// SPDX-License-Identifier: Apache-2.0 // © 2026 Lutar, Stephen P. — SZL Holdings // ORCID: 0009-0001-0110-4173 // // Layer 6 — a11oy policy gate for DeterministicReplay (A5) // // Policy rationale: // For canonical JSON + pinned PRNG + frozen registry, 5× replay must yield // byte-identical Merkle roots. This gate validates that a submitted replay // bundle reports the same root across all runs — enforcing determinism as // a first-class policy property before admitting any production operation. // // Lean axiom cited: `deterministicReplay` (A5) // Lean file: Lutar/Gate/DeterministicReplay.lean // Lean commit SHA: 1dca00032dfc9aa8559cc6c2e4b63192fcf52371 // Lean status: theorem (ENFORCED) // // Policy: if all replay roots are byte-identical → allow; else → deny // // References: // Zenodo: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20119582 // Thesis §4.6: deterministicReplay axiom export interface DeterministicReplayGateConfig { /** Required number of replay runs. Default: 5. */ requiredRuns?: number; } export interface DeterministicReplayGateOpts { /** Array of Merkle root hex strings from N replay runs. */ replayRoots: string[]; } export interface DeterministicReplayDecision { allow: boolean; rationale: string; formula: string; leanTheorem: string; leanFile: string; leanCommitSha: string; requiredRuns: number; actualRuns: number; uniqueRoots: number; canonicalRoot: string; lambdaScore: number; } const LEAN_THEOREM = "deterministicReplay"; const LEAN_FILE = "Lutar/Gate/DeterministicReplay.lean"; const LEAN_COMMIT = "1dca00032dfc9aa8559cc6c2e4b63192fcf52371"; const DEFAULT_RUNS = 5; // ── Inline formula ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── // A5: ∀i ∈ {1..5}: root_i = canonical ⟺ canonical JSON ∧ pinned PRNG ∧ frozen registry /** * DeterministicReplay (A5) policy gate. * * Validates that N replay runs produce byte-identical Merkle roots. * Accepts only if the run count meets the requirement and all roots * are identical. * * Lean axiom: `deterministicReplay` (A5) * Lean file: Lutar/Gate/DeterministicReplay.lean (commit 1dca00032dfc9aa8559cc6c2e4b63192fcf52371) * Zenodo: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20119582 */ export function deterministicReplayGate( config: DeterministicReplayGateConfig = {} ): (opts: DeterministicReplayGateOpts) => DeterministicReplayDecision { const requiredRuns = config.requiredRuns ?? DEFAULT_RUNS; if (!Number.isInteger(requiredRuns) || requiredRuns < 1) { throw new Error(`DeterministicReplayGate: requiredRuns must be ≥ 1; got ${requiredRuns}`); } return function gate(opts: DeterministicReplayGateOpts): DeterministicReplayDecision { const { replayRoots } = opts; if (!Array.isArray(replayRoots) || replayRoots.length < requiredRuns) { throw new Error(`DeterministicReplayGate: need ${requiredRuns} roots; got ${replayRoots?.length}`); } for (const r of replayRoots) { if (typeof r !== 'string' || r.length === 0) { throw new Error(`DeterministicReplayGate: each root must be a non-empty string`); } } const uniqueSet = new Set(replayRoots.slice(0, requiredRuns)); const uniqueRoots = uniqueSet.size; const canonicalRoot = replayRoots[0]; const allow = uniqueRoots === 1; const lambdaScore = allow ? 1.0 : 1.0 / uniqueRoots; const rationale = allow ? `DeterministicReplay (A5): ${requiredRuns} runs → 1 unique root "${canonicalRoot.slice(0, 16)}…". Byte-identical replay confirmed. Passes. Lean: ${LEAN_THEOREM} @${LEAN_COMMIT.slice(0, 12)}` : `DeterministicReplay (A5): ${requiredRuns} runs → ${uniqueRoots} distinct roots — non-determinism detected. Denied. Lean: ${LEAN_THEOREM} @${LEAN_COMMIT.slice(0, 12)}`; return { allow, rationale, formula: "DeterministicReplay", leanTheorem: LEAN_THEOREM, leanFile: LEAN_FILE, leanCommitSha: LEAN_COMMIT, requiredRuns, actualRuns: replayRoots.length, uniqueRoots, canonicalRoot, lambdaScore }; }; }