diff --git "a/metrics/benchmark.json" "b/metrics/benchmark.json" --- "a/metrics/benchmark.json" +++ "b/metrics/benchmark.json" @@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ "transfer_v9_test": 0.15 }, "protocol_sha256": "ab97f652ab890eaefdd5373dd2deeb1e26588815f1f339eee4bcaa610846b0af", - "statistics_sha256": "c73006e701434d215264f2d623160f213cebf2a8ff9b4f8c0d3402b3b99436d3", + "statistics_sha256": "8406aea215dc1c4ee2645130c94472b336bb065ba46c6efac4f742589499463b", "source_per_model": { "Jev": { "statistics_sha256": "b319a993ac569ea1fa8da027ccb2195868557e4efe232a5d06091db2884086be", @@ -119,9 +119,9 @@ } }, "Lux": { - "statistics_sha256": "49c1195fcd88860620fa7d5eb48bb77d6bc759cbac6db89ab11a6faf485644fa", - "source_model_key": "Lux-semantic-format-candidate", - "manifest_sha256": "485e1f7505d390fb6e84c34edca5812c6803f4d7a48b3f752f7784decdf58559", + "statistics_sha256": "71251a31ed6435d8c94df6d2a5241e9183613c19a87f8970145afec8ec948efc", + "source_model_key": "Lux-reading-source-candidate", + "manifest_sha256": "7107a2a8264a0416fa75fe40e57f3d06e4cb0395527eaedfa7b7335d8e37109a", "qualified_runtime": { "python": "3.12.13", "numpy": "2.3.5" @@ -5296,59 +5296,59 @@ "Lux": { "panels": { "old_core": { - "point": 0.8417410714285715, - "exact_fraction": "3771/4480", + "point": 0.8438244047619048, + "exact_fraction": "11341/13440", "ci95": [ - 0.8145452008928572, - 0.8688244047619047 + 0.8172237723214285, + 0.8705357142857142 ] }, "v3_core": { "point": 0.5275, "exact_fraction": "211/400", "ci95": [ - 0.49416666666666675, - 0.5608333333333333 + 0.49375, + 0.56125 ] }, "v4": { - "point": 0.896875, - "exact_fraction": "287/320", + "point": 0.9015625, + "exact_fraction": "577/640", "ci95": [ - 0.8629459433229814, - 0.9277075669696847 + 0.8683564268867926, + 0.9324785297746995 ] }, "v5": { - "point": 0.9125, - "exact_fraction": "73/80", + "point": 0.9145833333333333, + "exact_fraction": "439/480", "ci95": [ - 0.8866503163407948, - 0.9366505343021726 + 0.8889180415782575, + 0.9378879473136665 ] }, "transfer_v9_test": { - "point": 0.7762906309751434, - "exact_fraction": "406/523", + "point": 0.777246653919694, + "exact_fraction": "813/1046", "ci95": [ - 0.7482989865877792, - 0.8032481563248626 + 0.7490309134919917, + 0.8043278866211298 ] }, "original_four_panel_mean": { - "point": 0.7946540178571428, - "exact_fraction": "71201/89600", + "point": 0.7968675595238095, + "exact_fraction": "107099/134400", "ci95": [ - 0.7794567024393497, - 0.8092736519074929 + 0.7818603628416357, + 0.8112560296673489 ] }, "weighted_mean": { - "point": 0.7722471660748429, - "exact_fraction": "904703/1171520", + "point": 0.7740311945165256, + "exact_fraction": "36271721/46860800", "ci95": [ - 0.7583454502909792, - 0.785859954609448 + 0.7601225402834362, + 0.7877175850518867 ] } }, @@ -5383,15 +5383,15 @@ "requested": 64 }, "relational_composition": { - "correct": 57, + "correct": 58, "requested": 96 }, "scoped_evidence": { - "correct": 91, + "correct": 93, "requested": 96 }, "state_tracking": { - "correct": 28, + "correct": 27, "requested": 96 }, "unknown_rejection": { @@ -5410,7 +5410,7 @@ "requested": 80 }, "capacitated_assignment": { - "correct": 58, + "correct": 59, "requested": 80 }, "constraint_assignment": { @@ -5430,7 +5430,7 @@ "requested": 80 }, "ordinal_service_loss": { - "correct": 22, + "correct": 21, "requested": 80 }, "paraconsistent_rule_closure": { @@ -5438,11 +5438,11 @@ "requested": 80 }, "temporal_exclusion": { - "correct": 31, + "correct": 30, "requested": 80 }, "transaction_recovery": { - "correct": 42, + "correct": 43, "requested": 80 } } @@ -5453,7 +5453,7 @@ "valid_probability_rows": 480, "families": { "boolq": { - "correct": 142, + "correct": 143, "requested": 160 }, "belebele_en": { @@ -5461,7 +5461,7 @@ "requested": 160 }, "belebele_zh": { - "correct": 142, + "correct": 143, "requested": 160 } } @@ -5484,7 +5484,7 @@ "requested": 120 }, "qasc": { - "correct": 116, + "correct": 117, "requested": 120 } } @@ -5494,101 +5494,101 @@ "clean": { "requested": 1046, "valid_probability_rows": 1046, - "correct": 812, - "accuracy": 0.7762906309751434, + "correct": 813, + "accuracy": 0.777246653919694, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 1046, - "nll": 0.5940603022446113, - "acc": 0.7762906309751434, - "ece": 0.05558262070294892, - "brier": 0.2937157813621403, - "mean_conf": 0.8318732516780923, - "confident_error_rate": 0.02390057361376673, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5860420650095602, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9592169657422512, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6347992351816444, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3030592734225621, - "aurc": 0.05816033320114623, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.040783034257748776, - "confidence_bias": 0.05558262070294895, + "nll": 0.5870477618581573, + "acc": 0.777246653919694, + "ece": 0.04794282897297868, + "brier": 0.2910675481135292, + "mean_conf": 0.8251894828926727, + "confident_error_rate": 0.02198852772466539, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5717017208413002, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9615384615384616, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6338432122370937, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.29923518164435947, + "aurc": 0.057865847250986556, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.038461538461538464, + "confidence_bias": 0.047942828972978635, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 613, - "errors": 25, - "error_rate": 0.040783034257748776 + "n": 598, + "errors": 23, + "error_rate": 0.038461538461538464 }, "0.95": { - "n": 514, - "errors": 12, - "error_rate": 0.023346303501945526 + "n": 491, + "errors": 9, + "error_rate": 0.018329938900203666 }, "0.99": { - "n": 207, + "n": 174, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.014492753623188406 + "error_rate": 0.017241379310344827 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { - "coverage": 0.5009560229445507, - "accuracy": 0.9770992366412213, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.947606086730957 + "coverage": 0.5, + "accuracy": 0.9751434034416826, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9408829808235168 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8001912045889101, - "accuracy": 0.8781362007168458, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.647434909565297 + "accuracy": 0.8793309438470729, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6510422047867755 } }, - "score_mae": 0.18149603870298436, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.051063424067515496 + "score_mae": 0.18602619774583048, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.050882127676710784 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 1046, - "nll": 0.5940603022446113, - "acc": 0.7762906309751434, - "ece": 0.05558262070294892, - "brier": 0.2937157813621403, - "mean_conf": 0.8318732516780923, - "confident_error_rate": 0.02390057361376673, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5860420650095602, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9592169657422512, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6347992351816444, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3030592734225621, - "aurc": 0.05816033320114623, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.040783034257748776, - "confidence_bias": 0.05558262070294895, + "nll": 0.5870477618581573, + "acc": 0.777246653919694, + "ece": 0.04794282897297868, + "brier": 0.2910675481135292, + "mean_conf": 0.8251894828926727, + "confident_error_rate": 0.02198852772466539, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5717017208413002, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9615384615384616, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6338432122370937, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.29923518164435947, + "aurc": 0.057865847250986556, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.038461538461538464, + "confidence_bias": 0.047942828972978635, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 613, - "errors": 25, - "error_rate": 0.040783034257748776 + "n": 598, + "errors": 23, + "error_rate": 0.038461538461538464 }, "0.95": { - "n": 514, - "errors": 12, - "error_rate": 0.023346303501945526 + "n": 491, + "errors": 9, + "error_rate": 0.018329938900203666 }, "0.99": { - "n": 207, + "n": 174, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.014492753623188406 + "error_rate": 0.017241379310344827 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { - "coverage": 0.5009560229445507, - "accuracy": 0.9770992366412213, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.947606086730957 + "coverage": 0.5, + "accuracy": 0.9751434034416826, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9408829808235168 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8001912045889101, - "accuracy": 0.8781362007168458, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.647434909565297 + "accuracy": 0.8793309438470729, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6510422047867755 } }, - "score_mae": 0.18149603870298436, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.051063424067515496 + "score_mae": 0.18602619774583048, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.050882127676710784 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, @@ -5600,11 +5600,11 @@ "accuracy": 0.45, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 1.4899537928777824, + "nll": 1.4638562023564279, "acc": 0.45, - "ece": 0.3017003229117818, - "brier": 0.6913230901539468, - "mean_conf": 0.6857035964205832, + "ece": 0.22400769818984456, + "brier": 0.685438069283081, + "mean_conf": 0.6594526435269211, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.75, @@ -5612,7 +5612,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.05, "aurc": 0.3734132508358514, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.25, - "confidence_bias": 0.2357035964205832, + "confidence_bias": 0.2094526435269211, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 4, @@ -5634,22 +5634,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.6, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.720178043538323 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6973127263072573 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.49892304084621675 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.483508165065625 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 1.4899537928777824, + "nll": 1.4638562023564279, "acc": 0.45, - "ece": 0.3017003229117818, - "brier": 0.6913230901539468, - "mean_conf": 0.6857035964205832, + "ece": 0.22400769818984456, + "brier": 0.685438069283081, + "mean_conf": 0.6594526435269211, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.75, @@ -5657,7 +5657,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.05, "aurc": 0.3734132508358514, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.25, - "confidence_bias": 0.2357035964205832, + "confidence_bias": 0.2094526435269211, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 4, @@ -5679,12 +5679,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.6, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.720178043538323 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6973127263072573 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.49892304084621675 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.483508165065625 } } }, @@ -5697,24 +5697,24 @@ "accuracy": 0.8, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 0.391154446854581, + "nll": 0.36403248618468526, "acc": 0.8, - "ece": 0.0909007219853577, - "brier": 0.24269024392468377, - "mean_conf": 0.8773054444371697, + "ece": 0.1295361487173242, + "brier": 0.2257044216488208, + "mean_conf": 0.8831790381288052, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9285714285714286, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.65, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9230769230769231, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.45, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.45, - "aurc": 0.06282346007965203, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.07142857142857142, - "confidence_bias": 0.07730544443716969, + "aurc": 0.05397950583128602, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.07692307692307693, + "confidence_bias": 0.08317903812880512, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 14, + "n": 13, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.07142857142857142 + "error_rate": 0.07692307692307693 }, "0.95": { "n": 12, @@ -5731,35 +5731,35 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.9, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9649345170900093 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9546051514751633 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7085450713959379 + "accuracy": 0.9375, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7867595084452922 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 0.391154446854581, + "nll": 0.36403248618468526, "acc": 0.8, - "ece": 0.0909007219853577, - "brier": 0.24269024392468377, - "mean_conf": 0.8773054444371697, + "ece": 0.1295361487173242, + "brier": 0.2257044216488208, + "mean_conf": 0.8831790381288052, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9285714285714286, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.65, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9230769230769231, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.45, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.45, - "aurc": 0.06282346007965203, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.07142857142857142, - "confidence_bias": 0.07730544443716969, + "aurc": 0.05397950583128602, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.07692307692307693, + "confidence_bias": 0.08317903812880512, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 14, + "n": 13, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.07142857142857142 + "error_rate": 0.07692307692307693 }, "0.95": { "n": 12, @@ -5776,12 +5776,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.9, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9649345170900093 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9546051514751633 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7085450713959379 + "accuracy": 0.9375, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7867595084452922 } } }, @@ -5794,32 +5794,32 @@ "accuracy": 0.9, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 0.173920037838875, + "nll": 0.18031139864262885, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.08884237104933625, - "brier": 0.11334577453222641, - "mean_conf": 0.9453143823740051, + "ece": 0.0817012190955263, + "brier": 0.11604628935827062, + "mean_conf": 0.9409710011124263, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.85, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.9, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.9, "aurc": 0.0076315789473684215, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.04531438237400509, + "confidence_bias": 0.04097100111242624, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 17, + "n": 16, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 16, + "n": 15, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 2, + "n": 1, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -5828,43 +5828,43 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9793051012887353 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9736818072730682 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9588658106453812 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9485171543268541 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 0.173920037838875, + "nll": 0.18031139864262885, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.08884237104933625, - "brier": 0.11334577453222641, - "mean_conf": 0.9453143823740051, + "ece": 0.0817012190955263, + "brier": 0.11604628935827062, + "mean_conf": 0.9409710011124263, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.85, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.9, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.9, "aurc": 0.0076315789473684215, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.04531438237400509, + "confidence_bias": 0.04097100111242624, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 17, + "n": 16, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 16, + "n": 15, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 2, + "n": 1, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -5873,12 +5873,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9793051012887353 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9736818072730682 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9588658106453812 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9485171543268541 } } }, @@ -5891,19 +5891,19 @@ "accuracy": 0.4, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 0.963421060535776, + "nll": 0.9361317272289519, "acc": 0.4, - "ece": 0.3598356256038071, - "brier": 0.7060594827987038, - "mean_conf": 0.7594032993432073, + "ece": 0.3467800262809543, + "brier": 0.6890225027879284, + "mean_conf": 0.7467800262809542, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.1, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.05, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.05, - "aurc": 0.45470466259746445, + "aurc": 0.46809751974032154, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, - "confidence_bias": 0.35940329934320725, + "confidence_bias": 0.34678002628095417, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -5911,9 +5911,9 @@ "error_rate": 0.5 }, "0.95": { - "n": 2, - "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.5 + "n": 1, + "errors": 0, + "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { "n": 0, @@ -5925,30 +5925,30 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7584096306325441 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7481542379764177 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.4375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6582031053840188 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6360844184135074 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 0.963421060535776, + "nll": 0.9361317272289519, "acc": 0.4, - "ece": 0.3598356256038071, - "brier": 0.7060594827987038, - "mean_conf": 0.7594032993432073, + "ece": 0.3467800262809543, + "brier": 0.6890225027879284, + "mean_conf": 0.7467800262809542, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.1, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.05, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.05, - "aurc": 0.45470466259746445, + "aurc": 0.46809751974032154, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, - "confidence_bias": 0.35940329934320725, + "confidence_bias": 0.34678002628095417, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -5956,9 +5956,9 @@ "error_rate": 0.5 }, "0.95": { - "n": 2, - "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.5 + "n": 1, + "errors": 0, + "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { "n": 0, @@ -5970,12 +5970,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7584096306325441 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7481542379764177 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.4375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6582031053840188 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6360844184135074 } } }, @@ -5988,19 +5988,19 @@ "accuracy": 0.96875, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.13034778836964267, + "nll": 0.12979322912048136, "acc": 0.96875, - "ece": 0.07387770926294471, - "brier": 0.06436468242012063, - "mean_conf": 0.9252340474017305, + "ece": 0.05865632527071586, + "brier": 0.06221598573997203, + "mean_conf": 0.9181713626206109, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.75, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 1.0, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.84375, - "aurc": 0.005186349167726045, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.875, + "aurc": 0.004070277739154617, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.04351595259826946, + "confidence_bias": -0.05057863737938906, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 24, @@ -6008,7 +6008,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 17, + "n": 11, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -6020,32 +6020,32 @@ }, "selective": { "0.5": { - "coverage": 0.53125, + "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9517537497245334 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9449616248177756 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8932077222078463 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8779250187145542 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.13034778836964267, + "nll": 0.12979322912048136, "acc": 0.96875, - "ece": 0.07387770926294471, - "brier": 0.06436468242012063, - "mean_conf": 0.9252340474017305, + "ece": 0.05865632527071586, + "brier": 0.06221598573997203, + "mean_conf": 0.9181713626206109, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.75, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 1.0, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.84375, - "aurc": 0.005186349167726045, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.875, + "aurc": 0.004070277739154617, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.04351595259826946, + "confidence_bias": -0.05057863737938906, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 24, @@ -6053,7 +6053,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 17, + "n": 11, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -6065,14 +6065,14 @@ }, "selective": { "0.5": { - "coverage": 0.53125, + "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9517537497245334 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9449616248177756 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8932077222078463 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8779250187145542 } } }, @@ -6085,19 +6085,19 @@ "accuracy": 0.90625, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.24646259109043608, + "nll": 0.24455502641087398, "acc": 0.90625, - "ece": 0.08165686202673392, - "brier": 0.13219691386769145, - "mean_conf": 0.9344170796872766, + "ece": 0.079792014916701, + "brier": 0.13577654408819648, + "mean_conf": 0.9357865299742769, "confident_error_rate": 0.03125, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.75, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9583333333333334, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.9375, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.375, - "aurc": 0.033345170986070205, + "aurc": 0.033363772176546395, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.041666666666666664, - "confidence_bias": 0.02816707968727661, + "confidence_bias": 0.029536529974276915, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 24, @@ -6110,7 +6110,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.05555555555555555 }, "0.99": { - "n": 6, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6119,30 +6119,30 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9769813800539988 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9711615479408262 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8125, "accuracy": 0.9615384615384616, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8745144680431802 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8868939148352457 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.24646259109043608, + "nll": 0.24455502641087398, "acc": 0.90625, - "ece": 0.08165686202673392, - "brier": 0.13219691386769145, - "mean_conf": 0.9344170796872766, + "ece": 0.079792014916701, + "brier": 0.13577654408819648, + "mean_conf": 0.9357865299742769, "confident_error_rate": 0.03125, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.75, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9583333333333334, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.9375, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.375, - "aurc": 0.033345170986070205, + "aurc": 0.033363772176546395, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.041666666666666664, - "confidence_bias": 0.02816707968727661, + "confidence_bias": 0.029536529974276915, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 24, @@ -6155,7 +6155,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.05555555555555555 }, "0.99": { - "n": 6, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6164,12 +6164,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9769813800539988 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9711615479408262 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8125, "accuracy": 0.9615384615384616, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8745144680431802 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8868939148352457 } } }, @@ -6182,11 +6182,11 @@ "accuracy": 0.96875, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.17366660442192522, + "nll": 0.1799321903230246, "acc": 0.96875, - "ece": 0.139280642091471, - "brier": 0.09349301051833991, - "mean_conf": 0.8684549516140397, + "ece": 0.10182879137977313, + "brier": 0.09774414276889377, + "mean_conf": 0.8675840743934221, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5625, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -6194,7 +6194,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.875, "aurc": 0.004072377873563219, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.10029504838596026, + "confidence_bias": -0.10116592560657789, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 18, @@ -6207,7 +6207,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 5, + "n": 4, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6216,22 +6216,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.53125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9398574478142043 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9276751556299673 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7353225569523143 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7040075273516038 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.17366660442192522, + "nll": 0.1799321903230246, "acc": 0.96875, - "ece": 0.139280642091471, - "brier": 0.09349301051833991, - "mean_conf": 0.8684549516140397, + "ece": 0.10182879137977313, + "brier": 0.09774414276889377, + "mean_conf": 0.8675840743934221, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5625, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -6239,7 +6239,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.875, "aurc": 0.004072377873563219, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.10029504838596026, + "confidence_bias": -0.10116592560657789, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 18, @@ -6252,7 +6252,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 5, + "n": 4, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6261,12 +6261,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.53125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9398574478142043 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9276751556299673 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7353225569523143 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7040075273516038 } } }, @@ -6279,11 +6279,11 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 40, - "nll": 0.010156044928884202, + "nll": 0.012461149245409892, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.010082175827252016, - "brier": 0.0002922128455344832, - "mean_conf": 0.989917824172748, + "ece": 0.012352988030602807, + "brier": 0.0004269628768902182, + "mean_conf": 0.9876470119693972, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -6291,7 +6291,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.010082175827252016, + "confidence_bias": -0.012352988030602807, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 40, @@ -6313,22 +6313,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.994282735900115 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9926770167945137 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9830883529872735 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9794385287249308 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 40, - "nll": 0.010156044928884202, + "nll": 0.012461149245409892, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.010082175827252016, - "brier": 0.0002922128455344832, - "mean_conf": 0.989917824172748, + "ece": 0.012352988030602807, + "brier": 0.0004269628768902182, + "mean_conf": 0.9876470119693972, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -6336,7 +6336,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.010082175827252016, + "confidence_bias": -0.012352988030602807, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 40, @@ -6358,12 +6358,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.994282735900115 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9926770167945137 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9830883529872735 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9794385287249308 } } }, @@ -6376,32 +6376,32 @@ "accuracy": 0.9, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 40, - "nll": 0.2578333370423695, + "nll": 0.26407278866821826, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.08339734125029008, - "brier": 0.1539668312012304, - "mean_conf": 0.8928125003966263, + "ece": 0.05245202539688848, + "brier": 0.15778553734614284, + "mean_conf": 0.8829211192449822, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.575, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.725, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.65, - "aurc": 0.02394744920629697, + "aurc": 0.02308538024077973, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.007187499603373726, + "confidence_bias": -0.017078880755017845, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 24, + "n": 23, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 16, + "n": 15, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 8, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6410,45 +6410,45 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9320149317531109 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9200535815570202 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8366438894497547 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8251958593609416 } }, - "score_mae": 0.16359197313913096, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.03911601810015416 + "score_mae": 0.17291673608415475, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.04024927146404126 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 40, - "nll": 0.2578333370423695, + "nll": 0.26407278866821826, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.08339734125029008, - "brier": 0.1539668312012304, - "mean_conf": 0.8928125003966263, + "ece": 0.05245202539688848, + "brier": 0.15778553734614284, + "mean_conf": 0.8829211192449822, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.575, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.725, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.65, - "aurc": 0.02394744920629697, + "aurc": 0.02308538024077973, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.007187499603373726, + "confidence_bias": -0.017078880755017845, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 24, + "n": 23, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 16, + "n": 15, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 8, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6457,111 +6457,111 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9320149317531109 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9200535815570202 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8366438894497547 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8251958593609416 } }, - "score_mae": 0.16359197313913096, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.03911601810015416 + "score_mae": 0.17291673608415475, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.04024927146404126 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, "emotion": { "requested": 80, "valid_probability_rows": 80, - "correct": 49, - "accuracy": 0.6125, + "correct": 48, + "accuracy": 0.6, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 1.3250366616414988, - "acc": 0.6125, - "ece": 0.2033677770446442, - "brier": 0.578098657406022, - "mean_conf": 0.7837558603474908, - "confident_error_rate": 0.075, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.45, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8333333333333334, + "nll": 1.2865095689254165, + "acc": 0.6, + "ece": 0.19167859824830136, + "brier": 0.5660599536581878, + "mean_conf": 0.7759389293425664, + "confident_error_rate": 0.0625, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.4, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.84375, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.025, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.025, - "aurc": 0.2465828605574525, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.16666666666666666, - "confidence_bias": 0.17125586034749074, + "aurc": 0.24689075981896816, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.15625, + "confidence_bias": 0.17593892934256639, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 36, - "errors": 6, - "error_rate": 0.16666666666666666 + "n": 32, + "errors": 5, + "error_rate": 0.15625 }, "0.95": { - "n": 24, + "n": 22, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.125 + "error_rate": 0.13636363636363635 }, "0.99": { - "n": 7, + "n": 5, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.2857142857142857 + "error_rate": 0.4 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8534444506954815 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8358595503583666 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.65625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5796189437721434 + "accuracy": 0.671875, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5660683528503451 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 1.3250366616414988, - "acc": 0.6125, - "ece": 0.2033677770446442, - "brier": 0.578098657406022, - "mean_conf": 0.7837558603474908, - "confident_error_rate": 0.075, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.45, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8333333333333334, + "nll": 1.2865095689254165, + "acc": 0.6, + "ece": 0.19167859824830136, + "brier": 0.5660599536581878, + "mean_conf": 0.7759389293425664, + "confident_error_rate": 0.0625, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.4, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.84375, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.025, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.025, - "aurc": 0.2465828605574525, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.16666666666666666, - "confidence_bias": 0.17125586034749074, + "aurc": 0.24689075981896816, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.15625, + "confidence_bias": 0.17593892934256639, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 36, - "errors": 6, - "error_rate": 0.16666666666666666 + "n": 32, + "errors": 5, + "error_rate": 0.15625 }, "0.95": { - "n": 24, + "n": 22, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.125 + "error_rate": 0.13636363636363635 }, "0.99": { - "n": 7, + "n": 5, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.2857142857142857 + "error_rate": 0.4 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8534444506954815 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8358595503583666 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.65625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5796189437721434 + "accuracy": 0.671875, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5660683528503451 } } }, @@ -6570,23 +6570,23 @@ "mmlu": { "requested": 80, "valid_probability_rows": 80, - "correct": 59, - "accuracy": 0.7375, + "correct": 60, + "accuracy": 0.75, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.6466641422955599, - "acc": 0.7375, - "ece": 0.10575227809040644, - "brier": 0.3381993704155934, - "mean_conf": 0.8239887221865458, + "nll": 0.64319962297488, + "acc": 0.75, + "ece": 0.07583444934027661, + "brier": 0.336846797840859, + "mean_conf": 0.815404454455512, "confident_error_rate": 0.025, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5125, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9512195121951219, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.5875, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.4125, - "aurc": 0.07075415004878534, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.575, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.425, + "aurc": 0.06990146624747551, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.04878048780487805, - "confidence_bias": 0.0864887221865458, + "confidence_bias": 0.06540445445551202, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 41, @@ -6594,12 +6594,12 @@ "error_rate": 0.04878048780487805 }, "0.95": { - "n": 31, + "n": 29, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 9, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6608,30 +6608,30 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.95, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9179506124738418 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9107307477881781 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.859375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6428546144492293 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.631165847975779 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.6466641422955599, - "acc": 0.7375, - "ece": 0.10575227809040644, - "brier": 0.3381993704155934, - "mean_conf": 0.8239887221865458, + "nll": 0.64319962297488, + "acc": 0.75, + "ece": 0.07583444934027661, + "brier": 0.336846797840859, + "mean_conf": 0.815404454455512, "confident_error_rate": 0.025, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5125, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9512195121951219, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.5875, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.4125, - "aurc": 0.07075415004878534, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.575, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.425, + "aurc": 0.06990146624747551, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.04878048780487805, - "confidence_bias": 0.0864887221865458, + "confidence_bias": 0.06540445445551202, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 41, @@ -6639,12 +6639,12 @@ "error_rate": 0.04878048780487805 }, "0.95": { - "n": 31, + "n": 29, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 9, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6653,12 +6653,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.95, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9179506124738418 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9107307477881781 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.859375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6428546144492293 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.631165847975779 } } }, @@ -6671,32 +6671,32 @@ "accuracy": 0.53, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 200, - "nll": 1.3111522675312284, + "nll": 1.3020212799561357, "acc": 0.53, - "ece": 0.08739805659958974, - "brier": 0.5728987396461885, - "mean_conf": 0.5899912710608897, + "ece": 0.057886156442029546, + "brier": 0.5699198585015737, + "mean_conf": 0.5796763608829093, "confident_error_rate": 0.005, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.23, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9782608695652174, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.25, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.19, - "aurc": 0.21980746104696547, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.021739130434782608, - "confidence_bias": 0.05999127106088964, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.21, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9761904761904762, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.255, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.185, + "aurc": 0.22101453807685856, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.023809523809523808, + "confidence_bias": 0.049676360882909276, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 46, + "n": 42, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.021739130434782608 + "error_rate": 0.023809523809523808 }, "0.95": { - "n": 29, + "n": 28, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 6, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6704,44 +6704,44 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.75, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.57725688415424 + "accuracy": 0.76, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5622010178659016 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.26950159367730925 + "accuracy": 0.6125, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.28172954890715934 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 200, - "nll": 1.3111522675312284, + "nll": 1.3020212799561357, "acc": 0.53, - "ece": 0.08739805659958974, - "brier": 0.5728987396461885, - "mean_conf": 0.5899912710608897, + "ece": 0.057886156442029546, + "brier": 0.5699198585015737, + "mean_conf": 0.5796763608829093, "confident_error_rate": 0.005, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.23, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9782608695652174, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.25, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.19, - "aurc": 0.21980746104696547, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.021739130434782608, - "confidence_bias": 0.05999127106088964, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.21, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9761904761904762, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.255, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.185, + "aurc": 0.22101453807685856, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.023809523809523808, + "confidence_bias": 0.049676360882909276, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 46, + "n": 42, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.021739130434782608 + "error_rate": 0.023809523809523808 }, "0.95": { - "n": 29, + "n": 28, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 6, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6749,13 +6749,13 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.75, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.57725688415424 + "accuracy": 0.76, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5622010178659016 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.26950159367730925 + "accuracy": 0.6125, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.28172954890715934 } } }, @@ -6764,95 +6764,95 @@ "paws": { "requested": 80, "valid_probability_rows": 80, - "correct": 72, - "accuracy": 0.9, + "correct": 73, + "accuracy": 0.9125, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.28314251837212323, - "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.06247439765758463, - "brier": 0.15885879977500503, - "mean_conf": 0.9412949163036171, - "confident_error_rate": 0.0625, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8375, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9253731343283582, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.775, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.2875, - "aurc": 0.030912620564059478, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.07462686567164178, - "confidence_bias": 0.041294916303617035, + "nll": 0.2779227201992138, + "acc": 0.9125, + "ece": 0.05493591159180497, + "brier": 0.15753943063635653, + "mean_conf": 0.9357409581036927, + "confident_error_rate": 0.05, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8125, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9384615384615385, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7625, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3, + "aurc": 0.0308044058290765, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.06153846153846154, + "confidence_bias": 0.023240958103692755, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 67, - "errors": 5, - "error_rate": 0.07462686567164178 + "n": 65, + "errors": 4, + "error_rate": 0.06153846153846154 }, "0.95": { - "n": 60, + "n": 58, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.03333333333333333 + "error_rate": 0.034482758620689655 }, "0.99": { - "n": 2, + "n": 0, "errors": 0, - "error_rate": 0.0 + "error_rate": null } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.975, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9773598813644135 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9736310261741858 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9395250222016129 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9301026006058246 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.28314251837212323, - "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.06247439765758463, - "brier": 0.15885879977500503, - "mean_conf": 0.9412949163036171, - "confident_error_rate": 0.0625, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8375, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9253731343283582, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.775, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.2875, - "aurc": 0.030912620564059478, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.07462686567164178, - "confidence_bias": 0.041294916303617035, + "nll": 0.2779227201992138, + "acc": 0.9125, + "ece": 0.05493591159180497, + "brier": 0.15753943063635653, + "mean_conf": 0.9357409581036927, + "confident_error_rate": 0.05, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8125, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9384615384615385, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7625, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3, + "aurc": 0.0308044058290765, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.06153846153846154, + "confidence_bias": 0.023240958103692755, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 67, - "errors": 5, - "error_rate": 0.07462686567164178 + "n": 65, + "errors": 4, + "error_rate": 0.06153846153846154 }, "0.95": { - "n": 60, + "n": 58, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.03333333333333333 + "error_rate": 0.034482758620689655 }, "0.99": { - "n": 2, + "n": 0, "errors": 0, - "error_rate": 0.0 + "error_rate": null } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.975, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9773598813644135 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9736310261741858 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9395250222016129 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9301026006058246 } } }, @@ -6865,91 +6865,91 @@ "accuracy": 0.9125, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.2161076588398619, + "nll": 0.21231177025039338, "acc": 0.9125, - "ece": 0.038010106954782505, - "brier": 0.11745397306383834, - "mean_conf": 0.9376866478309165, + "ece": 0.026039786769557725, + "brier": 0.11561259420716938, + "mean_conf": 0.9322130681411511, "confident_error_rate": 0.025, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8375, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9701492537313433, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.825, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9696969696969697, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.925, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.075, - "aurc": 0.039172223012800614, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.029850746268656716, - "confidence_bias": 0.02518664783091651, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.1, + "aurc": 0.03569781457299058, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.030303030303030304, + "confidence_bias": 0.019713068141151147, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 67, + "n": 66, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.029850746268656716 + "error_rate": 0.030303030303030304 }, "0.95": { - "n": 62, - "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.03225806451612903 + "n": 61, + "errors": 1, + "error_rate": 0.01639344262295082 }, "0.99": { - "n": 26, + "n": 14, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.038461538461538464 + "error_rate": 0.07142857142857142 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.975, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9851611733370504 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9814442414444764 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.96875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9458952863255798 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9395185848998813 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.2161076588398619, + "nll": 0.21231177025039338, "acc": 0.9125, - "ece": 0.038010106954782505, - "brier": 0.11745397306383834, - "mean_conf": 0.9376866478309165, + "ece": 0.026039786769557725, + "brier": 0.11561259420716938, + "mean_conf": 0.9322130681411511, "confident_error_rate": 0.025, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8375, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9701492537313433, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.825, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9696969696969697, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.925, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.075, - "aurc": 0.039172223012800614, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.029850746268656716, - "confidence_bias": 0.02518664783091651, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.1, + "aurc": 0.03569781457299058, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.030303030303030304, + "confidence_bias": 0.019713068141151147, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 67, + "n": 66, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.029850746268656716 + "error_rate": 0.030303030303030304 }, "0.95": { - "n": 62, - "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.03225806451612903 + "n": 61, + "errors": 1, + "error_rate": 0.01639344262295082 }, "0.99": { - "n": 26, + "n": 14, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.038461538461538464 + "error_rate": 0.07142857142857142 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.975, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9851611733370504 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9814442414444764 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.96875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9458952863255798 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9395185848998813 } } }, @@ -6962,11 +6962,11 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.006236348098711358, + "nll": 0.007801897547958209, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.006149372309216639, - "brier": 0.00030747770792780715, - "mean_conf": 0.9938506276907834, + "ece": 0.007676312134330843, + "brier": 0.0004369807984377848, + "mean_conf": 0.9923236878656692, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -6974,7 +6974,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.006149372309216639, + "confidence_bias": -0.007676312134330843, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 80, @@ -6982,12 +6982,12 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 79, + "n": 78, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 69, + "n": 65, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6996,22 +6996,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9978451209130044 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9965300683221596 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9938674921230647 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9921908745945206 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.006236348098711358, + "nll": 0.007801897547958209, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.006149372309216639, - "brier": 0.00030747770792780715, - "mean_conf": 0.9938506276907834, + "ece": 0.007676312134330843, + "brier": 0.0004369807984377848, + "mean_conf": 0.9923236878656692, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7019,7 +7019,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.006149372309216639, + "confidence_bias": -0.007676312134330843, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 80, @@ -7027,12 +7027,12 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 79, + "n": 78, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 69, + "n": 65, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -7041,12 +7041,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9978451209130044 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9965300683221596 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9938674921230647 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9921908745945206 } } }, @@ -7059,19 +7059,19 @@ "accuracy": 0.75, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.47556818540480367, + "nll": 0.4720489807336611, "acc": 0.75, - "ece": 0.07643617030229378, - "brier": 0.3199264336587134, - "mean_conf": 0.8258139805835978, + "ece": 0.0761936963725907, + "brier": 0.3177754348396661, + "mean_conf": 0.8169291651727064, "confident_error_rate": 0.0375, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.4125, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9090909090909091, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.3625, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.35, - "aurc": 0.09222008593150528, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3375, + "aurc": 0.09282282377572246, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.09090909090909091, - "confidence_bias": 0.07581398058359778, + "confidence_bias": 0.06692916517270642, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 33, @@ -7079,7 +7079,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.09090909090909091 }, "0.95": { - "n": 24, + "n": 21, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -7092,31 +7092,31 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.9, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8609209785002616 + "accuracy": 0.925, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8560822733652931 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.828125, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6948713064193726 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6797098123940769 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.47556818540480367, + "nll": 0.4720489807336611, "acc": 0.75, - "ece": 0.07643617030229378, - "brier": 0.3199264336587134, - "mean_conf": 0.8258139805835978, + "ece": 0.0761936963725907, + "brier": 0.3177754348396661, + "mean_conf": 0.8169291651727064, "confident_error_rate": 0.0375, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.4125, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9090909090909091, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.3625, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.35, - "aurc": 0.09222008593150528, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3375, + "aurc": 0.09282282377572246, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.09090909090909091, - "confidence_bias": 0.07581398058359778, + "confidence_bias": 0.06692916517270642, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 33, @@ -7124,7 +7124,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.09090909090909091 }, "0.95": { - "n": 24, + "n": 21, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -7137,13 +7137,13 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.9, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8609209785002616 + "accuracy": 0.925, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8560822733652931 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.828125, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6948713064193726 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6797098123940769 } } }, @@ -7156,11 +7156,11 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.007841155789564139, + "nll": 0.01010806429581184, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.007806247293806301, - "brier": 0.00013872505147745316, - "mean_conf": 0.9921937527061937, + "ece": 0.010050520182894429, + "brier": 0.00022828427851469854, + "mean_conf": 0.9899494798171056, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7168,7 +7168,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.007806247293806301, + "confidence_bias": -0.010050520182894429, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -7181,7 +7181,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 6, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -7190,22 +7190,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9939010793872055 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9920052497980926 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9896593136903282 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9867894292404178 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.007841155789564139, + "nll": 0.01010806429581184, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.007806247293806301, - "brier": 0.00013872505147745316, - "mean_conf": 0.9921937527061937, + "ece": 0.010050520182894429, + "brier": 0.00022828427851469854, + "mean_conf": 0.9899494798171056, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7213,7 +7213,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.007806247293806301, + "confidence_bias": -0.010050520182894429, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -7226,7 +7226,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 6, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -7235,12 +7235,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9939010793872055 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9920052497980926 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9896593136903282 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9867894292404178 } } }, @@ -7253,11 +7253,11 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.0107929267557592, + "nll": 0.013336190464884707, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.010701462639340464, - "brier": 0.00036120660545170313, - "mean_conf": 0.9892985373606595, + "ece": 0.013199482511126015, + "brier": 0.0005383885458560314, + "mean_conf": 0.986800517488874, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7265,7 +7265,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.010701462639340464, + "confidence_bias": -0.013199482511126015, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -7287,22 +7287,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9969034000449554 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9957628189842604 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9816944573491596 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9774085096482822 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.0107929267557592, + "nll": 0.013336190464884707, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.010701462639340464, - "brier": 0.00036120660545170313, - "mean_conf": 0.9892985373606595, + "ece": 0.013199482511126015, + "brier": 0.0005383885458560314, + "mean_conf": 0.986800517488874, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7310,7 +7310,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.010701462639340464, + "confidence_bias": -0.013199482511126015, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -7332,12 +7332,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9969034000449554 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9957628189842604 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9816944573491596 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9774085096482822 } } }, @@ -7350,11 +7350,11 @@ "accuracy": 0.8, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.2138260506584651, + "nll": 0.22694873211843464, "acc": 0.8, - "ece": 0.15741611133328517, - "brier": 0.1276425479499806, - "mean_conf": 0.856580016184909, + "ece": 0.16555386795989538, + "brier": 0.13550345474895487, + "mean_conf": 0.8535695538437231, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7362,7 +7362,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.8, "aurc": 0.03111111111111111, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.05658001618490893, + "confidence_bias": 0.05356955384372308, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 6, @@ -7370,12 +7370,12 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 4, + "n": 3, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 2, + "n": 1, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -7384,24 +7384,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9426117959877142 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9367303412067545 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8415699130530643 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8305143644338201 } }, - "score_mae": 0.16071754616245987, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.03275971187271286 + "score_mae": 0.16955440723819443, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.034895014874681045 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.2138260506584651, + "nll": 0.22694873211843464, "acc": 0.8, - "ece": 0.15741611133328517, - "brier": 0.1276425479499806, - "mean_conf": 0.856580016184909, + "ece": 0.16555386795989538, + "brier": 0.13550345474895487, + "mean_conf": 0.8535695538437231, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7409,7 +7409,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.8, "aurc": 0.03111111111111111, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.05658001618490893, + "confidence_bias": 0.05356955384372308, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 6, @@ -7417,12 +7417,12 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 4, + "n": 3, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 2, + "n": 1, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -7431,16 +7431,16 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9426117959877142 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9367303412067545 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8415699130530643 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8305143644338201 } }, - "score_mae": 0.16071754616245987, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.03275971187271286 + "score_mae": 0.16955440723819443, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.034895014874681045 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, @@ -7451,11 +7451,11 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.07005694097555375, + "nll": 0.061294700563837144, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.0540813816797954, - "brier": 0.04110395968042234, - "mean_conf": 0.9459186183202046, + "ece": 0.04980564296050656, + "brier": 0.03092495951104666, + "mean_conf": 0.9501943570394934, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.9, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7463,7 +7463,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.05408138167979537, + "confidence_bias": -0.0498056429605066, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 9, @@ -7476,7 +7476,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 6, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -7485,24 +7485,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.993819476814992 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9916381797053619 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9798565648382314 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9777806624356902 } }, - "score_mae": 0.0487152458265909, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.00975869637261514 + "score_mae": 0.04333117262198813, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.007196645402378658 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.07005694097555375, + "nll": 0.061294700563837144, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.0540813816797954, - "brier": 0.04110395968042234, - "mean_conf": 0.9459186183202046, + "ece": 0.04980564296050656, + "brier": 0.03092495951104666, + "mean_conf": 0.9501943570394934, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.9, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7510,7 +7510,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.05408138167979537, + "confidence_bias": -0.0498056429605066, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 9, @@ -7523,7 +7523,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 6, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -7532,16 +7532,16 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.993819476814992 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9916381797053619 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9798565648382314 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9777806624356902 } }, - "score_mae": 0.0487152458265909, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.00975869637261514 + "score_mae": 0.04333117262198813, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.007196645402378658 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, @@ -7552,22 +7552,22 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.10819644087102691, + "nll": 0.12423624782442941, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.0954442527194344, - "brier": 0.039610537719924295, - "mean_conf": 0.9045557472805654, + "ece": 0.10880820844844666, + "brier": 0.04779494768609947, + "mean_conf": 0.8911917915515533, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 1.0, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.09544425271943457, + "confidence_bias": -0.10880820844844674, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 7, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -7586,33 +7586,33 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9656626177441163 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9558210808739257 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.881241046212756 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8866819137686461 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.10819644087102691, + "nll": 0.12423624782442941, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.0954442527194344, - "brier": 0.039610537719924295, - "mean_conf": 0.9045557472805654, + "ece": 0.10880820844844666, + "brier": 0.04779494768609947, + "mean_conf": 0.8911917915515533, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 1.0, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.09544425271943457, + "confidence_bias": -0.10880820844844674, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 7, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -7631,12 +7631,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9656626177441163 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9558210808739257 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.881241046212756 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8866819137686461 } } }, @@ -7649,11 +7649,11 @@ "accuracy": 0.6, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.8939128624245644, + "nll": 0.8828182838634889, "acc": 0.6, - "ece": 0.39838756334240605, - "brier": 0.6386225586932958, - "mean_conf": 0.8386086717206818, + "ece": 0.3920235500266451, + "brier": 0.6280874258674091, + "mean_conf": 0.8410658551406985, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7661,7 +7661,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.2, "aurc": 0.288968253968254, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.2386086717206818, + "confidence_bias": 0.24106585514069856, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -7683,22 +7683,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8853410746258817 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8732116352500265 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8282266608409089 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8179686895920922 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.8939128624245644, + "nll": 0.8828182838634889, "acc": 0.6, - "ece": 0.39838756334240605, - "brier": 0.6386225586932958, - "mean_conf": 0.8386086717206818, + "ece": 0.3920235500266451, + "brier": 0.6280874258674091, + "mean_conf": 0.8410658551406985, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7706,7 +7706,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.2, "aurc": 0.288968253968254, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.2386086717206818, + "confidence_bias": 0.24106585514069856, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -7728,12 +7728,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8853410746258817 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8732116352500265 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8282266608409089 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8179686895920922 } } }, @@ -7746,11 +7746,11 @@ "accuracy": 0.9, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.3878790410817737, + "nll": 0.38549807963539046, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.20366310890419706, - "brier": 0.23894788485153878, - "mean_conf": 0.8019263309455292, + "ece": 0.20288794178646427, + "brier": 0.23489325574634798, + "mean_conf": 0.8015680467880623, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.3, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7758,7 +7758,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5, "aurc": 0.06456349206349207, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.09807366905447079, + "confidence_bias": -0.09843195321193776, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 3, @@ -7780,24 +7780,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8513163369222139 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8456577690156466 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7305872644461858 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6947201852727033 } }, - "score_mae": 0.2577528085044144, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.05968224629533503 + "score_mae": 0.2564750859760038, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.05882371330201126 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.3878790410817737, + "nll": 0.38549807963539046, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.20366310890419706, - "brier": 0.23894788485153878, - "mean_conf": 0.8019263309455292, + "ece": 0.20288794178646427, + "brier": 0.23489325574634798, + "mean_conf": 0.8015680467880623, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.3, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7805,7 +7805,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5, "aurc": 0.06456349206349207, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.09807366905447079, + "confidence_bias": -0.09843195321193776, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 3, @@ -7827,16 +7827,16 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8513163369222139 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8456577690156466 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7305872644461858 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6947201852727033 } }, - "score_mae": 0.2577528085044144, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.05968224629533503 + "score_mae": 0.2564750859760038, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.05882371330201126 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, @@ -7847,11 +7847,11 @@ "accuracy": 0.7, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.7470384623310196, + "nll": 0.7292834955292916, "acc": 0.7, - "ece": 0.22029693644423792, - "brier": 0.4309736445646065, - "mean_conf": 0.9202969364442379, + "ece": 0.21088673885292936, + "brier": 0.4247531105085889, + "mean_conf": 0.9108867388529293, "confident_error_rate": 0.1, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8571428571428571, @@ -7859,7 +7859,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.4, "aurc": 0.12817460317460316, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.14285714285714285, - "confidence_bias": 0.22029693644423798, + "confidence_bias": 0.2108867388529293, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 7, @@ -7881,24 +7881,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9773512719149 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9757163386049921 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.75, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8938853735717587 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8745092806607159 } }, - "score_mae": 0.2732574139836782, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.10706854764238136 + "score_mae": 0.27669455495743667, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.1053871341351588 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.7470384623310196, + "nll": 0.7292834955292916, "acc": 0.7, - "ece": 0.22029693644423792, - "brier": 0.4309736445646065, - "mean_conf": 0.9202969364442379, + "ece": 0.21088673885292936, + "brier": 0.4247531105085889, + "mean_conf": 0.9108867388529293, "confident_error_rate": 0.1, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8571428571428571, @@ -7906,7 +7906,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.4, "aurc": 0.12817460317460316, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.14285714285714285, - "confidence_bias": 0.22029693644423798, + "confidence_bias": 0.2108867388529293, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 7, @@ -7928,16 +7928,16 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9773512719149 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9757163386049921 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.75, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8938853735717587 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8745092806607159 } }, - "score_mae": 0.2732574139836782, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.10706854764238136 + "score_mae": 0.27669455495743667, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.1053871341351588 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, @@ -7948,11 +7948,11 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.004226216609183238, + "nll": 0.005872511904691692, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.004215976897349094, - "brier": 3.4649667131696104e-05, - "mean_conf": 0.9957840231026509, + "ece": 0.005852885976918243, + "brier": 6.553204955281063e-05, + "mean_conf": 0.9941471140230818, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7960,7 +7960,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.004215976897349094, + "confidence_bias": -0.005852885976918243, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -7982,22 +7982,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9969052065210677 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9956017537902697 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9942030038674581 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.992077102727452 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.004226216609183238, + "nll": 0.005872511904691692, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.004215976897349094, - "brier": 3.4649667131696104e-05, - "mean_conf": 0.9957840231026509, + "ece": 0.005852885976918243, + "brier": 6.553204955281063e-05, + "mean_conf": 0.9941471140230818, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -8005,7 +8005,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.004215976897349094, + "confidence_bias": -0.005852885976918243, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -8027,12 +8027,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9969052065210677 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9956017537902697 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9942030038674581 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.992077102727452 } } }, @@ -8045,11 +8045,11 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.007053870282788843, + "nll": 0.009442501422597043, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.007024441570579243, - "brier": 9.776258511132903e-05, - "mean_conf": 0.9929755584294208, + "ece": 0.009390689401267194, + "brier": 0.00017066799723336928, + "mean_conf": 0.9906093105987328, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -8057,7 +8057,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.007024441570579243, + "confidence_bias": -0.009390689401267194, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -8079,24 +8079,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9932447768419814 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9912854619430778 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9898739137651561 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9857135990468268 } }, - "score_mae": 0.007660911551517352, - "ranked_probability_score": 2.757223086398964e-05 + "score_mae": 0.010231745432055298, + "ranked_probability_score": 4.863796909247521e-05 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.007053870282788843, + "nll": 0.009442501422597043, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.007024441570579243, - "brier": 9.776258511132903e-05, - "mean_conf": 0.9929755584294208, + "ece": 0.009390689401267194, + "brier": 0.00017066799723336928, + "mean_conf": 0.9906093105987328, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -8104,7 +8104,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.007024441570579243, + "confidence_bias": -0.009390689401267194, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -8126,16 +8126,16 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9932447768419814 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9912854619430778 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9898739137651561 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9857135990468268 } }, - "score_mae": 0.007660911551517352, - "ranked_probability_score": 2.757223086398964e-05 + "score_mae": 0.010231745432055298, + "ranked_probability_score": 4.863796909247521e-05 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, @@ -8146,11 +8146,11 @@ "accuracy": 0.5, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.9724116266401464, + "nll": 0.9490781913515873, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.37317330379992186, - "brier": 0.592356663184495, - "mean_conf": 0.7285382769948201, + "ece": 0.36923739486967955, + "brier": 0.5785088804997336, + "mean_conf": 0.710935585802415, "confident_error_rate": 0.1, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, @@ -8158,7 +8158,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.1, "aurc": 0.356468253968254, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, - "confidence_bias": 0.2285382769948201, + "confidence_bias": 0.210935585802415, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -8166,9 +8166,9 @@ "error_rate": 0.5 }, "0.95": { - "n": 2, - "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.5 + "n": 1, + "errors": 0, + "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { "n": 0, @@ -8180,24 +8180,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.6, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7507937755021719 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6925948236413493 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.597999206215155 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.586704671382904 } }, - "score_mae": 0.41248856844465875, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.14487339386062986 + "score_mae": 0.41230806689600685, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.14147304522762058 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.9724116266401464, + "nll": 0.9490781913515873, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.37317330379992186, - "brier": 0.592356663184495, - "mean_conf": 0.7285382769948201, + "ece": 0.36923739486967955, + "brier": 0.5785088804997336, + "mean_conf": 0.710935585802415, "confident_error_rate": 0.1, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, @@ -8205,7 +8205,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.1, "aurc": 0.356468253968254, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, - "confidence_bias": 0.2285382769948201, + "confidence_bias": 0.210935585802415, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -8213,9 +8213,9 @@ "error_rate": 0.5 }, "0.95": { - "n": 2, - "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.5 + "n": 1, + "errors": 0, + "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { "n": 0, @@ -8227,42 +8227,42 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.6, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7507937755021719 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6925948236413493 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.597999206215155 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.586704671382904 } }, - "score_mae": 0.41248856844465875, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.14487339386062986 + "score_mae": 0.41230806689600685, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.14147304522762058 }, "coverage": 1.0 } }, - "clean_task_macro_accuracy": 0.8235648148148148, + "clean_task_macro_accuracy": 0.8240277777777778, "permutation": { "requested_pairs": 36, "valid_pairs": 36, "both_correct_requested": 0.7777777777777778, "flip_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "covered_only_flip_rate": 0.08333333333333333, - "half_l1": 0.08515840387623191 + "half_l1": 0.08228615038271361 }, "unknowable": { "requested": 110, "valid": 110, "accuracy": null, "full_confidence_metrics": { - "mean_max_p": 0.6485130260679773, - "share_at_0_9": 0.21818181818181817, - "normalized_entropy": 0.7184893503275872 + "mean_max_p": 0.6359851141873526, + "share_at_0_9": 0.20909090909090908, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7358129257673091 }, "covered_only_confidence_metrics": { - "mean_max_p": 0.6485130260679773, - "share_at_0_9": 0.21818181818181817, - "normalized_entropy": 0.7184893503275872 + "mean_max_p": 0.6359851141873526, + "share_at_0_9": 0.20909090909090908, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7358129257673091 }, "controls": { "requested": 110, @@ -8271,32 +8271,32 @@ "accuracy": 0.8636363636363636, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 110, - "nll": 0.31120323585634946, + "nll": 0.30890154536131303, "acc": 0.8636363636363636, - "ece": 0.055639968292740274, - "brier": 0.1918081945957669, - "mean_conf": 0.9060614972263522, + "ece": 0.055763619767470476, + "brier": 0.18922444613084882, + "mean_conf": 0.9019016682678792, "confident_error_rate": 0.01818181818181818, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6909090909090909, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9736842105263158, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7727272727272727, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5454545454545454, - "aurc": 0.029014791714251358, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.02631578947368421, - "confidence_bias": 0.04242513358998856, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6818181818181818, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9733333333333334, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7545454545454545, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5363636363636364, + "aurc": 0.029053269688156625, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.02666666666666667, + "confidence_bias": 0.03826530463151556, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 76, + "n": 75, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.02631578947368421 + "error_rate": 0.02666666666666667 }, "0.95": { - "n": 68, - "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.029411764705882353 + "n": 66, + "errors": 1, + "error_rate": 0.015151515151515152 }, "0.99": { - "n": 40, + "n": 37, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -8305,45 +8305,45 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9818909453374407 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9777806624356902 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.9431818181818182, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8415699130530643 + "accuracy": 0.9318181818181818, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8305143644338201 } }, - "score_mae": 0.19343208241221987, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.05902836137908972 + "score_mae": 0.19476583885361418, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.05797069848515713 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 110, - "nll": 0.31120323585634946, + "nll": 0.30890154536131303, "acc": 0.8636363636363636, - "ece": 0.055639968292740274, - "brier": 0.1918081945957669, - "mean_conf": 0.9060614972263522, + "ece": 0.055763619767470476, + "brier": 0.18922444613084882, + "mean_conf": 0.9019016682678792, "confident_error_rate": 0.01818181818181818, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6909090909090909, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9736842105263158, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7727272727272727, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5454545454545454, - "aurc": 0.029014791714251358, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.02631578947368421, - "confidence_bias": 0.04242513358998856, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6818181818181818, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9733333333333334, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7545454545454545, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5363636363636364, + "aurc": 0.029053269688156625, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.02666666666666667, + "confidence_bias": 0.03826530463151556, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 76, + "n": 75, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.02631578947368421 + "error_rate": 0.02666666666666667 }, "0.95": { - "n": 68, - "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.029411764705882353 + "n": 66, + "errors": 1, + "error_rate": 0.015151515151515152 }, "0.99": { - "n": 40, + "n": 37, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -8352,22 +8352,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9818909453374407 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9777806624356902 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.9431818181818182, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8415699130530643 + "accuracy": 0.9318181818181818, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8305143644338201 } }, - "score_mae": 0.19343208241221987, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.05902836137908972 + "score_mae": 0.19476583885361418, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.05797069848515713 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, "requested_pairs": 110, "valid_pairs": 110, - "paired_confidence_drop": 0.2575484711583747 + "paired_confidence_drop": 0.2659165540805263 }, "coverage": { "questions": 1264, @@ -8376,7 +8376,7 @@ "truncated_questions": 0 }, "complete_unchanged_upstream_report": { - "objective": -0.42681700298384834, + "objective": -0.4212918162126965, "paired_flip": { "pairs": 64, "flip_rate": 0.953125, @@ -8387,69 +8387,69 @@ }, "unknowable": { "n": 110, - "mean_max_p": 0.6485130260679773, - "share_at_0_9": 0.21818181818181817, - "control_mean_max_p": 0.9060614972263522, - "control_share_at_0_9": 0.6909090909090909, + "mean_max_p": 0.6359851141873526, + "share_at_0_9": 0.20909090909090908, + "control_mean_max_p": 0.9019016682678792, + "control_share_at_0_9": 0.6818181818181818, "control_acc": 0.8636363636363636, - "paired_confidence_drop": 0.2575484711583747, - "share_less_confident_than_control": 0.9 + "paired_confidence_drop": 0.2659165540805263, + "share_less_confident_than_control": 0.9090909090909091 }, "clean": { "n": 1046, - "nll": 0.5940603022446113, - "acc": 0.7762906309751434, - "ece": 0.05558262070294892, - "brier": 0.2937157813621403, - "mean_conf": 0.8318732516780923, - "confident_error_rate": 0.02390057361376673, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5860420650095602, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9592169657422512, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6347992351816444, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3030592734225621, - "aurc": 0.05816033320114623, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.040783034257748776, - "confidence_bias": 0.05558262070294895, + "nll": 0.5870477618581573, + "acc": 0.777246653919694, + "ece": 0.04794282897297868, + "brier": 0.2910675481135292, + "mean_conf": 0.8251894828926727, + "confident_error_rate": 0.02198852772466539, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5717017208413002, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9615384615384616, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6338432122370937, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.29923518164435947, + "aurc": 0.057865847250986556, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.038461538461538464, + "confidence_bias": 0.047942828972978635, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 613, - "errors": 25, - "error_rate": 0.040783034257748776 + "n": 598, + "errors": 23, + "error_rate": 0.038461538461538464 }, "0.95": { - "n": 514, - "errors": 12, - "error_rate": 0.023346303501945526 + "n": 491, + "errors": 9, + "error_rate": 0.018329938900203666 }, "0.99": { - "n": 207, + "n": 174, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.014492753623188406 + "error_rate": 0.017241379310344827 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { - "coverage": 0.5009560229445507, - "accuracy": 0.9770992366412213, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.947606086730957 + "coverage": 0.5, + "accuracy": 0.9751434034416826, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9408829808235168 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8001912045889101, - "accuracy": 0.8781362007168458, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.647434909565297 + "accuracy": 0.8793309438470729, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6510422047867755 } }, - "score_mae": 0.18149603870298436, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.051063424067515496 + "score_mae": 0.18602619774583048, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.050882127676710784 }, "tasks": { "buried_emotion": { "n": 20, - "nll": 1.4899537928777824, + "nll": 1.4638562023564279, "acc": 0.45, - "ece": 0.3017003229117818, - "brier": 0.6913230901539468, - "mean_conf": 0.6857035964205832, + "ece": 0.22400769818984456, + "brier": 0.685438069283081, + "mean_conf": 0.6594526435269211, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.75, @@ -8457,7 +8457,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.05, "aurc": 0.3734132508358514, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.25, - "confidence_bias": 0.2357035964205832, + "confidence_bias": 0.2094526435269211, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 4, @@ -8479,35 +8479,35 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.6, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.720178043538323 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6973127263072573 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.49892304084621675 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.483508165065625 } } }, "buried_paws": { "n": 20, - "nll": 0.391154446854581, + "nll": 0.36403248618468526, "acc": 0.8, - "ece": 0.0909007219853577, - "brier": 0.24269024392468377, - "mean_conf": 0.8773054444371697, + "ece": 0.1295361487173242, + "brier": 0.2257044216488208, + "mean_conf": 0.8831790381288052, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9285714285714286, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.65, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9230769230769231, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.45, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.45, - "aurc": 0.06282346007965203, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.07142857142857142, - "confidence_bias": 0.07730544443716969, + "aurc": 0.05397950583128602, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.07692307692307693, + "confidence_bias": 0.08317903812880512, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 14, + "n": 13, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.07142857142857142 + "error_rate": 0.07692307692307693 }, "0.95": { "n": 12, @@ -8524,43 +8524,43 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.9, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9649345170900093 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9546051514751633 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7085450713959379 + "accuracy": 0.9375, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7867595084452922 } } }, "buried_qnli": { "n": 20, - "nll": 0.173920037838875, + "nll": 0.18031139864262885, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.08884237104933625, - "brier": 0.11334577453222641, - "mean_conf": 0.9453143823740051, + "ece": 0.0817012190955263, + "brier": 0.11604628935827062, + "mean_conf": 0.9409710011124263, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.85, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.9, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.9, "aurc": 0.0076315789473684215, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.04531438237400509, + "confidence_bias": 0.04097100111242624, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 17, + "n": 16, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 16, + "n": 15, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 2, + "n": 1, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -8569,30 +8569,30 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9793051012887353 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9736818072730682 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9588658106453812 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9485171543268541 } } }, "buried_tweet_offensive": { "n": 20, - "nll": 0.963421060535776, + "nll": 0.9361317272289519, "acc": 0.4, - "ece": 0.3598356256038071, - "brier": 0.7060594827987038, - "mean_conf": 0.7594032993432073, + "ece": 0.3467800262809543, + "brier": 0.6890225027879284, + "mean_conf": 0.7467800262809542, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.1, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.05, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.05, - "aurc": 0.45470466259746445, + "aurc": 0.46809751974032154, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, - "confidence_bias": 0.35940329934320725, + "confidence_bias": 0.34678002628095417, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -8600,9 +8600,9 @@ "error_rate": 0.5 }, "0.95": { - "n": 2, - "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.5 + "n": 1, + "errors": 0, + "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { "n": 0, @@ -8614,30 +8614,30 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7584096306325441 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7481542379764177 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.4375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6582031053840188 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6360844184135074 } } }, "composition_final_combination": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.13034778836964267, + "nll": 0.12979322912048136, "acc": 0.96875, - "ece": 0.07387770926294471, - "brier": 0.06436468242012063, - "mean_conf": 0.9252340474017305, + "ece": 0.05865632527071586, + "brier": 0.06221598573997203, + "mean_conf": 0.9181713626206109, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.75, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 1.0, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.84375, - "aurc": 0.005186349167726045, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.875, + "aurc": 0.004070277739154617, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.04351595259826946, + "confidence_bias": -0.05057863737938906, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 24, @@ -8645,7 +8645,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 17, + "n": 11, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -8657,32 +8657,32 @@ }, "selective": { "0.5": { - "coverage": 0.53125, + "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9517537497245334 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9449616248177756 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8932077222078463 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8779250187145542 } } }, "composition_final_exception": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.24646259109043608, + "nll": 0.24455502641087398, "acc": 0.90625, - "ece": 0.08165686202673392, - "brier": 0.13219691386769145, - "mean_conf": 0.9344170796872766, + "ece": 0.079792014916701, + "brier": 0.13577654408819648, + "mean_conf": 0.9357865299742769, "confident_error_rate": 0.03125, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.75, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9583333333333334, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.9375, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.375, - "aurc": 0.033345170986070205, + "aurc": 0.033363772176546395, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.041666666666666664, - "confidence_bias": 0.02816707968727661, + "confidence_bias": 0.029536529974276915, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 24, @@ -8695,7 +8695,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.05555555555555555 }, "0.99": { - "n": 6, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -8704,22 +8704,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9769813800539988 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9711615479408262 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8125, "accuracy": 0.9615384615384616, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8745144680431802 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8868939148352457 } } }, "composition_final_negation": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.17366660442192522, + "nll": 0.1799321903230246, "acc": 0.96875, - "ece": 0.139280642091471, - "brier": 0.09349301051833991, - "mean_conf": 0.8684549516140397, + "ece": 0.10182879137977313, + "brier": 0.09774414276889377, + "mean_conf": 0.8675840743934221, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5625, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -8727,7 +8727,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.875, "aurc": 0.004072377873563219, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.10029504838596026, + "confidence_bias": -0.10116592560657789, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 18, @@ -8740,7 +8740,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 5, + "n": 4, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -8749,22 +8749,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.53125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9398574478142043 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9276751556299673 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7353225569523143 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7040075273516038 } } }, "contrastive_authorization": { "n": 40, - "nll": 0.010156044928884202, + "nll": 0.012461149245409892, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.010082175827252016, - "brier": 0.0002922128455344832, - "mean_conf": 0.989917824172748, + "ece": 0.012352988030602807, + "brier": 0.0004269628768902182, + "mean_conf": 0.9876470119693972, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -8772,7 +8772,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.010082175827252016, + "confidence_bias": -0.012352988030602807, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 40, @@ -8794,43 +8794,43 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.994282735900115 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9926770167945137 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9830883529872735 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9794385287249308 } } }, "contrastive_deadline": { "n": 40, - "nll": 0.2578333370423695, + "nll": 0.26407278866821826, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.08339734125029008, - "brier": 0.1539668312012304, - "mean_conf": 0.8928125003966263, + "ece": 0.05245202539688848, + "brier": 0.15778553734614284, + "mean_conf": 0.8829211192449822, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.575, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.725, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.65, - "aurc": 0.02394744920629697, + "aurc": 0.02308538024077973, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.007187499603373726, + "confidence_bias": -0.017078880755017845, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 24, + "n": 23, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 16, + "n": 15, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 8, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -8839,77 +8839,77 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9320149317531109 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9200535815570202 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8366438894497547 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8251958593609416 } }, - "score_mae": 0.16359197313913096, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.03911601810015416 + "score_mae": 0.17291673608415475, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.04024927146404126 }, "emotion": { "n": 80, - "nll": 1.3250366616414988, - "acc": 0.6125, - "ece": 0.2033677770446442, - "brier": 0.578098657406022, - "mean_conf": 0.7837558603474908, - "confident_error_rate": 0.075, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.45, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8333333333333334, + "nll": 1.2865095689254165, + "acc": 0.6, + "ece": 0.19167859824830136, + "brier": 0.5660599536581878, + "mean_conf": 0.7759389293425664, + "confident_error_rate": 0.0625, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.4, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.84375, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.025, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.025, - "aurc": 0.2465828605574525, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.16666666666666666, - "confidence_bias": 0.17125586034749074, + "aurc": 0.24689075981896816, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.15625, + "confidence_bias": 0.17593892934256639, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 36, - "errors": 6, - "error_rate": 0.16666666666666666 + "n": 32, + "errors": 5, + "error_rate": 0.15625 }, "0.95": { - "n": 24, + "n": 22, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.125 + "error_rate": 0.13636363636363635 }, "0.99": { - "n": 7, + "n": 5, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.2857142857142857 + "error_rate": 0.4 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8534444506954815 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8358595503583666 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.65625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5796189437721434 + "accuracy": 0.671875, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5660683528503451 } } }, "mmlu": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.6466641422955599, - "acc": 0.7375, - "ece": 0.10575227809040644, - "brier": 0.3381993704155934, - "mean_conf": 0.8239887221865458, + "nll": 0.64319962297488, + "acc": 0.75, + "ece": 0.07583444934027661, + "brier": 0.336846797840859, + "mean_conf": 0.815404454455512, "confident_error_rate": 0.025, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5125, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9512195121951219, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.5875, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.4125, - "aurc": 0.07075415004878534, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.575, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.425, + "aurc": 0.06990146624747551, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.04878048780487805, - "confidence_bias": 0.0864887221865458, + "confidence_bias": 0.06540445445551202, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 41, @@ -8917,12 +8917,12 @@ "error_rate": 0.04878048780487805 }, "0.95": { - "n": 31, + "n": 29, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 9, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -8931,43 +8931,43 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.95, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9179506124738418 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9107307477881781 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.859375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6428546144492293 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.631165847975779 } } }, "mmlu_pro": { "n": 200, - "nll": 1.3111522675312284, + "nll": 1.3020212799561357, "acc": 0.53, - "ece": 0.08739805659958974, - "brier": 0.5728987396461885, - "mean_conf": 0.5899912710608897, + "ece": 0.057886156442029546, + "brier": 0.5699198585015737, + "mean_conf": 0.5796763608829093, "confident_error_rate": 0.005, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.23, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9782608695652174, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.25, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.19, - "aurc": 0.21980746104696547, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.021739130434782608, - "confidence_bias": 0.05999127106088964, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.21, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9761904761904762, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.255, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.185, + "aurc": 0.22101453807685856, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.023809523809523808, + "confidence_bias": 0.049676360882909276, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 46, + "n": 42, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.021739130434782608 + "error_rate": 0.023809523809523808 }, "0.95": { - "n": 29, + "n": 28, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 6, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -8975,113 +8975,113 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.75, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.57725688415424 + "accuracy": 0.76, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5622010178659016 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.26950159367730925 + "accuracy": 0.6125, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.28172954890715934 } } }, "paws": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.28314251837212323, - "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.06247439765758463, - "brier": 0.15885879977500503, - "mean_conf": 0.9412949163036171, - "confident_error_rate": 0.0625, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8375, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9253731343283582, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.775, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.2875, - "aurc": 0.030912620564059478, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.07462686567164178, - "confidence_bias": 0.041294916303617035, + "nll": 0.2779227201992138, + "acc": 0.9125, + "ece": 0.05493591159180497, + "brier": 0.15753943063635653, + "mean_conf": 0.9357409581036927, + "confident_error_rate": 0.05, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8125, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9384615384615385, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7625, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3, + "aurc": 0.0308044058290765, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.06153846153846154, + "confidence_bias": 0.023240958103692755, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 67, - "errors": 5, - "error_rate": 0.07462686567164178 + "n": 65, + "errors": 4, + "error_rate": 0.06153846153846154 }, "0.95": { - "n": 60, + "n": 58, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.03333333333333333 + "error_rate": 0.034482758620689655 }, "0.99": { - "n": 2, + "n": 0, "errors": 0, - "error_rate": 0.0 + "error_rate": null } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.975, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9773598813644135 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9736310261741858 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9395250222016129 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9301026006058246 } } }, "qnli": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.2161076588398619, + "nll": 0.21231177025039338, "acc": 0.9125, - "ece": 0.038010106954782505, - "brier": 0.11745397306383834, - "mean_conf": 0.9376866478309165, + "ece": 0.026039786769557725, + "brier": 0.11561259420716938, + "mean_conf": 0.9322130681411511, "confident_error_rate": 0.025, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8375, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9701492537313433, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.825, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9696969696969697, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.925, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.075, - "aurc": 0.039172223012800614, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.029850746268656716, - "confidence_bias": 0.02518664783091651, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.1, + "aurc": 0.03569781457299058, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.030303030303030304, + "confidence_bias": 0.019713068141151147, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 67, + "n": 66, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.029850746268656716 + "error_rate": 0.030303030303030304 }, "0.95": { - "n": 62, - "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.03225806451612903 + "n": 61, + "errors": 1, + "error_rate": 0.01639344262295082 }, "0.99": { - "n": 26, + "n": 14, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.038461538461538464 + "error_rate": 0.07142857142857142 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.975, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9851611733370504 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9814442414444764 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.96875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9458952863255798 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9395185848998813 } } }, "sciq": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.006236348098711358, + "nll": 0.007801897547958209, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.006149372309216639, - "brier": 0.00030747770792780715, - "mean_conf": 0.9938506276907834, + "ece": 0.007676312134330843, + "brier": 0.0004369807984377848, + "mean_conf": 0.9923236878656692, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9089,7 +9089,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.006149372309216639, + "confidence_bias": -0.007676312134330843, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 80, @@ -9097,12 +9097,12 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 79, + "n": 78, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 69, + "n": 65, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -9111,30 +9111,30 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9978451209130044 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9965300683221596 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9938674921230647 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9921908745945206 } } }, "tweet_offensive": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.47556818540480367, + "nll": 0.4720489807336611, "acc": 0.75, - "ece": 0.07643617030229378, - "brier": 0.3199264336587134, - "mean_conf": 0.8258139805835978, + "ece": 0.0761936963725907, + "brier": 0.3177754348396661, + "mean_conf": 0.8169291651727064, "confident_error_rate": 0.0375, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.4125, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9090909090909091, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.3625, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.35, - "aurc": 0.09222008593150528, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3375, + "aurc": 0.09282282377572246, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.09090909090909091, - "confidence_bias": 0.07581398058359778, + "confidence_bias": 0.06692916517270642, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 33, @@ -9142,7 +9142,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.09090909090909091 }, "0.95": { - "n": 24, + "n": 21, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -9155,23 +9155,23 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.9, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8609209785002616 + "accuracy": 0.925, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8560822733652931 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.828125, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6948713064193726 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6797098123940769 } } }, "unknowable_age_eligibility": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.8382027962956439, + "nll": 0.8159140816405721, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.23136963355477053, - "brier": 0.6189159675554958, - "mean_conf": 0.7313696335547706, + "ece": 0.21421574323774287, + "brier": 0.6032897524261119, + "mean_conf": 0.7142157432377428, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, @@ -9179,7 +9179,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, "aurc": 0.5, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": 0.23136963355477058, + "confidence_bias": 0.21421574323774284, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -9201,35 +9201,35 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.6, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7283886075019836 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7100501272097268 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6479771137237549 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6407661437988281 } } }, "unknowable_authorization": { "n": 10, - "nll": 1.1053561068085782, + "nll": 1.0676248278306069, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.3656208440260864, - "brier": 0.7581604276839656, - "mean_conf": 0.8656208440260865, - "confident_error_rate": 0.3, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, + "ece": 0.35543382596706624, + "brier": 0.7452622091449328, + "mean_conf": 0.8554338259670662, + "confident_error_rate": 0.2, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.6, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.2, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.2, - "aurc": 0.32313492063492066, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, - "confidence_bias": 0.3656208440260865, + "aurc": 0.3481349206349207, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.4, + "confidence_bias": 0.3554338259670662, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 6, - "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.5 + "n": 5, + "errors": 2, + "error_rate": 0.4 }, "0.95": { "n": 0, @@ -9246,22 +9246,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.6, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9161812663078308 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9051045381673695 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7894018645317196 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7762378934586363 } } }, "unknowable_control_age_eligibility": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.007841155789564139, + "nll": 0.01010806429581184, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.007806247293806301, - "brier": 0.00013872505147745316, - "mean_conf": 0.9921937527061937, + "ece": 0.010050520182894429, + "brier": 0.00022828427851469854, + "mean_conf": 0.9899494798171056, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9269,7 +9269,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.007806247293806301, + "confidence_bias": -0.010050520182894429, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -9282,7 +9282,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 6, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -9291,22 +9291,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9939010793872055 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9920052497980926 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9896593136903282 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9867894292404178 } } }, "unknowable_control_authorization": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.0107929267557592, + "nll": 0.013336190464884707, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.010701462639340464, - "brier": 0.00036120660545170313, - "mean_conf": 0.9892985373606595, + "ece": 0.013199482511126015, + "brier": 0.0005383885458560314, + "mean_conf": 0.986800517488874, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9314,7 +9314,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.010701462639340464, + "confidence_bias": -0.013199482511126015, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -9336,22 +9336,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9969034000449554 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9957628189842604 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9816944573491596 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9774085096482822 } } }, "unknowable_control_deadline": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.2138260506584651, + "nll": 0.22694873211843464, "acc": 0.8, - "ece": 0.15741611133328517, - "brier": 0.1276425479499806, - "mean_conf": 0.856580016184909, + "ece": 0.16555386795989538, + "brier": 0.13550345474895487, + "mean_conf": 0.8535695538437231, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9359,7 +9359,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.8, "aurc": 0.03111111111111111, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.05658001618490893, + "confidence_bias": 0.05356955384372308, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 6, @@ -9367,12 +9367,12 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 4, + "n": 3, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 2, + "n": 1, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -9381,24 +9381,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9426117959877142 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9367303412067545 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8415699130530643 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8305143644338201 } }, - "score_mae": 0.16071754616245987, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.03275971187271286 + "score_mae": 0.16955440723819443, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.034895014874681045 }, "unknowable_control_late_fee": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.07005694097555375, + "nll": 0.061294700563837144, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.0540813816797954, - "brier": 0.04110395968042234, - "mean_conf": 0.9459186183202046, + "ece": 0.04980564296050656, + "brier": 0.03092495951104666, + "mean_conf": 0.9501943570394934, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.9, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9406,7 +9406,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.05408138167979537, + "confidence_bias": -0.0498056429605066, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 9, @@ -9419,7 +9419,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 6, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -9428,35 +9428,35 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.993819476814992 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9916381797053619 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9798565648382314 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9777806624356902 } }, - "score_mae": 0.0487152458265909, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.00975869637261514 + "score_mae": 0.04333117262198813, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.007196645402378658 }, "unknowable_control_quantity_limit": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.10819644087102691, + "nll": 0.12423624782442941, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.0954442527194344, - "brier": 0.039610537719924295, - "mean_conf": 0.9045557472805654, + "ece": 0.10880820844844666, + "brier": 0.04779494768609947, + "mean_conf": 0.8911917915515533, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 1.0, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.09544425271943457, + "confidence_bias": -0.10880820844844674, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 7, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -9475,22 +9475,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9656626177441163 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9558210808739257 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.881241046212756 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8866819137686461 } } }, "unknowable_control_return_window": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.8939128624245644, + "nll": 0.8828182838634889, "acc": 0.6, - "ece": 0.39838756334240605, - "brier": 0.6386225586932958, - "mean_conf": 0.8386086717206818, + "ece": 0.3920235500266451, + "brier": 0.6280874258674091, + "mean_conf": 0.8410658551406985, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9498,7 +9498,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.2, "aurc": 0.288968253968254, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.2386086717206818, + "confidence_bias": 0.24106585514069856, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -9520,22 +9520,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8853410746258817 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8732116352500265 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8282266608409089 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8179686895920922 } } }, "unknowable_control_shipping_delay": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.3878790410817737, + "nll": 0.38549807963539046, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.20366310890419706, - "brier": 0.23894788485153878, - "mean_conf": 0.8019263309455292, + "ece": 0.20288794178646427, + "brier": 0.23489325574634798, + "mean_conf": 0.8015680467880623, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.3, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9543,7 +9543,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5, "aurc": 0.06456349206349207, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.09807366905447079, + "confidence_bias": -0.09843195321193776, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 3, @@ -9565,24 +9565,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8513163369222139 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8456577690156466 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7305872644461858 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6947201852727033 } }, - "score_mae": 0.2577528085044144, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.05968224629533503 + "score_mae": 0.2564750859760038, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.05882371330201126 }, "unknowable_control_sla_response": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.7470384623310196, + "nll": 0.7292834955292916, "acc": 0.7, - "ece": 0.22029693644423792, - "brier": 0.4309736445646065, - "mean_conf": 0.9202969364442379, + "ece": 0.21088673885292936, + "brier": 0.4247531105085889, + "mean_conf": 0.9108867388529293, "confident_error_rate": 0.1, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8571428571428571, @@ -9590,7 +9590,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.4, "aurc": 0.12817460317460316, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.14285714285714285, - "confidence_bias": 0.22029693644423798, + "confidence_bias": 0.2108867388529293, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 7, @@ -9612,24 +9612,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9773512719149 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9757163386049921 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.75, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8938853735717587 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8745092806607159 } }, - "score_mae": 0.2732574139836782, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.10706854764238136 + "score_mae": 0.27669455495743667, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.1053871341351588 }, "unknowable_control_spend_threshold": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.004226216609183238, + "nll": 0.005872511904691692, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.004215976897349094, - "brier": 3.4649667131696104e-05, - "mean_conf": 0.9957840231026509, + "ece": 0.005852885976918243, + "brier": 6.553204955281063e-05, + "mean_conf": 0.9941471140230818, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9637,7 +9637,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.004215976897349094, + "confidence_bias": -0.005852885976918243, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -9659,22 +9659,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9969052065210677 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9956017537902697 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9942030038674581 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.992077102727452 } } }, "unknowable_control_volume_discount": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.007053870282788843, + "nll": 0.009442501422597043, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.007024441570579243, - "brier": 9.776258511132903e-05, - "mean_conf": 0.9929755584294208, + "ece": 0.009390689401267194, + "brier": 0.00017066799723336928, + "mean_conf": 0.9906093105987328, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9682,7 +9682,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.007024441570579243, + "confidence_bias": -0.009390689401267194, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -9704,24 +9704,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9932447768419814 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9912854619430778 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9898739137651561 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9857135990468268 } }, - "score_mae": 0.007660911551517352, - "ranked_probability_score": 2.757223086398964e-05 + "score_mae": 0.010231745432055298, + "ranked_probability_score": 4.863796909247521e-05 }, "unknowable_control_warranty_claim": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.9724116266401464, + "nll": 0.9490781913515873, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.37317330379992186, - "brier": 0.592356663184495, - "mean_conf": 0.7285382769948201, + "ece": 0.36923739486967955, + "brier": 0.5785088804997336, + "mean_conf": 0.710935585802415, "confident_error_rate": 0.1, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, @@ -9729,7 +9729,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.1, "aurc": 0.356468253968254, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, - "confidence_bias": 0.2285382769948201, + "confidence_bias": 0.210935585802415, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -9737,9 +9737,9 @@ "error_rate": 0.5 }, "0.95": { - "n": 2, - "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.5 + "n": 1, + "errors": 0, + "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { "n": 0, @@ -9751,32 +9751,32 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.6, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7507937755021719 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6925948236413493 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.597999206215155 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.586704671382904 } }, - "score_mae": 0.41248856844465875, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.14487339386062986 + "score_mae": 0.41230806689600685, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.14147304522762058 }, "unknowable_deadline": { "n": 10, - "nll": 1.2106218946046243, + "nll": 1.1936892937872634, "acc": 0.3, - "ece": 0.17861993312941266, - "brier": 0.7343701548653422, - "mean_conf": 0.47861993312941264, + "ece": 0.17490025011213214, + "brier": 0.7253276456261111, + "mean_conf": 0.4749002501121321, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.0, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, - "aurc": 0.7779761904761905, + "aurc": 0.7589285714285715, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": 0.17861993312941266, + "confidence_bias": 0.17490025011213212, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -9798,32 +9798,32 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.2, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.49840795241629865 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.4989907294211009 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.4385092854499817 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.4357915260916039 } }, - "score_mae": 0.7449380524877681, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.24553973235698762 + "score_mae": 0.7352555113184743, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.2420866592785548 }, "unknowable_late_fee": { "n": 10, - "nll": 1.3276710177178344, + "nll": 1.2923453860166598, "acc": 0.3, - "ece": 0.27106129862072126, - "brier": 0.8180838268143074, - "mean_conf": 0.5710612986207213, + "ece": 0.23038840334765942, + "brier": 0.7937115661256419, + "mean_conf": 0.5303884033476594, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.0, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, - "aurc": 0.7483333333333333, + "aurc": 0.7733333333333332, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": 0.2710612986207213, + "confidence_bias": 0.23038840334765937, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -9845,24 +9845,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.6, "accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.550855944974189 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5093778740147706 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.4580442284371989 + "accuracy": 0.25, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.44214211890736754 } }, - "score_mae": 0.7681052591130838, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.2644686148936013 + "score_mae": 0.7422305550581385, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.25270907837522644 }, "unknowable_quantity_limit": { "n": 10, - "nll": 2.4681683362881595, + "nll": 2.364100794867005, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.48573829809507685, - "brier": 0.9783875577934342, - "mean_conf": 0.9857382980950768, + "ece": 0.4827107892011071, + "brier": 0.9737439215308642, + "mean_conf": 0.9827107892011071, "confident_error_rate": 0.5, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, @@ -9870,7 +9870,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, "aurc": 0.5, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, - "confidence_bias": 0.48573829809507685, + "confidence_bias": 0.4827107892011071, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -9892,30 +9892,30 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.6, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9864682188832252 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9826534113523934 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9834588178510609 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.98013697658372 } } }, "unknowable_return_window": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.7972145494828772, - "acc": 0.6, - "ece": 0.18620925667194407, - "brier": 0.5676903556290133, - "mean_conf": 0.5894333514724946, + "nll": 0.7914668987099229, + "acc": 0.7, + "ece": 0.286885017017804, + "brier": 0.5690036879176795, + "mean_conf": 0.585196890317801, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.0, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, - "aurc": 0.48813492063492064, + "aurc": 0.5203571428571429, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": -0.010566648527505329, + "confidence_bias": -0.11480310968219898, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -9936,23 +9936,23 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.6, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5594538450241089 + "accuracy": 0.4, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5657328367233276 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5314476331637015 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5336925983428955 } } }, "unknowable_shipping_delay": { "n": 10, - "nll": 1.3036386445451955, + "nll": 1.2682712288665416, "acc": 0.2, - "ece": 0.30095968800211725, - "brier": 0.8031605478655157, - "mean_conf": 0.4567572303779661, + "ece": 0.29121892684207396, + "brier": 0.781447600806538, + "mean_conf": 0.4462795720835988, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, @@ -9960,7 +9960,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, "aurc": 0.9309920634920636, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": 0.2567572303779661, + "confidence_bias": 0.2462795720835988, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -9982,24 +9982,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.4595779615514863 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.4459783434867859 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.125, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.41920896115276335 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.4014878571033478 } }, - "score_mae": 0.8655138350919522, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.28876623510920263 + "score_mae": 0.8435188873044972, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.27948214430957724 }, "unknowable_sla_response": { "n": 10, - "nll": 1.2124338307190397, + "nll": 1.200518862016904, "acc": 0.2, - "ece": 0.2761916374516639, - "brier": 0.746030154235981, - "mean_conf": 0.47619163745166393, + "ece": 0.25713645324930595, + "brier": 0.7363382258751557, + "mean_conf": 0.45713645324930585, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, @@ -10007,7 +10007,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, "aurc": 0.7266666666666668, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": 0.2761916374516639, + "confidence_bias": 0.25713645324930584, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -10029,24 +10029,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.6, "accuracy": 0.16666666666666666, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.4481450452847792 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.4304346442222595 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.25, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.4357074330957959 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.4151159699226627 } }, - "score_mae": 0.6120337496191068, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.21905875267992797 + "score_mae": 0.5909151001699179, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.21421444884056046 }, "unknowable_spend_threshold": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.736875114520118, + "nll": 0.7380288693535819, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.07921755937455173, - "brier": 0.5233519615225514, - "mean_conf": 0.5792175593745517, + "ece": 0.07006097788326784, + "brier": 0.520722008501961, + "mean_conf": 0.5699825910724938, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, @@ -10054,7 +10054,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, "aurc": 0.5, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": 0.07921755937455166, + "confidence_bias": 0.06998259107249383, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -10076,22 +10076,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.6, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5943543182085235 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5894361470891768 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5139663834645092 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.502282899723621 } } }, "unknowable_volume_discount": { "n": 10, - "nll": 2.5691700417991905, + "nll": 2.475799282190841, "acc": 0.4, - "ece": 0.5382559019399908, - "brier": 1.121603982108248, - "mean_conf": 0.9382559019399908, + "ece": 0.5247692963711266, + "brier": 1.1101745871995399, + "mean_conf": 0.9247692963711266, "confident_error_rate": 0.5, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.375, @@ -10099,7 +10099,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, "aurc": 0.5783333333333334, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.625, - "confidence_bias": 0.5382559019399907, + "confidence_bias": 0.5247692963711266, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 8, @@ -10121,32 +10121,32 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.6, "accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9634562251390246 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9584822208396057 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9614389381469302 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9566530548759113 } }, - "score_mae": 0.9905057090116424, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.4635245683115593 + "score_mae": 0.9890203760461705, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.456901425188147 }, "unknowable_warranty_claim": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.9921422537254998, - "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.2020352656125068, - "brier": 0.6100410016954086, - "mean_conf": 0.46137759870501566, + "nll": 0.9999682429218097, + "acc": 0.4, + "ece": 0.16837300755606652, + "brier": 0.6134949708297965, + "mean_conf": 0.4548224411008467, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.1, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.1, - "aurc": 0.4818650793650794, + "aurc": 0.5029761904761905, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": -0.03862240129498434, + "confidence_bias": 0.054822441100846664, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -10168,86 +10168,86 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.6, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.42317827905448857 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.42227191991424323 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.40588767546080573 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.4032192648416538 } }, - "score_mae": 0.5401415858390292, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.17205966045392337 + "score_mae": 0.5399159280722049, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.17294328544089552 } }, "variants": { "clean": { "n": 1156, - "nll": 0.6634965588347153, - "acc": 0.7413494809688581, - "ece": 0.07307599837609173, - "brier": 0.3373915801751656, - "mean_conf": 0.8144254793449499, - "confident_error_rate": 0.0328719723183391, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.551038062283737, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9403453689167975, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.5077854671280276, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.1185121107266436, - "aurc": 0.08049307232208963, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.059654631083202514, - "confidence_bias": 0.0730759983760918, - "top_bins": { - "0.9": { - "n": 637, - "errors": 38, - "error_rate": 0.059654631083202514 - }, - "0.95": { - "n": 532, - "errors": 22, - "error_rate": 0.041353383458646614 + "nll": 0.6540910351086936, + "acc": 0.7422145328719724, + "ece": 0.06497107410583432, + "brier": 0.33406731581885374, + "mean_conf": 0.8071856069778066, + "confident_error_rate": 0.03027681660899654, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.53719723183391, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9436392914653784, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.5086505190311419, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.11245674740484429, + "aurc": 0.08035729090618272, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.05636070853462158, + "confidence_bias": 0.06497107410583425, + "top_bins": { + "0.9": { + "n": 621, + "errors": 35, + "error_rate": 0.05636070853462158 + }, + "0.95": { + "n": 509, + "errors": 19, + "error_rate": 0.03732809430255403 }, "0.99": { - "n": 207, + "n": 174, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.014492753623188406 + "error_rate": 0.017241379310344827 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.9515570934256056, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9346480717751411 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9274184747088865 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.801038062283737, - "accuracy": 0.8412526997840173, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5943543182085235 + "accuracy": 0.8390928725701944, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5894361470891768 } }, - "score_mae": 0.3960124111370266, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.13525323778002232 + "score_mae": 0.3938198959642317, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.13294739488750432 }, "none_absent": { "n": 36, - "nll": 1.2780587311745955, + "nll": 1.2677850992926212, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.28787280132015003, - "brier": 0.7144050226937334, - "mean_conf": 0.6869218961640411, + "ece": 0.278053484436123, + "brier": 0.7154228122314299, + "mean_conf": 0.6718423502744483, "confident_error_rate": 0.08333333333333333, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.1111111111111111, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.25, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.08333333333333333, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.0, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, - "aurc": 0.5376174183815399, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.75, - "confidence_bias": 0.1869218961640411, + "aurc": 0.5441880853688735, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 1.0, + "confidence_bias": 0.17184235027444827, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 4, + "n": 3, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.75 + "error_rate": 1.0 }, "0.95": { "n": 2, @@ -10264,33 +10264,33 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.6111111111111112, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.696060664667048 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6822161181306214 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8055555555555556, "accuracy": 0.5172413793103449, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.4846763048647645 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.4968951628630185 } } }, "none_present": { "n": 36, - "nll": 0.7460177433221598, + "nll": 0.7499526141523112, "acc": 0.7777777777777778, - "ece": 0.14627996115067443, - "brier": 0.28709997650834473, - "mean_conf": 0.8017359444765791, + "ece": 0.10875199149059422, + "brier": 0.2872316962408804, + "mean_conf": 0.7911516003199925, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5555555555555556, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5277777777777778, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7222222222222222, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.6666666666666666, - "aurc": 0.04264397382032627, + "aurc": 0.0406940559221325, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.023958166698801353, + "confidence_bias": 0.013373822542214753, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 20, + "n": 19, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -10300,7 +10300,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 6, + "n": 5, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -10309,43 +10309,43 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9382298345728617 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9345858612432604 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8055555555555556, - "accuracy": 0.8620689655172413, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5789058197682615 + "accuracy": 0.896551724137931, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5753147944995638 } } }, "permuted": { "n": 36, - "nll": 0.7203281270997002, + "nll": 0.7075736943294805, "acc": 0.7777777777777778, - "ece": 0.09527377914540269, - "brier": 0.27961577244776725, - "mean_conf": 0.836032418535974, + "ece": 0.11496218985382063, + "brier": 0.2750490327493021, + "mean_conf": 0.8292829467749867, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6388888888888888, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6111111111111112, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7777777777777778, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.6666666666666666, - "aurc": 0.03678940551365068, + "aurc": 0.037657461069206234, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.0582546407581962, + "confidence_bias": 0.05150516899720892, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 23, + "n": 22, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 18, + "n": 16, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 9, + "n": 7, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -10354,12 +10354,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9544422568229554 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9415673543396044 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8055555555555556, "accuracy": 0.9310344827586207, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6258627504206388 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6202919952139035 } } } @@ -10367,56 +10367,56 @@ "heldout_tasks": {}, "permutation": { "n": 36, - "mean_max_delta": 0.08279943035271198, + "mean_max_delta": 0.08021796939627156, "flip_rate": 0.08333333333333333 }, "temperature": 1.0, "calibrated_clean": { "n": 1046, - "nll": 0.5940603022446113, - "acc": 0.7762906309751434, - "ece": 0.05558262070294892, - "brier": 0.2937157813621403, - "mean_conf": 0.8318732516780923, - "confident_error_rate": 0.02390057361376673, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5860420650095602, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9592169657422512, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6347992351816444, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3030592734225621, - "aurc": 0.05816033320114623, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.040783034257748776, - "confidence_bias": 0.05558262070294895, + "nll": 0.5870477618581573, + "acc": 0.777246653919694, + "ece": 0.04794282897297868, + "brier": 0.2910675481135292, + "mean_conf": 0.8251894828926727, + "confident_error_rate": 0.02198852772466539, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5717017208413002, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9615384615384616, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6338432122370937, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.29923518164435947, + "aurc": 0.057865847250986556, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.038461538461538464, + "confidence_bias": 0.047942828972978635, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 613, - "errors": 25, - "error_rate": 0.040783034257748776 + "n": 598, + "errors": 23, + "error_rate": 0.038461538461538464 }, "0.95": { - "n": 514, - "errors": 12, - "error_rate": 0.023346303501945526 + "n": 491, + "errors": 9, + "error_rate": 0.018329938900203666 }, "0.99": { - "n": 207, + "n": 174, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.014492753623188406 + "error_rate": 0.017241379310344827 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { - "coverage": 0.5009560229445507, - "accuracy": 0.9770992366412213, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.947606086730957 + "coverage": 0.5, + "accuracy": 0.9751434034416826, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9408829808235168 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8001912045889101, - "accuracy": 0.8781362007168458, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.647434909565297 + "accuracy": 0.8793309438470729, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6510422047867755 } }, - "score_mae": 0.18149603870298436, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.051063424067515496 + "score_mae": 0.18602619774583048, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.050882127676710784 }, "metric_policy": { "version": 2,