diff --git "a/metrics/benchmark.json" "b/metrics/benchmark.json" --- "a/metrics/benchmark.json" +++ "b/metrics/benchmark.json" @@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ "transfer_v9_test": 0.15 }, "protocol_sha256": "ab97f652ab890eaefdd5373dd2deeb1e26588815f1f339eee4bcaa610846b0af", - "statistics_sha256": "169bdbb413aa3302369d56f814d35641a5b4e1de82ef3ae688c28ca740b3b0dc", + "statistics_sha256": "c73006e701434d215264f2d623160f213cebf2a8ff9b4f8c0d3402b3b99436d3", "source_per_model": { "Jev": { "statistics_sha256": "b319a993ac569ea1fa8da027ccb2195868557e4efe232a5d06091db2884086be", @@ -119,9 +119,9 @@ } }, "Lux": { - "statistics_sha256": "bfc75a9080fb0fa22a45ac21c23048d5c8e5deac81dcc202792254565951d8e7", - "source_model_key": "Lux-retention-candidate", - "manifest_sha256": "469d9e05ff0283cb50efe45307c7e7bcefa9cb124cc5103b9aa319e2537801a0", + "statistics_sha256": "49c1195fcd88860620fa7d5eb48bb77d6bc759cbac6db89ab11a6faf485644fa", + "source_model_key": "Lux-semantic-format-candidate", + "manifest_sha256": "485e1f7505d390fb6e84c34edca5812c6803f4d7a48b3f752f7784decdf58559", "qualified_runtime": { "python": "3.12.13", "numpy": "2.3.5" @@ -5296,19 +5296,19 @@ "Lux": { "panels": { "old_core": { - "point": 0.8409598214285714, - "exact_fraction": "1507/1792", + "point": 0.8417410714285715, + "exact_fraction": "3771/4480", "ci95": [ - 0.8149553571428573, - 0.866630394345238 + 0.8145452008928572, + 0.8688244047619047 ] }, "v3_core": { - "point": 0.5175, - "exact_fraction": "207/400", + "point": 0.5275, + "exact_fraction": "211/400", "ci95": [ - 0.48583333333333345, - 0.5491666666666666 + 0.49416666666666675, + 0.5608333333333333 ] }, "v4": { @@ -5320,35 +5320,35 @@ ] }, "v5": { - "point": 0.9145833333333333, - "exact_fraction": "439/480", + "point": 0.9125, + "exact_fraction": "73/80", "ci95": [ - 0.8888980313342782, - 0.9377058522747549 + 0.8866503163407948, + 0.9366505343021726 ] }, "transfer_v9_test": { - "point": 0.7734225621414914, - "exact_fraction": "809/1046", + "point": 0.7762906309751434, + "exact_fraction": "406/523", "ci95": [ - 0.7450787401574803, - 0.8005593780665484 + 0.7482989865877792, + 0.8032481563248626 ] }, "original_four_panel_mean": { - "point": 0.7924795386904762, - "exact_fraction": "426037/537600", + "point": 0.7946540178571428, + "exact_fraction": "71201/89600", "ci95": [ - 0.7777779110823996, - 0.8066691389450736 + 0.7794567024393497, + 0.8092736519074929 ] }, "weighted_mean": { - "point": 0.7693950807497951, - "exact_fraction": "36054469/46860800", + "point": 0.7722471660748429, + "exact_fraction": "904703/1171520", "ci95": [ - 0.7559702781267388, - 0.7824389898408891 + 0.7583454502909792, + 0.785859954609448 ] } }, @@ -5359,7 +5359,7 @@ "valid_probability_rows": 880, "families": { "ag_news": { - "correct": 113, + "correct": 114, "requested": 128 }, "boolean_constraints": { @@ -5375,7 +5375,7 @@ "requested": 64 }, "option_carrier": { - "correct": 62, + "correct": 70, "requested": 96 }, "ordinal_rubric": { @@ -5383,15 +5383,15 @@ "requested": 64 }, "relational_composition": { - "correct": 59, + "correct": 57, "requested": 96 }, "scoped_evidence": { - "correct": 94, + "correct": 91, "requested": 96 }, "state_tracking": { - "correct": 31, + "correct": 28, "requested": 96 }, "unknown_rejection": { @@ -5406,15 +5406,15 @@ "valid_probability_rows": 880, "families": { "canonical_record_identity": { - "correct": 51, + "correct": 49, "requested": 80 }, "capacitated_assignment": { - "correct": 50, + "correct": 58, "requested": 80 }, "constraint_assignment": { - "correct": 30, + "correct": 26, "requested": 80 }, "massive_en": { @@ -5426,23 +5426,23 @@ "requested": 120 }, "multiset_reconciliation": { - "correct": 21, + "correct": 23, "requested": 80 }, "ordinal_service_loss": { - "correct": 19, + "correct": 22, "requested": 80 }, "paraconsistent_rule_closure": { - "correct": 25, + "correct": 29, "requested": 80 }, "temporal_exclusion": { - "correct": 36, + "correct": 31, "requested": 80 }, "transaction_recovery": { - "correct": 40, + "correct": 42, "requested": 80 } } @@ -5472,7 +5472,7 @@ "valid_probability_rows": 480, "families": { "cosmos_qa": { - "correct": 100, + "correct": 99, "requested": 120 }, "squad2_answerability": { @@ -5494,101 +5494,101 @@ "clean": { "requested": 1046, "valid_probability_rows": 1046, - "correct": 809, - "accuracy": 0.7734225621414914, + "correct": 812, + "accuracy": 0.7762906309751434, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 1046, - "nll": 0.6086212459300988, - "acc": 0.7734225621414914, - "ece": 0.05889322575332617, - "brier": 0.3004372452589081, - "mean_conf": 0.8323157878948174, + "nll": 0.5940603022446113, + "acc": 0.7762906309751434, + "ece": 0.05558262070294892, + "brier": 0.2937157813621403, + "mean_conf": 0.8318732516780923, "confident_error_rate": 0.02390057361376673, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5774378585086042, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9586092715231788, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6338432122370937, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.38336520076481834, - "aurc": 0.061361186701696054, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.041390728476821195, - "confidence_bias": 0.058893225753326006, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5860420650095602, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9592169657422512, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6347992351816444, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3030592734225621, + "aurc": 0.05816033320114623, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.040783034257748776, + "confidence_bias": 0.05558262070294895, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 604, + "n": 613, "errors": 25, - "error_rate": 0.041390728476821195 + "error_rate": 0.040783034257748776 }, "0.95": { - "n": 525, - "errors": 15, - "error_rate": 0.02857142857142857 + "n": 514, + "errors": 12, + "error_rate": 0.023346303501945526 }, "0.99": { - "n": 226, + "n": 207, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.01327433628318584 + "error_rate": 0.014492753623188406 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { - "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.97131931166348, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9503957614513975 + "coverage": 0.5009560229445507, + "accuracy": 0.9770992366412213, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.947606086730957 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8001912045889101, - "accuracy": 0.8745519713261649, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6527601881992761 + "accuracy": 0.8781362007168458, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.647434909565297 } }, - "score_mae": 0.19182332300936422, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.05030124964901672 + "score_mae": 0.18149603870298436, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.051063424067515496 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 1046, - "nll": 0.6086212459300988, - "acc": 0.7734225621414914, - "ece": 0.05889322575332617, - "brier": 0.3004372452589081, - "mean_conf": 0.8323157878948174, + "nll": 0.5940603022446113, + "acc": 0.7762906309751434, + "ece": 0.05558262070294892, + "brier": 0.2937157813621403, + "mean_conf": 0.8318732516780923, "confident_error_rate": 0.02390057361376673, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5774378585086042, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9586092715231788, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6338432122370937, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.38336520076481834, - "aurc": 0.061361186701696054, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.041390728476821195, - "confidence_bias": 0.058893225753326006, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5860420650095602, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9592169657422512, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6347992351816444, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3030592734225621, + "aurc": 0.05816033320114623, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.040783034257748776, + "confidence_bias": 0.05558262070294895, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 604, + "n": 613, "errors": 25, - "error_rate": 0.041390728476821195 + "error_rate": 0.040783034257748776 }, "0.95": { - "n": 525, - "errors": 15, - "error_rate": 0.02857142857142857 + "n": 514, + "errors": 12, + "error_rate": 0.023346303501945526 }, "0.99": { - "n": 226, + "n": 207, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.01327433628318584 + "error_rate": 0.014492753623188406 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { - "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.97131931166348, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9503957614513975 + "coverage": 0.5009560229445507, + "accuracy": 0.9770992366412213, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.947606086730957 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8001912045889101, - "accuracy": 0.8745519713261649, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6527601881992761 + "accuracy": 0.8781362007168458, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.647434909565297 } }, - "score_mae": 0.19182332300936422, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.05030124964901672 + "score_mae": 0.18149603870298436, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.051063424067515496 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, @@ -5600,29 +5600,29 @@ "accuracy": 0.45, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 1.5449426114821578, + "nll": 1.4899537928777824, "acc": 0.45, - "ece": 0.24636374641400255, - "brier": 0.7048268473893603, - "mean_conf": 0.6963637464140026, + "ece": 0.3017003229117818, + "brier": 0.6913230901539468, + "mean_conf": 0.6857035964205832, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.25, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.75, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.05, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.05, - "aurc": 0.3654720743652632, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.2, - "confidence_bias": 0.24636374641400255, + "aurc": 0.3734132508358514, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.25, + "confidence_bias": 0.2357035964205832, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 5, + "n": 4, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.2 + "error_rate": 0.25 }, "0.95": { - "n": 2, - "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.5 + "n": 1, + "errors": 0, + "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { "n": 0, @@ -5633,41 +5633,41 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.7, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7313402914926098 + "accuracy": 0.6, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.720178043538323 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5043779386113015 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.49892304084621675 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 1.5449426114821578, + "nll": 1.4899537928777824, "acc": 0.45, - "ece": 0.24636374641400255, - "brier": 0.7048268473893603, - "mean_conf": 0.6963637464140026, + "ece": 0.3017003229117818, + "brier": 0.6913230901539468, + "mean_conf": 0.6857035964205832, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.25, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.75, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.05, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.05, - "aurc": 0.3654720743652632, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.2, - "confidence_bias": 0.24636374641400255, + "aurc": 0.3734132508358514, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.25, + "confidence_bias": 0.2357035964205832, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 5, + "n": 4, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.2 + "error_rate": 0.25 }, "0.95": { - "n": 2, - "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.5 + "n": 1, + "errors": 0, + "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { "n": 0, @@ -5678,13 +5678,13 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.7, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7313402914926098 + "accuracy": 0.6, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.720178043538323 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5043779386113015 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.49892304084621675 } } }, @@ -5697,19 +5697,19 @@ "accuracy": 0.8, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 0.3590183753756898, + "nll": 0.391154446854581, "acc": 0.8, - "ece": 0.12098253375100354, - "brier": 0.2234753942109866, - "mean_conf": 0.8746775461236951, + "ece": 0.0909007219853577, + "brier": 0.24269024392468377, + "mean_conf": 0.8773054444371697, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9285714285714286, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.5, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5, - "aurc": 0.04897950583128602, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.45, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.45, + "aurc": 0.06282346007965203, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.07142857142857142, - "confidence_bias": 0.07467754612369504, + "confidence_bias": 0.07730544443716969, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 14, @@ -5730,31 +5730,31 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9621361601591426 + "accuracy": 0.9, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9649345170900093 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.708977460861206 + "accuracy": 0.875, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7085450713959379 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 0.3590183753756898, + "nll": 0.391154446854581, "acc": 0.8, - "ece": 0.12098253375100354, - "brier": 0.2234753942109866, - "mean_conf": 0.8746775461236951, + "ece": 0.0909007219853577, + "brier": 0.24269024392468377, + "mean_conf": 0.8773054444371697, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9285714285714286, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.5, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5, - "aurc": 0.04897950583128602, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.45, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.45, + "aurc": 0.06282346007965203, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.07142857142857142, - "confidence_bias": 0.07467754612369504, + "confidence_bias": 0.07730544443716969, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 14, @@ -5775,13 +5775,13 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9621361601591426 + "accuracy": 0.9, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9649345170900093 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.708977460861206 + "accuracy": 0.875, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7085450713959379 } } }, @@ -5794,22 +5794,22 @@ "accuracy": 0.9, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 0.17230822458126488, + "nll": 0.173920037838875, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.07775387997537764, - "brier": 0.11106925746781111, - "mean_conf": 0.9399342803070365, + "ece": 0.08884237104933625, + "brier": 0.11334577453222641, + "mean_conf": 0.9453143823740051, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.85, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.9, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.9, "aurc": 0.0076315789473684215, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.039934280307036496, + "confidence_bias": 0.04531438237400509, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 16, + "n": 17, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -5828,33 +5828,33 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9794639367227702 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9793051012887353 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9520198042701821 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9588658106453812 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 0.17230822458126488, + "nll": 0.173920037838875, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.07775387997537764, - "brier": 0.11106925746781111, - "mean_conf": 0.9399342803070365, + "ece": 0.08884237104933625, + "brier": 0.11334577453222641, + "mean_conf": 0.9453143823740051, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.85, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.9, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.9, "aurc": 0.0076315789473684215, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.039934280307036496, + "confidence_bias": 0.04531438237400509, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 16, + "n": 17, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -5873,12 +5873,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9794639367227702 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9793051012887353 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9520198042701821 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9588658106453812 } } }, @@ -5891,19 +5891,19 @@ "accuracy": 0.4, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 1.0747043813664825, + "nll": 0.963421060535776, "acc": 0.4, - "ece": 0.376769070482061, - "brier": 0.7839551359464374, - "mean_conf": 0.776769070482061, + "ece": 0.3598356256038071, + "brier": 0.7060594827987038, + "mean_conf": 0.7594032993432073, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.1, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.0, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, - "aurc": 0.5897093311315447, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.05, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.05, + "aurc": 0.45470466259746445, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, - "confidence_bias": 0.376769070482061, + "confidence_bias": 0.35940329934320725, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -5925,30 +5925,30 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7923556442472722 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7584096306325441 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.3125, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6593232357905366 + "accuracy": 0.4375, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6582031053840188 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 20, - "nll": 1.0747043813664825, + "nll": 0.963421060535776, "acc": 0.4, - "ece": 0.376769070482061, - "brier": 0.7839551359464374, - "mean_conf": 0.776769070482061, + "ece": 0.3598356256038071, + "brier": 0.7060594827987038, + "mean_conf": 0.7594032993432073, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.1, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.0, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, - "aurc": 0.5897093311315447, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.05, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.05, + "aurc": 0.45470466259746445, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, - "confidence_bias": 0.376769070482061, + "confidence_bias": 0.35940329934320725, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -5970,12 +5970,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7923556442472722 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7584096306325441 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.3125, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6593232357905366 + "accuracy": 0.4375, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6582031053840188 } } }, @@ -5988,22 +5988,22 @@ "accuracy": 0.96875, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.1488496730625657, + "nll": 0.13034778836964267, "acc": 0.96875, - "ece": 0.0518019411069781, - "brier": 0.07608424815707887, - "mean_conf": 0.9169480588930219, + "ece": 0.07387770926294471, + "brier": 0.06436468242012063, + "mean_conf": 0.9252340474017305, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6875, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.75, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 1.0, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.8125, - "aurc": 0.006343756575133452, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.84375, + "aurc": 0.005186349167726045, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.05180194110697811, + "confidence_bias": -0.04351595259826946, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 22, + "n": 24, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -6020,35 +6020,35 @@ }, "selective": { "0.5": { - "coverage": 0.5, + "coverage": 0.53125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9526311826156912 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9517537497245334 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8658791104483075 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8932077222078463 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.1488496730625657, + "nll": 0.13034778836964267, "acc": 0.96875, - "ece": 0.0518019411069781, - "brier": 0.07608424815707887, - "mean_conf": 0.9169480588930219, + "ece": 0.07387770926294471, + "brier": 0.06436468242012063, + "mean_conf": 0.9252340474017305, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6875, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.75, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 1.0, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.8125, - "aurc": 0.006343756575133452, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.84375, + "aurc": 0.005186349167726045, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.05180194110697811, + "confidence_bias": -0.04351595259826946, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 22, + "n": 24, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -6065,14 +6065,14 @@ }, "selective": { "0.5": { - "coverage": 0.5, + "coverage": 0.53125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9526311826156912 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9517537497245334 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8658791104483075 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8932077222078463 } } }, @@ -6085,32 +6085,32 @@ "accuracy": 0.90625, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.2775084906134728, + "nll": 0.24646259109043608, "acc": 0.90625, - "ece": 0.05746431889041253, - "brier": 0.15312468872339335, - "mean_conf": 0.9174051821778417, + "ece": 0.08165686202673392, + "brier": 0.13219691386769145, + "mean_conf": 0.9344170796872766, "confident_error_rate": 0.03125, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.65625, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9523809523809523, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.84375, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.75, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9583333333333334, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.9375, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.375, - "aurc": 0.03975357109250195, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.047619047619047616, - "confidence_bias": 0.011155182177841727, + "aurc": 0.033345170986070205, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.041666666666666664, + "confidence_bias": 0.02816707968727661, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 21, + "n": 24, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.047619047619047616 + "error_rate": 0.041666666666666664 }, "0.95": { - "n": 16, + "n": 18, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.0625 + "error_rate": 0.05555555555555555 }, "0.99": { - "n": 4, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6119,43 +6119,43 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9714136069375261 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9769813800539988 }, "0.8": { - "coverage": 0.84375, - "accuracy": 0.9629629629629629, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.866120457649231 + "coverage": 0.8125, + "accuracy": 0.9615384615384616, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8745144680431802 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.2775084906134728, + "nll": 0.24646259109043608, "acc": 0.90625, - "ece": 0.05746431889041253, - "brier": 0.15312468872339335, - "mean_conf": 0.9174051821778417, + "ece": 0.08165686202673392, + "brier": 0.13219691386769145, + "mean_conf": 0.9344170796872766, "confident_error_rate": 0.03125, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.65625, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9523809523809523, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.84375, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.75, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9583333333333334, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.9375, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.375, - "aurc": 0.03975357109250195, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.047619047619047616, - "confidence_bias": 0.011155182177841727, + "aurc": 0.033345170986070205, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.041666666666666664, + "confidence_bias": 0.02816707968727661, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 21, + "n": 24, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.047619047619047616 + "error_rate": 0.041666666666666664 }, "0.95": { - "n": 16, + "n": 18, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.0625 + "error_rate": 0.05555555555555555 }, "0.99": { - "n": 4, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6164,12 +6164,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9714136069375261 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9769813800539988 }, "0.8": { - "coverage": 0.84375, - "accuracy": 0.9629629629629629, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.866120457649231 + "coverage": 0.8125, + "accuracy": 0.9615384615384616, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8745144680431802 } } }, @@ -6178,26 +6178,26 @@ "composition_final_negation": { "requested": 32, "valid_probability_rows": 32, - "correct": 28, - "accuracy": 0.875, + "correct": 31, + "accuracy": 0.96875, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.23890017515673415, - "acc": 0.875, - "ece": 0.14167053791272208, - "brier": 0.14524192276307057, - "mean_conf": 0.8435546575020636, + "nll": 0.17366660442192522, + "acc": 0.96875, + "ece": 0.139280642091471, + "brier": 0.09349301051833991, + "mean_conf": 0.8684549516140397, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.46875, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5625, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.90625, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.84375, - "aurc": 0.012148294732242174, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 1.0, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.875, + "aurc": 0.004072377873563219, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.0314453424979364, + "confidence_bias": -0.10029504838596026, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 15, + "n": 18, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -6216,33 +6216,33 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.53125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8950825933794926 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9398574478142043 }, "0.8": { - "coverage": 0.84375, + "coverage": 0.8125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6886792778968811 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7353225569523143 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.23890017515673415, - "acc": 0.875, - "ece": 0.14167053791272208, - "brier": 0.14524192276307057, - "mean_conf": 0.8435546575020636, + "nll": 0.17366660442192522, + "acc": 0.96875, + "ece": 0.139280642091471, + "brier": 0.09349301051833991, + "mean_conf": 0.8684549516140397, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.46875, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5625, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.90625, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.84375, - "aurc": 0.012148294732242174, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 1.0, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.875, + "aurc": 0.004072377873563219, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.0314453424979364, + "confidence_bias": -0.10029504838596026, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 15, + "n": 18, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -6261,12 +6261,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.53125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8950825933794926 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9398574478142043 }, "0.8": { - "coverage": 0.84375, + "coverage": 0.8125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6886792778968811 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7353225569523143 } } }, @@ -6279,11 +6279,11 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 40, - "nll": 0.009534104113565645, + "nll": 0.010156044928884202, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.009472102695785245, - "brier": 0.0002455458386976324, - "mean_conf": 0.9905278973042148, + "ece": 0.010082175827252016, + "brier": 0.0002922128455344832, + "mean_conf": 0.989917824172748, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -6291,7 +6291,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.009472102695785245, + "confidence_bias": -0.010082175827252016, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 40, @@ -6313,22 +6313,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9938308764165708 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.994282735900115 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9842986932208933 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9830883529872735 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 40, - "nll": 0.009534104113565645, + "nll": 0.010156044928884202, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.009472102695785245, - "brier": 0.0002455458386976324, - "mean_conf": 0.9905278973042148, + "ece": 0.010082175827252016, + "brier": 0.0002922128455344832, + "mean_conf": 0.989917824172748, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -6336,7 +6336,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.009472102695785245, + "confidence_bias": -0.010082175827252016, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 40, @@ -6358,12 +6358,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9938308764165708 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.994282735900115 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9842986932208933 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9830883529872735 } } }, @@ -6376,27 +6376,27 @@ "accuracy": 0.9, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 40, - "nll": 0.24068925250396264, + "nll": 0.2578333370423695, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.08521130467101881, - "brier": 0.13743249520879042, - "mean_conf": 0.869609319103461, + "ece": 0.08339734125029008, + "brier": 0.1539668312012304, + "mean_conf": 0.8928125003966263, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.675, - "aurc": 0.020352482782383177, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.65, + "aurc": 0.02394744920629697, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.03039068089653907, + "confidence_bias": -0.007187499603373726, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 20, + "n": 24, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 14, + "n": 16, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -6410,40 +6410,40 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9031725006679073 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9320149317531109 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.773653912414944 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8366438894497547 } }, - "score_mae": 0.17163726291792777, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.03497160888154245 + "score_mae": 0.16359197313913096, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.03911601810015416 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 40, - "nll": 0.24068925250396264, + "nll": 0.2578333370423695, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.08521130467101881, - "brier": 0.13743249520879042, - "mean_conf": 0.869609319103461, + "ece": 0.08339734125029008, + "brier": 0.1539668312012304, + "mean_conf": 0.8928125003966263, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.675, - "aurc": 0.020352482782383177, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.65, + "aurc": 0.02394744920629697, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.03039068089653907, + "confidence_bias": -0.007187499603373726, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 20, + "n": 24, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 14, + "n": 16, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -6457,111 +6457,111 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9031725006679073 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9320149317531109 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.773653912414944 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8366438894497547 } }, - "score_mae": 0.17163726291792777, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.03497160888154245 + "score_mae": 0.16359197313913096, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.03911601810015416 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, "emotion": { "requested": 80, "valid_probability_rows": 80, - "correct": 48, - "accuracy": 0.6, + "correct": 49, + "accuracy": 0.6125, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 1.404957749606962, - "acc": 0.6, - "ece": 0.2239237429633081, - "brier": 0.5924528456339091, - "mean_conf": 0.8068140896390107, + "nll": 1.3250366616414988, + "acc": 0.6125, + "ece": 0.2033677770446442, + "brier": 0.578098657406022, + "mean_conf": 0.7837558603474908, "confident_error_rate": 0.075, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.4625, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8378378378378378, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.45, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8333333333333334, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.025, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.025, - "aurc": 0.249645290423344, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.16216216216216217, - "confidence_bias": 0.2068140896390107, + "aurc": 0.2465828605574525, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.16666666666666666, + "confidence_bias": 0.17125586034749074, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 37, + "n": 36, "errors": 6, - "error_rate": 0.16216216216216217 + "error_rate": 0.16666666666666666 }, "0.95": { - "n": 31, - "errors": 5, - "error_rate": 0.16129032258064516 + "n": 24, + "errors": 3, + "error_rate": 0.125 }, "0.99": { - "n": 10, + "n": 7, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.2 + "error_rate": 0.2857142857142857 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.825, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8734302110272708 + "accuracy": 0.8, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8534444506954815 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.612044678035727 + "accuracy": 0.65625, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5796189437721434 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 1.404957749606962, - "acc": 0.6, - "ece": 0.2239237429633081, - "brier": 0.5924528456339091, - "mean_conf": 0.8068140896390107, + "nll": 1.3250366616414988, + "acc": 0.6125, + "ece": 0.2033677770446442, + "brier": 0.578098657406022, + "mean_conf": 0.7837558603474908, "confident_error_rate": 0.075, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.4625, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8378378378378378, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.45, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8333333333333334, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.025, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.025, - "aurc": 0.249645290423344, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.16216216216216217, - "confidence_bias": 0.2068140896390107, + "aurc": 0.2465828605574525, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.16666666666666666, + "confidence_bias": 0.17125586034749074, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 37, + "n": 36, "errors": 6, - "error_rate": 0.16216216216216217 + "error_rate": 0.16666666666666666 }, "0.95": { - "n": 31, - "errors": 5, - "error_rate": 0.16129032258064516 + "n": 24, + "errors": 3, + "error_rate": 0.125 }, "0.99": { - "n": 10, + "n": 7, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.2 + "error_rate": 0.2857142857142857 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.825, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8734302110272708 + "accuracy": 0.8, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8534444506954815 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.612044678035727 + "accuracy": 0.65625, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5796189437721434 } } }, @@ -6574,32 +6574,32 @@ "accuracy": 0.7375, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.6291131826963371, + "nll": 0.6466641422955599, "acc": 0.7375, - "ece": 0.09166398596467382, - "brier": 0.32846647117297145, - "mean_conf": 0.8291639859646738, + "ece": 0.10575227809040644, + "brier": 0.3381993704155934, + "mean_conf": 0.8239887221865458, "confident_error_rate": 0.025, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5625, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9555555555555556, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.475, - "aurc": 0.06444573232402091, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.044444444444444446, - "confidence_bias": 0.09166398596467373, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5125, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9512195121951219, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.5875, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.4125, + "aurc": 0.07075415004878534, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.04878048780487805, + "confidence_bias": 0.0864887221865458, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 45, + "n": 41, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.044444444444444446 + "error_rate": 0.04878048780487805 }, "0.95": { - "n": 35, + "n": 31, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 12, + "n": 9, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6608,43 +6608,43 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.95, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9337377421761286 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9179506124738418 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6497676638791126 + "accuracy": 0.859375, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6428546144492293 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.6291131826963371, + "nll": 0.6466641422955599, "acc": 0.7375, - "ece": 0.09166398596467382, - "brier": 0.32846647117297145, - "mean_conf": 0.8291639859646738, + "ece": 0.10575227809040644, + "brier": 0.3381993704155934, + "mean_conf": 0.8239887221865458, "confident_error_rate": 0.025, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5625, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9555555555555556, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.475, - "aurc": 0.06444573232402091, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.044444444444444446, - "confidence_bias": 0.09166398596467373, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5125, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9512195121951219, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.5875, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.4125, + "aurc": 0.07075415004878534, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.04878048780487805, + "confidence_bias": 0.0864887221865458, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 45, + "n": 41, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.044444444444444446 + "error_rate": 0.04878048780487805 }, "0.95": { - "n": 35, + "n": 31, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 12, + "n": 9, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6653,12 +6653,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.95, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9337377421761286 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9179506124738418 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6497676638791126 + "accuracy": 0.859375, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6428546144492293 } } }, @@ -6671,32 +6671,32 @@ "accuracy": 0.53, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 200, - "nll": 1.3194872971476064, + "nll": 1.3111522675312284, "acc": 0.53, - "ece": 0.0712459960944238, - "brier": 0.57596282275509, - "mean_conf": 0.5988417766167529, - "confident_error_rate": 0.01, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.245, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9591836734693877, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.265, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.185, - "aurc": 0.22156004538018903, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.04081632653061224, - "confidence_bias": 0.06884177661675284, + "ece": 0.08739805659958974, + "brier": 0.5728987396461885, + "mean_conf": 0.5899912710608897, + "confident_error_rate": 0.005, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.23, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9782608695652174, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.25, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.19, + "aurc": 0.21980746104696547, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.021739130434782608, + "confidence_bias": 0.05999127106088964, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 49, - "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.04081632653061224 + "n": 46, + "errors": 1, + "error_rate": 0.021739130434782608 }, "0.95": { - "n": 36, + "n": 29, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 9, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6704,44 +6704,44 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.73, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5902113030216032 + "accuracy": 0.75, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.57725688415424 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.2801405568637054 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.26950159367730925 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 200, - "nll": 1.3194872971476064, + "nll": 1.3111522675312284, "acc": 0.53, - "ece": 0.0712459960944238, - "brier": 0.57596282275509, - "mean_conf": 0.5988417766167529, - "confident_error_rate": 0.01, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.245, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9591836734693877, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.265, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.185, - "aurc": 0.22156004538018903, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.04081632653061224, - "confidence_bias": 0.06884177661675284, + "ece": 0.08739805659958974, + "brier": 0.5728987396461885, + "mean_conf": 0.5899912710608897, + "confident_error_rate": 0.005, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.23, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9782608695652174, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.25, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.19, + "aurc": 0.21980746104696547, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.021739130434782608, + "confidence_bias": 0.05999127106088964, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 49, - "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.04081632653061224 + "n": 46, + "errors": 1, + "error_rate": 0.021739130434782608 }, "0.95": { - "n": 36, + "n": 29, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 9, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6749,13 +6749,13 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.73, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5902113030216032 + "accuracy": 0.75, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.57725688415424 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.2801405568637054 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.26950159367730925 } } }, @@ -6768,29 +6768,29 @@ "accuracy": 0.9, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.2774054133452753, + "nll": 0.28314251837212323, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.04500883219029569, - "brier": 0.1577162228589053, - "mean_conf": 0.9337538243395758, - "confident_error_rate": 0.05, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8125, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9384615384615385, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7875, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.35, - "aurc": 0.027700444825567955, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.06153846153846154, - "confidence_bias": 0.033753824339575744, + "ece": 0.06247439765758463, + "brier": 0.15885879977500503, + "mean_conf": 0.9412949163036171, + "confident_error_rate": 0.0625, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8375, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9253731343283582, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.775, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.2875, + "aurc": 0.030912620564059478, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.07462686567164178, + "confidence_bias": 0.041294916303617035, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 65, - "errors": 4, - "error_rate": 0.06153846153846154 + "n": 67, + "errors": 5, + "error_rate": 0.07462686567164178 }, "0.95": { - "n": 59, + "n": 60, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.03389830508474576 + "error_rate": 0.03333333333333333 }, "0.99": { "n": 2, @@ -6802,40 +6802,40 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.975, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9777894020080566 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9773598813644135 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9301801601105976 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9395250222016129 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.2774054133452753, + "nll": 0.28314251837212323, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.04500883219029569, - "brier": 0.1577162228589053, - "mean_conf": 0.9337538243395758, - "confident_error_rate": 0.05, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8125, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9384615384615385, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7875, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.35, - "aurc": 0.027700444825567955, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.06153846153846154, - "confidence_bias": 0.033753824339575744, + "ece": 0.06247439765758463, + "brier": 0.15885879977500503, + "mean_conf": 0.9412949163036171, + "confident_error_rate": 0.0625, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8375, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9253731343283582, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.775, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.2875, + "aurc": 0.030912620564059478, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.07462686567164178, + "confidence_bias": 0.041294916303617035, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 65, - "errors": 4, - "error_rate": 0.06153846153846154 + "n": 67, + "errors": 5, + "error_rate": 0.07462686567164178 }, "0.95": { - "n": 59, + "n": 60, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.03389830508474576 + "error_rate": 0.03333333333333333 }, "0.99": { "n": 2, @@ -6847,12 +6847,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.975, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9777894020080566 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9773598813644135 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9301801601105976 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9395250222016129 } } }, @@ -6865,91 +6865,91 @@ "accuracy": 0.9125, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.21752679625446542, + "nll": 0.2161076588398619, "acc": 0.9125, - "ece": 0.03901376668147833, - "brier": 0.11730868195084412, - "mean_conf": 0.9352517996137696, + "ece": 0.038010106954782505, + "brier": 0.11745397306383834, + "mean_conf": 0.9376866478309165, "confident_error_rate": 0.025, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8125, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9692307692307692, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.9125, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0625, - "aurc": 0.040943653344357525, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.03076923076923077, - "confidence_bias": 0.022751799613769608, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8375, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9701492537313433, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.925, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.075, + "aurc": 0.039172223012800614, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.029850746268656716, + "confidence_bias": 0.02518664783091651, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 65, + "n": 67, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.03076923076923077 + "error_rate": 0.029850746268656716 }, "0.95": { - "n": 63, + "n": 62, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.031746031746031744 + "error_rate": 0.03225806451612903 }, "0.99": { - "n": 28, + "n": 26, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.03571428571428571 + "error_rate": 0.038461538461538464 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.975, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9841503702581936 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9851611733370504 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.96875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9355465034314021 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9458952863255798 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.21752679625446542, + "nll": 0.2161076588398619, "acc": 0.9125, - "ece": 0.03901376668147833, - "brier": 0.11730868195084412, - "mean_conf": 0.9352517996137696, + "ece": 0.038010106954782505, + "brier": 0.11745397306383834, + "mean_conf": 0.9376866478309165, "confident_error_rate": 0.025, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8125, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9692307692307692, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.9125, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0625, - "aurc": 0.040943653344357525, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.03076923076923077, - "confidence_bias": 0.022751799613769608, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8375, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9701492537313433, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.925, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.075, + "aurc": 0.039172223012800614, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.029850746268656716, + "confidence_bias": 0.02518664783091651, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 65, + "n": 67, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.03076923076923077 + "error_rate": 0.029850746268656716 }, "0.95": { - "n": 63, + "n": 62, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.031746031746031744 + "error_rate": 0.03225806451612903 }, "0.99": { - "n": 28, + "n": 26, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.03571428571428571 + "error_rate": 0.038461538461538464 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.975, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9841503702581936 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9851611733370504 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.96875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9355465034314021 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9458952863255798 } } }, @@ -6962,11 +6962,11 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.004514713334100866, + "nll": 0.006236348098711358, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.004458343565561407, - "brier": 0.00020475202026520086, - "mean_conf": 0.9955416564344386, + "ece": 0.006149372309216639, + "brier": 0.00030747770792780715, + "mean_conf": 0.9938506276907834, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -6974,7 +6974,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.004458343565561407, + "confidence_bias": -0.006149372309216639, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 80, @@ -6982,12 +6982,12 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 78, + "n": 79, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 70, + "n": 69, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -6996,22 +6996,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9987595494699697 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9978451209130044 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9963549793899044 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9938674921230647 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.004514713334100866, + "nll": 0.006236348098711358, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.004458343565561407, - "brier": 0.00020475202026520086, - "mean_conf": 0.9955416564344386, + "ece": 0.006149372309216639, + "brier": 0.00030747770792780715, + "mean_conf": 0.9938506276907834, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7019,7 +7019,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.004458343565561407, + "confidence_bias": -0.006149372309216639, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 80, @@ -7027,12 +7027,12 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 78, + "n": 79, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 70, + "n": 69, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -7041,12 +7041,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9987595494699697 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9978451209130044 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9963549793899044 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9938674921230647 } } }, @@ -7055,31 +7055,31 @@ "tweet_offensive": { "requested": 80, "valid_probability_rows": 80, - "correct": 59, - "accuracy": 0.7375, + "correct": 60, + "accuracy": 0.75, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.5266044697812845, - "acc": 0.7375, - "ece": 0.10983391602437403, - "brier": 0.3587274567128259, - "mean_conf": 0.8256957228540391, + "nll": 0.47556818540480367, + "acc": 0.75, + "ece": 0.07643617030229378, + "brier": 0.3199264336587134, + "mean_conf": 0.8258139805835978, "confident_error_rate": 0.0375, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.425, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9117647058823529, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.35, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3, - "aurc": 0.11516294025516034, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.08823529411764706, - "confidence_bias": 0.0881957228540391, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.4125, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9090909090909091, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.3625, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.35, + "aurc": 0.09222008593150528, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.09090909090909091, + "confidence_bias": 0.07581398058359778, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 34, + "n": 33, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.08823529411764706 + "error_rate": 0.09090909090909091 }, "0.95": { - "n": 23, + "n": 24, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -7093,38 +7093,38 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.9, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8725079970057013 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8609209785002616 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.765625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6975352375964892 + "accuracy": 0.828125, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6948713064193726 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.5266044697812845, - "acc": 0.7375, - "ece": 0.10983391602437403, - "brier": 0.3587274567128259, - "mean_conf": 0.8256957228540391, + "nll": 0.47556818540480367, + "acc": 0.75, + "ece": 0.07643617030229378, + "brier": 0.3199264336587134, + "mean_conf": 0.8258139805835978, "confident_error_rate": 0.0375, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.425, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9117647058823529, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.35, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3, - "aurc": 0.11516294025516034, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.08823529411764706, - "confidence_bias": 0.0881957228540391, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.4125, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9090909090909091, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.3625, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.35, + "aurc": 0.09222008593150528, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.09090909090909091, + "confidence_bias": 0.07581398058359778, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 34, + "n": 33, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.08823529411764706 + "error_rate": 0.09090909090909091 }, "0.95": { - "n": 23, + "n": 24, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -7138,12 +7138,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.9, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8725079970057013 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8609209785002616 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.765625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6975352375964892 + "accuracy": 0.828125, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6948713064193726 } } }, @@ -7156,11 +7156,11 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.006876414004309999, + "nll": 0.007841155789564139, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.0068486883882732386, - "brier": 0.00011023848598835957, - "mean_conf": 0.9931513116117268, + "ece": 0.007806247293806301, + "brier": 0.00013872505147745316, + "mean_conf": 0.9921937527061937, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7168,7 +7168,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.0068486883882732386, + "confidence_bias": -0.007806247293806301, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -7181,7 +7181,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 9, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -7190,22 +7190,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9946927960913962 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9939010793872055 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9907611704497484 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9896593136903282 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.006876414004309999, + "nll": 0.007841155789564139, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.0068486883882732386, - "brier": 0.00011023848598835957, - "mean_conf": 0.9931513116117268, + "ece": 0.007806247293806301, + "brier": 0.00013872505147745316, + "mean_conf": 0.9921937527061937, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7213,7 +7213,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.0068486883882732386, + "confidence_bias": -0.007806247293806301, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -7226,7 +7226,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 9, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -7235,12 +7235,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9946927960913962 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9939010793872055 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9907611704497484 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9896593136903282 } } }, @@ -7253,11 +7253,11 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.010054244756134334, + "nll": 0.0107929267557592, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.009977028457380022, - "brier": 0.0003052461514864493, - "mean_conf": 0.99002297154262, + "ece": 0.010701462639340464, + "brier": 0.00036120660545170313, + "mean_conf": 0.9892985373606595, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7265,7 +7265,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.009977028457380022, + "confidence_bias": -0.010701462639340464, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -7287,22 +7287,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9966472206636919 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9969034000449554 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9836865232385298 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9816944573491596 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.010054244756134334, + "nll": 0.0107929267557592, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.009977028457380022, - "brier": 0.0003052461514864493, - "mean_conf": 0.99002297154262, + "ece": 0.010701462639340464, + "brier": 0.00036120660545170313, + "mean_conf": 0.9892985373606595, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7310,7 +7310,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.009977028457380022, + "confidence_bias": -0.010701462639340464, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -7332,12 +7332,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9966472206636919 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9969034000449554 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9836865232385298 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9816944573491596 } } }, @@ -7346,31 +7346,31 @@ "unknowable_control_deadline": { "requested": 10, "valid_probability_rows": 10, - "correct": 10, - "accuracy": 1.0, + "correct": 8, + "accuracy": 0.8, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.20875349707626656, - "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.16950983158479752, - "brier": 0.10697640035089204, - "mean_conf": 0.8304901684152025, + "nll": 0.2138260506584651, + "acc": 0.8, + "ece": 0.15741611133328517, + "brier": 0.1276425479499806, + "mean_conf": 0.856580016184909, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 1.0, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, - "aurc": 0.0, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.8, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.8, + "aurc": 0.03111111111111111, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.1695098315847975, + "confidence_bias": 0.05658001618490893, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 5, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 3, + "n": 4, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -7384,40 +7384,40 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9212612921563369 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9426117959877142 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7564743954513996 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8415699130530643 } }, - "score_mae": 0.1696031781535504, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.027307549723045547 + "score_mae": 0.16071754616245987, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.03275971187271286 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.20875349707626656, - "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.16950983158479752, - "brier": 0.10697640035089204, - "mean_conf": 0.8304901684152025, + "nll": 0.2138260506584651, + "acc": 0.8, + "ece": 0.15741611133328517, + "brier": 0.1276425479499806, + "mean_conf": 0.856580016184909, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 1.0, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, - "aurc": 0.0, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.8, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.8, + "aurc": 0.03111111111111111, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.1695098315847975, + "confidence_bias": 0.05658001618490893, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 5, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 3, + "n": 4, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -7431,16 +7431,16 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9212612921563369 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9426117959877142 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7564743954513996 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8415699130530643 } }, - "score_mae": 0.1696031781535504, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.027307549723045547 + "score_mae": 0.16071754616245987, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.03275971187271286 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, @@ -7451,11 +7451,11 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.07820821810037346, + "nll": 0.07005694097555375, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.05979035227629538, - "brier": 0.04652092623743477, - "mean_conf": 0.9402096477237045, + "ece": 0.0540813816797954, + "brier": 0.04110395968042234, + "mean_conf": 0.9459186183202046, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.9, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7463,7 +7463,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.05979035227629548, + "confidence_bias": -0.05408138167979537, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 9, @@ -7476,7 +7476,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 7, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -7485,24 +7485,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9956810330664218 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.993819476814992 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9593766863298722 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9798565648382314 } }, - "score_mae": 0.0541174703260209, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.011129613417488322 + "score_mae": 0.0487152458265909, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.00975869637261514 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.07820821810037346, + "nll": 0.07005694097555375, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.05979035227629538, - "brier": 0.04652092623743477, - "mean_conf": 0.9402096477237045, + "ece": 0.0540813816797954, + "brier": 0.04110395968042234, + "mean_conf": 0.9459186183202046, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.9, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7510,7 +7510,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.05979035227629548, + "confidence_bias": -0.05408138167979537, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 9, @@ -7523,7 +7523,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 7, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -7532,16 +7532,16 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9956810330664218 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.993819476814992 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9593766863298722 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9798565648382314 } }, - "score_mae": 0.0541174703260209, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.011129613417488322 + "score_mae": 0.0487152458265909, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.00975869637261514 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, @@ -7552,11 +7552,11 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.10634568298556582, + "nll": 0.10819644087102691, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.09157236085416048, - "brier": 0.043689973951603296, - "mean_conf": 0.9084276391458393, + "ece": 0.0954442527194344, + "brier": 0.039610537719924295, + "mean_conf": 0.9045557472805654, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7564,7 +7564,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.09157236085416065, + "confidence_bias": -0.09544425271943457, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 7, @@ -7577,31 +7577,31 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 2, + "n": 0, "errors": 0, - "error_rate": 0.0 + "error_rate": null } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9648931116321414 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9656626177441163 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8787499248169464 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.881241046212756 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.10634568298556582, + "nll": 0.10819644087102691, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.09157236085416048, - "brier": 0.043689973951603296, - "mean_conf": 0.9084276391458393, + "ece": 0.0954442527194344, + "brier": 0.039610537719924295, + "mean_conf": 0.9045557472805654, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7609,7 +7609,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.09157236085416065, + "confidence_bias": -0.09544425271943457, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 7, @@ -7622,21 +7622,21 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 2, + "n": 0, "errors": 0, - "error_rate": 0.0 + "error_rate": null } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9648931116321414 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9656626177441163 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8787499248169464 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.881241046212756 } } }, @@ -7649,19 +7649,19 @@ "accuracy": 0.6, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.7842587765663349, + "nll": 0.8939128624245644, "acc": 0.6, - "ece": 0.3758565683544252, - "brier": 0.5730022276631428, - "mean_conf": 0.8042052849775017, + "ece": 0.39838756334240605, + "brier": 0.6386225586932958, + "mean_conf": 0.8386086717206818, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.3, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3, - "aurc": 0.25563492063492066, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.2, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.2, + "aurc": 0.288968253968254, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.20420528497750168, + "confidence_bias": 0.2386086717206818, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -7683,30 +7683,30 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8447330845812883 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8853410746258817 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7434658255258695 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8282266608409089 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.7842587765663349, + "nll": 0.8939128624245644, "acc": 0.6, - "ece": 0.3758565683544252, - "brier": 0.5730022276631428, - "mean_conf": 0.8042052849775017, + "ece": 0.39838756334240605, + "brier": 0.6386225586932958, + "mean_conf": 0.8386086717206818, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.3, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3, - "aurc": 0.25563492063492066, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.2, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.2, + "aurc": 0.288968253968254, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.20420528497750168, + "confidence_bias": 0.2386086717206818, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -7728,12 +7728,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8447330845812883 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8853410746258817 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7434658255258695 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8282266608409089 } } }, @@ -7746,11 +7746,11 @@ "accuracy": 0.9, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.3877484850113062, + "nll": 0.3878790410817737, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.1957660562559332, - "brier": 0.23322717018981343, - "mean_conf": 0.8058850082032224, + "ece": 0.20366310890419706, + "brier": 0.23894788485153878, + "mean_conf": 0.8019263309455292, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.3, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7758,7 +7758,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5, "aurc": 0.06456349206349207, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.09411499179677763, + "confidence_bias": -0.09807366905447079, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 3, @@ -7780,24 +7780,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8255768464444774 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8513163369222139 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.734157871218888 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7305872644461858 } }, - "score_mae": 0.2481150404394402, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.05778942095101965 + "score_mae": 0.2577528085044144, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.05968224629533503 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.3877484850113062, + "nll": 0.3878790410817737, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.1957660562559332, - "brier": 0.23322717018981343, - "mean_conf": 0.8058850082032224, + "ece": 0.20366310890419706, + "brier": 0.23894788485153878, + "mean_conf": 0.8019263309455292, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.3, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7805,7 +7805,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5, "aurc": 0.06456349206349207, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.09411499179677763, + "confidence_bias": -0.09807366905447079, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 3, @@ -7827,16 +7827,16 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8255768464444774 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8513163369222139 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.734157871218888 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7305872644461858 } }, - "score_mae": 0.2481150404394402, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.05778942095101965 + "score_mae": 0.2577528085044144, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.05968224629533503 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, @@ -7847,29 +7847,29 @@ "accuracy": 0.7, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.753852089972006, + "nll": 0.7470384623310196, "acc": 0.7, - "ece": 0.21322026889904205, - "brier": 0.44008690936983347, - "mean_conf": 0.9132202688990422, + "ece": 0.22029693644423792, + "brier": 0.4309736445646065, + "mean_conf": 0.9202969364442379, "confident_error_rate": 0.1, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8333333333333334, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8571428571428571, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.4, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.4, "aurc": 0.12817460317460316, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.16666666666666666, - "confidence_bias": 0.21322026889904222, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.14285714285714285, + "confidence_bias": 0.22029693644423798, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 6, + "n": 7, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.16666666666666666 + "error_rate": 0.14285714285714285 }, "0.95": { - "n": 5, + "n": 6, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.2 + "error_rate": 0.16666666666666666 }, "0.99": { "n": 3, @@ -7881,42 +7881,42 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9756218860055605 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9773512719149 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.75, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8950916416154385 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8938853735717587 } }, - "score_mae": 0.28450960978161083, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.10937006220858798 + "score_mae": 0.2732574139836782, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.10706854764238136 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.753852089972006, + "nll": 0.7470384623310196, "acc": 0.7, - "ece": 0.21322026889904205, - "brier": 0.44008690936983347, - "mean_conf": 0.9132202688990422, + "ece": 0.22029693644423792, + "brier": 0.4309736445646065, + "mean_conf": 0.9202969364442379, "confident_error_rate": 0.1, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8333333333333334, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8571428571428571, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.4, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.4, "aurc": 0.12817460317460316, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.16666666666666666, - "confidence_bias": 0.21322026889904222, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.14285714285714285, + "confidence_bias": 0.22029693644423798, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 6, + "n": 7, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.16666666666666666 + "error_rate": 0.14285714285714285 }, "0.95": { - "n": 5, + "n": 6, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.2 + "error_rate": 0.16666666666666666 }, "0.99": { "n": 3, @@ -7928,16 +7928,16 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9756218860055605 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9773512719149 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.75, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8950916416154385 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8938853735717587 } }, - "score_mae": 0.28450960978161083, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.10937006220858798 + "score_mae": 0.2732574139836782, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.10706854764238136 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, @@ -7948,11 +7948,11 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.0029451718587351072, + "nll": 0.004226216609183238, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.0029393785852619425, - "brier": 2.0483928291246792e-05, - "mean_conf": 0.9970606214147381, + "ece": 0.004215976897349094, + "brier": 3.4649667131696104e-05, + "mean_conf": 0.9957840231026509, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -7960,7 +7960,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.0029393785852619425, + "confidence_bias": -0.004215976897349094, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -7982,22 +7982,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9985005648070538 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9969052065210677 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9953866143850587 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9942030038674581 } } }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.0029451718587351072, + "nll": 0.004226216609183238, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.0029393785852619425, - "brier": 2.0483928291246792e-05, - "mean_conf": 0.9970606214147381, + "ece": 0.004215976897349094, + "brier": 3.4649667131696104e-05, + "mean_conf": 0.9957840231026509, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -8005,7 +8005,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.0029393785852619425, + "confidence_bias": -0.004215976897349094, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -8027,12 +8027,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9985005648070538 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9969052065210677 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9953866143850587 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9942030038674581 } } }, @@ -8045,11 +8045,11 @@ "accuracy": 1.0, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.00544297332787101, + "nll": 0.007053870282788843, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.005423762486261863, - "brier": 6.639927679627542e-05, - "mean_conf": 0.9945762375137381, + "ece": 0.007024441570579243, + "brier": 9.776258511132903e-05, + "mean_conf": 0.9929755584294208, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -8057,7 +8057,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.005423762486261863, + "confidence_bias": -0.007024441570579243, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -8070,7 +8070,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 10, + "n": 7, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -8079,24 +8079,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9954970691885048 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9932447768419814 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9907873254440961 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9898739137651561 } }, - "score_mae": 0.005819174097637415, - "ranked_probability_score": 1.8048948557090246e-05 + "score_mae": 0.007660911551517352, + "ranked_probability_score": 2.757223086398964e-05 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.00544297332787101, + "nll": 0.007053870282788843, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.005423762486261863, - "brier": 6.639927679627542e-05, - "mean_conf": 0.9945762375137381, + "ece": 0.007024441570579243, + "brier": 9.776258511132903e-05, + "mean_conf": 0.9929755584294208, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -8104,7 +8104,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.005423762486261863, + "confidence_bias": -0.007024441570579243, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -8117,7 +8117,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 10, + "n": 7, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -8126,16 +8126,16 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9954970691885048 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9932447768419814 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9907873254440961 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9898739137651561 } }, - "score_mae": 0.005819174097637415, - "ranked_probability_score": 1.8048948557090246e-05 + "score_mae": 0.007660911551517352, + "ranked_probability_score": 2.757223086398964e-05 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, @@ -8146,19 +8146,19 @@ "accuracy": 0.5, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 1.0149049311837293, + "nll": 0.9724116266401464, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.42166657051283946, - "brier": 0.6278537954984514, - "mean_conf": 0.711034663533795, + "ece": 0.37317330379992186, + "brier": 0.592356663184495, + "mean_conf": 0.7285382769948201, "confident_error_rate": 0.1, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.1, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.1, - "aurc": 0.3800793650793651, + "aurc": 0.356468253968254, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, - "confidence_bias": 0.21103466353379496, + "confidence_bias": 0.2285382769948201, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -8180,32 +8180,32 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.6, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7399423277412458 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7507937755021719 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5655117799494201 + "accuracy": 0.625, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.597999206215155 } }, - "score_mae": 0.46951970562367135, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.1575113657152988 + "score_mae": 0.41248856844465875, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.14487339386062986 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 10, - "nll": 1.0149049311837293, + "nll": 0.9724116266401464, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.42166657051283946, - "brier": 0.6278537954984514, - "mean_conf": 0.711034663533795, + "ece": 0.37317330379992186, + "brier": 0.592356663184495, + "mean_conf": 0.7285382769948201, "confident_error_rate": 0.1, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.1, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.1, - "aurc": 0.3800793650793651, + "aurc": 0.356468253968254, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, - "confidence_bias": 0.21103466353379496, + "confidence_bias": 0.2285382769948201, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -8227,76 +8227,76 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.6, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7399423277412458 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7507937755021719 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5655117799494201 + "accuracy": 0.625, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.597999206215155 } }, - "score_mae": 0.46951970562367135, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.1575113657152988 + "score_mae": 0.41248856844465875, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.14487339386062986 }, "coverage": 1.0 } }, - "clean_task_macro_accuracy": 0.8265740740740741, + "clean_task_macro_accuracy": 0.8235648148148148, "permutation": { "requested_pairs": 36, "valid_pairs": 36, "both_correct_requested": 0.7777777777777778, "flip_rate": 0.08333333333333333, "covered_only_flip_rate": 0.08333333333333333, - "half_l1": 0.08193039842124604 + "half_l1": 0.08515840387623191 }, "unknowable": { "requested": 110, "valid": 110, "accuracy": null, "full_confidence_metrics": { - "mean_max_p": 0.6367563362463791, - "share_at_0_9": 0.16363636363636364, - "normalized_entropy": 0.7292206320388325 + "mean_max_p": 0.6485130260679773, + "share_at_0_9": 0.21818181818181817, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7184893503275872 }, "covered_only_confidence_metrics": { - "mean_max_p": 0.6367563362463791, - "share_at_0_9": 0.16363636363636364, - "normalized_entropy": 0.7292206320388325 + "mean_max_p": 0.6485130260679773, + "share_at_0_9": 0.21818181818181817, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7184893503275872 }, "controls": { "requested": 110, "valid_probability_rows": 110, - "correct": 97, - "accuracy": 0.8818181818181818, + "correct": 95, + "accuracy": 0.8636363636363636, "full_probability_metrics": { "n": 110, - "nll": 0.3053991349856939, - "acc": 0.8818181818181818, - "ece": 0.0526352555914349, - "brier": 0.18835088828215762, - "mean_conf": 0.8989348929982847, + "nll": 0.31120323585634946, + "acc": 0.8636363636363636, + "ece": 0.055639968292740274, + "brier": 0.1918081945957669, + "mean_conf": 0.9060614972263522, "confident_error_rate": 0.01818181818181818, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6727272727272727, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.972972972972973, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7818181818181819, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5272727272727272, - "aurc": 0.029171898955925056, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.02702702702702703, - "confidence_bias": 0.017116711180102828, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6909090909090909, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9736842105263158, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7727272727272727, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5454545454545454, + "aurc": 0.029014791714251358, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.02631578947368421, + "confidence_bias": 0.04242513358998856, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 74, + "n": 76, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.02702702702702703 + "error_rate": 0.02631578947368421 }, "0.95": { - "n": 66, + "n": 68, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.030303030303030304 + "error_rate": 0.029411764705882353 }, "0.99": { - "n": 49, + "n": 40, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -8305,45 +8305,45 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9837696603934573 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9818909453374407 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.9318181818181818, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8159752894198687 + "accuracy": 0.9431818181818182, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8415699130530643 } }, - "score_mae": 0.20528069640365518, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.06052101016066624 + "score_mae": 0.19343208241221987, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.05902836137908972 }, "covered_only_probability_metrics": { "n": 110, - "nll": 0.3053991349856939, - "acc": 0.8818181818181818, - "ece": 0.0526352555914349, - "brier": 0.18835088828215762, - "mean_conf": 0.8989348929982847, + "nll": 0.31120323585634946, + "acc": 0.8636363636363636, + "ece": 0.055639968292740274, + "brier": 0.1918081945957669, + "mean_conf": 0.9060614972263522, "confident_error_rate": 0.01818181818181818, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6727272727272727, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.972972972972973, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7818181818181819, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5272727272727272, - "aurc": 0.029171898955925056, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.02702702702702703, - "confidence_bias": 0.017116711180102828, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6909090909090909, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9736842105263158, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7727272727272727, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5454545454545454, + "aurc": 0.029014791714251358, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.02631578947368421, + "confidence_bias": 0.04242513358998856, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 74, + "n": 76, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.02702702702702703 + "error_rate": 0.02631578947368421 }, "0.95": { - "n": 66, + "n": 68, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.030303030303030304 + "error_rate": 0.029411764705882353 }, "0.99": { - "n": 49, + "n": 40, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -8352,22 +8352,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9837696603934573 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9818909453374407 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.9318181818181818, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8159752894198687 + "accuracy": 0.9431818181818182, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8415699130530643 } }, - "score_mae": 0.20528069640365518, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.06052101016066624 + "score_mae": 0.19343208241221987, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.05902836137908972 }, "coverage": 1.0 }, "requested_pairs": 110, "valid_pairs": 110, - "paired_confidence_drop": 0.26217855675190543 + "paired_confidence_drop": 0.2575484711583747 }, "coverage": { "questions": 1264, @@ -8376,98 +8376,98 @@ "truncated_questions": 0 }, "complete_unchanged_upstream_report": { - "objective": -0.4372390887135022, + "objective": -0.42681700298384834, "paired_flip": { "pairs": 64, - "flip_rate": 0.9375, - "both_correct_rate": 0.875, + "flip_rate": 0.953125, + "both_correct_rate": 0.890625, "invariant_pairs": 24, "invariance_rate": 1.0, - "invariant_both_correct_rate": 0.9166666666666666 + "invariant_both_correct_rate": 0.9583333333333334 }, "unknowable": { "n": 110, - "mean_max_p": 0.6367563362463791, - "share_at_0_9": 0.16363636363636364, - "control_mean_max_p": 0.8989348929982847, - "control_share_at_0_9": 0.6727272727272727, - "control_acc": 0.8818181818181818, - "paired_confidence_drop": 0.26217855675190543, - "share_less_confident_than_control": 0.8909090909090909 + "mean_max_p": 0.6485130260679773, + "share_at_0_9": 0.21818181818181817, + "control_mean_max_p": 0.9060614972263522, + "control_share_at_0_9": 0.6909090909090909, + "control_acc": 0.8636363636363636, + "paired_confidence_drop": 0.2575484711583747, + "share_less_confident_than_control": 0.9 }, "clean": { "n": 1046, - "nll": 0.6086212459300988, - "acc": 0.7734225621414914, - "ece": 0.05889322575332617, - "brier": 0.3004372452589081, - "mean_conf": 0.8323157878948174, + "nll": 0.5940603022446113, + "acc": 0.7762906309751434, + "ece": 0.05558262070294892, + "brier": 0.2937157813621403, + "mean_conf": 0.8318732516780923, "confident_error_rate": 0.02390057361376673, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5774378585086042, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9586092715231788, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6338432122370937, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.38336520076481834, - "aurc": 0.061361186701696054, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.041390728476821195, - "confidence_bias": 0.058893225753326006, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5860420650095602, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9592169657422512, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6347992351816444, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3030592734225621, + "aurc": 0.05816033320114623, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.040783034257748776, + "confidence_bias": 0.05558262070294895, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 604, + "n": 613, "errors": 25, - "error_rate": 0.041390728476821195 + "error_rate": 0.040783034257748776 }, "0.95": { - "n": 525, - "errors": 15, - "error_rate": 0.02857142857142857 + "n": 514, + "errors": 12, + "error_rate": 0.023346303501945526 }, "0.99": { - "n": 226, + "n": 207, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.01327433628318584 + "error_rate": 0.014492753623188406 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { - "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.97131931166348, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9503957614513975 + "coverage": 0.5009560229445507, + "accuracy": 0.9770992366412213, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.947606086730957 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8001912045889101, - "accuracy": 0.8745519713261649, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6527601881992761 + "accuracy": 0.8781362007168458, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.647434909565297 } }, - "score_mae": 0.19182332300936422, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.05030124964901672 + "score_mae": 0.18149603870298436, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.051063424067515496 }, "tasks": { "buried_emotion": { "n": 20, - "nll": 1.5449426114821578, + "nll": 1.4899537928777824, "acc": 0.45, - "ece": 0.24636374641400255, - "brier": 0.7048268473893603, - "mean_conf": 0.6963637464140026, + "ece": 0.3017003229117818, + "brier": 0.6913230901539468, + "mean_conf": 0.6857035964205832, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.25, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.75, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.05, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.05, - "aurc": 0.3654720743652632, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.2, - "confidence_bias": 0.24636374641400255, + "aurc": 0.3734132508358514, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.25, + "confidence_bias": 0.2357035964205832, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 5, + "n": 4, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.2 + "error_rate": 0.25 }, "0.95": { - "n": 2, - "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.5 + "n": 1, + "errors": 0, + "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { "n": 0, @@ -8478,31 +8478,31 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.7, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7313402914926098 + "accuracy": 0.6, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.720178043538323 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5043779386113015 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.49892304084621675 } } }, "buried_paws": { "n": 20, - "nll": 0.3590183753756898, + "nll": 0.391154446854581, "acc": 0.8, - "ece": 0.12098253375100354, - "brier": 0.2234753942109866, - "mean_conf": 0.8746775461236951, + "ece": 0.0909007219853577, + "brier": 0.24269024392468377, + "mean_conf": 0.8773054444371697, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9285714285714286, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.5, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5, - "aurc": 0.04897950583128602, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.45, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.45, + "aurc": 0.06282346007965203, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.07142857142857142, - "confidence_bias": 0.07467754612369504, + "confidence_bias": 0.07730544443716969, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 14, @@ -8523,34 +8523,34 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9621361601591426 + "accuracy": 0.9, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9649345170900093 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.708977460861206 + "accuracy": 0.875, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7085450713959379 } } }, "buried_qnli": { "n": 20, - "nll": 0.17230822458126488, + "nll": 0.173920037838875, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.07775387997537764, - "brier": 0.11106925746781111, - "mean_conf": 0.9399342803070365, + "ece": 0.08884237104933625, + "brier": 0.11334577453222641, + "mean_conf": 0.9453143823740051, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.85, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.9, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.9, "aurc": 0.0076315789473684215, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.039934280307036496, + "confidence_bias": 0.04531438237400509, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 16, + "n": 17, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -8569,30 +8569,30 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9794639367227702 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9793051012887353 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9520198042701821 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9588658106453812 } } }, "buried_tweet_offensive": { "n": 20, - "nll": 1.0747043813664825, + "nll": 0.963421060535776, "acc": 0.4, - "ece": 0.376769070482061, - "brier": 0.7839551359464374, - "mean_conf": 0.776769070482061, + "ece": 0.3598356256038071, + "brier": 0.7060594827987038, + "mean_conf": 0.7594032993432073, "confident_error_rate": 0.05, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.1, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.0, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, - "aurc": 0.5897093311315447, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.05, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.05, + "aurc": 0.45470466259746445, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, - "confidence_bias": 0.376769070482061, + "confidence_bias": 0.35940329934320725, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -8614,33 +8614,33 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7923556442472722 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7584096306325441 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.3125, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6593232357905366 + "accuracy": 0.4375, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6582031053840188 } } }, "composition_final_combination": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.1488496730625657, + "nll": 0.13034778836964267, "acc": 0.96875, - "ece": 0.0518019411069781, - "brier": 0.07608424815707887, - "mean_conf": 0.9169480588930219, + "ece": 0.07387770926294471, + "brier": 0.06436468242012063, + "mean_conf": 0.9252340474017305, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6875, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.75, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 1.0, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.8125, - "aurc": 0.006343756575133452, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.84375, + "aurc": 0.005186349167726045, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.05180194110697811, + "confidence_bias": -0.04351595259826946, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 22, + "n": 24, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -8657,45 +8657,45 @@ }, "selective": { "0.5": { - "coverage": 0.5, + "coverage": 0.53125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9526311826156912 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9517537497245334 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8658791104483075 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8932077222078463 } } }, "composition_final_exception": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.2775084906134728, + "nll": 0.24646259109043608, "acc": 0.90625, - "ece": 0.05746431889041253, - "brier": 0.15312468872339335, - "mean_conf": 0.9174051821778417, + "ece": 0.08165686202673392, + "brier": 0.13219691386769145, + "mean_conf": 0.9344170796872766, "confident_error_rate": 0.03125, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.65625, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9523809523809523, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.84375, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.75, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9583333333333334, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.9375, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.375, - "aurc": 0.03975357109250195, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.047619047619047616, - "confidence_bias": 0.011155182177841727, + "aurc": 0.033345170986070205, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.041666666666666664, + "confidence_bias": 0.02816707968727661, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 21, + "n": 24, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.047619047619047616 + "error_rate": 0.041666666666666664 }, "0.95": { - "n": 16, + "n": 18, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.0625 + "error_rate": 0.05555555555555555 }, "0.99": { - "n": 4, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -8704,33 +8704,33 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9714136069375261 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9769813800539988 }, "0.8": { - "coverage": 0.84375, - "accuracy": 0.9629629629629629, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.866120457649231 + "coverage": 0.8125, + "accuracy": 0.9615384615384616, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8745144680431802 } } }, "composition_final_negation": { "n": 32, - "nll": 0.23890017515673415, - "acc": 0.875, - "ece": 0.14167053791272208, - "brier": 0.14524192276307057, - "mean_conf": 0.8435546575020636, + "nll": 0.17366660442192522, + "acc": 0.96875, + "ece": 0.139280642091471, + "brier": 0.09349301051833991, + "mean_conf": 0.8684549516140397, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.46875, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5625, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.90625, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.84375, - "aurc": 0.012148294732242174, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 1.0, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.875, + "aurc": 0.004072377873563219, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.0314453424979364, + "confidence_bias": -0.10029504838596026, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 15, + "n": 18, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -8749,22 +8749,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.53125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8950825933794926 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9398574478142043 }, "0.8": { - "coverage": 0.84375, + "coverage": 0.8125, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6886792778968811 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7353225569523143 } } }, "contrastive_authorization": { "n": 40, - "nll": 0.009534104113565645, + "nll": 0.010156044928884202, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.009472102695785245, - "brier": 0.0002455458386976324, - "mean_conf": 0.9905278973042148, + "ece": 0.010082175827252016, + "brier": 0.0002922128455344832, + "mean_conf": 0.989917824172748, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -8772,7 +8772,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.009472102695785245, + "confidence_bias": -0.010082175827252016, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 40, @@ -8794,38 +8794,38 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9938308764165708 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.994282735900115 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9842986932208933 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9830883529872735 } } }, "contrastive_deadline": { "n": 40, - "nll": 0.24068925250396264, + "nll": 0.2578333370423695, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.08521130467101881, - "brier": 0.13743249520879042, - "mean_conf": 0.869609319103461, + "ece": 0.08339734125029008, + "brier": 0.1539668312012304, + "mean_conf": 0.8928125003966263, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.675, - "aurc": 0.020352482782383177, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.65, + "aurc": 0.02394744920629697, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.03039068089653907, + "confidence_bias": -0.007187499603373726, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 20, + "n": 24, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 14, + "n": 16, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -8839,90 +8839,90 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9031725006679073 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9320149317531109 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.773653912414944 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8366438894497547 } }, - "score_mae": 0.17163726291792777, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.03497160888154245 + "score_mae": 0.16359197313913096, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.03911601810015416 }, "emotion": { "n": 80, - "nll": 1.404957749606962, - "acc": 0.6, - "ece": 0.2239237429633081, - "brier": 0.5924528456339091, - "mean_conf": 0.8068140896390107, + "nll": 1.3250366616414988, + "acc": 0.6125, + "ece": 0.2033677770446442, + "brier": 0.578098657406022, + "mean_conf": 0.7837558603474908, "confident_error_rate": 0.075, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.4625, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8378378378378378, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.45, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8333333333333334, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.025, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.025, - "aurc": 0.249645290423344, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.16216216216216217, - "confidence_bias": 0.2068140896390107, + "aurc": 0.2465828605574525, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.16666666666666666, + "confidence_bias": 0.17125586034749074, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 37, + "n": 36, "errors": 6, - "error_rate": 0.16216216216216217 + "error_rate": 0.16666666666666666 }, "0.95": { - "n": 31, - "errors": 5, - "error_rate": 0.16129032258064516 + "n": 24, + "errors": 3, + "error_rate": 0.125 }, "0.99": { - "n": 10, + "n": 7, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.2 + "error_rate": 0.2857142857142857 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.825, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8734302110272708 + "accuracy": 0.8, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8534444506954815 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.612044678035727 + "accuracy": 0.65625, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5796189437721434 } } }, "mmlu": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.6291131826963371, + "nll": 0.6466641422955599, "acc": 0.7375, - "ece": 0.09166398596467382, - "brier": 0.32846647117297145, - "mean_conf": 0.8291639859646738, + "ece": 0.10575227809040644, + "brier": 0.3381993704155934, + "mean_conf": 0.8239887221865458, "confident_error_rate": 0.025, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5625, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9555555555555556, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.475, - "aurc": 0.06444573232402091, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.044444444444444446, - "confidence_bias": 0.09166398596467373, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5125, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9512195121951219, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.5875, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.4125, + "aurc": 0.07075415004878534, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.04878048780487805, + "confidence_bias": 0.0864887221865458, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 45, + "n": 41, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.044444444444444446 + "error_rate": 0.04878048780487805 }, "0.95": { - "n": 35, + "n": 31, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 12, + "n": 9, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -8931,43 +8931,43 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.95, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9337377421761286 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9179506124738418 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6497676638791126 + "accuracy": 0.859375, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6428546144492293 } } }, "mmlu_pro": { "n": 200, - "nll": 1.3194872971476064, + "nll": 1.3111522675312284, "acc": 0.53, - "ece": 0.0712459960944238, - "brier": 0.57596282275509, - "mean_conf": 0.5988417766167529, - "confident_error_rate": 0.01, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.245, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9591836734693877, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.265, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.185, - "aurc": 0.22156004538018903, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.04081632653061224, - "confidence_bias": 0.06884177661675284, + "ece": 0.08739805659958974, + "brier": 0.5728987396461885, + "mean_conf": 0.5899912710608897, + "confident_error_rate": 0.005, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.23, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9782608695652174, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.25, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.19, + "aurc": 0.21980746104696547, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.021739130434782608, + "confidence_bias": 0.05999127106088964, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 49, - "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.04081632653061224 + "n": 46, + "errors": 1, + "error_rate": 0.021739130434782608 }, "0.95": { - "n": 36, + "n": 29, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 9, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -8975,41 +8975,41 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.73, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5902113030216032 + "accuracy": 0.75, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.57725688415424 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.2801405568637054 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.26950159367730925 } } }, "paws": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.2774054133452753, + "nll": 0.28314251837212323, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.04500883219029569, - "brier": 0.1577162228589053, - "mean_conf": 0.9337538243395758, - "confident_error_rate": 0.05, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8125, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9384615384615385, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7875, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.35, - "aurc": 0.027700444825567955, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.06153846153846154, - "confidence_bias": 0.033753824339575744, + "ece": 0.06247439765758463, + "brier": 0.15885879977500503, + "mean_conf": 0.9412949163036171, + "confident_error_rate": 0.0625, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8375, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9253731343283582, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.775, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.2875, + "aurc": 0.030912620564059478, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.07462686567164178, + "confidence_bias": 0.041294916303617035, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 65, - "errors": 4, - "error_rate": 0.06153846153846154 + "n": 67, + "errors": 5, + "error_rate": 0.07462686567164178 }, "0.95": { - "n": 59, + "n": 60, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.03389830508474576 + "error_rate": 0.03333333333333333 }, "0.99": { "n": 2, @@ -9021,67 +9021,67 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.975, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9777894020080566 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9773598813644135 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.9375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9301801601105976 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9395250222016129 } } }, "qnli": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.21752679625446542, + "nll": 0.2161076588398619, "acc": 0.9125, - "ece": 0.03901376668147833, - "brier": 0.11730868195084412, - "mean_conf": 0.9352517996137696, + "ece": 0.038010106954782505, + "brier": 0.11745397306383834, + "mean_conf": 0.9376866478309165, "confident_error_rate": 0.025, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8125, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9692307692307692, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.9125, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0625, - "aurc": 0.040943653344357525, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.03076923076923077, - "confidence_bias": 0.022751799613769608, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8375, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9701492537313433, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.925, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.075, + "aurc": 0.039172223012800614, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.029850746268656716, + "confidence_bias": 0.02518664783091651, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 65, + "n": 67, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.03076923076923077 + "error_rate": 0.029850746268656716 }, "0.95": { - "n": 63, + "n": 62, "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.031746031746031744 + "error_rate": 0.03225806451612903 }, "0.99": { - "n": 28, + "n": 26, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.03571428571428571 + "error_rate": 0.038461538461538464 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.975, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9841503702581936 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9851611733370504 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.96875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9355465034314021 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9458952863255798 } } }, "sciq": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.004514713334100866, + "nll": 0.006236348098711358, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.004458343565561407, - "brier": 0.00020475202026520086, - "mean_conf": 0.9955416564344386, + "ece": 0.006149372309216639, + "brier": 0.00030747770792780715, + "mean_conf": 0.9938506276907834, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9089,7 +9089,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.004458343565561407, + "confidence_bias": -0.006149372309216639, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 80, @@ -9097,12 +9097,12 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 78, + "n": 79, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 70, + "n": 69, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -9111,38 +9111,38 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9987595494699697 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9978451209130044 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9963549793899044 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9938674921230647 } } }, "tweet_offensive": { "n": 80, - "nll": 0.5266044697812845, - "acc": 0.7375, - "ece": 0.10983391602437403, - "brier": 0.3587274567128259, - "mean_conf": 0.8256957228540391, + "nll": 0.47556818540480367, + "acc": 0.75, + "ece": 0.07643617030229378, + "brier": 0.3199264336587134, + "mean_conf": 0.8258139805835978, "confident_error_rate": 0.0375, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.425, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9117647058823529, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.35, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3, - "aurc": 0.11516294025516034, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.08823529411764706, - "confidence_bias": 0.0881957228540391, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.4125, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9090909090909091, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.3625, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.35, + "aurc": 0.09222008593150528, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.09090909090909091, + "confidence_bias": 0.07581398058359778, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 34, + "n": 33, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.08823529411764706 + "error_rate": 0.09090909090909091 }, "0.95": { - "n": 23, + "n": 24, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -9156,22 +9156,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.9, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8725079970057013 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8609209785002616 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.765625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6975352375964892 + "accuracy": 0.828125, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6948713064193726 } } }, "unknowable_age_eligibility": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.8324197880179746, + "nll": 0.8382027962956439, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.22689295488829114, - "brier": 0.6148228531344591, - "mean_conf": 0.7268929548882912, + "ece": 0.23136963355477053, + "brier": 0.6189159675554958, + "mean_conf": 0.7313696335547706, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, @@ -9179,7 +9179,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, "aurc": 0.5, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": 0.2268929548882912, + "confidence_bias": 0.23136963355477058, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -9201,35 +9201,35 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.6, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7211191224384831 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7283886075019836 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6453390525180384 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6479771137237549 } } }, "unknowable_authorization": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.9725861213638396, + "nll": 1.1053561068085782, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.3223304189350404, - "brier": 0.7008324242939181, - "mean_conf": 0.8223304189350402, - "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, - "accuracy_at_0_9": null, + "ece": 0.3656208440260864, + "brier": 0.7581604276839656, + "mean_conf": 0.8656208440260865, + "confident_error_rate": 0.3, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.2, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.2, "aurc": 0.32313492063492066, - "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": 0.3223304189350402, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, + "confidence_bias": 0.3656208440260865, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 0, - "errors": 0, - "error_rate": null + "n": 6, + "errors": 3, + "error_rate": 0.5 }, "0.95": { "n": 0, @@ -9246,22 +9246,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.6, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8713734149932861 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9161812663078308 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.625, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7420693039894104 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7894018645317196 } } }, "unknowable_control_age_eligibility": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.006876414004309999, + "nll": 0.007841155789564139, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.0068486883882732386, - "brier": 0.00011023848598835957, - "mean_conf": 0.9931513116117268, + "ece": 0.007806247293806301, + "brier": 0.00013872505147745316, + "mean_conf": 0.9921937527061937, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9269,7 +9269,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.0068486883882732386, + "confidence_bias": -0.007806247293806301, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -9282,7 +9282,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 9, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -9291,22 +9291,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9946927960913962 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9939010793872055 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9907611704497484 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9896593136903282 } } }, "unknowable_control_authorization": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.010054244756134334, + "nll": 0.0107929267557592, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.009977028457380022, - "brier": 0.0003052461514864493, - "mean_conf": 0.99002297154262, + "ece": 0.010701462639340464, + "brier": 0.00036120660545170313, + "mean_conf": 0.9892985373606595, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9314,7 +9314,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.009977028457380022, + "confidence_bias": -0.010701462639340464, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -9336,38 +9336,38 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9966472206636919 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9969034000449554 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9836865232385298 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9816944573491596 } } }, "unknowable_control_deadline": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.20875349707626656, - "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.16950983158479752, - "brier": 0.10697640035089204, - "mean_conf": 0.8304901684152025, + "nll": 0.2138260506584651, + "acc": 0.8, + "ece": 0.15741611133328517, + "brier": 0.1276425479499806, + "mean_conf": 0.856580016184909, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 1.0, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, - "aurc": 0.0, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.8, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.8, + "aurc": 0.03111111111111111, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.1695098315847975, + "confidence_bias": 0.05658001618490893, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 5, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 3, + "n": 4, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, @@ -9381,24 +9381,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9212612921563369 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9426117959877142 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7564743954513996 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8415699130530643 } }, - "score_mae": 0.1696031781535504, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.027307549723045547 + "score_mae": 0.16071754616245987, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.03275971187271286 }, "unknowable_control_late_fee": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.07820821810037346, + "nll": 0.07005694097555375, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.05979035227629538, - "brier": 0.04652092623743477, - "mean_conf": 0.9402096477237045, + "ece": 0.0540813816797954, + "brier": 0.04110395968042234, + "mean_conf": 0.9459186183202046, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.9, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9406,7 +9406,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.05979035227629548, + "confidence_bias": -0.05408138167979537, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 9, @@ -9419,7 +9419,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 7, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -9428,24 +9428,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9956810330664218 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.993819476814992 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9593766863298722 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9798565648382314 } }, - "score_mae": 0.0541174703260209, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.011129613417488322 + "score_mae": 0.0487152458265909, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.00975869637261514 }, "unknowable_control_quantity_limit": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.10634568298556582, + "nll": 0.10819644087102691, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.09157236085416048, - "brier": 0.043689973951603296, - "mean_conf": 0.9084276391458393, + "ece": 0.0954442527194344, + "brier": 0.039610537719924295, + "mean_conf": 0.9045557472805654, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9453,7 +9453,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.09157236085416065, + "confidence_bias": -0.09544425271943457, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 7, @@ -9466,39 +9466,39 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 2, + "n": 0, "errors": 0, - "error_rate": 0.0 + "error_rate": null } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9648931116321414 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9656626177441163 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8787499248169464 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.881241046212756 } } }, "unknowable_control_return_window": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.7842587765663349, + "nll": 0.8939128624245644, "acc": 0.6, - "ece": 0.3758565683544252, - "brier": 0.5730022276631428, - "mean_conf": 0.8042052849775017, + "ece": 0.39838756334240605, + "brier": 0.6386225586932958, + "mean_conf": 0.8386086717206818, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.3, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3, - "aurc": 0.25563492063492066, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.2, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.2, + "aurc": 0.288968253968254, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.20420528497750168, + "confidence_bias": 0.2386086717206818, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -9520,22 +9520,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8447330845812883 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8853410746258817 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7434658255258695 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8282266608409089 } } }, "unknowable_control_shipping_delay": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.3877484850113062, + "nll": 0.3878790410817737, "acc": 0.9, - "ece": 0.1957660562559332, - "brier": 0.23322717018981343, - "mean_conf": 0.8058850082032224, + "ece": 0.20366310890419706, + "brier": 0.23894788485153878, + "mean_conf": 0.8019263309455292, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.3, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9543,7 +9543,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.5, "aurc": 0.06456349206349207, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.09411499179677763, + "confidence_bias": -0.09807366905447079, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 3, @@ -9565,42 +9565,42 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8255768464444774 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8513163369222139 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.875, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.734157871218888 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7305872644461858 } }, - "score_mae": 0.2481150404394402, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.05778942095101965 + "score_mae": 0.2577528085044144, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.05968224629533503 }, "unknowable_control_sla_response": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.753852089972006, + "nll": 0.7470384623310196, "acc": 0.7, - "ece": 0.21322026889904205, - "brier": 0.44008690936983347, - "mean_conf": 0.9132202688990422, + "ece": 0.22029693644423792, + "brier": 0.4309736445646065, + "mean_conf": 0.9202969364442379, "confident_error_rate": 0.1, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8333333333333334, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.7, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.8571428571428571, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.4, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.4, "aurc": 0.12817460317460316, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.16666666666666666, - "confidence_bias": 0.21322026889904222, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.14285714285714285, + "confidence_bias": 0.22029693644423798, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 6, + "n": 7, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.16666666666666666 + "error_rate": 0.14285714285714285 }, "0.95": { - "n": 5, + "n": 6, "errors": 1, - "error_rate": 0.2 + "error_rate": 0.16666666666666666 }, "0.99": { "n": 3, @@ -9612,24 +9612,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9756218860055605 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9773512719149 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.75, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.8950916416154385 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.8938853735717587 } }, - "score_mae": 0.28450960978161083, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.10937006220858798 + "score_mae": 0.2732574139836782, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.10706854764238136 }, "unknowable_control_spend_threshold": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.0029451718587351072, + "nll": 0.004226216609183238, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.0029393785852619425, - "brier": 2.0483928291246792e-05, - "mean_conf": 0.9970606214147381, + "ece": 0.004215976897349094, + "brier": 3.4649667131696104e-05, + "mean_conf": 0.9957840231026509, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9637,7 +9637,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.0029393785852619425, + "confidence_bias": -0.004215976897349094, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -9659,22 +9659,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9985005648070538 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9969052065210677 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9953866143850587 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9942030038674581 } } }, "unknowable_control_volume_discount": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.00544297332787101, + "nll": 0.007053870282788843, "acc": 1.0, - "ece": 0.005423762486261863, - "brier": 6.639927679627542e-05, - "mean_conf": 0.9945762375137381, + "ece": 0.007024441570579243, + "brier": 9.776258511132903e-05, + "mean_conf": 0.9929755584294208, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, @@ -9682,7 +9682,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 1.0, "aurc": 0.0, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": -0.005423762486261863, + "confidence_bias": -0.007024441570579243, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -9695,7 +9695,7 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 10, + "n": 7, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -9704,32 +9704,32 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9954970691885048 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9932447768419814 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9907873254440961 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9898739137651561 } }, - "score_mae": 0.005819174097637415, - "ranked_probability_score": 1.8048948557090246e-05 + "score_mae": 0.007660911551517352, + "ranked_probability_score": 2.757223086398964e-05 }, "unknowable_control_warranty_claim": { "n": 10, - "nll": 1.0149049311837293, + "nll": 0.9724116266401464, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.42166657051283946, - "brier": 0.6278537954984514, - "mean_conf": 0.711034663533795, + "ece": 0.37317330379992186, + "brier": 0.592356663184495, + "mean_conf": 0.7285382769948201, "confident_error_rate": 0.1, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.2, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.1, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.1, - "aurc": 0.3800793650793651, + "aurc": 0.356468253968254, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, - "confidence_bias": 0.21103466353379496, + "confidence_bias": 0.2285382769948201, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 2, @@ -9751,32 +9751,32 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.6, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7399423277412458 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.7507937755021719 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5655117799494201 + "accuracy": 0.625, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.597999206215155 } }, - "score_mae": 0.46951970562367135, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.1575113657152988 + "score_mae": 0.41248856844465875, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.14487339386062986 }, "unknowable_deadline": { "n": 10, - "nll": 1.2613031418151548, + "nll": 1.2106218946046243, "acc": 0.3, - "ece": 0.177877089961919, - "brier": 0.7619243213513173, - "mean_conf": 0.47787708996191897, + "ece": 0.17861993312941266, + "brier": 0.7343701548653422, + "mean_conf": 0.47861993312941264, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.0, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, - "aurc": 0.8029761904761905, + "aurc": 0.7779761904761905, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": 0.17787708996191898, + "confidence_bias": 0.17861993312941266, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -9798,24 +9798,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.2, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.48771480379363924 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.49840795241629865 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.4396536350250244 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.4385092854499817 } }, - "score_mae": 0.7850845186781722, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.25791158776503814 + "score_mae": 0.7449380524877681, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.24553973235698762 }, "unknowable_late_fee": { "n": 10, - "nll": 1.3357243996610713, + "nll": 1.3276710177178344, "acc": 0.3, - "ece": 0.29319184809035176, - "brier": 0.8256903429309619, - "mean_conf": 0.5931918480903517, + "ece": 0.27106129862072126, + "brier": 0.8180838268143074, + "mean_conf": 0.5710612986207213, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, @@ -9823,7 +9823,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, "aurc": 0.7483333333333333, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": 0.29319184809035176, + "confidence_bias": 0.2710612986207213, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -9845,24 +9845,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.6, "accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5555960536003113 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.550855944974189 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5130325938040461 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.4580442284371989 } }, - "score_mae": 0.7734692048269523, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.26795404663537026 + "score_mae": 0.7681052591130838, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.2644686148936013 }, "unknowable_quantity_limit": { "n": 10, - "nll": 2.5834206860160718, + "nll": 2.4681683362881595, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.48893830922980164, - "brier": 0.9830983666698885, - "mean_conf": 0.9889383092298016, + "ece": 0.48573829809507685, + "brier": 0.9783875577934342, + "mean_conf": 0.9857382980950768, "confident_error_rate": 0.5, "coverage_at_0_9": 1.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5, @@ -9870,7 +9870,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, "aurc": 0.5, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.5, - "confidence_bias": 0.48893830922980164, + "confidence_bias": 0.48573829809507685, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 10, @@ -9883,39 +9883,39 @@ "error_rate": 0.5 }, "0.99": { - "n": 4, - "errors": 2, - "error_rate": 0.5 + "n": 0, + "errors": 0, + "error_rate": null } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.6, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9883533902636489 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9864682188832252 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9880483656587639 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9834588178510609 } } }, "unknowable_return_window": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.7914498549035975, - "acc": 0.4, - "ece": 0.2586710117345311, - "brier": 0.564890331573083, - "mean_conf": 0.5866955698025846, + "nll": 0.7972145494828772, + "acc": 0.6, + "ece": 0.18620925667194407, + "brier": 0.5676903556290133, + "mean_conf": 0.5894333514724946, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.0, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, - "aurc": 0.470079365079365, + "aurc": 0.48813492063492064, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": 0.18669556980258462, + "confidence_bias": -0.010566648527505329, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -9936,31 +9936,31 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.8, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5635976195335388 + "accuracy": 0.6, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5594538450241089 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, - "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5168146049027027 + "accuracy": 0.625, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5314476331637015 } } }, "unknowable_shipping_delay": { "n": 10, - "nll": 1.220605702584383, - "acc": 0.1, - "ece": 0.3079504190526222, - "brier": 0.7506021687077564, - "mean_conf": 0.40795041905262225, + "nll": 1.3036386445451955, + "acc": 0.2, + "ece": 0.30095968800211725, + "brier": 0.8031605478655157, + "mean_conf": 0.4567572303779661, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.0, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, - "aurc": 0.9354365079365079, + "aurc": 0.9309920634920636, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": 0.3079504190526222, + "confidence_bias": 0.2567572303779661, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -9982,32 +9982,32 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.4146924738494299 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.4595779615514863 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.125, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.36222461945487916 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.41920896115276335 } }, - "score_mae": 0.8003548520533641, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.26340505165600425 + "score_mae": 0.8655138350919522, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.28876623510920263 }, "unknowable_sla_response": { "n": 10, - "nll": 1.1849194907444107, - "acc": 0.3, - "ece": 0.23103561236057332, - "brier": 0.7234547014672483, - "mean_conf": 0.42642234811077023, + "nll": 1.2124338307190397, + "acc": 0.2, + "ece": 0.2761916374516639, + "brier": 0.746030154235981, + "mean_conf": 0.47619163745166393, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.0, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, - "aurc": 0.7066666666666667, + "aurc": 0.7266666666666668, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": 0.12642234811077024, + "confidence_bias": 0.2761916374516639, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -10029,24 +10029,24 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.6, "accuracy": 0.16666666666666666, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.4009427965249298 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.4481450452847792 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.25, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.3769512660219888 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.4357074330957959 } }, - "score_mae": 0.5576178724416314, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.2080023406010124 + "score_mae": 0.6120337496191068, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.21905875267992797 }, "unknowable_spend_threshold": { "n": 10, - "nll": 0.7170838524635513, + "nll": 0.736875114520118, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.04376563079830731, - "brier": 0.5072300370099999, - "mean_conf": 0.5437656307983073, + "ece": 0.07921755937455173, + "brier": 0.5233519615225514, + "mean_conf": 0.5792175593745517, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, @@ -10054,7 +10054,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, "aurc": 0.5, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": 0.04376563079830731, + "confidence_bias": 0.07921755937455166, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -10076,22 +10076,22 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.6, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.5350574633706056 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5943543182085235 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.5, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.524120391391442 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5139663834645092 } } }, "unknowable_volume_discount": { "n": 10, - "nll": 2.5951350581644688, + "nll": 2.5691700417991905, "acc": 0.4, - "ece": 0.5367841896964539, - "brier": 1.1191814760526815, - "mean_conf": 0.9367841896964538, + "ece": 0.5382559019399908, + "brier": 1.121603982108248, + "mean_conf": 0.9382559019399908, "confident_error_rate": 0.5, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.8, "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.375, @@ -10099,7 +10099,7 @@ "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, "aurc": 0.5783333333333334, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.625, - "confidence_bias": 0.5367841896964538, + "confidence_bias": 0.5382559019399907, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 8, @@ -10121,32 +10121,32 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.6, "accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9647726422546125 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9634562251390246 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9562801656369482 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9614389381469302 } }, - "score_mae": 0.9910966577040741, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.46291982849495855 + "score_mae": 0.9905057090116424, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.4635245683115593 }, "unknowable_warranty_claim": { "n": 10, - "nll": 1.0334042098876344, - "acc": 0.3, - "ece": 0.25287419134987343, - "brier": 0.6389076662084439, - "mean_conf": 0.49347092014402827, + "nll": 0.9921422537254998, + "acc": 0.5, + "ece": 0.2020352656125068, + "brier": 0.6100410016954086, + "mean_conf": 0.46137759870501566, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.0, "accuracy_at_0_9": null, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.1, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.1, - "aurc": 0.5163095238095238, + "aurc": 0.4818650793650794, "error_rate_at_0_9": null, - "confidence_bias": 0.19347092014402828, + "confidence_bias": -0.03862240129498434, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 0, @@ -10167,91 +10167,91 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.4, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.456228187213608 + "accuracy": 0.6, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.42317827905448857 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.375, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.4479904637339573 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.40588767546080573 } }, - "score_mae": 0.5853934211989685, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.18462148323551122 + "score_mae": 0.5401415858390292, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.17205966045392337 } }, "variants": { "clean": { "n": 1156, - "nll": 0.6763826525078761, - "acc": 0.7352941176470589, - "ece": 0.07841307190750933, - "brier": 0.3427021673311552, - "mean_conf": 0.8137071895545681, - "confident_error_rate": 0.03027681660899654, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5380622837370242, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9437299035369775, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.49480968858131485, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.08996539792387544, - "aurc": 0.08414303631087763, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.05627009646302251, - "confidence_bias": 0.07841307190750924, + "nll": 0.6634965588347153, + "acc": 0.7413494809688581, + "ece": 0.07307599837609173, + "brier": 0.3373915801751656, + "mean_conf": 0.8144254793449499, + "confident_error_rate": 0.0328719723183391, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.551038062283737, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9403453689167975, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.5077854671280276, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.1185121107266436, + "aurc": 0.08049307232208963, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.059654631083202514, + "confidence_bias": 0.0730759983760918, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 622, - "errors": 35, - "error_rate": 0.05627009646302251 + "n": 637, + "errors": 38, + "error_rate": 0.059654631083202514 }, "0.95": { - "n": 543, - "errors": 25, - "error_rate": 0.04604051565377532 + "n": 532, + "errors": 22, + "error_rate": 0.041353383458646614 }, "0.99": { - "n": 230, - "errors": 5, - "error_rate": 0.021739130434782608 + "n": 207, + "errors": 3, + "error_rate": 0.014492753623188406 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.9480968858131488, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9341998365643388 + "accuracy": 0.9515570934256056, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9346480717751411 }, "0.8": { - "coverage": 0.8001730103806228, - "accuracy": 0.8367567567567568, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.603660772359405 + "coverage": 0.801038062283737, + "accuracy": 0.8412526997840173, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5943543182085235 } }, - "score_mae": 0.4007031098123003, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.13423917717987888 + "score_mae": 0.3960124111370266, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.13525323778002232 }, "none_absent": { "n": 36, - "nll": 1.348957280222087, + "nll": 1.2780587311745955, "acc": 0.5, - "ece": 0.27815703262096336, - "brier": 0.7471379703062733, - "mean_conf": 0.7039376629223564, + "ece": 0.28787280132015003, + "brier": 0.7144050226937334, + "mean_conf": 0.6869218961640411, "confident_error_rate": 0.08333333333333333, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.19444444444444445, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.5714285714285714, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.1111111111111111, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.25, "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.0, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.0, - "aurc": 0.5426191429149073, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.42857142857142855, - "confidence_bias": 0.20393766292235638, + "aurc": 0.5376174183815399, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.75, + "confidence_bias": 0.1869218961640411, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 7, + "n": 4, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.42857142857142855 + "error_rate": 0.75 }, "0.95": { - "n": 3, - "errors": 3, + "n": 2, + "errors": 2, "error_rate": 1.0 }, "0.99": { @@ -10263,44 +10263,44 @@ "selective": { "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.5555555555555556, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.7471419202300652 + "accuracy": 0.6111111111111112, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.696060664667048 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8055555555555556, - "accuracy": 0.4827586206896552, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.4767019156513086 + "accuracy": 0.5172413793103449, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.4846763048647645 } } }, "none_present": { "n": 36, - "nll": 0.772544457721986, + "nll": 0.7460177433221598, "acc": 0.7777777777777778, - "ece": 0.12491830434756149, - "brier": 0.2839371787047634, - "mean_conf": 0.8153893515459814, + "ece": 0.14627996115067443, + "brier": 0.28709997650834473, + "mean_conf": 0.8017359444765791, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5833333333333334, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5555555555555556, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.75, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.7222222222222222, - "aurc": 0.03655983623235726, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7222222222222222, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.6666666666666666, + "aurc": 0.04264397382032627, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.037611573768203566, + "confidence_bias": 0.023958166698801353, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 21, + "n": 20, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 19, + "n": 17, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 7, + "n": 6, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -10309,30 +10309,30 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9658129517830465 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9382298345728617 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8055555555555556, - "accuracy": 0.896551724137931, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6244481662411653 + "accuracy": 0.8620689655172413, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.5789058197682615 } } }, "permuted": { "n": 36, - "nll": 0.747860200951205, + "nll": 0.7203281270997002, "acc": 0.7777777777777778, - "ece": 0.09222810570822655, - "brier": 0.2793216011169781, - "mean_conf": 0.8462041294668327, + "ece": 0.09527377914540269, + "brier": 0.27961577244776725, + "mean_conf": 0.836032418535974, "confident_error_rate": 0.0, "coverage_at_0_9": 0.6388888888888888, "accuracy_at_0_9": 1.0, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7222222222222222, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.7777777777777778, "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.6666666666666666, - "aurc": 0.03881027559007631, + "aurc": 0.03678940551365068, "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.0, - "confidence_bias": 0.06842635168905487, + "confidence_bias": 0.0582546407581962, "top_bins": { "0.9": { "n": 23, @@ -10340,12 +10340,12 @@ "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.95": { - "n": 20, + "n": 18, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 }, "0.99": { - "n": 10, + "n": 9, "errors": 0, "error_rate": 0.0 } @@ -10354,12 +10354,12 @@ "0.5": { "coverage": 0.5, "accuracy": 1.0, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9705536273462746 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.9544422568229554 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8055555555555556, "accuracy": 0.9310344827586207, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6554697446772016 + "confidence_cutoff": 0.6258627504206388 } } } @@ -10367,56 +10367,56 @@ "heldout_tasks": {}, "permutation": { "n": 36, - "mean_max_delta": 0.08050750512860985, + "mean_max_delta": 0.08279943035271198, "flip_rate": 0.08333333333333333 }, "temperature": 1.0, "calibrated_clean": { "n": 1046, - "nll": 0.6086212459300988, - "acc": 0.7734225621414914, - "ece": 0.05889322575332617, - "brier": 0.3004372452589081, - "mean_conf": 0.8323157878948174, + "nll": 0.5940603022446113, + "acc": 0.7762906309751434, + "ece": 0.05558262070294892, + "brier": 0.2937157813621403, + "mean_conf": 0.8318732516780923, "confident_error_rate": 0.02390057361376673, - "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5774378585086042, - "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9586092715231788, - "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6338432122370937, - "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.38336520076481834, - "aurc": 0.061361186701696054, - "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.041390728476821195, - "confidence_bias": 0.058893225753326006, + "coverage_at_0_9": 0.5860420650095602, + "accuracy_at_0_9": 0.9592169657422512, + "coverage_at_5pct_error": 0.6347992351816444, + "coverage_at_1pct_error": 0.3030592734225621, + "aurc": 0.05816033320114623, + "error_rate_at_0_9": 0.040783034257748776, + "confidence_bias": 0.05558262070294895, "top_bins": { "0.9": { - "n": 604, + "n": 613, "errors": 25, - "error_rate": 0.041390728476821195 + "error_rate": 0.040783034257748776 }, "0.95": { - "n": 525, - "errors": 15, - "error_rate": 0.02857142857142857 + "n": 514, + "errors": 12, + "error_rate": 0.023346303501945526 }, "0.99": { - "n": 226, + "n": 207, "errors": 3, - "error_rate": 0.01327433628318584 + "error_rate": 0.014492753623188406 } }, "selective": { "0.5": { - "coverage": 0.5, - "accuracy": 0.97131931166348, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.9503957614513975 + "coverage": 0.5009560229445507, + "accuracy": 0.9770992366412213, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.947606086730957 }, "0.8": { "coverage": 0.8001912045889101, - "accuracy": 0.8745519713261649, - "confidence_cutoff": 0.6527601881992761 + "accuracy": 0.8781362007168458, + "confidence_cutoff": 0.647434909565297 } }, - "score_mae": 0.19182332300936422, - "ranked_probability_score": 0.05030124964901672 + "score_mae": 0.18149603870298436, + "ranked_probability_score": 0.051063424067515496 }, "metric_policy": { "version": 2,