SabaPivot's picture
Add full-public-MATH hard-soft agreement audit and bundle v3
8d3cfa6 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
5.46 kB
{
"claim": "DCF soft/hard agreement across alpha=0.01..0.10",
"scope": "benchmark-scale proxy; not the unreleased paper scorer/ADGs",
"dataset": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/qwedsacf/competition_math",
"dataset_revision": "e839825f9ec5c6cfa585c654a59610969ec13993",
"dataset_file_sha256": "2325458edc03d786939ee9e1e5795efb9e2480247b6e1ed2c51f41bea7369c6a",
"examples": 12500,
"solution_claim_nodes": 57661,
"step_count": {
"minimum": 1,
"median": 4.0,
"maximum": 24
},
"graph_construction": "sentence/TeX-step split; sequential chain with transitive ancestors",
"risk_proxy": "deterministic structural features plus pinned BLAKE2 jitter; not learned factuality",
"threshold_grid": [
0.05,
0.1,
0.15,
0.2,
0.25,
0.3,
0.35,
0.4,
0.45,
0.5,
0.55,
0.6,
0.65,
0.7,
0.75,
0.8,
0.85,
0.9,
0.95
],
"temperature": 0.01,
"ancestor_weight": 1.0,
"rows": [
{
"alpha": 0.01,
"calibrated_tau_alpha": 0.9485867535480055,
"examples": 12500,
"claim_nodes": 57661,
"exact_set_matches": 12126,
"exact_set_agreement_percent": 97.008,
"node_matches": 56650,
"node_agreement_percent": 98.24664851459391,
"hard_retained_nodes": 53769,
"soft_retained_nodes": 54776,
"minimum_selected_threshold_mass": 0.9932620530009145
},
{
"alpha": 0.02,
"calibrated_tau_alpha": 0.9058958085932685,
"examples": 12500,
"claim_nodes": 57661,
"exact_set_matches": 12126,
"exact_set_agreement_percent": 97.008,
"node_matches": 56650,
"node_agreement_percent": 98.24664851459391,
"hard_retained_nodes": 53769,
"soft_retained_nodes": 54776,
"minimum_selected_threshold_mass": 0.9932620530009145
},
{
"alpha": 0.03,
"calibrated_tau_alpha": 0.872870755145197,
"examples": 12500,
"claim_nodes": 57661,
"exact_set_matches": 12033,
"exact_set_agreement_percent": 96.264,
"node_matches": 56431,
"node_agreement_percent": 97.86684240647925,
"hard_retained_nodes": 51082,
"soft_retained_nodes": 52310,
"minimum_selected_threshold_mass": 0.9932620530009145
},
{
"alpha": 0.04,
"calibrated_tau_alpha": 0.8452746675506868,
"examples": 12500,
"claim_nodes": 57661,
"exact_set_matches": 11992,
"exact_set_agreement_percent": 95.936,
"node_matches": 56289,
"node_agreement_percent": 97.62057543226791,
"hard_retained_nodes": 47914,
"soft_retained_nodes": 49284,
"minimum_selected_threshold_mass": 0.9932620530009145
},
{
"alpha": 0.05,
"calibrated_tau_alpha": 0.8213467377375022,
"examples": 12500,
"claim_nodes": 57661,
"exact_set_matches": 11992,
"exact_set_agreement_percent": 95.936,
"node_matches": 56289,
"node_agreement_percent": 97.62057543226791,
"hard_retained_nodes": 47914,
"soft_retained_nodes": 49284,
"minimum_selected_threshold_mass": 0.9932620530009145
},
{
"alpha": 0.06,
"calibrated_tau_alpha": 0.7987028271142255,
"examples": 12500,
"claim_nodes": 57661,
"exact_set_matches": 12093,
"exact_set_agreement_percent": 96.744,
"node_matches": 56442,
"node_agreement_percent": 97.8859194256083,
"hard_retained_nodes": 45596,
"soft_retained_nodes": 46813,
"minimum_selected_threshold_mass": 0.9932620530009147
},
{
"alpha": 0.07,
"calibrated_tau_alpha": 0.7680811225829118,
"examples": 12500,
"claim_nodes": 57661,
"exact_set_matches": 12093,
"exact_set_agreement_percent": 96.744,
"node_matches": 56442,
"node_agreement_percent": 97.8859194256083,
"hard_retained_nodes": 45596,
"soft_retained_nodes": 46813,
"minimum_selected_threshold_mass": 0.9932620530009147
},
{
"alpha": 0.08,
"calibrated_tau_alpha": 0.7362484987343773,
"examples": 12500,
"claim_nodes": 57661,
"exact_set_matches": 12017,
"exact_set_agreement_percent": 96.136,
"node_matches": 56334,
"node_agreement_percent": 97.69861778325038,
"hard_retained_nodes": 43181,
"soft_retained_nodes": 44506,
"minimum_selected_threshold_mass": 0.9932620530009147
},
{
"alpha": 0.09,
"calibrated_tau_alpha": 0.7093421666704366,
"examples": 12500,
"claim_nodes": 57661,
"exact_set_matches": 12017,
"exact_set_agreement_percent": 96.136,
"node_matches": 56334,
"node_agreement_percent": 97.69861778325038,
"hard_retained_nodes": 43181,
"soft_retained_nodes": 44506,
"minimum_selected_threshold_mass": 0.9932620530009147
},
{
"alpha": 0.1,
"calibrated_tau_alpha": 0.6835161550334733,
"examples": 12500,
"claim_nodes": 57661,
"exact_set_matches": 12038,
"exact_set_agreement_percent": 96.304,
"node_matches": 56324,
"node_agreement_percent": 97.6812750385876,
"hard_retained_nodes": 40560,
"soft_retained_nodes": 41895,
"minimum_selected_threshold_mass": 0.9932620530009145
}
],
"minimum_exact_set_agreement_percent": 95.936,
"maximum_exact_set_agreement_percent": 97.008,
"minimum_node_agreement_percent": 97.62057543226791,
"maximum_node_agreement_percent": 98.24664851459391
}