Getaway” (or “[Town] for Little Explorers”); hashtag: #FamilyFinds[Town]
**Co... | [8] | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_10 | {'us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_8_8_US-1_5': {'paragraph_idx_list': [8], 'detector_id': 'US-1', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Want a week‑by‑week content calendar or a sample hero video script?', 'explanation': 'This closing question is overly conversational and casual, which disrupts the professi... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I want to rebrand a lesser-known small town in the United States as a family travel destination. Plan some killer contents. | Great — here’s a compact, ready-to-execute content plan to rebrand a small town as a family travel destination. Customize details to your town’s unique assets (parks, festivals, history, farms, museums).
**Campaign name**
- “[Town] Family Getaway” (or “[Town] for Little Explorers”); hashtag: #FamilyFinds[Town]
**Co... | [8] | us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_11 | {'us_idea-family-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_8_8_gpt-5.1-2025-11-13_5': {'paragraph_idx_list': [8], 'detector_id': 'gpt-5.1-2025-11-13', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'Want a week‑by‑week content calendar or a sample hero video script?', 'explanation': "This sentence is a fragment missing an explicit subject an... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning a business idea that American families can enjoy together on weekends with their children. Suggest 3 specific ideas targeting families with elementary school-aged children. | Here are three concrete weekend business ideas for American families with elementary‑aged children. Each includes what you do, why it works, sample pricing, ops and growth ideas.
1) Family STEM Maker Lab (hands‑on projects parents & kids build together)
- Concept: 90‑minute themed sessions (robots, simple woodworkin... | [0] | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_00 | {'us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_0_0_US-3_1': {'paragraph_idx_list': [0], 'detector_id': 'US-3', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'ops', 'explanation': 'The term "ops" is business jargon that may be difficult for a general audience to understand. It should be expanded to "operations" to ensure clarity.... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning a business idea that American families can enjoy together on weekends with their children. Suggest 3 specific ideas targeting families with elementary school-aged children. | Here are three concrete weekend business ideas for American families with elementary‑aged children. Each includes what you do, why it works, sample pricing, ops and growth ideas.
1) Family STEM Maker Lab (hands‑on projects parents & kids build together)
- Concept: 90‑minute themed sessions (robots, simple woodworkin... | [1] | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_01 | {'us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_1_1_US-1_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [1], 'detector_id': 'US-1', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Ops', 'explanation': 'The term "Ops" is an abbreviation or shorthand. In this context, the full word "Operations" should be used instead.', 'raw_annotation': '{"error_span"... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning a business idea that American families can enjoy together on weekends with their children. Suggest 3 specific ideas targeting families with elementary school-aged children. | Here are three concrete weekend business ideas for American families with elementary‑aged children. Each includes what you do, why it works, sample pricing, ops and growth ideas.
1) Family STEM Maker Lab (hands‑on projects parents & kids build together)
- Concept: 90‑minute themed sessions (robots, simple woodworkin... | [1] | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_02 | {'us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_1_1_US-1_3': {'paragraph_idx_list': [1], 'detector_id': 'US-1', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Tools kid‑safe', 'explanation': 'The phrasing is awkward and unnatural. It should be reversed to "kid-safe tools" to follow standard English adjective-noun word order.', 'r... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning a business idea that American families can enjoy together on weekends with their children. Suggest 3 specific ideas targeting families with elementary school-aged children. | Here are three concrete weekend business ideas for American families with elementary‑aged children. Each includes what you do, why it works, sample pricing, ops and growth ideas.
1) Family STEM Maker Lab (hands‑on projects parents & kids build together)
- Concept: 90‑minute themed sessions (robots, simple woodworkin... | [1] | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_03 | {'us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_1_1_US-1_4': {'paragraph_idx_list': [1], 'detector_id': 'US-1', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'PPE', 'explanation': 'The abbreviation "PPE" is used without prior definition. For better clarity, it should be written out as "Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)" before ... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning a business idea that American families can enjoy together on weekends with their children. Suggest 3 specific ideas targeting families with elementary school-aged children. | Here are three concrete weekend business ideas for American families with elementary‑aged children. Each includes what you do, why it works, sample pricing, ops and growth ideas.
1) Family STEM Maker Lab (hands‑on projects parents & kids build together)
- Concept: 90‑minute themed sessions (robots, simple woodworkin... | [1] | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_04 | {'us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_1_1_US-1_5': {'paragraph_idx_list': [1], 'detector_id': 'US-1', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'PTA', 'explanation': 'The abbreviation "PTA" is used without being spelled out first. Although it is a common term in the US, it may be unfamiliar to international readers.... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning a business idea that American families can enjoy together on weekends with their children. Suggest 3 specific ideas targeting families with elementary school-aged children. | Here are three concrete weekend business ideas for American families with elementary‑aged children. Each includes what you do, why it works, sample pricing, ops and growth ideas.
1) Family STEM Maker Lab (hands‑on projects parents & kids build together)
- Concept: 90‑minute themed sessions (robots, simple woodworkin... | [2] | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_05 | {'us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_US-1_7': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'US-1', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Ops', 'explanation': "The abbreviation 'Ops' is overly informal for this context and should be spelled out fully as 'Operations' for better clarity and professionalism.", '... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning a business idea that American families can enjoy together on weekends with their children. Suggest 3 specific ideas targeting families with elementary school-aged children. | Here are three concrete weekend business ideas for American families with elementary‑aged children. Each includes what you do, why it works, sample pricing, ops and growth ideas.
1) Family STEM Maker Lab (hands‑on projects parents & kids build together)
- Concept: 90‑minute themed sessions (robots, simple woodworkin... | [2] | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_06 | {'us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_gpt-5.1-2025-11-13_1': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'gpt-5.1-2025-11-13', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'Fresh air, movement, low cost, appeals to a wide geographic area and seasonal repeat customers.', 'explanation': "The list mixes noun phrases ('... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning a business idea that American families can enjoy together on weekends with their children. Suggest 3 specific ideas targeting families with elementary school-aged children. | Here are three concrete weekend business ideas for American families with elementary‑aged children. Each includes what you do, why it works, sample pricing, ops and growth ideas.
1) Family STEM Maker Lab (hands‑on projects parents & kids build together)
- Concept: 90‑minute themed sessions (robots, simple woodworkin... | [3] | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_07 | {'us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_3_3_US-3_6': {'paragraph_idx_list': [3], 'detector_id': 'US-3', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'add wine for adults as an upsell.', 'explanation': 'Suggesting wine as an upsell is inappropriate for a family-oriented cooking class targeting elementary school-aged child... | ['Cultural Incoherence'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning a business idea that American families can enjoy together on weekends with their children. Suggest 3 specific ideas targeting families with elementary school-aged children. | Here are three concrete weekend business ideas for American families with elementary‑aged children. Each includes what you do, why it works, sample pricing, ops and growth ideas.
1) Family STEM Maker Lab (hands‑on projects parents & kids build together)
- Concept: 90‑minute themed sessions (robots, simple woodworkin... | [3] | us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_08 | {'us_idea-family-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_3_3_US-1_8': {'paragraph_idx_list': [3], 'detector_id': 'US-1', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Ops', 'explanation': 'The abbreviation "Ops" is used instead of the full word "Operations." To maintain stylistic consistency with the other fully spelled-out categories in... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm looking to start a business based on gifts that American parents would like. Recommend three specific business ideas. | Here are three specific, actionable gift-business ideas aimed at American parents — each includes what it is, why it’ll sell, a revenue model, and quick launch steps.
1) Monthly Milestone & Keepsake Subscription (Baby + Parent Editions)
- What: A subscription box delivered monthly for the baby’s first year (or toddl... | [2] | us_idea-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_00 | {'us_idea-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_gpt-5.1-2025-11-13_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'gpt-5.1-2025-11-13', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'helps maintain couple connection', 'explanation': 'This phrase is grammatically awkward in standard English. A more natural expression would be ... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm looking to start a business based on gifts that American parents would like. Recommend three specific business ideas. | Here are three specific, actionable gift-business ideas aimed at American parents — each includes what it is, why it’ll sell, a revenue model, and quick launch steps.
1) Monthly Milestone & Keepsake Subscription (Baby + Parent Editions)
- What: A subscription box delivered monthly for the baby’s first year (or toddl... | [2] | us_idea-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_01 | {'us_idea-family-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_gpt-5.1-2025-11-13_3': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'gpt-5.1-2025-11-13', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'subscription quarterly refreshes', 'explanation': 'The phrase is unnatural and confusing because of the word "refreshes." A subscription already... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Today was the day the United States played a sports match against a rival country. Write a detailed diary entry from the perspective of someone who watched the game. | November 28, 2025
I still can’t feel my knees. I watched the whole thing from the edge of the couch like a spectator at the edge of a cliff — heart in my throat, fingers clenched until they tingled. Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battleg... | [1] | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_00 | {'us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_1_1_US-4_1': {'paragraph_idx_list': [1], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battlegrounds for three hours.', 'explanation': "The annot... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Today was the day the United States played a sports match against a rival country. Write a detailed diary entry from the perspective of someone who watched the game. | November 28, 2025
I still can’t feel my knees. I watched the whole thing from the edge of the couch like a spectator at the edge of a cliff — heart in my throat, fingers clenched until they tingled. Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battleg... | [2] | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_01 | {'us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_US-4_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'boxed up the chilly weather', 'explanation': "The phrase 'boxed up' is unnatural and confusing in this context. A more appropriate word choice, such as 'fought' or 'fought... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error', 'Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Today was the day the United States played a sports match against a rival country. Write a detailed diary entry from the perspective of someone who watched the game. | November 28, 2025
I still can’t feel my knees. I watched the whole thing from the edge of the couch like a spectator at the edge of a cliff — heart in my throat, fingers clenched until they tingled. Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battleg... | [2] | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_02 | {'us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_US-4_3': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'on kickoff', 'explanation': "The preposition 'on' is incorrectly used in this context. The standard phrase is 'at kickoff,' which indicates the specific time the game star... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Today was the day the United States played a sports match against a rival country. Write a detailed diary entry from the perspective of someone who watched the game. | November 28, 2025
I still can’t feel my knees. I watched the whole thing from the edge of the couch like a spectator at the edge of a cliff — heart in my throat, fingers clenched until they tingled. Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battleg... | [3] | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_03 | {'us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_3_3_US-7_3': {'paragraph_idx_list': [3], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'a small death and escape.', 'explanation': 'The phrase is an uncommon rhetorical device in American English. It sounds unnatural in the context of a casual diary entry and... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Today was the day the United States played a sports match against a rival country. Write a detailed diary entry from the perspective of someone who watched the game. | November 28, 2025
I still can’t feel my knees. I watched the whole thing from the edge of the couch like a spectator at the edge of a cliff — heart in my throat, fingers clenched until they tingled. Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battleg... | [3] | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_04 | {'us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_3_3_US-4_4': {'paragraph_idx_list': [3], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'midfield', 'explanation': "The text uses the term 'midfield', but it should be changed to 'midfielder' to properly refer to a specific player on the field.", 'raw_annotati... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Today was the day the United States played a sports match against a rival country. Write a detailed diary entry from the perspective of someone who watched the game. | November 28, 2025
I still can’t feel my knees. I watched the whole thing from the edge of the couch like a spectator at the edge of a cliff — heart in my throat, fingers clenched until they tingled. Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battleg... | [3] | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_05 | {'us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_3_3_US-4_5': {'paragraph_idx_list': [3], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': '37th minute', 'explanation': "The time of the event is expressed using an ordinal phrase, but the annotator suggests it should be formatted as a numerical timestamp (e.g.,... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Today was the day the United States played a sports match against a rival country. Write a detailed diary entry from the perspective of someone who watched the game. | November 28, 2025
I still can’t feel my knees. I watched the whole thing from the edge of the couch like a spectator at the edge of a cliff — heart in my throat, fingers clenched until they tingled. Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battleg... | [4] | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_06 | {'us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_4_4_US-7_4': {'paragraph_idx_list': [4], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'a river of chances', 'explanation': 'The phrase "a river of chances" is an uncommon and awkward metaphor, and the text does not provide any subsequent context to justify i... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Today was the day the United States played a sports match against a rival country. Write a detailed diary entry from the perspective of someone who watched the game. | November 28, 2025
I still can’t feel my knees. I watched the whole thing from the edge of the couch like a spectator at the edge of a cliff — heart in my throat, fingers clenched until they tingled. Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battleg... | [4] | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_07 | {'us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_4_4_US-7_5': {'paragraph_idx_list': [4], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'minutes of sand falling.', 'explanation': 'The phrase "minutes of sand falling" is an unnatural and uncommon expression in American English. A native speaker would more co... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error', 'Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Today was the day the United States played a sports match against a rival country. Write a detailed diary entry from the perspective of someone who watched the game. | November 28, 2025
I still can’t feel my knees. I watched the whole thing from the edge of the couch like a spectator at the edge of a cliff — heart in my throat, fingers clenched until they tingled. Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battleg... | [4] | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_08 | {'us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_4_4_US-4_6': {'paragraph_idx_list': [4], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'back; there', 'explanation': "The semicolon is flagged as incorrect punctuation. It should be replaced with a period to separate the clauses into two distinct sentences, r... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Today was the day the United States played a sports match against a rival country. Write a detailed diary entry from the perspective of someone who watched the game. | November 28, 2025
I still can’t feel my knees. I watched the whole thing from the edge of the couch like a spectator at the edge of a cliff — heart in my throat, fingers clenched until they tingled. Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battleg... | [4] | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_09 | {'us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_4_4_US-4_7': {'paragraph_idx_list': [4], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': '78th minute', 'explanation': "The time of the event is written in a descriptive format ('78th minute'), but it should be expressed as a numerical timestamp ('78:00').", 'r... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Today was the day the United States played a sports match against a rival country. Write a detailed diary entry from the perspective of someone who watched the game. | November 28, 2025
I still can’t feel my knees. I watched the whole thing from the edge of the couch like a spectator at the edge of a cliff — heart in my throat, fingers clenched until they tingled. Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battleg... | [5] | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_10 | {'us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_5_5_US-7_6': {'paragraph_idx_list': [5], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'sat bolt upright', 'explanation': "The phrase 'sat bolt upright' is considered by the annotator to be an uncommon expression. A more natural and frequently used variation ... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Today was the day the United States played a sports match against a rival country. Write a detailed diary entry from the perspective of someone who watched the game. | November 28, 2025
I still can’t feel my knees. I watched the whole thing from the edge of the couch like a spectator at the edge of a cliff — heart in my throat, fingers clenched until they tingled. Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battleg... | [5] | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_11 | {'us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_5_5_US-7_7': {'paragraph_idx_list': [5], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'tiny explosions of relief', 'explanation': "The use of the word 'explosions' is flagged as an unnatural word choice because it is typically reserved for physical, tangible... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Today was the day the United States played a sports match against a rival country. Write a detailed diary entry from the perspective of someone who watched the game. | November 28, 2025
I still can’t feel my knees. I watched the whole thing from the edge of the couch like a spectator at the edge of a cliff — heart in my throat, fingers clenched until they tingled. Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battleg... | [5] | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_12 | {'us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_5_5_US-7_8': {'paragraph_idx_list': [5], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'The whole building sounded like it was going to lift off.', 'explanation': "This sentence is awkwardly phrased. The structure 'The [subject] sounded like it was going to [... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Today was the day the United States played a sports match against a rival country. Write a detailed diary entry from the perspective of someone who watched the game. | November 28, 2025
I still can’t feel my knees. I watched the whole thing from the edge of the couch like a spectator at the edge of a cliff — heart in my throat, fingers clenched until they tingled. Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battleg... | [5] | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_13 | {'us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_5_5_US-4_8': {'paragraph_idx_list': [5], 'detector_id': 'US-4', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'We went in order', 'explanation': "The phrase 'We went in order' is awkwardly worded in this context. Because it is immediately followed by a list of feelings ('joy, disap... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Today was the day the United States played a sports match against a rival country. Write a detailed diary entry from the perspective of someone who watched the game. | November 28, 2025
I still can’t feel my knees. I watched the whole thing from the edge of the couch like a spectator at the edge of a cliff — heart in my throat, fingers clenched until they tingled. Today was the day: USA vs. our oldest rival, the kind of match that turns living rooms, bars, and sidewalks into battleg... | [6] | us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_14 | {'us_story-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_6_6_gemini-3-pro-preview_4': {'paragraph_idx_list': [6], 'detector_id': 'gemini-3-pro-preview', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'more aching', 'explanation': "The phrase 'more aching' is an unnatural collocation in English when describing the feeling of losses. A nati... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [0] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_00 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_0_0_US-7_1': {'paragraph_idx_list': [0], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'its yawning ring', 'explanation': 'The phrase "yawning ring" is an unusual and unnatural word choice to describe the sound of a school bell.', 'raw_annotation': '{"error_s... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [0] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_01 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_0_0_US-7_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [0], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link', 'explanation': 'The imagery in this clause is confusing and redundant, as it describes backpacks forming a "fence" al... | ['Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [0] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_02 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_0_0_US-7_4': {'paragraph_idx_list': [0], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'cleats have chewed them into ragged moons', 'explanation': "The phrase is an example of purple prose that relies on an unusual and overwrought metaphor. Describing grass a... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [0] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_03 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_0_0_US-7_5': {'paragraph_idx_list': [0], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Kids run like they are trying to outrun the bell.', 'explanation': "The phrase relies on a logically and physically flawed simile. Since humans cannot outrun the speed of ... | ['Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [0] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_04 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_0_0_gpt-5.1-2025-11-13_1': {'paragraph_idx_list': [0], 'detector_id': 'gpt-5.1-2025-11-13', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'by the time lunch bell', 'explanation': 'In standard English, a singular, countable noun like "bell" usually takes an article. It would be more... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [1] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_05 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_1_1_US-7_6': {'paragraph_idx_list': [1], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'a chorus of shouts that sound like both an invitation and an order.', 'explanation': 'The wording is confusing because comparing the shouts to both "an invitation and an o... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [1] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_06 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_1_1_US-7_7': {'paragraph_idx_list': [1], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Sixth grade has different names for the moments she wants—center, picked, seen—and she knows them all and how they rarely include her.', 'explanation': 'While the general ... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [2] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_07 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_US-7_8': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'It hits the metal bench and thumps back, rolling to Lena’s feet.', 'explanation': 'The physical mechanics described in the sentence are confusing and difficult to visualiz... | ['Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [2] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_08 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_US-7_25': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'teenage blur', 'explanation': 'The adjective "teenage" is an unnatural modifier for the noun "blur," as a blur cannot inherently possess an age. It would be more appropri... | ['Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [3] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_09 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_3_3_US-7_9': {'paragraph_idx_list': [3], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'smelling like dust and feet.', 'explanation': 'It is unclear how the protagonist is able to smell the soccer ball simply by placing her hand on it. The description lacks t... | ['Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [3] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_10 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_3_3_gemini-3-pro-preview_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [3], 'detector_id': 'gemini-3-pro-preview', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'you are going to sit', 'explanation': "In informal spoken American English, especially among middle schoolers playing sports, contractions ... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [4] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_11 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_4_4_US-7_10': {'paragraph_idx_list': [4], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'the scrape of his voice is softer now', 'explanation': 'The word "scrape" carries a harsh, abrasive connotation that conflicts with the narrator\'s observation that the b... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [4] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_12 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_4_4_US-7_11': {'paragraph_idx_list': [4], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': "there's a sliver of waiting.", 'explanation': 'The phrase "a sliver of waiting" is overly abstract and confusing. It fails to clearly communicate what the character is ob... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [5] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_13 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_5_5_US-7_12': {'paragraph_idx_list': [5], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': "“All right,” she says. She can't remember the last time she said yes to anything that wasn't pre‑measured and labeled.", 'explanation': 'The narrative treats the characte... | ['Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [6] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_14 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_6_6_US-7_13': {'paragraph_idx_list': [6], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'The game shifts as if someone has pushed a pebble.', 'explanation': 'The simile used here is awkward and confusing. It fails to effectively communicate meaningful informa... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error', 'Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [6] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_15 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_6_6_US-7_14': {'paragraph_idx_list': [6], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'knees remembering how to move', 'explanation': 'The phrase is awkward and unnatural. While intended to be metaphorical, it is a clunky and unusual way to describe a chara... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [6] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_16 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_6_6_US-7_15': {'paragraph_idx_list': [6], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': "Someone calls her name—it's Mateo, who teased her about her math paper last week—throwing it like a test.", 'explanation': "The phrase 'throwing it like a test' is a conf... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error', 'Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [7] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_17 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_7_7_US-7_16': {'paragraph_idx_list': [7], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'her ankle snaps', 'explanation': 'The word "snaps" is a poor word choice in this context. While intended to describe a quick, sharp movement to kick the ball, it carries ... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [7] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_18 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_7_7_US-7_17': {'paragraph_idx_list': [7], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'old, frayed, more sag than taut', 'explanation': 'The phrase uses overly artistic and unnecessary imagery (purple prose) to describe the soccer net, which feels excessive... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [7] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_19 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_7_7_US-7_18': {'paragraph_idx_list': [7], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'For half a heartbeat', 'explanation': 'The phrase "half a heartbeat" is unusually worded. In creative writing, a "heartbeat" is typically used as the smallest metaphorica... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [7] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_20 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_7_7_US-7_19': {'paragraph_idx_list': [7], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'squeal of cleats hangs', 'explanation': "The word 'squeal' is inaccurate in this context because cleats on a grass or turf field rarely make a squealing noise, which is a... | ['Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [8] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_21 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_8_8_US-7_20': {'paragraph_idx_list': [8], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'The applesauce cup in her hand feels like a different weight.', 'explanation': 'There is a logical inconsistency in the narrative: the text implies Lena participates in a... | ['Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [9] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_22 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_9_9_US-7_22': {'paragraph_idx_list': [9], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'They keep kicking and laughing and rearranging themselves into a new pattern where one goal can tilt the geometry of the field.', 'explanation': "The wording in this sent... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [10] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_23 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_10_10_US-7_23': {'paragraph_idx_list': [10], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'suddenly irrelevant.', 'explanation': "The narrative states that the abandoned spoon is 'suddenly irrelevant' without providing clear context or logical justification,... | ['Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a piece of fiction set on the sports field of an American middle school during lunchtime. | The sun has already baked the painted lines into the turf by the time lunch bell finishes its yawning ring. Backpacks form a crooked fence along the chain‑link, sticky juice boxes abandoned like tiny, colorful buoys. On the field, patches of grass are brown in the places cleats have chewed them into ragged moons. Kids ... | [10] | us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_24 | {'us_story-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_10_10_US-7_24': {'paragraph_idx_list': [10], 'detector_id': 'US-7', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'She tucks the ball under her arm like a small, impossible promise and thinks she might come back tomorrow.', 'explanation': 'The narrative implies that Lena takes the ... | ['Logical Error', 'Cultural Inaccuracy'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a diary entry that an American elementary school student may write on the day of their school sports day. | Dear Diary,
Today was Sports Day at school! We called it Field Day, but it was the same fun. I was so excited, I woke up early. The weather was sunny and not too hot, which was perfect.
When we got to school, everyone was wearing our team colors. I was on the blue team. We had a little opening ceremony with the princ... | [1] | us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_00 | {'us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_1_1_US-2_1': {'paragraph_idx_list': [1], 'detector_id': 'US-2', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'Today was Sports Day at school! We called it Field Day, but it was the same fun.', 'explanation': 'This phrasing is unnatural for a child\'s personal diary entry. An Ameri... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a diary entry that an American elementary school student may write on the day of their school sports day. | Dear Diary,
Today was Sports Day at school! We called it Field Day, but it was the same fun. I was so excited, I woke up early. The weather was sunny and not too hot, which was perfect.
When we got to school, everyone was wearing our team colors. I was on the blue team. We had a little opening ceremony with the princ... | [1] | us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_01 | {'us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_1_1_gemini-3-pro-preview_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [1], 'detector_id': 'gemini-3-pro-preview', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'it was the same fun', 'explanation': 'The phrase "it was the same fun" is linguistically awkward and unnatural for a native English speaker... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error', 'Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a diary entry that an American elementary school student may write on the day of their school sports day. | Dear Diary,
Today was Sports Day at school! We called it Field Day, but it was the same fun. I was so excited, I woke up early. The weather was sunny and not too hot, which was perfect.
When we got to school, everyone was wearing our team colors. I was on the blue team. We had a little opening ceremony with the princ... | [1] | us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_02 | {'us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_1_1_gpt-5.1-2025-11-13_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [1], 'detector_id': 'gpt-5.1-2025-11-13', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'I was so excited, I woke up early.', 'explanation': "This sentence uses a comma splice, joining two independent clauses with only a comma. It w... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a diary entry that an American elementary school student may write on the day of their school sports day. | Dear Diary,
Today was Sports Day at school! We called it Field Day, but it was the same fun. I was so excited, I woke up early. The weather was sunny and not too hot, which was perfect.
When we got to school, everyone was wearing our team colors. I was on the blue team. We had a little opening ceremony with the princ... | [2] | us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_03 | {'us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_gpt-5.1-2025-11-13_3': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'gpt-5.1-2025-11-13', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'everyone was wearing our team colors', 'explanation': 'The pronoun "our" is confusing here because it suggests that all students shared the sam... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a diary entry that an American elementary school student may write on the day of their school sports day. | Dear Diary,
Today was Sports Day at school! We called it Field Day, but it was the same fun. I was so excited, I woke up early. The weather was sunny and not too hot, which was perfect.
When we got to school, everyone was wearing our team colors. I was on the blue team. We had a little opening ceremony with the princ... | [4] | us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_04 | {'us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_4_4_US-6_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [4], 'detector_id': 'US-6', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'gold sticker', 'explanation': "The writer mentions winning second place in the relay race earlier in the text, but later states they received a 'gold sticker' for it. Gold... | ['Logical Error'] |
us | en | us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | Write a diary entry that an American elementary school student may write on the day of their school sports day. | Dear Diary,
Today was Sports Day at school! We called it Field Day, but it was the same fun. I was so excited, I woke up early. The weather was sunny and not too hot, which was perfect.
When we got to school, everyone was wearing our team colors. I was on the blue team. We had a little opening ceremony with the princ... | [5] | us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_05 | {'us_story-sports-3_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_5_5_US-2_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [5], 'detector_id': 'US-2', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'I might sleep early.', 'explanation': 'The phrase "I might sleep early" sounds unnatural for an American child of this age. It would be more natural for them to say "I mig... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning to film a vlog on the day of the upcoming sports match between the United States and a rival country. Help me plan the content reflecting an American culture. | Nice — here’s a compact, practical plan to film a day-of-match vlog that highlights American culture while staying respectful and engaging.
**Overall concept & tone**
- Celebratory, community‑first, upbeat. Emphasize traditions (tailgating, anthem, fandom) and sportsmanship rather than antagonism toward the rival coun... | [0] | us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_00 | {'us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_0_0_US-2_1': {'paragraph_idx_list': [0], 'detector_id': 'US-2', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'day-of-match', 'explanation': "The phrase 'day-of-match' sounds unnatural in this context. A more idiomatic phrasing would be 'match day' or 'game day'.", 'raw_annotation':... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning to film a vlog on the day of the upcoming sports match between the United States and a rival country. Help me plan the content reflecting an American culture. | Nice — here’s a compact, practical plan to film a day-of-match vlog that highlights American culture while staying respectful and engaging.
**Overall concept & tone**
- Celebratory, community‑first, upbeat. Emphasize traditions (tailgating, anthem, fandom) and sportsmanship rather than antagonism toward the rival coun... | [3] | us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_01 | {'us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_3_3_US-2_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [3], 'detector_id': 'US-2', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'making travel snacks (burger, hot dog', 'explanation': 'Burgers and hot dogs are typically considered full meals rather than portable "travel snacks." The response should s... | ['Cultural Incoherence'] |
us | en | us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning to film a vlog on the day of the upcoming sports match between the United States and a rival country. Help me plan the content reflecting an American culture. | Nice — here’s a compact, practical plan to film a day-of-match vlog that highlights American culture while staying respectful and engaging.
**Overall concept & tone**
- Celebratory, community‑first, upbeat. Emphasize traditions (tailgating, anthem, fandom) and sportsmanship rather than antagonism toward the rival coun... | [4] | us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_02 | {'us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_4_4_US-6_4': {'paragraph_idx_list': [4], 'detector_id': 'US-6', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'match day', 'explanation': "In American sports culture, the term 'game day' is much more commonly used and authentic than 'match day,' which generally has a more British or... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning to film a vlog on the day of the upcoming sports match between the United States and a rival country. Help me plan the content reflecting an American culture. | Nice — here’s a compact, practical plan to film a day-of-match vlog that highlights American culture while staying respectful and engaging.
**Overall concept & tone**
- Celebratory, community‑first, upbeat. Emphasize traditions (tailgating, anthem, fandom) and sportsmanship rather than antagonism toward the rival coun... | [4] | us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_03 | {'us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_4_4_US-6_7': {'paragraph_idx_list': [4], 'detector_id': 'US-6', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'CTA', 'explanation': 'The acronym "CTA" (Call to Action) is used without prior explanation, which can be confusing for users unfamiliar with content creation or marketing t... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning to film a vlog on the day of the upcoming sports match between the United States and a rival country. Help me plan the content reflecting an American culture. | Nice — here’s a compact, practical plan to film a day-of-match vlog that highlights American culture while staying respectful and engaging.
**Overall concept & tone**
- Celebratory, community‑first, upbeat. Emphasize traditions (tailgating, anthem, fandom) and sportsmanship rather than antagonism toward the rival coun... | [5] | us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_04 | {'us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_5_5_gemini-3-pro-preview_6': {'paragraph_idx_list': [5], 'detector_id': 'gemini-3-pro-preview', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'community chants', 'explanation': "The phrase 'community chants' is an unnatural collocation that is not standard in American sports termino... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning to film a vlog on the day of the upcoming sports match between the United States and a rival country. Help me plan the content reflecting an American culture. | Nice — here’s a compact, practical plan to film a day-of-match vlog that highlights American culture while staying respectful and engaging.
**Overall concept & tone**
- Celebratory, community‑first, upbeat. Emphasize traditions (tailgating, anthem, fandom) and sportsmanship rather than antagonism toward the rival coun... | [7] | us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_05 | {'us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_7_7_gpt-5.1-2025-11-13_3': {'paragraph_idx_list': [7], 'detector_id': 'gpt-5.1-2025-11-13', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'spare batteries/SD', 'explanation': 'The abbreviation "SD" is unclear in this context; it should be specified as "SD cards" or similar. Using on... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I'm planning to film a vlog on the day of the upcoming sports match between the United States and a rival country. Help me plan the content reflecting an American culture. | Nice — here’s a compact, practical plan to film a day-of-match vlog that highlights American culture while staying respectful and engaging.
**Overall concept & tone**
- Celebratory, community‑first, upbeat. Emphasize traditions (tailgating, anthem, fandom) and sportsmanship rather than antagonism toward the rival coun... | [8] | us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_06 | {'us_idea-sports-1_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_8_8_US-6_8': {'paragraph_idx_list': [8], 'detector_id': 'US-6', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': '#MatchDay', 'explanation': "In American sports culture, events are typically referred to as 'games' rather than 'matches' (which is more common in British English or specif... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I am a middle school teacher in the United States and I want to encourage all students to exercise during lunchtime. What kind of program would be good to organize? | Good idea — lunchtime is perfect for short, inclusive activity that builds a habit without cutting into class time. Here’s a practical, low‑cost program you can run: “Midday Move Club.”
Overview
- Goal: 20–30 minutes of fun physical activity every lunch period, with choices to suit different interests and fitness le... | [2] | us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_00 | {'us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_US-1_1': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'US-1', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'staff‑ or student‑led route around campus', 'explanation': "The phrasing uses a suspended hyphen structure ('staff- or student-led') that feels unnatural and can be difficu... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error', 'Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I am a middle school teacher in the United States and I want to encourage all students to exercise during lunchtime. What kind of program would be good to organize? | Good idea — lunchtime is perfect for short, inclusive activity that builds a habit without cutting into class time. Here’s a practical, low‑cost program you can run: “Midday Move Club.”
Overview
- Goal: 20–30 minutes of fun physical activity every lunch period, with choices to suit different interests and fitness le... | [2] | us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_01 | {'us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_US-1_4': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'US-1', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'portable equipment', 'explanation': 'The phrase "portable equipment" is somewhat vague and awkward when placed at the end of a list of specific items. Adding a conjunction ... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I am a middle school teacher in the United States and I want to encourage all students to exercise during lunchtime. What kind of program would be good to organize? | Good idea — lunchtime is perfect for short, inclusive activity that builds a habit without cutting into class time. Here’s a practical, low‑cost program you can run: “Midday Move Club.”
Overview
- Goal: 20–30 minutes of fun physical activity every lunch period, with choices to suit different interests and fitness le... | [2] | us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_02 | {'us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_gemini-3-pro-preview_1': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'gemini-3-pro-preview', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'Low‑key games — four‑square, kickball, capture‑the‑flag', 'explanation': "Describing kickball and capture the flag as 'low-key' is culturall... | ['Cultural Inaccuracy'] |
us | en | us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I am a middle school teacher in the United States and I want to encourage all students to exercise during lunchtime. What kind of program would be good to organize? | Good idea — lunchtime is perfect for short, inclusive activity that builds a habit without cutting into class time. Here’s a practical, low‑cost program you can run: “Midday Move Club.”
Overview
- Goal: 20–30 minutes of fun physical activity every lunch period, with choices to suit different interests and fitness le... | [2] | us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_03 | {'us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_2_2_gemini-3-pro-preview_2': {'paragraph_idx_list': [2], 'detector_id': 'gemini-3-pro-preview', 'detector_type': 'model', 'span': 'capture‑the‑flag', 'explanation': "In American English, the name of the game is standardly written as 'Capture the Flag' without hyphens. Fu... | ['Explicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I am a middle school teacher in the United States and I want to encourage all students to exercise during lunchtime. What kind of program would be good to organize? | Good idea — lunchtime is perfect for short, inclusive activity that builds a habit without cutting into class time. Here’s a practical, low‑cost program you can run: “Midday Move Club.”
Overview
- Goal: 20–30 minutes of fun physical activity every lunch period, with choices to suit different interests and fitness le... | [4] | us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_04 | {'us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_4_4_US-1_5': {'paragraph_idx_list': [4], 'detector_id': 'US-1', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': 'sensory‑sensitive students', 'explanation': "The phrase is awkwardly worded and the hyphenation is unnecessary. It would read more naturally if rephrased as 'students who n... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
us | en | us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07 | I am a middle school teacher in the United States and I want to encourage all students to exercise during lunchtime. What kind of program would be good to organize? | Good idea — lunchtime is perfect for short, inclusive activity that builds a habit without cutting into class time. Here’s a practical, low‑cost program you can run: “Midday Move Club.”
Overview
- Goal: 20–30 minutes of fun physical activity every lunch period, with choices to suit different interests and fitness le... | [5] | us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_05 | {'us_idea-sports-2_english_gpt-5-mini-2025-08-07_5_5_US-1_7': {'paragraph_idx_list': [5], 'detector_id': 'US-1', 'detector_type': 'human', 'span': '“passport.”', 'explanation': 'The term "passport" is awkward and its intended meaning is not immediately clear in this context. A clearer phrase like "participant activity ... | ['Implicit Linguistic Error'] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.